There has been a lot of talk of people moving out of California. To this effect, the Los Angeles Times has an article that goes by the subject "High taxes be damned, the rich keep moving to California". Has anyone read this yet?
(I didn't want to run afoul of the BP rules and so I did not post the link.)
When a Ca politician indicates poverty he may not be referring to Fed poverty levels but income levels higher than the fed definition but not enough income to live on in Ca. Using the fed poverty guidelines, CA is not very close to the highest poverty state (but is worse than the average state - in the 30s).
There are many people with jobs that cannot afford housing in CA. Young school teachers may have to share their BR to be able to afford housing. There are also people without jobs for one reason or another (most cannot keep a regular job due to various issues and it is not primarily they are lazy - various reasons from addiction to psychological issues, etc.).
The environmental climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Near the coast it rarely freezes or rarely breaks 90 in the summer. Environment climate wise there likely is no state better for homeless.
The political climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Food banks, homeless shelters, allowing people to live in their vehicles on the public streets (San Diego city allows people to live in their vehicle on any public street). Policy wise there are few states as accommodating of the homeless as Ca.
Why would a homeless person choose to live elsewhere? Not an easy problem to solve but it does explain part of why there are so many homeless in Ca (many and large homeless camps - there used to be a very large homeless camp by Angel stadium, not sure if it is still there, smaller encampments are everywhere).
Expensive housing, political and environment climate that accommodates the homeless contribute to the large homeless numbers. The economy is solid but the homeless problem seems to continue to get worse is So Cal.
BTW my brother has not held full time work in over a decade. He is 52 now. He has a range of issues. Psychological issues are persistent. He has fought drug dependencies a couple/few times. He is so unreliable that he cannot hold a regular job (even part-time job). We provide him a place to live. There are days that he does not leave the place. Other days he is great. Gardens, occasionally fishes, has a BBQ, goes out with friends. We have also provided him a car when we were done with it. I suspect it never had oil added/changed after we gave it to him. Are we enabling? I do not believe so because it is my view he is not capable of supporting himself. If we did not provide him a place to live he would be living on the street and possibly dead. My wife and I expect to need to help support my brother for life (ours or his). Due to my brother, I am familiar with the problem and the difficulties dealing with the problem.
In a few sectors, California has some very high paying jobs and opportunities. Yet the state has the highest poverty rate in the country and the middle class is shrinking. And housing is what keeps the poverty rate high.
@Brian Ploszay - Got any articles to back up the comments? I feel like your sentiment is common but I would love to read some opposing articles to the LA Times one. Thanks.
Actually, out of the new Governor's mouth. He admitted to the high poverty rate and its relation to the housing costs. Sorry, I do not have the video anymore.
@Francis A. since you live here you know what it is like to be in a city that has a lot of excitement, great weather, numerous companies and the opportunity to make your dreams come true.
With these great things comes a high price tag! It's not cheap to live here in Los Angeles but it's not cheap to live in New York either but people love both cities and want to be where there are opportunities.
If people can afford to live in both Los Angeles and New York they'll do it even if the taxes are high.
don't forget North side Chicago and Boston along with Seattle in the high priced category. and even Charleston SC
I just sold a house that I built in Charleston for just a TAD under 1000 a foot.. pretty cool for mid deep south
Yes, @Jay Hinrichs the cities you mentioned for the most party have high taxes with Charleston being the lowest on the list.
There's a reason people want to live in these cities even if the taxes are high.
I think both things are happening. A lot of people are moving out of California solely so they can experience more for their money (housing, general costs, etc. (can't say they get more amenities elsewhere)). At the same time, the people who can afford California are continuing to move here because California has arguably more to offer than just about anywhere else. Not everything it offers appeals to everyone, but it's pretty enticing. My parents, who swore for most of my life they would never live in California and my dad who is super-frugal so cringes at the thought of costs, ended up moving here and they tell people all day long they realize why it costs so much more--it's amazing. Way more for them here than in Georgia. Same for me.
So, I think both are happening at the same time and both are dictated by the costs here.
I definitely not a complainer. Glass will always be half full as a matter of principle.
I also know first hand about the expense of NY which I believe is higher than California on the average.
And by "California" and "NY", we should clarify that we're primarily talking about the major urban centers.
