Tenants supplying their own credit reports?

Tenants supplying their own credit reports?

Investor · Monterey, CA · Member since 2014 · 177 posts · 55 votes

In the last month or so I’ve received tenant applicants that would like  to supply their own credit reports? I have always ran their credit report and charged them. I use my own company that I work with. I hate to lose a good applicant because of this, but I’ve also had tenants lose interest when I asked them to supply me with the $35 to run the report.Has anyone had experience with this? Maybe since times are a bit tougher, I can tell them if I accept them as tenants that I will waive the $35 report? Thanks kindly

2Reply
413 views

Most Popular Reply

Theresa HarrisPro Member
Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
6y

@Gayle Eisner  I wouldn't trust the report that they provide any more than I would trust a reference letter from a perspective employee that they supplied.  

If they are worried about the $35, you can tell them if everything looks good and they sign the 1 year lease, you will apply a $35 discount to their rent at the end of the year.

See this reply in the discussion

59 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2020 · 5 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner I would not waiver from your current policy of running their credit through your normal processes. The report could be legitimate and they could be great renters. In my experience as a property manager, its hard to go wrong with running everyone through the same process no matter the situation.

  • Ryan GarrisonPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Olympia, WA · Member since 2017 · 237 posts · 83 votes
    6y

    Hard No.

    I make them use Zillow or Cozy and they can then use it for other landlords too, without paying again. 

    How easy is it to fake? If they can't shell out $40 or whatever, it probably isn't the right tenant.

  • Investor · Monterey, CA · Member since 2014 · 177 posts · 55 votes
    6y

    So does anyone know for sure if it is a hard hit or soft on their credit? Thanks so much to all who have responded! 

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Gayle Eisner:

    So does anyone know for sure if it is a hard hit or soft on their credit? Thanks so much to all who have responded! 

    It depends on the method used. I usually use Myrental and it's a soft pull. Always. The credit report is only a "piece" of the full background I use so them pulling it and providing it to me is not acceptable because I also want to know their criminal background, address history, eviction history, sex offender status, what judgements they have outstanding and so forth. I don't make a decision JUST based on a credit report. It's not common for me to run a report on multiple applicants. I screen them first to the extent able and then have them authorize and pay for the report. I consider placing tenants to be THE most important aspect of managing properties and making this work.

  • Dave SpoonerPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 870 posts · 823 votes
    6y

    I would stick to your current process and have them pay the $35 for screening. If they sign the lease you can always give them $35 off their first month's rent. To me if they aren't willing to pay $35 for the screening it would be a big red flag. I would also recommend pulling more than just their credit report, criminal and eviction history are also important parts in evaluating the quality of the tenant.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2010 · 377 posts · 314 votes
    6y

    Similar to Kyle Benham, the paid credit check is the LAST part of the process (after calling employers, etc). I would be glad to have someone give me a copy of their Credit Karma, FICO etc, but everyone has to pass a background check, no exceptions (it's a non-discrimination thing, if nothing else). I've use MySmartMove (SOFT pull),since they first started. I also never have possession of an applicant's SS# (safer for the applicant). 

    I own  property in rural Northern CA, so I'm often dealing with "C" tenant prospects...and some D & F. Multiple salmon poaching convictions? Felony conviction for stealing an airplane??? "Only uses ice water to produce shatter in the bathtub"?? Um, no!  No way in heck is anyone moving in without a background check!

    I do make clear before I run the background check that it is very, very, VERY thorough, and I give them at least 3 chances to "remember" what might show up. So far I've only had to reject one family for lying. I do applicants one at a time if there are multiple adults (I have them to start with the "worst" one). The deal is that the first 2 credit reports will be deductible from the first month's rent (all adults get screened though). If I reject them for something they already told me about I'll refund the credit report cost. If they lied they are out of luck (eliminates those who KNOW they will fail). I've only refunded once. I'm usually dealing with renters who are on a very tight budget. On the relative scale of turnover costs it's a pretty nominal cost for me, and a landlord's reputation of treating renters respectfully is even more important in a small community than in an urban area. 

