An applicant asks if I discriminate against "ex ex felons"

An applicant asks if I discriminate against "ex ex felons"

Rental Property Investor · South Padre Island, TX · Member since 2018 · 160 posts · 157 votes

An applicant contacted me on marketplace and asked me "So use discrimate against ex ex felons". They asked to come see the place and I said, as long as you meet the requirements we can move forward. They then proceeded to ask me that. The initial requirements are a favorable credit score, income 3 x the rent, and the last two check stubs. I replied that the application would be reviewed fairly and accordingly. It did catch me off guard. I had never been asked that before.

9Reply
283 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe SplitrockPro Member
Moderator
Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
6y

@Deisy P.

My answer would be, "No I don't discriminate against felons, but we do use criminal history in our screening process."

I would get details on the offense(s). Be prepared for a lengthy explanation that downplays the crime. "It was murder, but..." You are not the judge and jury, so accept the crime at face value. You may be able to save him from applying if it is just going to be a rejection. In most states it is perfectly legal to discriminate against felons, just like you can discriminate against someone with bad credit. Automatically when you use the word discriminate, it makes it sound wrong. Keep in mind there is a difference when you are discriminating against people because of choices they made, versus things out of their control (race, sex, etc.)

That being said, some people get overcharged, falsely accused and some simply make mistakes. I think it is wrong to define someone forever based on a single action. As a landlord it is not about punishing them for their past, but avoiding risk for yourself by placing a tenant who could cause trouble. If the tenant lands back in jail or loses their job, they can't pay rent. If they are a drug dealer or committing crimes on the property, it could risk the safety of other tenants or security of the property. 

Use these criteria to evaluate:

1. Look at the crime and severity. Non violent different than violent crimes or sex crimes.

2. Look at when it happened. Getting out of jail last week is different than 20 years ago.

3. Look at the pattern. Is it a one time thing or does the person keep committing crimes.

The fact that he has a decent job and credit score does show a good level of responsibility. I would put a little effort into vetting him. Some landlords have a hard line on "no felons" or "no violent felons or convicted sex offenders". Whatever policy you choose is your choice. Just be upfront with applicants. If you are going to deny them, do it fast so they can move on and find someone who will rent to them.

See this reply in the discussion

65 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Barstow, CA · Member since 2015 · 131 posts · 102 votes
    6y

    Hi Deisy, is an aggressive question sounds like the kind of person that gets up every morning hoping to be offended, but that’s just my opinion. In Ca my criteria includes no felonies the last 7 years. Hope this helps. Good luck to you.

  • Rental Property Investor · South Padre Island, TX · Member since 2018 · 160 posts · 157 votes
    6y

    Thank you, all. They ended up just replying "i'm good. thanks." I'm going to just leave it at that but now I know what to say for next time. Thanks for taking the time to provide feedback. It was all so helpful.

  • Rental Property Investor · St. Louis · Member since 2018 · 43 posts · 24 votes
    6y

    My criteria list includes "No violent felonies."

  • Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Deisy P.

    I’m no Scientologist but... isn’t an ex- ex felon a current felon? I’ll defer to my second grade teacher on this maybe.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Steve K.:

    If I'm not mistaken, a felon is someone who has committed a felony. The correct term for a felon who has served their time is still felon (or ex-convict/ex-con). 

    Sometimes I forget that there are people outside of California who have not yet been enlightened by our superior Woke ways. After they have served their time, they should be referred to as a “formerly incarcerated person,” or a “justice-involved person", or a “returning resident”. We used to use "returning citizen", but that was discriminatory against those here illegally without proper documentation. 🤮🤮🤮

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Deisy P.

    I’m no Scientologist but... isn’t an ex- ex felon a current felon? I’ll defer to my second grade teacher on this maybe.

     If you say ex ex that is a double negative, which is a positive. They probably meant ex-felon. Technically an ex-felon is not a felon, just like an ex wife is no longer your wife. The problem is felon is generally a life time label, unless you can get it expunged or your records sealed. The conviction still happened, but the records may not show it. You could still argue the person is a felon, but the legal label has been removed which allows them certain rights such as voting and owning guns. If the person is referring to no longer being in prison, that would be an ex-convict.

  • Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2014 · 133 posts · 29 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Deisy P.:

    An applicant contacted me on marketplace and asked me "So use discrimate against ex ex felons". They asked to come see the place and I said, as long as you meet the requirements we can move forward. They then proceeded to ask me that. The initial requirements are a favorable credit score, income 3 x the rent, and the last two check stubs. I replied that the application would be reviewed fairly and accordingly. It did catch me off guard. I had never been asked that before.

     @Joe Splitrock provides sage advice! That's the moral and legal process (note: moral prior to legal since not all legal is moral)

  • Specialist · Newark, NJ · Member since 2017 · 80 posts · 66 votes
    6y

    @Jesse M.

    Maybe he has just been turned down so much that he doesnt want to waste his time.

    I would ask too, maybe in a different way, but yea... honestly it’s the landlords job to make sure to ask something like that. The fact that he’s bring it up first shows good character to me.

  • Lender · Denver, CO · Member since 2010 · 36 posts · 18 votes
    6y

    I would like to add one thing to this thread as, aside from being a real estate investor, I work in prison with felons (violent, non-violent, etc.) and I also work for our state innocence project.  I consider @Joe Splitrock 's advice all good except I wouldn't eliminate an applicant if they just got out of prison.  Rather, I would ask them for a resume for what programs they've completed in prison.  If they have, in fact, completed any programs, ask for references from the group offering the program.  Many of these men and women have used their incarcerated time to turn their lives around.  

  • Specialist · Newark, NJ · Member since 2017 · 80 posts · 66 votes
    6y

    @Deisy P.

    So many dog whistles in this thread, especially in the comments. Lol let’s do better.

    We really shouldn’t just turn people away just because they were once criminals, or have made bad decisions in the past. People change. The threshold for a fellony is so low, that having a felony doesn’t necessarily make u a bad renter.

  • Rental Property Investor · South Padre Island, TX · Member since 2018 · 160 posts · 157 votes
    6y

    @Maimouna Sow Thank you for your feedback. Agreed.

  • Rental Property Investor · South Padre Island, TX · Member since 2018 · 160 posts · 157 votes
    6y

    @Danielle D. Thank you for this point of view. I'm grateful for the engagement this discussion has had. I'm still learning.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Danielle D.:

    I consider @Joe Splitrock 's advice all good except I wouldn't eliminate an applicant if they just got out of prison.  Rather, I would ask them for a resume for what programs they've completed in prison.  If they have, in fact, completed any programs, ask for references from the group offering the program.  Many of these men and women have used their incarcerated time to turn their lives around.  

    Statistics range from 45% to 77% of those released from prison will end up back in prison within 5 years. Add to that the ones that continue to commit crimes, but don't get caught. It's awesome that they received a merit badge in pottery making while in prison, but it's foolish to risk your investment on fanciful trust that they are part of the small percentage of people who turned their life around while incarcerated. No track record of change, no rental.

  • Rental Property Investor · Central Kentucky · Member since 2019 · 67 posts · 43 votes
    6y

    Felons.......hmm.... I think, if allowed by law, changing your criteria to "contingent upon satisfactory credit and criminal background checks" might be in order. I'm picturing every neighbor I've ever had in my life right now and what their response would be if I told them I was renting my property out to a felon... "Oh yeah Bob, new guy movin in next week.......convicted on 10 counts of armed robbery and assault..... twice. You cool with that?? By the way, hows the youngest liking kindergarten?" 

    Obviously you have to go by the letter of the law here so as to not set yourself up for a legal issue, and be reasonable (as in was it last year or 30yrs ago?), but that sort of thing seems sketchy to me at best.

  • Real Estate Appraiser · Isabella lake, CA · Member since 2018 · 628 posts · 491 votes
    6y

    I wonder if be ex ex felon they meant it was a long time ago.

    The only person I know with past felonies is,

    a landlord these days. LOL.

  • Rental Property Investor · Victor, ID · Member since 2017 · 51 posts · 31 votes
    6y

    @Deisy P.

    I agree with what a few other people have mentioned. Define your criteria for the property!