There are some really nice places in the rural parts of both states that I wouldn't mind having a home.
I'm mostly interesting in this news because you almost always read about how folks are moving away as opposed to moving here. And yet somehow, the 405 freeway AKA the busiest freeway in the nation keeps expanding...
Go figure.
Actually, out of the new Governor's mouth. He admitted to the high poverty rate and its relation to the housing costs. Sorry, I do not have the video anymore.
To be fair, trying to compare poverty is like saying, "hey, my illness is worse than yours".
Yes, California's economy is ranked 5th in the world. One State, so yes to have poverty here is a tough thing.
That being said, poverty is a multifaceted complex complex problem. Should you help, should you not help, who helps?... and on and on.
I don't think there is one way to attack the different ways people fall into poverty.
That being said...
Most of you might never have heard of this developer by the name of - Rick Caruso. ( caruso -dot-com )
He is fantastic as what he does. I'm amazed at how he built his business from the ground up. He blends residential and retail beautifully.
Here is the title of a talk he gave at his alma mater - USC.
He touches on poverty and what he thinks can be done by a leader who is determined to do something about it.
Google this title and give it a listen when you can. I think it starts around the 30 minute mark. Very interesting points.
Lewis Horne who runs CBRE also touches on poverty as ("one half of 1% of our population").
"Billionaire Rick Caruso & Lewis Horne: Becoming A Real Estate Developer and Advice (2018)"
@Ali Boone
I grew up in California. It has prettier scenery and better weather. However, the quality of life in Los Angeles almost seems to have declined a bit because of the traffic. If you're in Glendale and you have a meeting in Santa Monica, it is almost not workable anymore. San Diego seems to be more livable.
We have the ocean, mountains - you can swim and ski in the same day, all type of food and culture, MTV, Yahoo, Tesla, Space X, Ratheon, Amazon, SnapCat, Yahoo, Google - too many tech companies to list, Silicone Valley, Silicone Beach, two pro football teams, Olympics coming within a decade, hikes and amazing scenery, Hollywood, USC, UCLA, and amazing weather, LA San Diego, Santa Barbara, SF Bay. There's opportunity of all kinds. Poverty and homeless are an issue as with any populous city and state. There are many factors that have held people back in life, sometimes it's mental illness. A lot of these factors, including mental illness, is not unique to the state.
When a Ca politician indicates poverty he may not be referring to Fed poverty levels but income levels higher than the fed definition but not enough income to live on in Ca. Using the fed poverty guidelines, CA is not very close to the highest poverty state (but is worse than the average state - in the 30s).
There are many people with jobs that cannot afford housing in CA. Young school teachers may have to share their BR to be able to afford housing. There are also people without jobs for one reason or another (most cannot keep a regular job due to various issues and it is not primarily they are lazy - various reasons from addiction to psychological issues, etc.).
The environmental climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Near the coast it rarely freezes or rarely breaks 90 in the summer. Environment climate wise there likely is no state better for homeless.
The political climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Food banks, homeless shelters, allowing people to live in their vehicles on the public streets (San Diego city allows people to live in their vehicle on any public street). Policy wise there are few states as accommodating of the homeless as Ca.
Why would a homeless person choose to live elsewhere? Not an easy problem to solve but it does explain part of why there are so many homeless in Ca (many and large homeless camps - there used to be a very large homeless camp by Angel stadium, not sure if it is still there, smaller encampments are everywhere).
Expensive housing, political and environment climate that accommodates the homeless contribute to the large homeless numbers. The economy is solid but the homeless problem seems to continue to get worse is So Cal.
BTW my brother has not held full time work in over a decade. He is 52 now. He has a range of issues. Psychological issues are persistent. He has fought drug dependencies a couple/few times. He is so unreliable that he cannot hold a regular job (even part-time job). We provide him a place to live. There are days that he does not leave the place. Other days he is great. Gardens, occasionally fishes, has a BBQ, goes out with friends. We have also provided him a car when we were done with it. I suspect it never had oil added/changed after we gave it to him. Are we enabling? I do not believe so because it is my view he is not capable of supporting himself. If we did not provide him a place to live he would be living on the street and possibly dead. My wife and I expect to need to help support my brother for life (ours or his). Due to my brother, I am familiar with the problem and the difficulties dealing with the problem.
