Any plumbing pros that can answer crazy plumbing question?

Any plumbing pros that can answer crazy plumbing question?

UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes

I have a unit that has experienced way too many plumbing issues. Now it seems I have a toilet that has some issues. For one it doesn't seem to flush very well. The tenants have not complained, but I have noticed that it flushes very slow, has no 'power' to the flush, and you sometimes need to flush multiple times to get it to go down if there is anything but liquid in it.

Well then the other day the tenant sends me some pictures of the toilet filling up with soap bubbles. It seems that when the tenants upstairs take a bubble bath, that bubbles come up into the toilet bowl and up around the bolts and around/through the floor area. I have tried to attach pictures, but the bubbles basically come up from under the floor and up through the toilet. The bubbles on the floor came up through the floor (they did not overflow from the bowl onto the floor).

Does this indicate that the toilet is not installed properly? Or that the toilet needs replaced? Or is there a problem farther down the line? The bathtub in this bathroom was recently plugged but some draino took care of that. Apparently this soap bubble issue happened previously about 4-6 months ago, but they asked the upstairs tenants and found out they had taken a bubble bath and so they didn't worry about it until they saw it happen again this time. What would make the soap bubbles from upstairs come up through the toilet???

0Reply
134 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
12y

Mike you have what is known as a " Partial Stoppage"

In simple language its a "real Stoppage" getting ready to happen.

I strongly suggest you get the person responsible for the maintenance of the building to get a video pipe camera inspection of the main sewer line.These symptoms tell me there could be a really big problem down the road if not remedied quickly .Better take the bitter medicine now and fix things than suffer the consiquiences of a major raw sewage backup incident later

Dave Doyle.

PS Once you sewer line issue is resolved I would reccomend either a Kohler Wellworth or Gerber Avalance Tank Toilet.Very reliable ,,,,,hope this helps,,,DD

Los Angeles

See this reply in the discussion

45 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes
    12y

    Yes I was present. They snaked from upstream. At the time it seems like he said it was a soft blockage and the snake went through it and did not clear it. Seems he was thinking it was some kind of a goo type substance, like maybe food/grease. He said the jetter should take care of it, which it seemed to do for the time. The jetter was also done from upstream, passed by/through whatever was blocking, and pulled back out while jetting on the way back as well.

    So it sounds like the consensus is that a camera inspection would be worth the cost at this point. Does it sound urgent, or something that I can coordinate and schedule when I can be there (possibly a few weeks out)? Is it worth having the city inspect their end first or is this basically for sure on my end? Is it something that likely an annual maintenance snake/jetting will keep things working and save the expense of the camera and applicable repair? If so, can I buy a jetter and do this myself? I tried looking online and didn't find my except industrial jetters. The one they used just hooked to the garden hose, and it seems I could run something like that myself annually and probably save a bunch of money and be able to use it at other properties periodically as a maintenance item. Any idea where to get the right equipment in that case?

  • Investor · Fredericksburg, VA · Member since 2013 · 79 posts · 13 votes
    12y

    I didn't read all the reply's here as there are many. So if you don't read mine I won't be insulted. It sounds to me like there is a venting issue. This can be due to a clogged vent or improper piping behind the walls AND can be exclusive to this bathroom even though it's attached to others. Your first line of attack is to have the lines snaked and/or scoped. I think you did that and it has only lasted a short while. To me this supports the venting hypothesis. Check the website terrylove.com for more expert advice.

  • UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @David Doyle:

    PS Once you sewer line issue is resolved I would reccomend either a Kohler Wellworth or Gerber Avalance Tank Toilet.Very reliable ,,,,,hope this helps,,,DD

    Hey Dave:

    Is the Wellworth the one with the Flushmate pressure assisted flush? Also, how does the Gerber Avalance compare to the Gerber Viper? My plumber has a special on the Viper for $200 installed that seems like a good deal. And how do all these options compare to the Toto Drake that I hear is one of the more popular toilets?

    Thanks for the help.

  • Janesville, WI · Member since 2014 · 37 posts · 8 votes
    12y

    @Mike Palmer Plumber from Wisconsin here. It sounds to me like it is a tree root issue. From what I read it sounds like you have cast iron pipe underground which tends to rust out after a while. Especially with the house being built in 59. Trees seek abundant water so even after the roots have been snaked and jetted, a short time later they grow back. For this, like Mindy also suggested, either replace the lateral going from the house to the street, or have a yearly maintenance plan. At some point though, it will need replacing.

