Hi - I'm a 1st time investor under contract for a duplex in Indianapolis. It's a property listed as duplex, but reality it is 2 separate structures - a front and a back structure-legal. DSCR loan offered to me on $177k purchase, 25% down - financing $132,750 is a rate of 8.890%. My middle score is above 660. Shouldn't I be able to do better?
On a duplex that's really two separate structures, the lender has to treat it the right way, and some shops price that kind of property higher or just can't underwrite it. With 25% down and a middle score over 660, you should shop it before you lock anything in. Pricing on DSCR moves a lot with the lender, the points, and whether there's a prepay penalty, so compare the full cost and not just the rate. Ask for the rate with and without the prepay, and ask whether they count it as one 2-unit or two separate buildings. We close DSCR, fix and flip, hard money, commercial and conventional loans in-house, so I can price this out a few ways. Happy to walk through the numbers, give me a call (my number's in my signature below).
On a duplex that's really two separate structures, the lender has to treat it the right way, and some shops price that kind of property higher or just can't underwrite it. With 25% down and a middle score over 660, you should shop it before you lock anything in. Pricing on DSCR moves a lot with the lender, the points, and whether there's a prepay penalty, so compare the full cost and not just the rate. Ask for the rate with and without the prepay, and ask whether they count it as one 2-unit or two separate buildings. We close DSCR, fix and flip, hard money, commercial and conventional loans in-house, so I can price this out a few ways. Happy to walk through the numbers, give me a call (my number's in my signature below).
Terry, I'd shop it. Not because 8.89% is crazy, but because you really don't know if it's good until you have two or three quotes on the exact same terms.
From the DSCR rate sheets I've looked at this month, a 660-679 score at 75% LTV is mostly landing somewhere in the mid 7s to low 8s. Those sheets usually assume a bigger loan and a 5 year prepay penalty though, and smaller loans like yours often price a little higher. So you may not get to the advertised number, but it's worth asking.
When you ask, make the quotes match. Same down payment, same prepay, same points. Taking no prepay penalty can add half a point or more on some programs, so find out what this quote assumes. Also ask where your score sits in their tiers. If you're at 670-something, getting over 680 can bump you a tier, and that's sometimes worth a couple weeks if your contract timeline allows it. And ask if the front/back setup changes anything for them so there are no surprises at appraisal.
One Indy thing from the realtor side: make sure your numbers are using the right taxes. If the seller lived in one of the units, their bill may have the homestead cap on it. As a full rental you'll be at the 2% cap, so your escrow can come in higher than the listing shows, and that moves your DSCR ratio too. With two separate buildings I'd also get your insurance quote on both before closing.
What are the two units renting for? That'll tell you how much cushion you have at 8.89 vs something in the 7s.
Insurance agent here: how to insure it depends on how you plan to use the two buildings, for example leasing them to separate tenants, and on each carrier's rules. Most likely you'll end up with two policies, one for each building. Get quotes on both before closing, and confirm they meet your lender's requirements. Happy to help more by DM.
At a 660 middle score and 75% LTV, 8.89% isn't out of line, but it's worth shopping. The big levers on DSCR pricing: credit tier (680 and 700 are major breakpoints, so ask about a rapid rescore), LTV (70% often prices noticeably better than 75%), prepay (a 5-year prepay usually buys the rate down versus 3 years or none), and the DSCR ratio (1.25+ prices best). Ask whether the quote includes points, and compare rate and total cost together. Two separate structures can trip up some DSCR lenders, so confirm it's one parcel and one legal description before you lock. What do the two units rent for, and what prepay is the quote built on?
Hi Terry, congrats on your first deal! The lenders here have explained the rate side well, so just one thing I didn't see mentioned.
Since you're already under contract, you can ask the seller for credits toward your closing costs and use them to buy your rate down some sellers would rather give a credit than drop the price.
Also check your closing date before you switch lenders A new lender usually needs a new appraisal, so make sure you have enough time.