Real Estate Investing Forums

House hacking a double in Indy? What I walk first-time buyers through
House Hacking
Indianapolis, Indiana
House hacking a double in Indy? What I walk first-time buyers through

I get a lot of first-time investors asking about house hacking in Indy, usually a double where you live on one side and rent the other. It's still one of my favorite ways to start, mostly because an owner-occupied loan can mean a much smaller down payment than the 15 to 25% my investor clients us...

Indianapolis Investors - Looking to Connect with Investor - Friendly Agents
BRRRR - Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat
Indianapolis, Indiana
Indianapolis Investors - Looking to Connect with Investor - Friendly Agents

Hey everyone! I'm currenly looking at investment opportunities in Indianapolis with a focus on fix-and-flips and BRRRR properties. Some of the areas I'm interested in are Fountain Square, Garfield Park, Near Southside, Beech Grove, and 46201, but I'm open to other areas if the numbers make sense....

Out-of-State Investors (CA) Targeting Indianapolis for First Fix & Flip – Let's Conne
Rehabbing & House Flipping
Indianapolis, Indiana
Out-of-State Investors (CA) Targeting Indianapolis for First Fix & Flip – Let's Conne

Hello BP Community! 👋 My partner and I are officially launching our out-of-state real estate journey, and after running the numbers on several Midwest markets, we are zeroing in on Indianapolis, IN. I am based in San Francisco, CA, focusing on operations and networking, while my partner handles t...

Out-of-state BRRRR underwriting: what would you verify before buying?
Out of State Investing
Indianapolis, Indiana
Out-of-state BRRRR underwriting: what would you verify before buying?

I'm looking at an Indianapolis four-bedroom, one-bath house with a garage as a BRRRR example. It's 1,217 square feet, built in 1963 on a slab, and needs a roof, HVAC and cosmetics. The asking price is $80,000. Using a $60,000 renovation budget puts the purchase and rehab at $140,000, before closi...

DSCR 1st Time investor
Indianapolis Real Estate Forum
Indianapolis, Indiana
DSCR 1st Time investor

Hi - I’m a 1st time investor under contract for a duplex in Indianapolis. It’s a property listed as duplex, but reality it is 2 separate structures - a front and a back structure-legal. DSCR loan offered to me on $177k purchase, 25% down - financing $132,750 is a rate of 8.890%. My middle score i...

Beginner remote wholesaler: how do you vet an investor-friendly title company in Indi
Wholesaling
Indianapolis, Indiana
Beginner remote wholesaler: how do you vet an investor-friendly title company in Indi

Hi everyone, I'm Emmanuel, new to wholesaling and studying the Indianapolis market remotely. Before I put anything under contract, I want to understand the closing side. For those who have closed assignments or double closes in Indy: 1. What did you look for when choosing a title company? 2. Are ...

Buying an Airbnb in Indianapolis? The permit and tax basics in plain English
Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions
Indianapolis, Indiana
Buying an Airbnb in Indianapolis? The permit and tax basics in plain English

I'm an investor-focused agent here in Indy and our team manages short-term and midterm rentals, so I get some version of "can I even Airbnb this?" almost every week from out of state buyers. Figured I'd put the basics in one spot since the rules changed in the last couple years and a lot of older...

Terrible experience with my property manager in Indianapolis.
Managing Your Property
Indianapolis, Indiana
Terrible experience with my property manager in Indianapolis.

I purchased a duplex in Indianapolis (46205) toward the end of 2025, and unfortunately, my experience with T&H Realty as the property manager has been extremely disappointing. The property had one occupied unit when I purchased it, and that tenant has been great. The duplex was also in reasonably...

Adding a fourth bedroom increased Section 8 rent by $451/month in Indianapolis
BRRRR - Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat
Indianapolis, Indiana
Adding a fourth bedroom increased Section 8 rent by $451/month in Indianapolis

On a recent Indianapolis rental, we changed the door, closet and window layout to turn a three-bedroom house into a four-bedroom. That fourth bedroom added $451 a month in Section 8 rent—$5,412 a year in additional gross rent. The property now rents for $2,464 a month. Added expense only around $...

Property Management Referrals
General Landlording & Rental Properties
Indianapolis, Indiana
Property Management Referrals

Hey all, I am looking to find and vet property management companies in the greater Indianapolis area to add to the trusted network that I refer out to my clients. If you have an active recommendation for a local PM you trust for residential or small multi-family assets, please drop their name bel...

Is seller financing really happening?
Creative Real Estate Financing
Indianapolis, Indiana
Is seller financing really happening?

Hello, Looking to hear from owner's that have done a seller financed deal or knows of someone that did and what was the outcome, good or bad?

CLOSED — Looking to Buy Single-Family in Indianapolis (46219 / 46205)
General Real Estate Investing
Indianapolis, Indiana
CLOSED — Looking to Buy Single-Family in Indianapolis (46219 / 46205)

Update: no longer buying in this market — post closed.

Converting My First Primary Residence Into an Airbnb After Buying a Second Home
Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions
Indianapolis, Indiana
Converting My First Primary Residence Into an Airbnb After Buying a Second Home

Hi everyone, I'm looking for advice from investors who have gone through a similar situation, particularly those who purchased a new primary residence and converted their previous home into a short-term rental (Airbnb/Vrbo). Here's a little background on my situation: First home: Purchased in May...

