Hello,
Can anyone please give this first-time landlady some advice on this issue?
I bought a turnkey from Roofstock last summer. It is out of state and I have a PM to take care of it. It's supposed to cashflow about $100/mo. But there have been a lot of fixings and left me with negative cashflow. The major fix was on the gas line, one on tub drain, and a couple minor fixes like clogged pipe.
What should I do with this property? Should I keep it and hope it would cashflow this year or plan to sell it? What would be the worst thing that could happen if I keep having negative cashflow year after year? This situation makes me nervous about rental investment now. :(
Ok. The worst thing that would happen is you would keep negative cash flowing...which adds up, and subtracts. Think of it as having a job, that you pay the employer for the privilege to work there. So you say you can cover it with your current job. Fine, then let me reword what I just said.
It's like working full time, and making enough money so you can work a 2nd job...and pay that employer for the privilege of working there. If that was the case, what should you do? Probably quit the 2nd job...right? So I ask you this, using that same thought process, what should you do with this rental?
Now, onto the property specifics. I wouldn't buy any property that only has $100/month CF...and you're seeing why now. That's not positive CF...that's negative CF, guaranteed to happen.
Any money you lost so far though negative CF is gone, and you'll never get it back, as long as this job property has negative CF. If it starts to get positive CF, then in order to start making a profit, the first thing that has to happen is get all the negative CF back...from the new positive CF. How long will that take? How long and how far behind are you?
Don't fall in love with any property. The property is just the temporary resting place for your cash/equity until said time it grows enough for you move it forward into exponential gains. The longer you retain a negative CF property, the more negative CF you have to recover, the less money you have left to recover it with, and the longer it takes to actually recover it. Cut your losses, stop moving backwards, and move forward.
Time to make lemonade from lemons. If this is your first property yo should be using your losses and other investor related expenses to decrease your tax bill back to profitability in the short term.
Thank you for the advice. I've decided to hold it for another year and reevaluate the situation. In the meantime I'll see if I can improve it as well. =)
Time to make lemonade from lemons. If this is your first property yo should be using your losses and other investor related expenses to decrease your tax bill back to profitability in the short term.
Thank you. This is what I'll talk to my CPA as well.
DO NOT INVEST IN OUT OF STATE REAL ESTATE..... PLEEEEEEEEEEASE!!!! Hope this Helps and to ALL considering such As investment...(UNLESS you live in California #exodus)
DO NOT INVEST IN OUT OF STATE REAL ESTATE..... PLEEEEEEEEEEASE!!!! Hope this Helps and to ALL considering such As investment...(UNLESS you live in California #exodus)
Thank you for your advice. Would you please explain why we should not invest in OOS?
Supada There is ways to increase the revenue and decrease expenses, but it may be a little difficult to be new. IF it was me, it's still somewhat of a seller's market. I would just spruce up and look to sell it. Again not knowing the area that you are in, but most of the country is in a seller's market now.
If you keep taken money out of your pocket to have someone live there would defeat the purpose for you to get into the market.
@Supada L. Just so you know, you are not the only one that this happened. Many years ago I bought a turnkey property, that for many years was in the red (not right away). Not only did I have negative cashflow but I also couldn't sell or refinance it (it was 2008). I would have to probably pay for someone to buy it. So to ease my pain, I tell myself, I'm paying into my future.
It has appreciated quite a bit since. I never checked to see if I had put that money into the stock market, it would have had a similar return.
Best of luck
Supada There is ways to increase the revenue and decrease expenses, but it may be a little difficult to be new. IF it was me, it's still somewhat of a seller's market. I would just spruce up and look to sell it. Again not knowing the area that you are in, but most of the country is in a seller's market now.
If you keep taken money out of your pocket to have someone live there would defeat the purpose for you to get into the market.
Thank you for your advice. I'll do more research on the market and see if it's a seller's market as well.
@Supada L. Just so you know, you are not the only one that this happened. Many years ago I bought a turnkey property, that for many years was in the red (not right away). Not only did I have negative cashflow but I also couldn't sell or refinance it (it was 2008). I would have to probably pay for someone to buy it. So to ease my pain, I tell myself, I'm paying into my future.
It has appreciated quite a bit since. I never checked to see if I had put that money into the stock market, it would have had a similar return.
Best of luck
Thank you so much. It's good to know I'm not the only one. Thanks for sharing your story.
@Supada L. I do not hold rentals for this very reason. I stick to the private lending side. Forgive me for maybe stating something that has already been stated and asking questions that already have been asked...
~ After all operating expenses were calculated were you expecting a $100 per month cash flow?