    For a cheaper property I want their income to be minimum 3X the rent. For an A Class property I want at least 3X rent for income but I also want a minimum credit score of 620. I do background checks and credit checks and if a person is in a good place now and has been showing consistency and responsibility I take that into account.

    It makes me a little uncomfortable to ask, but I’ve asked for more information about the circumstances surrounding whatever happened and sometimes that can set you at ease too. Some people act irresponsible when there’s a death in the family, divorce, etc.

  • NJ, NJ · Member since 2014 · 63 posts · 88 votes
    6y

    This thread baffles me...i guess some of you havent had bad tenants that have dragged you through hell and back.  Ah well...if your best applicant is a felon good luck to you.  Especially to those house hacking....definitely want to avoid dog whistles so why dont you just skip the background check and choose the first applicant to invite into your property without any criteria since that would be most fair.  

  • Rental Property Investor · Central Kentucky · Member since 2019 · 67 posts · 43 votes
    6y

    @Jesse M.

    Sing it! I had tenants whose parents were “assisting” them with their rent and they just could never make ends meet. But obviously there’s more. It’s believed that he beat her (as proven by the destroyed door to the master bedroom) and that he was selling drugs on the side (tons of odd traffic). I had to have the PD start doing regular drive buys to check them out. By the time they left that house there was many thousands in damage and I thanked God the day a couple who wanted to paint everything and fix my chimney moved in.👍

  • NJ, NJ · Member since 2014 · 63 posts · 88 votes
    6y

    I hear ya Chris and feel your pain.  Im still hanging on to a judgement for one tenant that i will never see a dime from.

    Anyway im just frustrated at the situation landlords are in...my comment was a bit tongue in cheek since some states are forcing exactly that "first come first served" kind of thing and especially in the current environment i feel like a victim of a social movement that hates landlords and property owners....its just frustrating and hard not to go super protective mode on ones hard work and investments

  • Rental Property Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 83 posts · 46 votes
    6y

    @Deisy P.

    What does ex ex mean? Does that mean he is 2x an ex felon? I mean apparently he didn't learn from the first one.. I would be cautious. If he gets another one you will be without a tenant.

  • Professional · Parsippany, NJ · Member since 2013 · 384 posts · 262 votes
    6y

    If it is a weed charge tell him its all good. Any Violent crime robbery, rape, murder he can sleep on the street go back to jail or commit suicide 

  • Investor · Singapore · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    My PM screens them out, I think. But I do have one tenant that after he moved in went to jail for a bit. But he kept current on the rent and is still living there now. He is the best tenant I have. He doesn't move (probably cause most don't rent to felons), always pays on time and has minimal maintenance calls. So its not always a bad thing.

  • Specialist · Newark, NJ · Member since 2017 · 80 posts · 66 votes
    6y

    @Chris Thomas

    It’s funny because being denied where to live, and employment is a part of the reason why ex felons and convicts go back to prison.

  • Specialist · Newark, NJ · Member since 2017 · 80 posts · 66 votes
    6y

    @Jesse M. 😂😂😂 just because you consider felons doesn’t mean you let felons in no matter matter what. Like another lady said, some might have spent the time there turning life around. And didn’t sound like she was house-hacking, was she?

    If it’s a rental, where u don’t live there, and the ex-felon wasn’t violent, and maybe he has a family....and he had gone to school, and had even picked a trade of some sort, u will still not pick him because of some theories about the kind of person he was or the kind of person he could become again instead of the person he is NOW?

    And what exactly do you mean about not wanting to dog whistle?

  • Rental Property Investor · Central Kentucky · Member since 2019 · 67 posts · 43 votes
    6y

    @Maimouna Sow

    That’s a sad but true story. The question is does it become the investors social responsibility to help folks out or is it something best left for govt, which it consistently fails at?

    Obviously, it’s not the investors “job” to take on this roll as, after all, the reason you’re an investor is to make money not be a social worker. Sounds cruel and greedy, but it’s true. There’s a fine line here. Do you only exclude violent offenders or do you also exclude the white collar criminal who was found guilty of embezzlement and might try to sue his way into owning your house at some point?

    This is all why I said earlier, follow the law in your area, but this mess can get real sketchy. At the end of the day it’s the Wild West and the ones you really have to look out for are you and yours.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.