Real Estate Agent · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2022 · 195 posts · 79 votes
I'm an investor-focused agent here in Indy and our team manages short-term and midterm rentals, so I get some version of "can I even Airbnb this?" almost every week from out of state buyers. Figured I'd put the basics in one spot since the rules changed in the last couple years and a lot of older threads are out of date.
Indianapolis started its short-term rental permit program January 1, 2025. You need a permit for each STR unit, it's annual, and the first one is a one-time $150 fee. Renewals are free. The home also has to be a legally built dwelling that meets building code.
Indy can't just ban them either. State law (IC 36-1-24) limits what cities can regulate on STRs and caps the permit fee at $150. What it does NOT do is override HOA or condo rules. This is the one that bites people downtown. A lot of condo associations ban or limit stays under 30 days, so read the bylaws before you fall in love with a Mass Ave condo.
Taxes: stays under 30 days in Marion County carry 7% state sales tax plus 10% county innkeeper's tax, so 17% total. Airbnb and VRBO collect and remit that on bookings made through them. If you take direct bookings, that part is on you. Stays of 30+ days are generally outside both, which is part of why the traveling nurse / midterm model works so well here in the winter. Ask your CPA how to bill those.
And if you're looking in Speedway for race traffic, Speedway has its own STR ordinance separate from Indy's, so check theirs too.
The city's official info is on indy.gov under Landlord and Short-Term Rental Registries if you want to read it straight from the source. I'm not an attorney or a CPA, so run anything big by them.
For those already running STRs in Indy, what surprised you the most when you got set up?
This is a really useful roundup, and I like that the HOA point is right up front. A city permit doesn't help much if the condo bylaws say no to anything under 30 days.
The 30 day line is interesting from the guest side, too. My wife and I have spent the past four years living mostly in short-term and monthly rentals, and the month-long stays that went smoothest were the ones where the host treated them differently from the start, with a simple written agreement, clear utilities and one person to contact, rather than the same nightly check-in messages.
I'm curious, are most of your out of state buyers planning to run nightly all year, or mixing in midterm stays through the winter?
@Lee Futcher Thanks Lee, and that's a great point from the guest side. The month-long stays really are a different product, and the hosts who do best treat them that way.
A lot of my clients take a hybrid approach. In the slower months of the year they switch their STRs over to MTRs to get through them, and that's usually traveling nurses on 30+ day stays. It keeps the furniture working, and there are a lot fewer turnovers than with nightly guests.
Location plays into it too. Houses close to downtown, the convention center, and the stadiums can usually stay nightly longer, since that's where our event weekends hit hardest. Anything with an easy commute to one of the hospitals is a natural fit for the winter switch. I like to have clients run the numbers both ways before they buy, so the slow months have a plan instead of just sitting empty.