@Ali Boone
I grew up in California. It has prettier scenery and better weather. However, the quality of life in Los Angeles almost seems to have declined a bit because of the traffic. If you're in Glendale and you have a meeting in Santa Monica, it is almost not workable anymore. San Diego seems to be more livable.
I've lived in NYC and Los Angeles for very significant amount of times. I've spent quite a bit of going back and forth from the mid west too.
Choosing to live somewhere can be a choice. It's not always a choice but it can be.
This is an actual searchable title - "There are 6 ways to get from Glendale to Santa Monica Pier by train, subway, tram, bus, taxi, car or towncar"
I used to get my kicks in San Diego. From the Chula Vista all the way to the gas lamp district. San Diego is overall, very livable as you say but there are certain amenities that San Diego simply cannot match Los Angeles for. Again, it comes down to choice. Chicago and a few other cities in the mid west are great and can be almost as expensive too. It's all mostly a choice to be redundant. Believe it or not, these are "fancy" problems we're talking about (without sounding glib about this subject matter).
When a Ca politician indicates poverty he may not be referring to Fed poverty levels but income levels higher than the fed definition but not enough income to live on in Ca. Using the fed poverty guidelines, CA is not very close to the highest poverty state (but is worse than the average state - in the 30s).
There are many people with jobs that cannot afford housing in CA. Young school teachers may have to share their BR to be able to afford housing. There are also people without jobs for one reason or another (most cannot keep a regular job due to various issues and it is not primarily they are lazy - various reasons from addiction to psychological issues, etc.).
The environmental climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Near the coast it rarely freezes or rarely breaks 90 in the summer. Environment climate wise there likely is no state better for homeless.
The political climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Food banks, homeless shelters, allowing people to live in their vehicles on the public streets (San Diego city allows people to live in their vehicle on any public street). Policy wise there are few states as accommodating of the homeless as Ca.
Why would a homeless person choose to live elsewhere? Not an easy problem to solve but it does explain part of why there are so many homeless in Ca (many and large homeless camps - there used to be a very large homeless camp by Angel stadium, not sure if it is still there, smaller encampments are everywhere).
Expensive housing, political and environment climate that accommodates the homeless contribute to the large homeless numbers. The economy is solid but the homeless problem seems to continue to get worse is So Cal.
BTW my brother has not held full time work in over a decade. He is 52 now. He has a range of issues. Psychological issues are persistent. He has fought drug dependencies a couple/few times. He is so unreliable that he cannot hold a regular job (even part-time job). We provide him a place to live. There are days that he does not leave the place. Other days he is great. Gardens, occasionally fishes, has a BBQ, goes out with friends. We have also provided him a car when we were done with it. I suspect it never had oil added/changed after we gave it to him. Are we enabling? I do not believe so because it is my view he is not capable of supporting himself. If we did not provide him a place to live he would be living on the street and possibly dead. My wife and I expect to need to help support my brother for life (ours or his). Due to my brother, I am familiar with the problem and the difficulties dealing with the problem.
These paragraphs caught my attention:
"The environmental climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Near the coast it rarely freezes or rarely breaks 90 in the summer. Environment climate wise there likely is no state better for homeless."
When I made my first visit to the beach at Santa Monica and saw how the homeless lived (on the beach) with access to showers (again on the beach), I literally flashed back to all those homeless people I would see in NYC freezing in the winters, trying to warm themselves on the subway grated vents. I know quite a few of them lost their lives. Ditto in a few other mid west big cities.
"The political climate of Southern Ca is attractive for the homeless. Food banks, homeless shelters, allowing people to live in their vehicles on the public streets (San Diego city allows people to live in their vehicle on any public street). Policy wise there are few states as accommodating of the homeless as Ca.
Why would a homeless person choose to live elsewhere? Not an easy problem to solve but it does explain part of why there are so many homeless in Ca (many and large homeless camps - there used to be a very large homeless camp by Angel stadium, not sure if it is still there, smaller encampments are everywhere)."
I didn't think about this but you hear this over and over and over again. If you're in real estate in any shape form or fashion this thought has had to cross your mind at least once. If we just did nothing and allowed our neighbors to dangle in the wind, how long would it take till that plight arrived at our door steps. One day, some genius will wave a wand (Re: Years of thinking and planning) to permanently solve this problem.
