First rental turned out to be negative cash flowed.

First rental turned out to be negative cash flowed.

New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes

Hello,

Can anyone please give this first-time landlady some advice on this issue?

I bought a turnkey from Roofstock last summer. It is out of state and I have a PM to take care of it. It's supposed to cashflow about $100/mo. But there have been a lot of fixings and left me with negative cashflow. The major fix was on the gas line, one on tub drain, and a couple minor fixes like clogged pipe.

What should I do with this property? Should I keep it and hope it would cashflow this year or plan to sell it? What would be the worst thing that could happen if I keep having negative cashflow year after year? This situation makes me nervous about rental investment now. :(

84Reply
735 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe VilleneuvePro Member
Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
5y

Ok.  The worst thing that would happen is you would keep negative cash flowing...which adds up, and subtracts.  Think of it as having a job, that you pay the employer for the privilege to work there.  So you say you can cover it with your current job.  Fine, then let me reword what I just said.

It's like working full time, and making enough money so you can work a 2nd job...and pay that employer for the privilege of working there.  If that was the case, what should you do?  Probably quit the 2nd job...right?  So I ask you this, using that same thought process, what should you do with this rental?

Now, onto the property specifics.  I wouldn't buy any property that only has $100/month CF...and you're seeing why now.  That's not positive CF...that's negative CF, guaranteed to happen.

Any money you lost so far though negative CF is gone, and you'll never get it back, as long as this job property has negative CF.  If it starts to get positive CF, then in order to start making a profit, the first thing that has to happen is get all the negative CF back...from the new positive CF.  How long will that take?  How long and how far behind are you?

Don't fall in love with any property.  The property is just the temporary resting place for your cash/equity until said time it grows enough for you move it forward into exponential gains.  The longer you retain a negative CF property, the more negative CF you have to recover, the less money you have left to recover it with, and the longer it takes to actually recover it.  Cut your losses, stop moving backwards, and move forward.

See this reply in the discussion

191 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · St Petersburg, FL · Member since 2020 · 79 posts · 42 votes
    5y

    @Supada L. Well you have a lot of good advice to your question on the low cash flow issue! I have also come across that with a property of my own or with one of my investors. You have to decide what to do since it is now already purchased and you know that you may have made the mistake to start with, but now what to do is up to you. Nobody said RE Investing was easy!

    In the same type of situations I have had in the past I get a good accountant that will track my losses as a business expense for starters. From the minor repairs to the loss of income. I then also do what I call "boiling the frog". Any rental property that I have, even if the rent is maxed out or above market rents I will still raise the rents every lease renewal. How much depends on the area, but as an example if it is $1000 or less then I will raise it $25/mo. If it is more than $1000/mo I will raise it $50/mo. When I say raise it... you have to wait for a lease renewal then raise it. I have had properties that were $250/mo over market rent. Why does this work? Well if I have a tenant that is renting for $1000/mo and next year I raise it to $1050/mo they don't bat an eye. If they love the property they will stay verses finding a new place and then having to move. Once the current tenant is over the market rent by enough they will move out and then you just start marketing the property to get a new tenant at the same level as the last one left it at. Most tenants look at "How much can I afford?" and not at "Where is the current market rent?". If it doesn't rent then drop it $50/mo every two weeks until it does. Then next year start "boiling the frog" again!

    The concept of losing money with negative cash flow is more of a mental state of mind. If you have 5 properties and 3 are above market rent that can make up for the negative cash flow... then you are ok. Just don't make it a habit of buying with negative cash flow and you will be fine! By "boiling the frog" you may be able to make this one cash flow somewhere down the road and in the meantime take the loss as a business expense and soak up the equity until you can get it sold or refinanced to take some money out on the back end.

  • Real Estate Agent · Baltimore Maryland · Member since 2019 · 98 posts · 75 votes
    5y

    I would talk to the PM and see if you will be able to increase the rent to increase your cash flow in the near future. Sounds like a lot of repairs to take on for a property that only cash flows $100/month.  Also, it doesn't sound like the property was quite "turn key" as they promised.  Is there a warranty on the property?  The whole point of buying those turn key properties from those companies is peace of mind, which isn't the case here.

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Doug Crenshaw:

    @Supada L. Well you have a lot of good advice to your question on the low cash flow issue! I have also come across that with a property of my own or with one of my investors. You have to decide what to do since it is now already purchased and you know that you may have made the mistake to start with, but now what to do is up to you. Nobody said RE Investing was easy!

