Real Estate Investor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2016 · 451 posts · 150 votes
Hello Folks,
Its that time of year again, the request from the CPA's and accountants. However this year, I am in need of some help in that area. WHY?
Well my last CPA did a good job in filling 2023. However, I had some PII concerns. I would receive personal information [documents] that were for other clients. At the time, I was on the hills of some major identity theft and a compromised email account situation. So that was a huge red flag.
Current CPA has dropped the ball. I Provided my taxes for 2024 in time to file an extension. However it took so long that 2025 tax were submitted well in time for April 15. Yet in still, $2500 fine for 2024 and $5500 fine for 2025, for filling late. For 2025, I have 2 members in my LLC for some reason now.
What do I do, moving forward. How do i properly vet an Accountant, CPA and Bookkeeper? I am in Tennessee if that helps.
I would recommend referrals from other investors and also those on BP. There’s a lot of great real estate CPAs on here so try to see who you might connect well with and reach out.
Biggest things I’d be asking for:
1. How much capacity do you have and how many returns do you do? 2. What types of clients do you typically work with? 3. How familiar are you with cost segs/bonus depreciation?
Lot more questions but that’s a start!
On the late filing on the LLC, I would try to get first time abatement for one of the years if you haven't taken that.
Referrals is the best way to hire an accountant and a bookkeeper. Also, these roles as you already know, can really affect your finances in a big way. It's important to not select a person based on how cheap they are. My CPA is good, she is based in Orange county (California). If you want, I can give her contact info using DM.
I'm sorry you've been dealing with that. Those penalties may not be final, though. A $5,500 penalty with two LLC members looks like the late-filing penalty on a partnership return, which is charged per member per month. Small partnerships with 10 or fewer members can often get it removed under Rev. Proc. 84-35 if each member reported their share on time. First-time abatement can also cover a late-filing penalty if your prior three years are clean. It's worth requesting both before you pay.
The bigger question is why the LLC suddenly has two members. If someone added a member on the return without a real change in ownership, your filing requirement went from a Schedule E to a full partnership return, which may be what triggered all of this. Check how the IRS has the LLC classified, and fix it if it's wrong.
On vetting, confirm the license with the Tennessee Board of Accountancy, and ask whether they use a secure portal instead of email for documents, since tax preparers are required to have a written security plan. Get an engagement letter with filing dates in writing, and ask how many real estate clients they handle. Feel free to DM me, I’d be happy to share a few resources that might help.