~ What was your "turnkey" purchase price? (I assume it was turnkey because you named a company that you bought it from, therefore I am sure they sold it as "turnkey"). Also because it was turnkey, as well your statement "But there have been a lot of fixings and left me with negative cashflow." leaves me to assume you were expecting the property to have been inspected and refurbished of any lacking issues?
~ With you being out of state did you calculate the costs of a PM into your operating expenses?
I am terribly sorry this is the situation you find yourself in, however this is much more common than you may think. People invest into "turnkey" rentals, with the expectation they will build a portfolio to live off of. I don't know what your numbers are but $100 net cashflow seems REALLY low. I guess this is why I prefer private lending. If I have invested $100,000 into a loan and its a long term loan, to an investor like yourself who is building a portfolio, I may charge 7% annual... just on the interest (not including principal I am making $583.33 per month... and I, as the lender, am not assuming the liability nor responsibility of that asset (taxes, insurance, tenant issues, broken sewer pipes, water pipes breaking etc..). As well if its an amortized loan I am also reducing my exposure over time. I think more investors who are looking for "cash flow" should at least consider private lending as an option.
My advice, sale ASAP, even if at a discount. The ownership environment is changing, especially with incoming political actors, and long term hold expectations may be upended with radical shifts in protections for property owners
@Supada L. As a long term out-of-state investor myself, I think your biggest mistake is not that $100 cash flow, but the property is not located in a growth market(with high population and income growth). If it is located in a growth market, even at the start the cash flow is low or negative, with the property price appreciates fast, rent will catch up and lift your cash flow.
I wrote my own out-of-state investing experience here, in case you are interested:
As an Out-Of-State Investor for 9 Years… (biggerpockets.com)
As I said in the post, for OOS investing to be successful, appreciation must be put in higher priority.
what online website or tool did you use to find population and labor participation rate of Meridian?
Supata- lets start with the basics.
Go to apartments.com, zillow, redfin, hotpads, realtor, domu, craigslist, facebook marketplace, neighborhood paper and see what the comparable rents are in your exact area for your property.
Once you decide if your property is inline with rents what else can you do to maximize cash flow?
can you rent out the garage seperately?
can you rent out the basement? A couple rooms?
What expenses have you incurred? Can you have a company inspect the major issues now to give you a free estimate for final repairs?
can you add a bedroom or fixup a room and raise the rent? How about a dishwasher? Or a/c unit?
Have you thought of section 8 with this property?
next lets lower expenses.
Shop around for management now. Shop around for contractor/handyman on your own now. How about cheaper insurance? How about getting an attorney to lower property taxes- now.
Go to airbnb and vrbo and see what listings are in your immediate area and see if that is an avenue.
Check with other cpas for their fee.
-good luck. Weve all been behind the 8 ball at some point but sometimes we all need to dig ourselves out.
This is a great cautionary tale. I see a whole lot of hype about "building your stack" and "How to become a Real Estate Milllllyonaire!" The reality is that in hot markets, particularly the hot ones that are relevant to me (Northern Utah), buy and hold properties simply don't cash flow. Any SFH that comes on the market is being snapped up at or above the asking price by retail buyers. Appreciation is great, but is that really going to be all that attractive in the long run? Do I really want to lose money in the short run for the possibility of long term appreciation? Not really.
"But, but invest OOS!" Is the counter-mantra. But that's not necessarily a good choice, either. When you invest OOS, property management is generally mandatory, not optional. So that's a 8-10% expense that you pretty much have to spend that local investors don't necessarily need to. Also, you gotta ask why these properties are cash flowing in what has generally been a hot US market? In my view a lot of it can be explained by the simple lack of economic opportunity in the areas in question.
No, it can be explained by a complete lack of knowledge of how to analyze markets to find those opportunities, and understand that the best opportunities are made...not found.
I don't really know why, but I think this post just affirmed my desire to buy cashflow over "potential" appreciation. A bird in the hand as they say........
@Joe Villeneuve
I have a property with the same situation. It is my first rental property and it’s been my latter to learning first hand how things work. My property isn’t cash flowering and I’m still having to make repairs to get it up to standards. The tenants are basically helping me pay 3/4 of the mortgage but in a month or two I will be refinancing it and re-appraising it to see it’s value and I plan for the monthly payment to drop and with the things I’ve added I’m raising the rent. After all that it will be cash flowing 200 to 300 every month. Sometimes it just takes time when your learning the ropes but if it’s hurting your pockets pretty bad I would get rid of it.