    In the same type of situations I have had in the past I get a good accountant that will track my losses as a business expense for starters. From the minor repairs to the loss of income. I then also do what I call "boiling the frog". Any rental property that I have, even if the rent is maxed out or above market rents I will still raise the rents every lease renewal. How much depends on the area, but as an example if it is $1000 or less then I will raise it $25/mo. If it is more than $1000/mo I will raise it $50/mo. When I say raise it... you have to wait for a lease renewal then raise it. I have had properties that were $250/mo over market rent. Why does this work? Well if I have a tenant that is renting for $1000/mo and next year I raise it to $1050/mo they don't bat an eye. If they love the property they will stay verses finding a new place and then having to move. Once the current tenant is over the market rent by enough they will move out and then you just start marketing the property to get a new tenant at the same level as the last one left it at. Most tenants look at "How much can I afford?" and not at "Where is the current market rent?". If it doesn't rent then drop it $50/mo every two weeks until it does. Then next year start "boiling the frog" again!

    The concept of losing money with negative cash flow is more of a mental state of mind. If you have 5 properties and 3 are above market rent that can make up for the negative cash flow... then you are ok. Just don't make it a habit of buying with negative cash flow and you will be fine! By "boiling the frog" you may be able to make this one cash flow somewhere down the road and in the meantime take the loss as a business expense and soak up the equity until you can get it sold or refinanced to take some money out on the back end.

     Thank you so much for your advise. The lease renewal is coming up in a couple months. "Boiling the frog" sounds like a good idea. I will discuss with my PM if we can do that as well. Thank you. =)

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Chinyere Orie:

    I would talk to the PM and see if you will be able to increase the rent to increase your cash flow in the near future. Sounds like a lot of repairs to take on for a property that only cash flows $100/month.  Also, it doesn't sound like the property was quite "turn key" as they promised.  Is there a warranty on the property?  The whole point of buying those turn key properties from those companies is peace of mind, which isn't the case here.

    Thank you. I'll check with them if they have a warranty on the property. I will also talk to my PM about increasing the rent. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu, HAWAII (HI) · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5y

    Here is my beef turnkey (despite starting out with it back in 2012) with 300 dollars per property (2 months of work to buy a turnkey rental) you are going to need 20-40 of these to replace your income. I had 11 of these and good systems in place but still had 1-2 evictions a year and 3-4 big things that were normal annoyances like plumbing leaks, damages from hurricanes, or some vandalism. Image if I had 30, just 3 x those numbers.

    Directly investing in a turnkey rental or small MFH is a good way to start to learn and build up the war chest to go into my scaleable investments such as private placement syndications. 

  • Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y

    @Supada L.

    $100 is not cashflow. Any company that tells you otherwise is either clueless/ inexperienced or lying to you.

  • Cory WallacePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Norfolk, VA · Member since 2020 · 53 posts · 38 votes
    5y

    @Supada L. Having lived in Meridian, MS I know that entire city depends on the Navy base and that can be risky. I agree with the person that said having $100 CF each month brings about risk so be careful.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Barney Davis:

    @Joe Villeneuve I agree that $100 cash flow isn’t enough to get out of bed for. I’m curious what is the starting point for you? What the least amount of cash flow you personally are willing to invest in?

     It depends on what the timeline in my plan tells me

  • Real Estate Agent · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y

    Is there a way to make the property cash flowing?  For example once the tenant moves out switch it to a vacation rental or pass along services?  I charge a gardener fee to my tenants so it doesn't hurt my bottom line.

    As a learning experience, I wonder if some of these fixes could have been caught through a home inspection when you initially purchased the property.

  • Member since 2021 · 41 posts · 14 votes
    5y

    Signs you have a dog property.

    When the BP peanut gallery says keep it for the Tax Benefits.

    2n.   Paydown of mortgage is brought up as a reason to hold on.

    SELL N REASSSESSS.

  • Rental Property Investor · Jackson, MS · Member since 2019 · 33 posts · 9 votes
    5y

    @Joe Villeneuve wow! You missed your calling as a politician. 😂 sorry if I wasted any of your time, sir....

