Would you do it

Would you do it

James HolmesPro Member
Member since 2025 · 21 posts · 8 votes

Lookingat my first deal. I used the bigger pocket deal analyzer but I wanted to see what people thought here that are far more experienced and willing to help a young rook such as myself.

Would you buy this?

Duplex - 2bd, 2th on each side.

Turnkey - no work needed. Both units currently rented.

Price: 175K

25% down = $43750

Combined rents = $1,400 monthly

Tenants pay all untilities

BP calculated says it cash flows about 350monthly

Wold you do it for your first property?

2Reply
88 views

Most Popular Reply

Dan H.Pro Member
Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
1y
Quote from @James Holmes:

@Jaycee Greene good point and thank your for helping. Here are a lot of numbers :)

Price 175k

gross rent - $1,700. 850 for ea. unit

property tax- $2576 annually

insurance- $1200 annually

lease for both tenants are in place until late 2026

potentially, no repairs needed.

tenants pay all utilities

vacancy rate - 1%
management fee- $170 monthly

total monthly expenses $1391 (Mortgage-900, taxes-214, insurance-100, variable expenses-178)

total monthly income $1700


 If you are allocating for sustained expenses, you should allocate for maintenance and cap ex even if it is a new build.   As soon as an item is placed into service, the lifespan of the item has started.

For example if a water heater replacement is $1200 in your market and lifespan is expected to be 10 years, the water heater has maintenance/cap ex o $10/month.    2 water Heaters means $20/month.   When you do this for each item, your sustained expenses will result in this being cash negative.

Purchase price if $175k depicts an appreciation rate lower than inflation.

I do not see a profit that justifies the risk and effort of residential RE.  where do you see the return coming from?


good luck

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Greg WeikBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Denver, CO · Member since 2020 · 264 posts · 327 votes
    1y

    Hi @James Holmes those rents for each side sound really low - do you mean $1400 for each side, $2800 total? 

    I would want to know more:

    -How long have the current tenants been in each unit?

    -What is the credit score/qualifications/risk profile of each tenant? 

    -Is either tenant behind on rent, chronically late with rent, etc. 

    -Is either tenant on Section 8?

    -Age of major systems: furnace, hot water heater, roof, etc.  

    It sounds like it could be a good deal, but the details really matter on a deal like this. 

    Real Estate Solutions4.4383 Reviews
    • James HolmesPro Member
      OP
      Member since 2025 · 21 posts · 8 votes
      1y

      @Greg Weik great questions and thanks for expanding my approach to this deal. I did not think to ask about tenant rent history.  Not a section 8, but it I have been looking into this. I'll have to make another discussion for that one:) lol

      thanks for helping pay attention to details

  • Jaycee GreenePro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 728 votes
    1y
    Quote from @James Holmes:

    Lookingat my first deal. I used the bigger pocket deal analyzer but I wanted to see what people thought here that are far more experienced and willing to help a young rook such as myself.

    Would you buy this?

    Duplex - 2bd, 2th on each side.

    Turnkey - no work needed. Both units currently rented.

    Price: 175K

    25% down = $43750

    Combined rents = $1,400 monthly

    Tenants pay all untilities

    BP calculated says it cash flows about 350monthly

    Wold you do it for your first property?

    Hey @James Holmes! Given the $175k purchase price, I'm going to assume the rents are $700/month. I'm also assuming you're subtracting the loan payment from the cash flow (which is not the way most investors do it, but I know BP does it that way), is that accurate?

    Without knowing your op exp, vacancy rates, etc., it's really hard to validate your cash flow estimate. Can you share your report?

    • James HolmesPro Member
      OP
      Member since 2025 · 21 posts · 8 votes
      1y

      @Jaycee Greene good point and thank your for helping. Here are a lot of numbers :)

      Price 175k

      gross rent - $1,700. 850 for ea. unit

      property tax- $2576 annually

      insurance- $1200 annually

      lease for both tenants are in place until late 2026

      potentially, no repairs needed.

      tenants pay all utilities

      vacancy rate - 1%
      management fee- $170 monthly

      total monthly expenses $1391 (Mortgage-900, taxes-214, insurance-100, variable expenses-178)

      total monthly income $1700

    • Jaycee GreenePro Member
      Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 728 votes
      1y
      Quote from @James Holmes:

      @Jaycee Greene good point and thank your for helping. Here are a lot of numbers :)

      Price 175k

      gross rent - $1,700. 850 for ea. unit

      property tax- $2576 annually

      insurance- $1200 annually

      lease for both tenants are in place until late 2026

      potentially, no repairs needed.

      tenants pay all utilities

      vacancy rate - 1%
      management fee- $170 monthly

      total monthly expenses $1391 (Mortgage-900, taxes-214, insurance-100, variable expenses-178)

      total monthly income $1700

       @James Holmes What zip code/city is this property in? Even for S8, that rent seems very low for a 2BR unit. There are only a few metro areas in the US where the avg FMR for 2 BR units is less than $850 and most of them are in Alabama and Missouri.

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @James Holmes:

      @Jaycee Greene good point and thank your for helping. Here are a lot of numbers :)

      Price 175k

      gross rent - $1,700. 850 for ea. unit

      property tax- $2576 annually

      insurance- $1200 annually

      lease for both tenants are in place until late 2026

      potentially, no repairs needed.

      tenants pay all utilities

      vacancy rate - 1%
      management fee- $170 monthly

      total monthly expenses $1391 (Mortgage-900, taxes-214, insurance-100, variable expenses-178)

      total monthly income $1700


       If you are allocating for sustained expenses, you should allocate for maintenance and cap ex even if it is a new build.   As soon as an item is placed into service, the lifespan of the item has started.

      For example if a water heater replacement is $1200 in your market and lifespan is expected to be 10 years, the water heater has maintenance/cap ex o $10/month.    2 water Heaters means $20/month.   When you do this for each item, your sustained expenses will result in this being cash negative.

      Purchase price if $175k depicts an appreciation rate lower than inflation.

      I do not see a profit that justifies the risk and effort of residential RE.  where do you see the return coming from?


      good luck

  • Realtor · Westminster, CO · Member since 2022 · 15 posts · 5 votes
    1y

    @James Holmes

    Appreciate you running the numbers—you're off to a solid start! On the surface, $350/month cash flow with tenants paying utilities is decent, but the rent-to-price ratio is a bit tight at 0.8%. For a first deal, I'd want a bit more cushion unless the area has strong appreciation or upside potential. If it's truly turnkey and in a stable market, it's not a bad starter—but make sure reserves and vacancy are factored in. DM me and I’ll help you stress-test the numbers more thoroughly.

    All the best!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.