Real Estate Agent · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2022 · 195 posts · 79 votes
I get a lot of first-time investors asking about house hacking in Indy, usually a double where you live on one side and rent the other. It's still one of my favorite ways to start, mostly because an owner-occupied loan can mean a much smaller down payment than the 15 to 25% my investor clients usually put down on a straight rental.
A few things come up every single time.
Taxes are the one that trips people up. You can apply for the homestead deduction on the side you live in, but the rented side generally doesn't get the 1% homestead treatment. So don't just copy the seller's tax bill into your numbers. Check how the split works with the Marion County Auditor before you trust a monthly payment.
If it's in the City of Indianapolis, the rented side needs to be on the city's landlord registry too.
And think about the exit before you buy. When you move out, does the whole thing work as a two unit rental? Could your side work as a furnished midterm if it's near a hospital? I like doubles that work as more than one strategy, because your plans in year three probably won't look like your plans today.
For anyone who's house hacked here, how much of your payment did the other side actually cover?
Good checklist. On your question, coverage swings more on price than on rent. Rough example: a $260K double, 3.5% down FHA at 6.25%, comes to about $2,050-2,100 PITI with MIP. If the other side rents for $1,350, that's about 65% covered on paper. Set aside 10% for vacancy and repairs and it's closer to 58%.
One item I'd add to the list: get the tenant's lease and deposit records on the rented side before closing. On an occupied double, that's where the surprises tend to be.