Hello,
Can anyone please give this first-time landlady some advice on this issue?
I bought a turnkey from Roofstock last summer. It is out of state and I have a PM to take care of it. It's supposed to cashflow about $100/mo. But there have been a lot of fixings and left me with negative cashflow. The major fix was on the gas line, one on tub drain, and a couple minor fixes like clogged pipe.
What should I do with this property? Should I keep it and hope it would cashflow this year or plan to sell it? What would be the worst thing that could happen if I keep having negative cashflow year after year? This situation makes me nervous about rental investment now. :(
Ok. The worst thing that would happen is you would keep negative cash flowing...which adds up, and subtracts. Think of it as having a job, that you pay the employer for the privilege to work there. So you say you can cover it with your current job. Fine, then let me reword what I just said.
It's like working full time, and making enough money so you can work a 2nd job...and pay that employer for the privilege of working there. If that was the case, what should you do? Probably quit the 2nd job...right? So I ask you this, using that same thought process, what should you do with this rental?
Now, onto the property specifics. I wouldn't buy any property that only has $100/month CF...and you're seeing why now. That's not positive CF...that's negative CF, guaranteed to happen.
Any money you lost so far though negative CF is gone, and you'll never get it back, as long as this job property has negative CF. If it starts to get positive CF, then in order to start making a profit, the first thing that has to happen is get all the negative CF back...from the new positive CF. How long will that take? How long and how far behind are you?
Don't fall in love with any property. The property is just the temporary resting place for your cash/equity until said time it grows enough for you move it forward into exponential gains. The longer you retain a negative CF property, the more negative CF you have to recover, the less money you have left to recover it with, and the longer it takes to actually recover it. Cut your losses, stop moving backwards, and move forward.
Thank you very much for your advice. I've jotted down all of them.
It is listed as a turnkey. I will check with Roofstock if they have a warranty on it. Having a 3rd party PM to look at it is also a good idea. I will do that too.
It may be too late to get help on those repairs, but it'd a) be good to know the options and b) I recommend ALWAYS going directly to the provider of a turnkey property if things start to happen... you never know when they may be more than willing to help. I try to tell people to not just go with it all and not tell anyone! No one can help if you don't say anything.
Thant's really true. Thank you. I'm glad I posted it here. I've learned and got a lot of support from this community. =)
My basic advice: Avoid (My mantra is never) buy a property that is away rom your residence and depend upon expensive property management companies or Hotel programs to generate cash flows. I see a lot in my area and the owners dumping the homes (Especially condos) back after realizing they are losing $ big time
Thank you. I'll have to be more careful when I look for the next properties.
Most people dump a few hundred dollars a month into a savings account without thinking twice. If you're losing a few hundred dollars a month I don't think that's a big deal. Think of that property as a savings account. Except that the mortgage balance is getting paid down ($), you get great tax write offs ($$), and if you bought a decent property then the rent will increase ($$$) and the value will go up over time ($$$$).
If it was me, I'd keep it and move on to the next deal. You can always reposition it later (refinance, re-rent etc....).
I bought a deal that was a negative cash flow from day 1 because of my financing (13% interest rate), and I knew it was under valued but that the market hadn't caught up to it yet. I purchased it for 90k and based on the current available comps the appraiser also said it was worth 90k. But I knew it was worth at least 120k, but there were no comps to support it. So I bought it anyways and lost about $300/m. I have a great tenant pool in that area FYI (very important). 15 months later it appraised for 125k and I refinanced into a small positive cashflow but a huge equity position.
Not all negative cash flow deals are bad.
If you are not satisfied with your purchase, contact Roofstock within 30 days of closing and they will start the refund process.
Yeah, it's been about 10 months. But thank you anyway.
@Supada L. Was the repair made a surprise or something you knew coming in and thought it could be delayed? Also if you bought it last summer means you haven’t even owned it a year. Had I given up on my first rental property I would have sold it in 6 months too because
I was $3K in the hole because of a bad tenant situation. Now I own 3 properties (closing on 2
More in a month) and have $10K in extra cash flow and it’s adding up in a good way. If you can not afford or foresee crazy expenses that you should have known about in your due diligence by all means get out quickly.
