Tax, Self-Directed IRAs and Cost Segregation Forum

Cost seg on a seller-financed purchase — does the financing change the study?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg on a seller-financed purchase — does the financing change the study?

Looking at a small multifamily where the seller is carrying the note — 30-year amortization, below-market rate, 10% down. Price is a bit above what I'd pay with bank debt, which makes sense given the terms. My question for the cost seg folks: does seller financing change anything about the study ...

Cost seg before or after a major renovation — which order saves more?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg before or after a major renovation — which order saves more?

Say you buy a rental and plan a major renovation in the first year — new kitchen, baths, flooring, maybe HVAC. Do you do the cost seg study before the renovation, after it, or both? Before, you capture the old components while they are still there, and you can write off what gets demolished. Afte...

Year-one depreciation as a % of invested capital: what are you seeing?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Boise, Idaho
Year-one depreciation as a % of invested capital: what are you seeing?

We just got an engineered cost seg study back on a 45-unit we bought this year (1960s to 2000 vintage, about 75% loan to value). With bonus depreciation, the year-one deduction came to about 89% of invested capital. For those who've run studies on multifamily since bonus came back: - What did yea...

Poll
Filed a Prop 8 on my DTLA condo — anyone actually get a reduction in LA County?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Los Angeles, California
Filed a Prop 8 on my DTLA condo — anyone actually get a reduction in LA County?

Hi all, new here. I have a condo in downtown LA that I bought in 2021 for $615K. It sat on the market as low as $430K and still didn't sell, so it's rented out now. Meanwhile the county has it assessed at $679,005 — I'm paying $8,261 a year in property tax on a place the market clearly values way...

Rental back to primary residence — what happens to the cost seg depreciation?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Rental back to primary residence — what happens to the cost seg depreciation?

I keep seeing the primary-to-rental direction discussed, but the reverse trip comes up too: an investor moves back into a former rental, lives there a couple of years, then sells and expects the §121 exclusion to shelter the whole gain. The piece that surprises people is that the exclusion doesn'...

No invoices, no plans — can a cost segregation study still work on an older property?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
No invoices, no plans — can a cost segregation study still work on an older property?

I keep running into the same situation with older rentals: bought years ago, no original invoices, no blueprints, seller long gone. The owner wants a cost segregation study, but there's almost no paper trail — just the closing statement and county records. Can a study still be done properly on a ...

reverse 1031-buyer wants to increase purchase price to include CLOSING COSTS-TAX BOOT
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
reverse 1031-buyer wants to increase purchase price to include CLOSING COSTS-TAX BOOT

I am doing a reverse 1031. Selling my CT property. The agreed-upon purchase price is $612,500. However, the buyer is requesting that we increase the purchase price to $627,500, with a $15,000 seller credit toward his closing costs. Essentially, my net proceeds would remain the same. I’ve already ...

Selling a rental: how early do you start planning?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Selling a rental: how early do you start planning?

One of my tax advisory clients recently called after selling a rental property. Things moved pretty quickly, and now she's wondering what options she still has to defer the capital gain. It got me thinking about how often tax planning comes into the picture after the big decisions have already be...

Can one short-term rental really create $400K in tax benefits?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Miami, Florida
Can one short-term rental really create $400K in tax benefits?

I want to share something that doesn't get talked about enough, because when I first heard it I didn't believe it either. For certain short-term rental properties, if the average guest stay is 7 days or less and you materially participate in the activity (for example, meeting the IRS participatio...

Cost seg on a property bought with a tenant already in place — does the lease change
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg on a property bought with a tenant already in place — does the lease change

Say you buy a rental with a tenant already in place — lease has months left to run, rent is below market. The property is rented from day one, so placed-in-service timing is straightforward. But does the in-place lease change the cost seg study itself? My read is that the study is about the physi...

They owned the property for two days and deducted $702,000
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
They owned the property for two days and deducted $702,000

A group of investors bought a ~$4.5M residential rental and placed it in service December 30, 2025. Here's how they got there: • Land: ~$2.44M of the purchase price was land, which isn't depreciable. That left ~$2.08M to depreciate. • Cost segregation: a study reclassified ~$385K into 5-year prop...

Cost seg on a house-hack — how do you handle the unit you live in?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg on a house-hack — how do you handle the unit you live in?

For a house-hacked duplex, how does a cost seg study treat the unit the owner lives in? My read is that only the rented unit's share gets depreciated, so the study would only cover that portion, and the personal-use half stays out. Shared stuff gets murkier: the roof, the driveway, a furnace serv...

