Real Estate Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2013 · 98 posts · 48 votes
So here is the potential deal, love to hear any ideas. Purchase price is 600k on 3 unit property that should cash flow. I am trying to find out what is the best way to finance it either for short term (flip) or long term(30 years). Price is maybe a little high and that is why it has been sitting on MLS for about 200 days. It probably needs a lot of work. Owners only owe about 250k on the property so have some significant equity. What would you suggest is a good way to get the property with little money down?
My mortgage broker tells me that the owners can't give me the 25% down needed for down payment like it was done in the past. If the seller is willing to have me assume the loan what would be ways to pay them the remaining balance? If they are willing to give me seller financing what would be ways to pay off their loan? Or are their other ways to pick up this property? Thanks for your help.
Originally posted by :
Purchase price is 600k on 3 unit property that should cash flow.
A semi decent property that will cash flow in Los Angeles would likely have been scooped up, not sitting around for 200 days. I would do more research on your expenses to determine if you can change that statement to it will cash flow. Be sure to consider vacancy rate, repairs and maintenance and capital reserves in addition to the normal insurance and property taxes. Just use the 50% guide/rule if you aren't sure about those. If it needs a lot of work, just have your agent ask what type of shape the building systems are in.
If you are still good with it then you can think about partnering up and going for it, but on the surface it seems like something is not adding up.
@Alma Mills You might partner for it. Sounds like you may need to.
You find a money partner who puts in the down payment. You live, fix up, and manage the place in return for equity.
Since the price is high, you might need to speak directly with the owners to be creative with them. Or get the house under a contingent contract so you have something to offer.
What do you think the deal would need to look like?
Partner might be a good way to go. When you mention contingent contract what are you referring to? I am hoping the seller will be willing to be creative as they are currently asking for more than most want to pay. I am not sure what the deal will look like. I guess I would need a private lender to lend the remainder of the purchase if I assumed the sellers mortgage as I would not be able to get a new mortgage on the property right? If I got the seller to finance part of the purchase I suppose I would still need private money to pay off his note right?
If its been on the mls for 200 days , and they want 600K , and it may need work .You may want to ask yourself , " why hasn't someone already bought it? "
Originally posted by :
Purchase price is 600k on 3 unit property that should cash flow.
A semi decent property that will cash flow in Los Angeles would likely have been scooped up, not sitting around for 200 days. I would do more research on your expenses to determine if you can change that statement to it will cash flow. Be sure to consider vacancy rate, repairs and maintenance and capital reserves in addition to the normal insurance and property taxes. Just use the 50% guide/rule if you aren't sure about those. If it needs a lot of work, just have your agent ask what type of shape the building systems are in.
If you are still good with it then you can think about partnering up and going for it, but on the surface it seems like something is not adding up.
Certainly all valid points, its not a smokin deal at that price. Pro forma is $4500 a month in rents but that is not all true as the front house on property is owner occupied. What the condition will be like inside is yet to be determined, just trying to find out how I could pick it up even if the price were 500k. My best assumption is it needs some work but this is an area that is on the way up in value - over 50% increase in value year to year so if it only cash flows a little it will still be a wise decision. I am hoping the fact that is has been on the market for some time will motivate the seller to be flexible in price/finacing etc.
I'm not a long time investor, but I have learned some things. ask yourself some questions and be honest with your answers.
First off you make your money when you buy a place. If its over priced you are cutting into future profits the day you buy it. Did you ever pay too much for a car and try to hold it long enough to make a profit? If it is the RIGHT car and you wait long enough you might do it. (pretty doubtful though) Same goes for real estate. The more you over pay the worse your final outcome will be.
Second how close is it to fitting the 2% rule or the 50% rule. Just from reading your post based on the price, and a 20% down pmt. I wouldn't look at any more than the listing if I wasn't sure I could get 6k a month in combined rents. I'm not trying to start a huge discussion about these rules, but they can be used as guidelines. The 2% rule asks for 12k a month. Remember that's with 20% down, factor in whatever creative financing costs, VACANCY RATE (you gotta make the payment if one unit is empty), and maintenance. if this property will cash flow at an inflated price that is a huge red flag for me. What is driving that? Too high rent? deferred maintenance? or will it even cash flow? (Im bettin on the latter)
Third is this a good property to start my investment career in? do I want to own it in several years What is my escape route. how will I get out of this if it turns south? Remember selling won't be an option if its already over priced.(you will need to hold this one until the market catches up to the price.)
You can bet your gonna be on your own for financing. Banks, mortgage companys, and Private lenders, probably even the owner himself isn't going to be excited about paying too much for a property. (then again maybe he already did)
Buy the way I just sold a house in Colorado, where I did give the buyer $40k for his down payment. The house closed Sept 3rd 2013, so this is recent. the buyer was my son, and I don't know if this matters. It was in CO and I don't know if that matters, but we did gift him $40k as down payment on the loan.