However if you believe in your due diligence and think you can withstand this initial (and unfortunate) hit then I would hold my ground and let it play out a bit longer. All depends on where you’re at not all of us “experts” tell you here.
Happy to talk on the side to take a look at your numbers too.
Just my 2c.
Thank you for sharing your story. It's encouraging. Those were surprise repairs. I didn't expect anything big to happen since it'd been rehabbed before I bought. Anyway I've decided to hold it another year and reevaluate the situation. Thank you. =)
Did you do an inspection before you bought?
That was my first mistake. I relied on the inspection report from Roofstock. I should've had a 3rd-party inspection on the house. But I've learned now. Thank you. =)
Most people dump a few hundred dollars a month into a savings account without thinking twice. If you're losing a few hundred dollars a month I don't think that's a big deal. Think of that property as a savings account. Except that the mortgage balance is getting paid down ($), you get great tax write offs ($$), and if you bought a decent property then the rent will increase ($$$) and the value will go up over time ($$$$).
If it was me, I'd keep it and move on to the next deal. You can always reposition it later (refinance, re-rent etc....).
I bought a deal that was a negative cash flow from day 1 because of my financing (13% interest rate), and I knew it was under valued but that the market hadn't caught up to it yet. I purchased it for 90k and based on the current available comps the appraiser also said it was worth 90k. But I knew it was worth at least 120k, but there were no comps to support it. So I bought it anyways and lost about $300/m. I have a great tenant pool in that area FYI (very important). 15 months later it appraised for 125k and I refinanced into a small positive cashflow but a huge equity position.
Not all negative cash flow deals are bad.
Thank you so much for sharing your story. It's very encouraging. I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation. Thank you. =)
Most people dump a few hundred dollars a month into a savings account without thinking twice. If you're losing a few hundred dollars a month I don't think that's a big deal. Think of that property as a savings account. Except that the mortgage balance is getting paid down ($), you get great tax write offs ($$), and if you bought a decent property then the rent will increase ($$$) and the value will go up over time ($$$$).
If it was me, I'd keep it and move on to the next deal. You can always reposition it later (refinance, re-rent etc....).
I bought a deal that was a negative cash flow from day 1 because of my financing (13% interest rate), and I knew it was under valued but that the market hadn't caught up to it yet. I purchased it for 90k and based on the current available comps the appraiser also said it was worth 90k. But I knew it was worth at least 120k, but there were no comps to support it. So I bought it anyways and lost about $300/m. I have a great tenant pool in that area FYI (very important). 15 months later it appraised for 125k and I refinanced into a small positive cashflow but a huge equity position.
Not all negative cash flow deals are bad.
Thank you so much for sharing your story. It's very encouraging. I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation. Thank you. =)
>I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation.
You have indicated the pro forma is too aggressive. I showed, with cited references, that the historical rent and property appreciation is below the rate of inflation. Another poster pointed out the city has a declining population. I did not verify this information, but it seems likely seeing, in inflation adjusted dollars, the property value and rent has been declining.
What do you expect to happen in the next year? I suspect a best case, but unlikely because it has an aggressive pro forma, is that you get $1200 cash flow over the next 12 months. The more likely scenario is that you continue to have negative cash flow.
The negative cash flow would not bother me if there was good evidence that it would improve. Without rent or property appreciation (meaning the appreciation is less than the rate of inflation) I see little chance of the situation improving.
Some questions/thoughts:
Good luck
I am not fully aware of roofstock's fee structure or what you had to pay a realtor/roofstock to purchase the 'turnkey' property, but in my opinion it seems like a math problem...
If you sell it, you are out what those fees were, what your realtor fees and your negative cash flow and you would gain back the appreciation on the house if someone is willing to pay it.
