Indy buy-and-hold: 4bd/2ba at 1265 W 34th St—lining up buyer BEFORE I bid (HUD-owned)

Indy buy-and-hold: 4bd/2ba at 1265 W 34th St—lining up buyer BEFORE I bid (HUD-owned)

Member since 2026 · 1 post · 1 vote

Hi all — Arrell Rosswilliams with Stta-Qna LLC. I'm a wholesaler active in Indianapolis, and I'm lining up an end buyer BEFORE I bid on a HUD-owned rental in 46208, so I'm gauging interest here first.

1265 W 34th St, Indianapolis, IN 46208 — 4bd/2ba, ~1,564 sqft, built 1920 (Armstrong Park)

- Rent: $1,300/mo on this street (renovated comp at 1315 W 34th rents at $1,300)

- ARV: $160–170K | Targeting $98–105K to the end buyer

- Rehab: $30–45K — plumbing and electrical are the big items (both flagged in the HUD condition report); HVAC and water heater tested OK; garage roof needs repair; no appliances

- Taxes current, no liens, no open code cases (22 historical, all closed)

- All-in ~$135–140K → roughly a 1%-rule hold for a buy-and-hold landlord

Full transparency: the home is HUD-owned (Case #156-591937), listed at $93,600. My plan: bid ~$85–88K once a buyer is committed, then double-close. No bid goes in without a buyer — so if the numbers work for your buy box, let's talk before I submit.

Message me here on BiggerPockets and I'll send the full breakdown, comps, and the HUD condition report.

1Reply
596 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 487 posts · 166 votes
    3w

    The most important check here is not the headline rent or ARV, but whether the end buyer can actually close on the terms you are describing. A buyer who likes the numbers but cannot fund the purchase, the rehab, and the holding costs will not help you bid with confidence.

    Before committing, I would want the buyer's proof of funds or financing in writing, a clear agreement on price, rehab scope, and closing timeline, and confirmation of how the HUD bidding and any assignment or double-close rules would work for this specific sale. HUD-owned sales have their own bidding, deposit, and closing requirements, so the process should be confirmed rather than assumed.

    I would also verify the rent with comparable leased homes, not just one renovated example, and get a contractor’s view of the plumbing and electrical work, since those items can move the budget quickly. If the buyer, the bid rules, and the rehab scope all line up in writing, the deal is much easier to evaluate on its merits.

  • Technology · Cairo, Egypt · Member since 2026 · 41 posts · 9 votes
    3w

    Lining up the buyer before you bid is the right order on a HUD house, good call.

    A buy and hold buyer won't look at ARV much. They'll add what they pay you plus the rehab and hold that up against the rent. Your rehab range is wide enough that the same house is a decent rental at the low end and a tight one at the high end. So I'd pitch it to them at the high end. If it still works there, they don't walk when the plumbing and electrical bids come in.

    I'd also ask if they plan to refi out later, since that changes what price they can live with.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.