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Lane Kawaoka:

    Here is my beef turnkey (despite starting out with it back in 2012) with 300 dollars per property (2 months of work to buy a turnkey rental) you are going to need 20-40 of these to replace your income. I had 11 of these and good systems in place but still had 1-2 evictions a year and 3-4 big things that were normal annoyances like plumbing leaks, damages from hurricanes, or some vandalism. Image if I had 30, just 3 x those numbers.

    Directly investing in a turnkey rental or small MFH is a good way to start to learn and build up the war chest to go into my scaleable investments such as private placement syndications. 

     Thank you for your response. Yes. I'm still learning. This is my first year of investing in RE. It freaked me out to see the negative numbers.

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Supada L.

    $100 is not cashflow. Any company that tells you otherwise is either clueless/ inexperienced or lying to you.

    Thank you. I'll have to be aware of that. 

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Cory Wallace:

    @Supada L. Having lived in Meridian, MS I know that entire city depends on the Navy base and that can be risky. I agree with the person that said having $100 CF each month brings about risk so be careful.

    Thank you. I'll be careful on my next rental. 

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Rick Albert:

    Is there a way to make the property cash flowing?  For example once the tenant moves out switch it to a vacation rental or pass along services?  I charge a gardener fee to my tenants so it doesn't hurt my bottom line.

    As a learning experience, I wonder if some of these fixes could have been caught through a home inspection when you initially purchased the property.

    I don't think the area is good for a vacation rental, but there are many things I learned from this post and think would worth a shot. Thank you. =)

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Felicia Feliciano:

    Signs you have a dog property.

    When the BP peanut gallery says keep it for the Tax Benefits.

    2n.   Paydown of mortgage is brought up as a reason to hold on.

    SELL N REASSSESSS.

    Thank you. Those are what I will discuss with my CPA as well.

  • Member since 2021 · 41 posts · 14 votes
    5y

    Please do not even investigate what a private placement syndication is.   Horrible results, might even be worse than TK-  thats debateable.

  • Member since 2021 · 41 posts · 14 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Barney Davis:

    @Joe Villeneuve wow! You missed your calling as a politician. 😂 sorry if I wasted any of your time, sir....

    Joe is next level RE investor. Instead of Brandons book s he says study Geometry and Algebra.  Im on it,  always room for improvement.

  • Rental Property Investor · L.A. Ca · Member since 2020 · 129 posts · 43 votes
    5y

    I advise studying up more on what you should look for in a rental property, the set aside amounts you need a margin for (vacancies, repairs, capital improvements). You should know ahead of going into one what you can rent the property for. Know what you need in a property mgr. Nothing is every "turnkey" no matter what you are investing in business wise or real estate wise. One piece of advise I found to be the most useful is "Look, not listen". YOU look at and figure out the #s. YOU see if there is going to be enough for reserves for these items. YOU look at the property. YOU are responsible for your investment decisions and for the upkeep of your investments. Also another piece of advice is "If it isn't in writing, it isn't true" so if you have a contract with someone on their service, ensure it is in writing with them on the contract. Even if out of state there are a lot of ways to do all this. I have a few out of state properties & they are all cash flowing well. Unfornutely when I first started out, being from Ca where the taxes don't fluctuate like other states do when prices go up and not being familiar with hurricanes etc, I invested in areas where the taxes and the insur skyrocketed thus leaving a negative cashflow after I had done my #s. I learned the hard way to also invest in areas that don't have the harsh weather/higher insurances or potential high insur due to their location. So, I didnt' really do all my homework back then on that point. I should have called insur agents well ahead and checked out the taxes. It was up to me to do that. I couldn't blame the realtors or anyone for selling them to me. This business is a business as well just like any other. You must train yourself in this area. Read books on it. You can learn as you go as well, but YOU must learn, apply what you learn, and then manage your investments properly. 

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Supada L.:
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @Supada L. A couple of things immediately jump out. First of all, Roofstock isn't really a turn key company. They do not own and renovate the properties. They are an alternative marketplace to the MLS. Another big question is why did you choose Meridian, MS? From what I can see, it is a small market of only 40K people and the population has been declining significantly. It has only a 55% labor participation rate (national is 63%). It doesn't appear to have a very broad economic base with the majority of jobs being in military and healthcare. Personally, I don't see anything attractive as an investment market. You've also set your sights too low at $100 per month cash flow. There's just not enough margin there to overcome the times that things go wrong. The declining population doesn't bode well for being able to increase rents in the future.