  • Investor · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2016 · 34 posts · 16 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kris Mann:

    I have noticed that tenants are sometimes hesitant to apply, because they had past experience where landlords indiscriminately processed multiple applications for a single property, only to be rejected because the landlord found a better qualified tenant. These application fees add up for the tenants, when they have to apply for multiple properties given the shortage in my area. 

    So we ask all interested prospects to to send us their free credit report and proof of income as part of our pre-screening process. We only do the full screening if the credit and income looks good; otherwise we let them know that they don't qualify. I know this might slow down the process a little, but we have tons of applicants for each property in the DC Metro area, so this is not a major issue. More importantly, I have noticed that tenants appreciate the fact that you are trying not to waste their money, and that is a good start to the relationship if they end up becoming your tenant.  

    I agree with Kris, that's what I do if they are worried about qualifying based on their credit.  They can submit a CreditKarma (or similar) report so I can see the data ahead of time, and let them know if I have concerns prior to an actual credit pull.   I don't charge a fee as I do that as one of the last steps before offering someone the property and I confirm with them that they want me to pull their credit (a "no" response would halt the application process).  I also give them the option of letting me know in advance what I'm going to see on their credit report and let them know I will pull their credit through my vendor so they should be straight forward with me about it.  They know what should show on their credit report and how long it's been since their last late payment(s) (if any).  They are either straight forward with you on what you will see, or you will see them hesitate, pause, look for excuses and otherwise stumble on their story of what is on their credit report and why their score is so low.  Red flags that they aren't being up front with you and they're probably not a good fit.  Typical response of an applicant with low credit scores when I ask about their credit score is "I really don't know".  When I ask them to guess it's generally in the 450-500's; obviously those scores generally speak for themselves.  

    Everyone has their own system, this is a glimpse at mine, and for the most part it has served me well.  Other info off topic since I'm sharing...15 years as a landlord/investor and I have only had to do 1 eviction (last year).   My tenants generally stay multiple years and we generally have good and professional relationships.  As such, they generally allow me to show the property before they have moved out and that helps keep my vacancy period down to about 1-7 days max per property, which has resulted in a sustained 99% occupancy rate for 15 years.  Market the property as soon as you get notice from your Tenants that they are going to move and you should have a qualified applicant and new lease by the time they move out, only down time is minor repairs, paint, cleaning which generally doesn't take long with well maintained properties and good tenants who have taken care of your home.  I let them know in advance that it's my goal to give them back all or as much of their security deposit as I can, that way they are incentivized to take care of the property.  I also generally negotiate for 2 year leases, so if you do have a 7 day vacancy every 2 years, that's less than 1% vacancy rate.  

    Happy Landlording!

    Andrew

  • Property Manager · Ketchum, ID · Member since 2016 · 277 posts · 132 votes
    6y

    When I choose a tenant I want one that will be able to pay rent.  Most tenants expect to pay an application fee these days.  Everyone charges the application fee.  If they know that they will not qualify they will usually not want to pay the fee. Just ask them why, when the say they don't want to pay the fee.  There may be criminal history or even eviction history on the report and they know it.  For those who want to give the fee back, I suggest that you raise your rent $2-3 per month and then credit the fee back at the termination of the lease.  They have actually paid for it by then if it is a 12 month lease.  I would also qualify that refund in that they will be required to have paid rent on time every month, and have no damage at the time that they vacate.  It is sort of like getting the security deposit back; it gives the tenant an incentive.  If a tenant wishes to show me a credit report that they have in their possession, I will always look at it.  If it is obvious that they will not qualify, I tell them and go to the next applicant.  If there are no red flags I stick with my rule and tell them that in order for me to consider their application, I will need the application fee and for them to cooperate and complete a new tenant screening.  Just my 2 cents worth.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.