Tenants supplying their own credit reports?

Tenants supplying their own credit reports?

Investor · Monterey, CA · Member since 2014 · 177 posts · 55 votes

In the last month or so I’ve received tenant applicants that would like  to supply their own credit reports? I have always ran their credit report and charged them. I use my own company that I work with. I hate to lose a good applicant because of this, but I’ve also had tenants lose interest when I asked them to supply me with the $35 to run the report.Has anyone had experience with this? Maybe since times are a bit tougher, I can tell them if I accept them as tenants that I will waive the $35 report? Thanks kindly

2Reply
413 views

Most Popular Reply

Theresa HarrisPro Member
Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
6y

@Gayle Eisner  I wouldn't trust the report that they provide any more than I would trust a reference letter from a perspective employee that they supplied.  

If they are worried about the $35, you can tell them if everything looks good and they sign the 1 year lease, you will apply a $35 discount to their rent at the end of the year.

See this reply in the discussion

59 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 546 posts · 227 votes
    6y

    Hi Gayle, this is a great question and in many circumstances, self-supplied applications can be of some concern (ie. just like other self-reported recommendation letters, it may not always provide thorough enough insight into the applicant; however, some platforms (built with independent DIY rental owners in mind) make it possible for tenants/prospective renters to complete online applications and then share those applications with other landlords if, say for instance, they didn't get the first rental that they applied for — in fact, depending on the tool they use it can be a great way to only need to pull their credit once (which would include current credit score and a breakdown of their credit history, nationwide background check, and eviction history) if they have multiple applications circulation, which is not all that uncommon. Again it is always of best practice to make your own decision based on whether or not the applicant has met your screening criteria. @Gayle Eisner

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Chad Hale:

    @Gayle Eisner  What everyone else has already said.  I tell an applicant they are welcome to submit their report as part of their application but I will be running my own.

    One objection I hear is that the report is a "hard" hit on their credit.  You should verify what your reporting agency is doing.  The reports I use are a "soft" hit, IE it doesn't ding their credit.  When receiving push back, I simply say sorry this is company policy.

    On my last house I rented I had an applicant offer a previous report pulled and I let her know that I would accept it under the understanding that if she was accepted we would have to follow up with mine so that everyone is on the same page.  She admitted her credit wasn't good so I didn't think there was any reason to have her and her boyfriend spend $60 when there was a slim chance they would be selected.  I have also used Zillow Rental Manager since it is a soft hit and they can use it for 30 days if the other landlord accepts applications through Zillow. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    What I do is only run credit etc once I know the applicant is serious and I believe will pass my screening

    i do not charge application fees  i consider it a part of my job and a cost of doing business  

    i will say that what I have started doing is using a website to have the applicant pay for the credit report and the report generated comes to me  - applicants appreciate this as I am not making money off their screening. 

    There are several websites that do this (equifax, etc) 


    also fwiw, i have been looking at many different MF buildings lately and all of them have a revenue line that is "screening" so it IS part of the revenue stream, altho many places are legislating against this practice. 



  • Rental Property Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2019 · 34 posts · 19 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner

    I’m probably not nearly as experienced as others on here, but here’s my screening.

    1. Interested applicant fills out a pre-screening questionnaire (I made this and asks for work and previous landlord references). If they don’t pass me calling their references and checking the info, then I tell them sorry. If they pass this, then on to step 2. I wait 1-2 weeks to select the top 5 for step 2. No fee.

    2. We schedule a walk through so I can meet the individual, show them the place, and get to know them. I see how they dress, how clean their car is, etc... At this point I select my top 3, and I tell them where they stand and their chance of getting the place. No fee.

    3. I tell the top applicant the place is theirs if they pass the credit check and background check. I have them pay the fee upfront. I also tell them it is non-refundable if they don’t pass, so they need to disclose what I should expect to see so that I can tell them prior to spending money if they are wasting their time and money. If the reports come back good, then I refund them the fee on the first month’s rent (reduce the first month equal to the cost of the background and credit check). I don’t have the backup applicants pay for any checks until they become the top applicant.