@Alma Mills Can you describe the property? I think you're getting more deal advice than you requested, but your acquisition path does hinge on this being a good deal.
Regarding the contingent question, "contingent upon partner approval."
All advice is appreciated but would love to hear more about how to purchase a this type of property with creative financing ie. little to no money down. If we can negotiate it to a lower price etc.
@Alma Mills First off, you can't know if the property will produce cash flow or not if you have absolutely no idea what the purchase price is going to be, what the cost of your financing will be, what income will be generated by the property, the cost of any improvements, plus all the other costs of maintaining the property (taxes, insurance, etc.)
I will tell you for sure that no lender is going to loan on a property that is over priced, which it is, or it would have sold by now. A lender is going to require an appraisal. Do you at least have current comps for the property?
Nobody can give you helpful information because quite honestly, you don't have any actual information to work with.
In answer to your question, the only way to buy a property with no down payment is to have someone else put up the money, either the seller carrying back or another investor. If it's an investor, you would need to be adding value in some way, otherwise, why would they do that? However; anyone other than the seller will require proof of value, and people giving away money for 100% financing with you putting in nothing probably isn't going to happen. Most lenders will do 65-70% LTV on rehabs. Also, remember that even if you got 100% financing on the property, there's still a matter of coming up with commissions, closing costs, etc.
I don't mean to come off harshly, I understand your position, and trying to get something going. However; for the model you're proposing, it has to be a smoking deal! Maybe you should try to partner up with someone you know.
I like what Alma is saying no money but want a better deal. Have you tried borrowing the money from your family? Do you have cash for repairs, taxes, insurance and any reserves. You might want to visit your local bank to see if they can help you.
@Alma Mills All objections about whether this is a good deal aside, to answer your question, to purchase a property with little/no money down, you can borrow from someone, partner with someone, get private/hard money, or get seller financing. With the seller trying to get top dollar and having a lot of equity, seller financing sounds like the most promising route.
You would probably have to assume the seller's note - that can be risky though, as the lender may be able to call the note if they find out the property has been sold.
I would talk to a competent mortgage broker in the area and see what your options are - local rules and customs can vary.
Very true we do not know if the property will really cash flow until we have more information regarding everything but with conventional financing and using the pro forma rent rates it will, clearly much more information will be needed to make any final decisions. I think Ralph is just not sure if the bank allowed him to gift down payment funds to his buyer because it was his son or if any seller can do that.
Ellis,
My broker did not say that we could not do a subject to with a wrap I was just assuming that...so this can be done? This would be if the seller is willing to do seller financing and simply keep the current mortgage in place so I can buy the property right? What is a TD is it a 2nd mortgage?
@Alma Mills Here's the thing, apparently they aren't motivated or they would have lowered the price enough for the house to sell. Even if you agreed to pay them more than the actual value of the house, you say the house appears to need a lot of work, and you haven't even inspected the interior. For all you know it could be a complete gut to remodel. Therefore; where would you get the money to do the repairs and remodel?
You are wasting your time on this house. Though it's good for you to ask the questions and get your education, it's not a deal you can do.
1. Move into one of the units and get an FHA mortgage for 96.5% of the appraised value. Live there 1 year, rinse and repeat.
2. Assume seller's mortgage and have seller give second mortgage for most of the balance.
3. Buy subject to, not assuming, seller second.
4. Wrap existing first and new seller second into one affordable payment.
5. Have seller finance property at zero interest. (Not as far fetched as it sounds, know somebody who recently bought a 3 unit, moved into one unit and the seller is financing to him at zero interest, 100% of payments go to principle reduction.
I am not sure if the mortgage company allowed me to donate the down payment because I was selling to my son, or if it is something any seller can do for any buyer.
I too am not trying to be harsh, but this deal has too many red flags. Many of us have learned the hard ( and always expensive) way. Bigger pockets has helped me tremendously, unfortunately many things I have read here have only served to reinforce some lesson I have already learned the hard way. I still learn new things here. It is one thing to learn creative ways to buy properties, but would be devastating to purchase the wrong property using them.
Perhaps the approach should be how can you create a deal here that meets enough of the sellers needs to sign on the dotted line.
I sometimes get wrapped up in how many ways I can make the deal happen & ignore the most important factor. The seller. Have a conversation with the seller & probe for motivation.
Be careful with pro forma rents and other figures on the setup. These figures are usually engineered to make the deal look sweeter than it actually is. If you know what other 4-units are trading for in the area and you know what rental units command what price, you should be able to back into the maximum allowable offer that will make financial sense for you whatever terms you decide to set with the seller. Know the market, and you'll know where you need to be to close the deal. Good luck.