    Obviously before going to any extreme, the best thing to do is, like others suggested, spend a few hundred and get the drain snaked again. (To reduce water/backup.) Then send a color camera down. If its a decent camera they should have a locator with it and can tell you almost exactly where the blockage is and you'll be able to see exactly what it is.

    Also, assuming its not a broken toilet flange, which is what you bolt the toilet to, clearly your wax ring isn't sealing correctly. The plumber will replace that for you after the inspection.

    Good luck my friend and keep us all updated. Unfortunetly, with cast all over the country coming to age, many other investors will run into this problem.

  • Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
    12y

    Att. Mike Palmer and BP friends

    I would strongly suggest you stay away from th "Flushmate" stuff

    Its a time bomb,,,its a black plastic pill shaped vessel that collects compressed air on the water refill of the tank

    They are bad news,,,,if they fail in the middle of the night,,blow out and leak ,,youll have one hell of a problem and an angry client

    Stick to a reliable tank style toilet like the Kohler,Gerber or Toto and sleep at night,,,

    DD

    Los Angeles

  • Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
    12y

    Remember gang,,,

    You can do a camera inspection on a clogged line or a line holding water,,,

    It must be cleared first before you attempt an accurate pipe camera inspection

    Also have it narrated and mark the problems areas foot by foot ,every good video camera system will allow you to note and mark problems areas foot by foot,,

    Last,,,, make or burn a DVD ,,then play it back slowly .make notes,get a professional evalution and make a decision on repairs and an outcome,,,

    Do not procrastinate,,,

    Hope this helps

    DD in Los Angeles

  • UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes
    12y

    Good advice, thank you. If I had to guess I think it is roots. There are several large trees on the property, and that would seem to explain why it is reappearing after working fine for a while.

    Assuming that is the case, are the blasting and lining pipes from the inside (without trenching/digging up) a good reliable fix, or do I just need to bite the bullet and dig it up and replace the entire line?

  • Britt AbbeyPro Member
    Investor · Lowville, NY · Member since 2013 · 65 posts · 18 votes
    12y

    You could try a bottle of Root Kill ($12 at HD). I'd try that before replacing a line.

  • Janesville, WI · Member since 2014 · 37 posts · 8 votes
    12y

    @mike palmer I've heard of the inside lining fixes but I've never seen them done or know anybody in my area who does them. It would be worth checking into if somebody in your area has the equipment to do it. If so, I'd like to hear the price differences between a full repipe and having the liner blown in.

  • Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
    12y

    Hey Gang

    Check out some of the excellent demonstration videos both animation and live footage on ;

    "Trenchless Pipe Replacement" and/or

    "Pipe Bursting"

    Very informative,,,

    I do these type of jobs in So Calif so I can speak with some authority on the subject,,,

    Again my purpose is to strictly give good information and advice

    I like Trenchless as opposed to "pipe lining" because with Trenchless youre actually getting seamless New Pipe and Johns Manville guarantees the stuff 99 years.You can drive a Mack truck over it and it returns to shape.With Lining all youre doing is creating a fiberglass liner inside the original "ancient" clay pipe cracks and all .

    Hope this helps

    DD in L.A.

  • Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
    12y

    Sorry Gang

    I meant to say check out the excellent demonstration videos concerning Trenchless Pipe Replacement on You Tube

    DD in L.A.

  • Investor · Monrovia, CA · Member since 2012 · 219 posts · 79 votes
    12y

    Here is a link to You Tube Videos on the Trenchless Pipe Replacement process

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqQlweiNW1U

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_jmywlLtkI

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMUUCxDOXg4

    Hope theses videos help you visualize the process

    Just want to make a correction ;

    In a prior post I said you can do a camera pipe inspection in a drainline full of water,,,I misspoke ,that is NOT the case ,,,the line must be cleared before you can perform a successful camera inspection

    Best Regards

    Dave Doyle

    Monrovia Calid

  • Mark LangdonPro Member
    Investor · Whippany, NJ · Member since 2010 · 356 posts · 104 votes
    12y

    Stop messing around and get the camera done and then you find the issue once and for all. I had a similar problem on a foreclosure I bought where I couldn't figure it out after paying for 2 snake outs. Once I got them to camera it we found a main house U-trap that kept clogging with gunk. The clean outs were buried under my first floor where I had to cut open the hardwood floors to get at it and fix it once and for all. I had to remove the U-trap as they are illegal for this very reason.

    Camera it and you will know.

  • UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes
    12y

    Ok, so here is the latest on this never ending nightmare sage. I had someone come and pull the toilet and run a camera. They said the camera went all the way to the city line and beyond. Said everything looked great. There was one small root, but they said it was at the top of the line and was not interfering, and that it was beyond my line in the city.