    I do this because as an individual that has rented previously, I understand how frustrating the process is, and I want to make it better for the tenant. It also builds a trust between us as landlord and tenant that I’m not just looking for money, but I want a good tenant and will provide them a quality place to live with good service. Additionally, it helps me compete against the big complexes and “professionals” that charge a ton of fees prior to ever moving in. I also get a better pool of candidates.

    You might think I get too many, but that’s not typically the case because as soon as I email them the pre-screening questionnaire, probably 80-90% never fill it out and return it. So that narrows it down pretty quick.

    I hope some of this helps, good luck!

  • Property Manager · Seattle, WA · Member since 2019 · 7 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    I run a property management company in Seattle; I get this question once in a while. I heard so many horror stories from my clients because they skipped the background check or accepted credit report provided to them by the tenant. Offer to refund the $35 applicant fees if it is allowed legally.

  • New to Real Estate · Garden Grove, CA · Member since 2020 · 64 posts · 56 votes
    6y

    This is a very good discussion with different perspectives. It seems like the best solution in my opinion is to use a company that runs the report without putting a hard hit on a person's report. To some people, the hard-hit is more the issue than the actual $35 fee.

    I don't have my own property yet, but this thread provided a good mashup of different methods I can use when the time comes. But me personally, I don't think I would charge an application fee. But who knows, that might change once I realized what it's like to actually be a landlord.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    We have a tenant profile that prospective tenant reviews before they have an opportunity to see the property. If they see the property, then I'll accept an application (no view, no app, sorry)

    When I get an application, I review it and do some googling and social media investigation and if everything seems ok, THEN I submit them for the background/credit check. THEY pay the fee online and give authorization for the credit pull (soft pull). If they're multiple applicants, everybody gets checked but I do one at a time so I can pull the plug and save the others some money.

    There's a lot of info in the background check besides the credit report.

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Kyle Benham I would never fill out a “pre screening” form for a property I have not seen..... far too many reasons to NOT do this - topmost being privacy and scammers.

  • Real Estate Investor · Glenwood, IL · Member since 2015 · 84 posts · 22 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner I wouldnt trust it. Too much falsification of documentation goes on. If they lose interest over $35, they either cant afford to live there or werent interested enough anyways.

  • Rental Property Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    Sadly, you can't trust anyone.  DEFINITELY run your own. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Westboro, MA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 471 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner

    I would still run my own.. Tenant paid credit/background check 

  • Investor · White Haven PA · Member since 2014 · 363 posts · 221 votes
    6y

    I have my prospective tenants pull their own credit reports through Credit Karma and send me a copy.. (it's free and doesn't count as a hard pull if they pull it themselves) and I tell them if they are accepted I'll pull their credit myself and verify their scores, but only if their application is accepted.  That way they know their credit is only being pulled if they "Got" the rental.

  • Real Estate Coach · Salt Lake City, UT · Member since 2017 · 273 posts · 414 votes
    6y

    Few thoughts, and admittedly, at different points in my life, I'd have given very different answers.

    I don't necessarily think it's a red flag.  I'd call it a yellow flag.  Here's why...  I'm military and have moved every 1-3 years for at least the past 20 years, so am frequently looking for new places to live.  When I was younger and my budget was tighter, I would have asked the same question.  My 24 year-old self living in 2020 would have logged on to any of the free credit report websites, printed out a report, and tried to save $35.  Alternatively, I remember moving from Japan to San Diego in 2006 with two kids - the rental market was so tight that PMs had many qualified applications to choose from on each house, so I had to write several $35 checks hoping they wouldn't all get processed and cashed at the same time...  It made me nervous and I asked every time if there was a way around the fee...  My credit at the time was 700+ (my wife's was higher). So, is it automatically a sign of someone with bad credit?  Not necessarily.  Could be that #1 Moving is expensive and all the fees add up.  2. Maybe it's someone who just grew up in a family where $35 was a big expense.  

    Question: is their credit report verifiable? Can you call Experian, Transunion, etc. with their report number and verify its accuracy?