Pay with Line of Credit?
Investor Mindset
Indianapolis, Indiana
Pay with Line of Credit?

Hi! I'm looking for my first flip. I have a 200k line of credit. Should I purchase a property using my line of credit since its a significantly lower interest rate? It would essentially be a "cash offer" so maybe more negotiation room on purchase price? It's my first flip and it's not where I liv...

I’m new to the Indianapolis area
Indianapolis Real Estate Forum
Indianapolis, Indiana
I’m new to the Indianapolis area

Hey everyone! 👋 I’m new to the Indianapolis area and looking to connect with local real estate investors and fix-and-flippers. I work full-time but would love to help on my days off or weekends. I’ll swing a hammer, sweep floors, or buy you a coffee just to learn! Not looking for money or handout...

Buying a new construction rental in Indy? Here's what I'd ask the builder
Land & New Construction
Indianapolis, Indiana
Buying a new construction rental in Indy? Here's what I'd ask the builder

I build new construction duplexes and quads in Indianapolis, so I'm on the other side of this conversation a lot. These are the questions I think every buyer should ask, whoever the builder is. Was it designed as a rental? Two full baths, flooring that can take a beating. A house built for an own...

What’s Your Buy Box in the Indianapolis Market Right Now?
Wholesaling
Indianapolis, Indiana
What’s Your Buy Box in the Indianapolis Market Right Now?

Hey BP — I’ve been working the Indianapolis metro for a while now and I’m curious what other wholesalers and buyers are seeing on the ground. I’m pulling deals across inner-city Indy, the suburbs, and out into Hamilton County. ARVs in the $175K–$300K+ range seem to be where the most activity is, ...

Indianapolis: 1,184 of 3,501 homes for sale cover the full payment at 25% down
Market Trends & Data
Indianapolis, Indiana
Indianapolis: 1,184 of 3,501 homes for sale cover the full payment at 25% down

Each week I run all 1–4 unit homes for sale in the city of Indianapolis through one test: would a 12-month lease cover principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA? That's DSCR 1.0, the test a DSCR lender uses. Today's list (Oct 29): - 20% down: 849 homes pass - 25% down: 1,184 pass - 30% down: ...

22 Years Old With $60K Saved and $1K/Month Guaranteed Income – What Would You Do?
Buying & Selling Real Estate
Indianapolis, Indiana
22 Years Old With $60K Saved and $1K/Month Guaranteed Income – What Would You Do?

I’m 22 years old and trying to figure out the smartest way to get started in real estate investing. I’d love to hear what experienced investors would do if they were in my position. Here’s my current situation: $60,000 in savings that I can put toward investing. $1,000/month in guaranteed, non-ta...

Out of state investor needs advice
General Real Estate Investing
Indianapolis, Indiana
Out of state investor needs advice

Hello, I’m a Santa Barbara base investor looking to purchase one to three homes in the Indianapolis area in the next three-six months. Here are my expectations under $100,000 purchase price with $12-$15,000 in rehab cost and to have an ARV of plus $200k. I would like to refi within 90 days pull o...

Mutlifamilly Duplex or Triplex
Multi-Family and Apartment Investing
Indianapolis, Indiana
Mutlifamilly Duplex or Triplex

Hi everyone, It's been a while since I've posted in these forums, but here's a quick backstory. I have one investment property in Indianapolis that I purchased three years ago. It's a single-family home (SFH), and my goal has always been to purchase a duplex or triplex next. Is it possible to pur...

Indy buy-and-hold: 4bd/2ba at 1265 W 34th St—lining up buyer BEFORE I bid (HUD-owned)
Wholesaling
Indianapolis, Indiana
Indy buy-and-hold: 4bd/2ba at 1265 W 34th St—lining up buyer BEFORE I bid (HUD-owned)

Hi all — Arrell Rosswilliams with Stta-Qna LLC. I'm a wholesaler active in Indianapolis, and I'm lining up an end buyer BEFORE I bid on a HUD-owned rental in 46208, so I'm gauging interest here first. 1265 W 34th St, Indianapolis, IN 46208 — 4bd/2ba, ~1,564 sqft, built 1920 (Armstrong Park) - Ren...

Lending Options for First Time Rental Property Investor
Creative Real Estate Financing
Indianapolis, Indiana
Lending Options for First Time Rental Property Investor

New to the Property Investment space but learning more every day. I am looking for any positive and negative experiences, or preferences regarding financing first property. Does DSCR Loan make sense or standard mortgage financing? Curious on everyone's thoughts and experiences. Thanks!

Out-of-State Investor building my Indy team (value-Add deals)
Indianapolis Real Estate Forum
Indianapolis, Indiana
Out-of-State Investor building my Indy team (value-Add deals)

Hi, I’m Michal. I’m getting started investing in Indianapolis, focused on value-add opportunities and building a long-term presence in the market. Having a trusted local team is just as important to me as picking the right area. My first priority is connecting with an investor-friendly agent who ...

New- Looking to invest in LTR in Indy area using HELOC.
New Member Introductions
Indianapolis, Indiana
New- Looking to invest in LTR in Indy area using HELOC.

Hello, I am looking for more information about finding my next deal possibly using a HELOC. Any leads on a lender and info on how it works etc.. I'm thinking I would like to try and find a multiunit in the Indianapolis area. Currently I own 1 LTR in Greenwood, IN and live/own a condo in Los Angel...