@Joe Villeneuve
I have a property with the same situation. It is my first rental property and it’s been my latter to learning first hand how things work. My property isn’t cash flowering and I’m still having to make repairs to get it up to standards. The tenants are basically helping me pay 3/4 of the mortgage but in a month or two I will be refinancing it and re-appraising it to see it’s value and I plan for the monthly payment to drop and with the things I’ve added I’m raising the rent. After all that it will be cash flowing 200 to 300 every month. Sometimes it just takes time when your learning the ropes but if it’s hurting your pockets pretty bad I would get rid of it.
If you sold the property when you started to have negative CF, based on the cash you would have walked away with, and the negative CF you wouldn't have had, could you have found a different property that would have had the same value and positive CF you are guessing you will have after you refi and raise the rent? I'm assuming the answer is yes.
What that means is you lost money during the months before you did the refi, that you didn't have to lose.
Rationalization is expensive.
Yea from what I saw around the market there were much better properties in way better condition then mine. I was just too anxious to get started already I didn’t give myself more time.
I don't really know why, but I think this post just affirmed my desire to buy cashflow over "potential" appreciation. A bird in the hand as they say........
Cash flow vs appreciation. Why does it have to be one or the other. Why can't it be both? The answer is simple...it should be both. If you are choosing one over the other you are losing money.
Cash flow without appreciation only works if the CF is so large that it offsets any added costs that happen while owning the property over the next ????? (at least 15) years...and the only equity build up comes from the tenant paying the mortgage down. That's a verys slow process.
Appreciation without cash flow is....foolish (I used a much nicer work than the one I was thinking) at best. Appreciation only has value when you can access it...as in turn it into liquid cash. Equity, in the form of equity, is dead cash. Money out of pocket to cover the negative CF, is a cost to the REI that must be recovered before any profit is made. EQuity buildup is only profit when it is turned to liquid cash. So, the REI has to ask themselves 2 questions here:
1 - How long before I run out of cash, and I lose my "dead cash"?
2 - What could I be doing differently with the money I'm spending to cover negative cash flow, and how much added positive CF could I be getting if I used it to buy a different property that had the same equity build up as the property with negative CF?
Too many bad financial decisions are made because the REI falls in love with the wrong thing (the property), and doesn't understand what the actual asset is.
Yea from what I saw around the market there were much better properties in way better condition then mine. I was just too anxious to get started already I didn’t give myself more time.
Then sell it now, and replace it now, with one of those.
I can’t sale it now I have stuff I’m renovating in it and like I said before I’m close to starting a new lease with my current tenant so it will be cash flow positive plus with a lower bank monthly payment for me. If things still don’t work out and I see better opportunities after that then I’ll look into selling it. I would like to buy a duplex or triplex that does not need so much repair so I can move in one and rent the others out.
Well to me and I know it’s not the true meaning Turn Key means Newly Renovated and in your case PMed. But even with the property being up to par there are still lots of variables. And those are why I’m against distance real estate investing. There are risks to everything WE do but we must try to hedge against them if possible.
@Supada L. I do not hold rentals for this very reason. I stick to the private lending side. Forgive me for maybe stating something that has already been stated and asking questions that already have been asked...
~ After all operating expenses were calculated were you expecting a $100 per month cash flow?
~ What was your "turnkey" purchase price? (I assume it was turnkey because you named a company that you bought it from, therefore I am sure they sold it as "turnkey"). Also because it was turnkey, as well your statement "But there have been a lot of fixings and left me with negative cashflow." leaves me to assume you were expecting the property to have been inspected and refurbished of any lacking issues?
~ With you being out of state did you calculate the costs of a PM into your operating expenses?
I am terribly sorry this is the situation you find yourself in, however this is much more common than you may think. People invest into "turnkey" rentals, with the expectation they will build a portfolio to live off of. I don't know what your numbers are but $100 net cashflow seems REALLY low. I guess this is why I prefer private lending. If I have invested $100,000 into a loan and its a long term loan, to an investor like yourself who is building a portfolio, I may charge 7% annual... just on the interest (not including principal I am making $583.33 per month... and I, as the lender, am not assuming the liability nor responsibility of that asset (taxes, insurance, tenant issues, broken sewer pipes, water pipes breaking etc..). As well if its an amortized loan I am also reducing my exposure over time. I think more investors who are looking for "cash flow" should at least consider private lending as an option.
My advice, sale ASAP, even if at a discount. The ownership environment is changing, especially with incoming political actors, and long term hold expectations may be upended with radical shifts in protections for property owners
Yeah. My hair's beginning to turn grey because I keep worrying if the tenant will pay the rent, if/when surprise bills will show up, etc, etc.
The $100/mo is after taking the PM fees into account. The thing is I didn't expect anything to break as the company I bought it from said it was "turnkey" and "had been recently rehabbed". They even had the inspection report, list of the things they fixed and changed. But things still break.
Anyway thank you very much for your response.