    If I were still a "real estate hobbyist" (as my partner calls it) running small SF portfolio, I might show sympathy for the individual and at least look at their overall application package including income verification (but I would still call the credit reporting agency to verify accuracy).

    Now that I'm running a multifamily business with a millions of investor dollars at risk (and if you treat your portfolio like a business), I stick to pre-established processes. 

    **Note - I'm not calling people with small portfolios hobbyists...  I'm saying I treated my small SF portfolio like a hobby.

  • Rental Property Investor · Tyler, TX · Member since 2019 · 72 posts · 39 votes
    6y

    If they're unwilling to get a credit report by a third party then that's a red flag. 

  • Dave PoeppelmeierBusiness Member
    Realtor · Maumee, OH · Member since 2015 · 491 posts · 722 votes
    6y

    I put the ball in their court. The only "application fee" I charge is them going to tenantbackgroundsearch.com and paying for the pre-approved background check I select (they get an email link). I wouldn't trust them supplying their own, people have gotten pretty good at photoshop and whatnot. If they can't or won't afford a $30 background check, do you trust them to make your rent? I wouldn't. 

    Keller Williams Citywide | Dave Poeppelmeier535 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, NC · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Natalie Schanne:

    @Gayle Eisner - I’ve provided my own credit report to many places I’ve rented. But they can also google I went to a prestigious university and my income (job offer letter) was at least 5x the rent.

    Yes, anyone that attends a prestigious university is beyond reproach and should be exempt to the requirements of the common folk. 

  • Investor · Bayside, NY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Alvin Sylvain:
    Originally posted by @Frank Chin:
    Originally posted by @Alvin Sylvain:

    As it so happens, vetting an applicant is work, and somebody has to do it. That somebody is probably going to be none too happy about providing that service without some sort of payment.

    If you have to provide certain "free" services in order to be competitive in your market, then so be it. That doesn't mean it's a "ripoff".

    I talking about landlords that collect application fees, where the applicant in no way qualifies, but pays the fee just to be considered. What work? Put the application in the junk pile?

    ...

    A man seeing 15 - 20 places, pays $20 each for application fees, not totally fluent in English, not considered for any of them, if he doesn't feel ripped off, maybe we can invent another word to express it. It certainly is not the word "happy".


    I agree that collecting a fee for an applicant you already know doesn't qualify isn't fair. However, I can also see how it may be a legal requirement in some jurisdictions. Not accepting each and every application tendered, regardless of obvious qualification issues, carries the risk of being accused of illegal discrimination.

    The person who applies to 20 different places possibly is not doing his own due diligence, and is unknowingly applying to places where he clearly doesn't qualify. There's no way I can know, but I've never as a renter needed to apply to more than three places, and never as a landlord been told by an applicant that I was his 21st attempt.

    The person involved speaks limited English, looks kind of grumpy, so being a landlord myself, knowing each vacancy will attracted half a dozen qualified applicants, I do understand why he wasn't picked in all the places he looked at. He came to our agency seeking help somewhere along the line, we made calls for him, helped him with on-line applications. Those of us who looks and appear normal, speaks good English, can joke around little realize there are some people with no friends or nearby family members that can help would have such difficulty.

    The first thing I advised him was not all rentals charge application and credit report fees, and avoid those that do. Or hire an agent, at the rate he's going, pay the agent's normal one month's finder's fee, and let the agent handle things. I've seen agents pull credit reports for their clients to show landlords and prove they offer up qualified people.

    And the other thing is, I myself avoid renters that don't speak English. I was looking at a 4-plex to purchase, with renters in place, and the owner had to use one of the tenants at half rent to act as PM because it's a Spanish speaking area, and all the tenants speak Spanish, and the owner doesn't, and has no plans to take Spanish courses. Neither do I, so I didn't consider that property for that reason also.