This is an actual title I saw recently. I saved it to read at a later date. Maybe the time is now...
"Here's how Finland solved its homelessness problem"
@Ali Boone
I grew up in California. It has prettier scenery and better weather. However, the quality of life in Los Angeles almost seems to have declined a bit because of the traffic. If you're in Glendale and you have a meeting in Santa Monica, it is almost not workable anymore. San Diego seems to be more livable.
I've lived in NYC and Los Angeles for significant amount of times.
Choosing to live somewhere can be a choice. It's not always a choice but it can be.
This is an actual searchable title - "There are 6 ways to get from Glendale to Santa Monica Pier by train, subway, tram, bus, taxi, car or towncar"
I used to get my kicks in San Diego. From the Chula Vista all the way to the gas lamp district. San Diego is very livable as you say but there are certain amenities that San Diego simply cannot match Los Angeles for. Again, it comes down to choice. Chicago and a few other cities in the mid west are great and can be almost as expensive too. It's all mostly a choice to be redundant.
@Francis A.
It is a preference, but after I left California for New York, I realize I like urbanism. Los Angeles and its connected cities feels like one big suburb, dominated by the automobile. You're right, there is more to do in parts of Los Angeles. If I returned, I would have little interest in living in the Beach communities and more toward downtown/Hollywood.
Glendale/Santa Monica was an example of time consumption of travelling. I now fly into Burbank because the commute to LAX takes too long.
The people i know who are leaving san diego are the single earner families whos quality of life will be much better (for their kids). An engineer salary of 100-120 is still tight here wiith a family of 4. In another state the ratios work out.
Given that tax season is upon us, the sting of California income tax is still fresh on my mind. As much as I daydream about escaping it, what keeps me here is that a smaller slice of a really big pie... is still a lot of pie. There is just a heck of a lot of business to be done here.
@Francis A.
It is a preference, but after I left California for New York, I realize I like urbanism. Los Angeles and its connected cities feels like one big suburb, dominated by the automobile. You're right, there is more to do in parts of Los Angeles. If I returned, I would have little interest in living in the Beach communities and more toward downtown/Hollywood.
Glendale/Santa Monica was an example of time consumption of travelling. I now fly into Burbank because the commute to LAX takes too long.
@Brian Ploszay
I don't want to say that downtown LA was a shanty town when I moved here from the big apple. That's too strong a word but BOY was it scruffy. I give a metric TON+ of credit to Mr Anschutz for building the Staples Center. He was way way way ahead of his time on that score. That building alone and the entertainment draw that it is and still continues to be, has single handedly led the transformation of downtown here. The building boom has caught on so much that you're seeing it spread to Chinatown.
You should see the place now. You want Urbanism? You got urban but the price I'm afraid has steeped up sharply. Funnily enough, we now rent to relocated folks from your adopted town. I don't know if you're aware, but your town kicked the new George Lucas museum out of town. That structure is now above ground (so to speak) in the construction phase.
For some reason, it garnered a lot of ill will in your town. I was kind of shocked. One particular article was needlessly taunting in tone. Blew my mind. I have a certain family member who lived in Chi town for decades. He's still scratching his head at this. Meanwhile over here, I've taken pictures at each stage of the construction to document this. Once again, movement is afoot here. Downtown LA Honda has built a $30 million building a mere 3 blocks away in anticipation of future growth. New train stations are popping up in strategic locations which all but makes sure to enhance living (in terms of public transportation) here. As you know transportation and the 405 freeway alone can be a deal breaker.
USC ain't doing badly either. (We'll try to forget the recent news about overzealous parents "trying" to make sure that their babies have diplomas from that famous school).
Pick your choice and from the following headlines and Google this museum topic. I'm still shaking my head.
“Let’s celebrate the loss of the Lucas Museum”
“Editorial: Ugly parking lot victorious over Lucas Museum”
“Lucas Museum Chicago: Losing the Museum Would be Bad for Chicago”
"Lucas Museum drops plan to build in Chicago"
"Here's what you could have won: Lucas Museum breaks ground in LA"
"George Lucas Strikes Back: Inside the Fight to Build the Lucas Museum"
A while ago when the downtown transformation was taking place (and it still is) we almost rented an apartment above the Ralphs grocery store on the corner of Hope Street and 9th. I first saw that kind of mixed use building in Georgetown, DC. Shopping, restaurants, cinema and grocery shopping in one building? I was hooked.