CASE STUDIES part 1: expected vs actual savings from cost segregation
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
CASE STUDIES part 1: expected vs actual savings from cost segregation

Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word. Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” I wrote an entire post about this disconnect between two groups of tax professionals who both are trying hard to help you. Here I present to you a few case studies t...

Cost seg on an STR that fails the 7-day average-stay test — does it still help?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg on an STR that fails the 7-day average-stay test — does it still help?

Question I've been chewing on, curious how others here think about it. A short-term rental only escapes rental-activity treatment if the average customer stay is 7 days or less. If your average stay creeps over 7 days, say longer winter bookings, the property is a rental activity again. There is ...

100% bonus depreciation is back, but not for your 2023 or 2024 rental
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
100% bonus depreciation is back, but not for your 2023 or 2024 rental

Quick heads-up for anyone who bought a rental in 2023 or 2024 and is now thinking about a cost seg because 100% bonus is back. The 100% rate applies to property acquired after January 19, 2025. The bonus percentage is set by the year the property went into service, not the year you do the study. ...

Moving appreciated real estate out of an S corp without a major tax hit?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Moving appreciated real estate out of an S corp without a major tax hit?

Our family owns a commercial rental property through an LLC taxed as an S corporation with a QSub subsidiary. The original corporation elected S status in 1995; the parent/QSub structure was established in 2022. The property came through a 1031 exchange and has substantial appreciation, low remai...

Cost seg on a 1031 exchange: how does the exchanged basis change the study?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Cost seg on a 1031 exchange: how does the exchanged basis change the study?

For anyone who's done a cost seg on a property bought through a 1031 exchange: the depreciable basis carries over from the relinquished property, so the study is working off a lower number than the new purchase price. In practice, does that change how the study pencils out for you, or does the re...

How is land actually split out in a cost segregation study?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
How is land actually split out in a cost segregation study?

Every cost seg starts by carving land out of the purchase price, since land can't be depreciated. What I've seen in practice is three ways firms do the split: the tax assessor's land/building ratio, an appraisal, or an engineering estimate built into the study itself. The split matters because ev...

Has anyone stacked §179D with a cost seg on the same commercial building?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Has anyone stacked §179D with a cost seg on the same commercial building?

I work on cost seg studies, so I see the cost seg side of this daily. What I don't see often is section 179D on the same building. The two are separate deductions: 179D is for energy-efficient commercial building property, up to $5.81 per sq ft for property placed in service in 2025, with prevail...

CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
CASE STUDIES part 2: cost segregation saves you money with rate arbitrage

Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word. Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” I wrote an entire post about this disconnect between two groups of tax professionals who both are trying hard to help you. Here I present to you a few case studies t...

What hours do CPAs usually throw out when reviewing REPS or STR logs?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
What hours do CPAs usually throw out when reviewing REPS or STR logs?

I know things like listening to real estate podcasts or scrolling Zillow don't count toward REPS or the 100-hour STR rule. For those of you who have gone through a CPA review or an audit, what are the grey-area tasks that your CPA told you to remove from your time log? Trying to make sure people ...

Logging spouse hours separately for REPS vs STR material participation
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Logging spouse hours separately for REPS vs STR material participation

For married couples tracking hours together, how do you keep your logs organized between both spouses? Since spouse hours can be combined for the material participation tests, but one spouse still has to hit the 750-hour and 50% REPS threshold on their own, keeping everything mixed in one shared ...

What does a cost segregation report actually contain — and what should you check befo
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
What does a cost segregation report actually contain — and what should you check befo

I do cost segregation work every day, and the reports I see vary a lot. A real report should have a few things in it, and if any of them are missing, that is worth a second look before you pay. An asset schedule that breaks the building into 5, 7, 15, 27.5, and 39-year property, line by line, wit...

Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Occasional spats between CPAs and cost segregators boil down to one word

What word, you ask? Cost segregators say “always” where CPAs say “sometimes.” And I finally found a good analogy. When you see CPAs debating cost segregators (CS), think of a conversation between drivers (D) and freeway builders (FB). It goes like this: FB: freeways are an amazing way to travel f...

Cost Segregation Experiences?
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation
Columbus, Ohio
Cost Segregation Experiences?

I purchased a four unit building last year for $350K and replaced the roof. I'm looking to get a cost segregation done and I got several quotes from Cost Seg Guys, Seneca, etc. Seneca was estimating a reduction in my taxable income by $75-95k. CSSI was estimating a reduction of $40-60K which is a...