    So it's not a matter of due diligence on his part. A friend of mine came from China to attend college, looked for a waiter's job in New York City to supplement his income, those that speak better English than him always got picked first. Nothing says that Chinese restaurants has to hire Chinese waiters but in the NYC vicinity, they always do. Being NYC born and raised, I did find it strange when I vacation, I see Caucasian or black waiters in Chinese restaurants in rural areas. Finally a job agency said a Chinese restaurant in Jersey City had trouble finding Chinese waiters as it's a pain to get to, and would consider him. So I see non English speaking renters looking for apartments face the same issues.  

  • Real Estate Agent · Princeton, NJ · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Terrell Garren - no need to be snarky. I’m just saying I successfully downloaded my free credit karma and people used that report and rented me a place without checking my background or taking my social security number. I don’t know all the factors that made them decide that. I don’t know if going to a school that costs $70k/yr makes private individuals believe you can afford a $12k/year rent or that you will seek out enough job opportunities to successfully pay that rent. I have no idea. I just know it happened and it went fine.

    I declined to apply several places where it seemed like I was one of many and they were collecting excessive application fees from as many people as possible.

    Almost all my credit card companies include free credit score tracking and reports at this point.

    I have also rented to people, especially summer interns in a shared house as roommates, without taking all their information and in the past ten years it’s been fine.

    As an agent, I’m often touring other agent’s listings. I prepare a qualification package with their IDs, paystubs, credit and background check, etc. I run a tenant’s credit once on NTN or SmartMove and use that same application for many places within a 60 day period (until they’re accepted) vs having them pay $35-50 per adult PER house. Not every house that’s listed will be available for the renters because other qualified people will also apply. This is one of the main reasons imo to work with an agent as a renter, especially if you’re in a heavily competitive rental market. Otherwise you can easily be $300+ in fees and 3 hard credit pulls before getting a place. I

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 124 posts · 38 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner

    As a rule run your credit report. You can take theirs and compare, but you don’t prospect run your business. If they sweat about 35$-40$ pass on them.

  • Member since 2018 · 1 post · 0 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner my personal experience, I told my landlord that I prefer avoiding a credit inquiry. That I would my the credit report fee and he could direct to a site of his preference so I can pull my credit.

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 124 posts · 38 votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner it’s not a hard hit on the credit. They probably don t want you to see issues.

  • Contractor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2015 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Natalie Schanne I like it, i do hate the fact that it will show up on credit report as hard inq. My credit score is spotless with 0 late payments and 1-2 hard inquiries, if I apply for a rental and they’re all hard inq, i will not be happy. Some

    say they’re doing a soft inquiry, not true in some cases, makes you question why.

  • Member since 2020 · 24 posts · 16 votes
    6y

    I have allowed my tenants to pull their own report as long as it is recent (within 7 days). But for the most part like someone mentioned, you can use Experian or some other services that allows them to pull their own report but it is not a hard hit since they pull it and you get a copy.  Also, I agree that $35 is a bit high. It is not about affordability, but if they apply at 1-2 other places that's $100 and 3 hits on their credit that could be avoided. Plus after the 3 months if they apply again somewhere, this will again be a hard hit. Any savvy person that worries about their credit score will be concerned.  

    I think Experian is $15 or so that they pay themselves and you get a copy of the report. You have to set it up yourself and enter their email address at which point they get a notification to enter their personal info. It is less than the $35 and is not a hard hit, so certainly they would be more prone to do it. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2019 · 448 posts · 320 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Gayle Eisner:

    In the last month or so I’ve received tenant applicants that would like  to supply their own credit reports? I have always ran their credit report and charged them. I use my own company that I work with. I hate to lose a good applicant because of this, but I’ve also had tenants lose interest when I asked them to supply me with the $35 to run the report.Has anyone had experience with this? Maybe since times are a bit tougher, I can tell them if I accept them as tenants that I will waive the $35 report? Thanks kindly

     Make sure you honor the local laws concerning deposits, credit checks etc.  Different states have different rules regarding those.  But assuming it's legal, offering to reimburse or credit upon approval the $35 seems reasonable.  

  • Rental Property Investor · Ankeny, IA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Gayle Eisner

    Lol. No.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.