If you keep it, you first need to figure out a way to get the cash flow positive that some others have replied to on here. Raise rents, drop property management and manage yourself for a bit, etc. One quick action by you can take it positive, especially if you are okay with managing it yourself. If you get it positive, and you still want to sell it, your math equation becomes how many months do I need to own this to cover on the amount of fees/etc. that I paid to get the house. That gets you back to breaking even and you can do with the house what you would like.
Thanks,
Sam Domach
@Supada L. I have never invested yet, but I am an RE agent and can’t press enough how important getting a home inspection is before purchasing a property. It will save you so much money and leaves you with the ultimate decision to walk away from a property that doesn’t make sense to you and your numbers. I hope things get better for you 🙏
Most people dump a few hundred dollars a month into a savings account without thinking twice. If you're losing a few hundred dollars a month I don't think that's a big deal. Think of that property as a savings account. Except that the mortgage balance is getting paid down ($), you get great tax write offs ($$), and if you bought a decent property then the rent will increase ($$$) and the value will go up over time ($$$$).
If it was me, I'd keep it and move on to the next deal. You can always reposition it later (refinance, re-rent etc....).
I bought a deal that was a negative cash flow from day 1 because of my financing (13% interest rate), and I knew it was under valued but that the market hadn't caught up to it yet. I purchased it for 90k and based on the current available comps the appraiser also said it was worth 90k. But I knew it was worth at least 120k, but there were no comps to support it. So I bought it anyways and lost about $300/m. I have a great tenant pool in that area FYI (very important). 15 months later it appraised for 125k and I refinanced into a small positive cashflow but a huge equity position.
Not all negative cash flow deals are bad.
Thank you so much for sharing your story. It's very encouraging. I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation. Thank you. =)
>I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation.
You have indicated the pro forma is too aggressive. I showed, with cited references, that the historical rent and property appreciation is below the rate of inflation. Another poster pointed out the city has a declining population. I did not verify this information, but it seems likely seeing, in inflation adjusted dollars, the property value and rent has been declining.
What do you expect to happen in the next year? I suspect a best case, but unlikely because it has an aggressive pro forma, is that you get $1200 cash flow over the next 12 months. The more likely scenario is that you continue to have negative cash flow.
The negative cash flow would not bother me if there was good evidence that it would improve. Without rent or property appreciation (meaning the appreciation is less than the rate of inflation) I see little chance of the situation improving.
Some questions/thoughts:
Good luck
Thank you for your questions/thoughts. I'm not sure why the rent rate on Rent Jungle and Zillow do not match. This rental is 3BD/1BH. I'm renting out at $850. Zillow estimates $1000. I agree that the appreciation is not good. =(
I am not fully aware of roofstock's fee structure or what you had to pay a realtor/roofstock to purchase the 'turnkey' property, but in my opinion it seems like a math problem...
If you sell it, you are out what those fees were, what your realtor fees and your negative cash flow and you would gain back the appreciation on the house if someone is willing to pay it.
If you keep it, you first need to figure out a way to get the cash flow positive that some others have replied to on here. Raise rents, drop property management and manage yourself for a bit, etc. One quick action by you can take it positive, especially if you are okay with managing it yourself. If you get it positive, and you still want to sell it, your math equation becomes how many months do I need to own this to cover on the amount of fees/etc. that I paid to get the house. That gets you back to breaking even and you can do with the house what you would like.
Thanks,
Sam Domach
Thank you. The selling fees and the fact that the house price in the area has declined during COVID make me uncomfortable to sell right now. I think that's what I have to talk to my CPA as well.
@Supada L. I have never invested yet, but I am an RE agent and can’t press enough how important getting a home inspection is before purchasing a property. It will save you so much money and leaves you with the ultimate decision to walk away from a property that doesn’t make sense to you and your numbers. I hope things get better for you 🙏
Thank you so much. Inspection before buying is the big thing I have learned from here. =)
I covered my first year in my first "real property" in depth on this thread: https://www.biggerpockets.com/...
