@Liz C. well, I guess that's what it takes to find appreciation in the greater NYC market. That's what they said about Williamsburg and Hell's Kitchen in the 90s, Bed Stuy in the '00s, and Jersey City in the early '10s. Gentrification is a powerful thing and having seen it up front, I wouldn't bet against it. NYC is constantly expanding its borders. I don't think Newark is a sure thing but I think long-term buy and hold investors should be long Newark.
You should definitely reach out to @Darren Sager. In addition to being an investor agent he's a podcast guest and runs the Manhattan BP Meetup so a pretty good guy to get to know if you want to grow.