    Thank you for pointing out. I didn't study the market well enough and relied on the information Roofstock provided. They listed it as a turnkey though, with list of fixes they'd made. But you're right. I was supposed to do more study.

    @Supada L. The problem is that everyone has their own definition of turn key. For some, it just means that there is a tenant in place. Work with someone that you can fully trust but also do your own due diligence. When things go wrong, it's not always because the seller lied. Often times it's because there wasn't a common understanding and meeting of the minds. One of the most common areas that this happens is in describing property classes. What someone considers a C class property/neighborhood might be your D class. It's important to make sure you're on the same page.

  • Real Estate Agent · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2016 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    5y

    I would get rid of the property manager and keep that money. You can manage it from out of state. Talk to the tenants and tell them to report any issues to you directly. When you buy houses there are always unexpected costs out the gate. Once you fix them you should be smooth sailing after that. Everything you fix is one less thing to have to fix later. And when you do finally sell you can advertise all those items have been upgraded / fixed which means you can recoup those losses. 

  • Member since 2020 · 21 posts · 1 vote
    5y

    @Joe Villeneuve. Hey joe, how do you feel about positive cash flow around $240 a month? 

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Felicia Feliciano:

    Please do not even investigate what a private placement syndication is.   Horrible results, might even be worse than TK-  thats debateable.

    Thanks for the warning. I'll stay away from it. =) 

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Nicole W.:

    I advise studying up more on what you should look for in a rental property, the set aside amounts you need a margin for (vacancies, repairs, capital improvements). You should know ahead of going into one what you can rent the property for. Know what you need in a property mgr. Nothing is every "turnkey" no matter what you are investing in business wise or real estate wise. One piece of advise I found to be the most useful is "Look, not listen". YOU look at and figure out the #s. YOU see if there is going to be enough for reserves for these items. YOU look at the property. YOU are responsible for your investment decisions and for the upkeep of your investments. Also another piece of advice is "If it isn't in writing, it isn't true" so if you have a contract with someone on their service, ensure it is in writing with them on the contract. Even if out of state there are a lot of ways to do all this. I have a few out of state properties & they are all cash flowing well. Unfornutely when I first started out, being from Ca where the taxes don't fluctuate like other states do when prices go up and not being familiar with hurricanes etc, I invested in areas where the taxes and the insur skyrocketed thus leaving a negative cashflow after I had done my #s. I learned the hard way to also invest in areas that don't have the harsh weather/higher insurances or potential high insur due to their location. So, I didnt' really do all my homework back then on that point. I should have called insur agents well ahead and checked out the taxes. It was up to me to do that. I couldn't blame the realtors or anyone for selling them to me. This business is a business as well just like any other. You must train yourself in this area. Read books on it. You can learn as you go as well, but YOU must learn, apply what you learn, and then manage your investments properly. 

    Thank you so much for the advice and your story. They're very valuable.

    Can I ask a few more questions: Have you sold your first investment? If so, how long had you waited until you decided to sell? And how did you make the decision?

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 147 posts · 134 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:
    Originally posted by @Supada L.:
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @Supada L. A couple of things immediately jump out. First of all, Roofstock isn't really a turn key company. They do not own and renovate the properties. They are an alternative marketplace to the MLS. Another big question is why did you choose Meridian, MS? From what I can see, it is a small market of only 40K people and the population has been declining significantly. It has only a 55% labor participation rate (national is 63%). It doesn't appear to have a very broad economic base with the majority of jobs being in military and healthcare. Personally, I don't see anything attractive as an investment market. You've also set your sights too low at $100 per month cash flow. There's just not enough margin there to overcome the times that things go wrong. The declining population doesn't bode well for being able to increase rents in the future.

    Thank you for pointing out. I didn't study the market well enough and relied on the information Roofstock provided. They listed it as a turnkey though, with list of fixes they'd made. But you're right. I was supposed to do more study.

    @Supada L. The problem is that everyone has their own definition of turn key. For some, it just means that there is a tenant in place. Work with someone that you can fully trust but also do your own due diligence. When things go wrong, it's not always because the seller lied. Often times it's because there wasn't a common understanding and meeting of the minds. One of the most common areas that this happens is in describing property classes. What someone considers a C class property/neighborhood might be your D class. It's important to make sure you're on the same page.

    Thank you for re-posting this. I think I missed it somehow. But yes. I might not be careful enough and didn't do my due diligence. Thank you for pointing out.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.