    Come to find out the toilet did not have a flange. There was a wax ring and it seemed to be fine, and the toilet was bolted directly to the concrete floor. I am not sure if this would be the cause of allowing the bubbles to come up through the toilet, but a flange was installed.

    After giving it a clean bill of health and saying everything was good to go (and charging me about twice what I was expecting), they left and I thought we were good. Well then this morning I get the call and the floor drain in the utility room has backed up. Water all over the floor, and seeping to other rooms.

    So, now what? What could this be? There is small food particles in the water around the drain, and that drain is downline of the upstairs kitchen. They did not camera the internal lines because they said they were too small for their camera. Could I have a blockage on a line inside the house (and maybe from the upstairs tenant? How would I check this?

    What to do about the carpet--would a regular carpet cleaner be able to clean them and extract the water at the same time, or does this require a restoration company? Can this wait until tomorrow at this point (it would be much easier and cheaper to get someone out tomorrow), or does this need attended to NOW?

    Any further help/insight MUCH appreciated, and I am completely stumped and frustrated at this point. This is the kind of stuff that gets people out of the business. I would like to persevere and clear this up and hopefully carry on, but I am now over $2,500 and nearly 2 years into this and don't have a solution (or even a clue what the problem is). It is driving me nuts!!!

  • Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 49 posts · 17 votes
    12y

    Sounds like the vent stack. If you pour gas from a can and don't open the little vent at the back, the gas comes out slowly and gurgles. Same principle here. 

    You mentioned several times that it has been snaked. This is the downstream direction so I assume it is ok. The vent stack is the upstream direction. If you can get on the roof you might try running a snake down the vent.

    Good luck!

  • Property Manager · Livonia, MI · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    i just read this thread since i am having the same issue, although not for as long or extensive. i am trying to figure it out.

    no trees on property

    happens only on the fartherst area of the house where the kitchen is on top of basement bath

    suds come up from the sink in the bath and toilet. 

    the other bath is closer to the city, no mention of happening there

  • Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 688 votes
    11y
    The rules of logic will always lead you to the solution...ive found. 1. Water will always flow downhill....aka, if water from upstairs is coming underneath the toilet beneath it and not down the drain, something is preventing it from draining....could be several things: A. Is the drain vented properly? Aka air needs to leave the pipe when water takes its place (imagine a bottle of soda when drinking it how air has to enter when water leaves) not likely but possible. Check it to make sure. B. Main drain is stopped up on your side or city side. Maybe root growth, maybe something that allows water to pass slowly, maybe whatever. Needs to be repaired. C. Drain lines big enough? Throwing too much water down a line too small will cause water to sit until it can drain. Anything else is a conspiracy.
  • Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 688 votes
    11y
    The rules of logic will always lead you to the solution...ive found. 1. Water will always flow downhill....aka, if water from upstairs is coming underneath the toilet beneath it and not down the drain, something is preventing it from draining....could be several things: A. Is the drain vented properly? Aka air needs to leave the pipe when water takes its place (imagine a bottle of soda when drinking it how air has to enter when water leaves) not likely but possible. Check it to make sure. B. Main drain is stopped up on your side or city side. Maybe root growth, maybe something that allows water to pass slowly, maybe whatever. Needs to be repaired. C. Drain lines big enough? Throwing too much water down a line too small will cause water to sit until it can drain. Anything else is a conspiracy.
  • Investor · Jasper GA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    So...

    Did you get it fixed yet?
    What was the problem?

  • UT · Member since 2013 · 164 posts · 55 votes
    11y

    @Bob B.

    I am not sure who you are directing you question to, but I might as well chime in with an update. We believe that the main line has a fairly sharp curve/bend in it downstream, and it tends to gather any food particles or anything solid at all tends to collect there over time and then things start slowly backing up. The upstairs tenants were putting a lot of food and whatever else down the drain and it would start to cause problems. 

    It does tend to give warning signs and I have trained the tenants what to look for and to let me know immediately. I also had them install a strainer in the sink and told them that absolutely no solid waste of any kind is allowed down the drains. 

    I think we have a pretty good handle on it now, but I may just do an annual cleanout on that line to ensure that there are no unexpected issues.  

    @George P. I would assume looking at the pictures that you have something similar going on. In most cases an auger/snake has cleared it out, but in one case it had a lot of greasy build up and the snake would go through it and the goo would just close up again after the snake was pulled out, so we had to use a jetter on it that time. That seemed to clear it out really well and we didn't have a problem for over a year after that.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.