Check out "Curbed LA". Specifically, LA Development. You won't recognize it anymore. My folks down in MN and WI are still dealing with the winter. How's it where you are?
@Francis A. Good to talk about downtown. The downtown L.A. office market was anemic in the 90s. Office building were built in a decentralized way in So Cal. You have groupings in West LA, Glendale, Pasadena, Wilshire corridor, Century City, etc... But the way they built office buildings (decentralized) reflects that this is an automobile oriented city, which is my main contention with Los Angeles.
Downtown L.A. today is desirable and that is a good thing. And it is urbanism and I like it. Apartments are going up, all over the L.A. basin, and this is good.
I am aware of Chicago's problems. In my posts, I never touted Chicago. Chicago has always lost population to towns out West, but they made it up with immigrants. And the George Lucas museum was an inflicted wound for Chicago. Media museums rightly belong in LA anyway. A similar misstep recently happened in NYC with Amazon.
Since we are on a real estate blog, remember that California ranks dead last for impediments for new development in the Country. The main reason real estate is so expensive is not because "everybody wants to live there," but because the supply of real estate cannot be built to meet shifting and increasing demand.
During the remainder of my lifetime, California will retain one of the strongest economies in the Nation. And Southern California constantly transforms itself. I expect the City to look different in the next 20 years.
@Francis A. Losing the Lucas museum was ridiculous. But stuff happens. We have a Friends of the Park group that is pretty militant about protecting the lakefront. They are also fighting the Obama Library hard. They can seem ridiculous sometimes but overall they have kept it beautiful and it hasn't fallen to over-development.
If it wasn't for groups like them, I can only imagine the crap that would get constructed.
Conversation interrupted by life but I'm back! I hope you all are well. Interesting comments that you put forth. In the end I think mindset factors in hugely in terms of choosing where to invest in RE. If for whatever reason, the investor is in a tough part of the country, having a the fortitude and desire helps to weather storms and be creative in terms of sticking with said investor's RE investments.
I just watched this video by Los Angeles realtor STEPHAN GRAHAM. You should watch it when you can and see what you think. Both he and another channel on Youtube called MEET KEVIN are milking Grant Cardone for all their worth. I totally get their drift. This video is along those lines also.
Google -- " Lets talk about Grant Cardone and why I don’t buy 16+ unit properties".
Regarding losing the museum. I read about the Friends of the Park group. Ironically, I totally get them. I have people in my circle in the field of planning. It's tough. Sometimes, you're damned if you don't and damned if you do. In the end, all they can hope for is that their decisions in the past proves to be at least close to what they hoped for.
In the meantime, I'll send pictures (if I can). Ha!
Finally, there was another article that I think you all might enjoy reading for perspective on the Real Estate what the future portends.
Google --- " Big backyards and pools are California’s past. Apartment buildings are its future ".
Ya, it is frustrating when you take into account gas prices, car registration prices, price of gas, property taxes, state taxes, traffic, etc... but salaries and weather arent close in much of the rest of the country.
The high CA prices can be turned from a negative into a positive. We developed a program that helps homeowners with their payments, paying off their loan faster, or an additional stream of income. It works best because of the high loan values needed for most properties.
You hit the nail on the head. It seems you painted a picture for an article that came across my newsfeed this morning.
Here is a blurb: "San Francisco is considering imposing a fee to drive into its busiest neighborhoods. A fee to drive into parts of Manhattan was approved on Sunday as part of the New York State budget.
Here is the title:
Congestion Pricing: N.Y. Embraced It. Will Other Clogged Cities Follow?PS:
Your article on financing 2 times a year looks interesting. I have a friend who manages about 100 buildings here in LA. The one thing that stuck with me was what he said about his bosses constantly re-fi-ing their properties. Maybe they listened to you. I'll pass it around my network.
I would not be surprised if thats the way these cities go. It would force commuters to look into other modes of transportation besides driving their commuter everyday.
Yes, its a very lucrative way to invest in real estate or simply be mortgage free in a fraction of the time. And I appreciate the networking Francis. Once my borrowers have a few properties renting and refinancing at the same time, their income snowballs fast.