I did it for cathartic reasons, but also as a lesson and insight for others to see. The TL;DR version is I bought a duplex in an area that has low home prices but stable rents. Essentially looking at a 2% rule property...and while it showed well walking through, there was a lot wrong with it. I had a ton of maintenance and CAPEX items in year one, which I consider a partial year (August 2019 to December 2019) and the first full year was also negative cash flow.
However, I've turned the corner (or what I think is the corner) in year 3. I cash flowed $119 per month/per door this year, and that's with some unexpected bills that came through beyond my budgets. I wouldn't call it a perfect deal, but it provides some tax advantages, and I have investors texting me daily for it. It appraised 40k higher than what I bought it for in 2018 (just refinanced to a much better interest rate, which will save me ~$100 a month in PITI).
In the investment world, folks I respect and have learned from might call it a single. They might even call it a bang-bang play-at-first bunt single. But the amount of knowledge and experience this property continues to provide me, is worth me hanging onto it. I am re-evaluating every year and I need to maintain the $100 per month, per door cash flow, as it suits my CF goal for any property I have. Should my goals change, then my evaluation will change accordingly.
Point of this is to tell you year 1 is a stabilization year, especially for your first deal. If you're committing to investing, then commit to it. Bounce your financial expectations off another investor or two to make sure its sound, and then evaluate it against that. If you've essentially fixed or replaced all of the items you needed to, you crashed through your CAPEX budget early, but then your CF should be much better moving forward (in theory).
We have a saying “first year is the worst year”. There are usually unexpected problems and maintenance that first year. Also, I would love to have a 10 million dollar building, better yet a 100 M $ building break even while someone else pays down the debt. Hang in there, stay on top of your property manager, and keep an eye on your expenses. Buying a deal on a $100/month cash performance is too skinny of a deal, but you’re learning and now you’ll have a better idea of value in the future.
I covered my first year in my first "real property" in depth on this thread: https://www.biggerpockets.com/...
I did it for cathartic reasons, but also as a lesson and insight for others to see. The TL;DR version is I bought a duplex in an area that has low home prices but stable rents. Essentially looking at a 2% rule property...and while it showed well walking through, there was a lot wrong with it. I had a ton of maintenance and CAPEX items in year one, which I consider a partial year (August 2019 to December 2019) and the first full year was also negative cash flow.
However, I've turned the corner (or what I think is the corner) in year 3. I cash flowed $119 per month/per door this year, and that's with some unexpected bills that came through beyond my budgets. I wouldn't call it a perfect deal, but it provides some tax advantages, and I have investors texting me daily for it. It appraised 40k higher than what I bought it for in 2018 (just refinanced to a much better interest rate, which will save me ~$100 a month in PITI).
In the investment world, folks I respect and have learned from might call it a single. They might even call it a bang-bang play-at-first bunt single. But the amount of knowledge and experience this property continues to provide me, is worth me hanging onto it. I am re-evaluating every year and I need to maintain the $100 per month, per door cash flow, as it suits my CF goal for any property I have. Should my goals change, then my evaluation will change accordingly.
Point of this is to tell you year 1 is a stabilization year, especially for your first deal. If you're committing to investing, then commit to it. Bounce your financial expectations off another investor or two to make sure its sound, and then evaluate it against that. If you've essentially fixed or replaced all of the items you needed to, you crashed through your CAPEX budget early, but then your CF should be much better moving forward (in theory).
Thank you so much for your story. I hope it would be the case for me as well.
We have a saying “first year is the worst year”. There are usually unexpected problems and maintenance that first year. Also, I would love to have a 10 million dollar building, better yet a 100 M $ building break even while someone else pays down the debt. Hang in there, stay on top of your property manager, and keep an eye on your expenses. Buying a deal on a $100/month cash performance is too skinny of a deal, but you’re learning and now you’ll have a better idea of value in the future.
Yes. I have learned a lot from this property and the mistake I made. Thank you so much for your response.
I always set up contingencies in my estimate. These include 11 month rental periods (one month vacancy), repairs etc. If condo, check thoroughly if there are any future assessment plans (They are killers)
That's a good idea. I'll include that on my spreadsheet as well. Thank you.