First new construction infill build: How to make this a great deal?

First new construction infill build: How to make this a great deal?

Austin WilliamsPro Member
Developer · Fort Wayne, IN · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 6 votes

Hey BP,

This is my first new-construction spec build, and I'd like experienced builders and investors to look at this deal and make some comments and suggestions on how you would go about this project. I'm self-managing as a GC through my LLC on an infill lot in Southeast Fort Wayne (ZIP 46806).

The product

  • 1,483 sf, 3 bed / 2 bath, single-story, split-bedroom slab ranch

  • 1-car attached garage (300 sf), front and rear covered porches (278 sf combined)

  • Lot is about 1/4 acre with city water, sewer, gas, and electric available

Land
I already own the lot. It was acquired at no cost, so there’s no land basis in this deal.

Cost estimate
My total build estimate is $197,012 (about $133/sf), from a StartBuild Cost-to-Build report run in June 2026 at a “Good” material class. That covers everything from soft costs and site work through foundation, shell, mechanicals, and interior finishes.

Comps: new construction (built 2020+) in 46806, 3 bed, sold in the last 3 months as of 11/17/26

  • 4292 Werling Dr (0.7 mi from my lot): built 2026, sold October 27, 2026 for $220,000, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,203 sf. That’s $183/sf.

  • 3704 Grayston Ave (1.3 mi): built 2025, sold October 16, 2026 for $259,900, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,361 sf. That’s $191/sf.

  • 3708 Grayston Ave (1.3 mi): built 2025, sold October 2, 2026 for $257,800, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,361 sf. That’s $189/sf.

  • 4528 S Park Dr (0.9 mi): built 2026, sold August 25, 2026 for $182,000, 3 bed / 1 full + 1 half bath, 1,158 sf. That’s $157/sf.

I would love your feedback!

Thanks in advance.

2Reply
430 views

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
    1d

    Running your 1,483 sf through those comps gives roughly 233k at the low end (157/sf) up to about 283k at the high end, so your gross spread is somewhere around 36k to 86k on a 197k build. Before calling it a great deal I'd make sure the 197k includes permits, any utility tap or impact fees, builders risk insurance, interest and carrying costs while it's built and listed, plus your selling costs, since those can eat a big piece of that low end. I'd also lean hardest on the comps closest to your street and check whether they were new or older homes, because 157/sf versus the 190s is a big swing on a first build.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Dhaka, Dhaka · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 5 votes
    1d

    Hey Austin, massive props for taking on your first infill spec build. Self-managing as a GC keeps your margins intact, but 46806 (Southeast Fort Wayne) has some very specific micro-market nuances you’ll want to tighten up before breaking ground.

    Looking at your numbers and comps:

    1. The S/F Spread: Your build estimate of $133/sf ($197k total) leaves a healthy buffer compared to the Grayston Ave comps ($189–$191/sf). However, infill builds in 46806 often hit hidden snags with site prep or utility tie-ins that software calculators miss make sure your $197k includes at least a 10–15% contingency reserve.

    2. The 1-Car Garage Factor: Your plan is a 1-car garage (300 sf) on a 1,483 sf 3-bed/2-bath home. In Fort Wayne resale markets, buyers heavily favor 2-car garages. If local zoning and lot width permit expanding that garage to a 2-car footprint, it will dramatically speed up your absorption rate and resale valuation when you list it.

    3. Exit & Absorption: With interest rates where they are, spec builds sitting over 60 days will eat your projected profit through holding costs.

    Having analyzed sub-market absorption and deep-equity spreads across multiple states, the builders who win on infill spec builds are the ones who cross-reference their retail comps with verified buyer demand before pouring the slab.

    Have you pulled the absorption rates for 3-bed comps specifically in the immediate zip code over the last 60 days, or are you planning to list closer to the median price point of those Grayston sales?

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 615 posts · 175 votes
    1d

    This one gets made in the bids, not the comps. Owning the lot outright is a real head start, and the next step is turning a June software estimate into signed sub quotes for slab, framing, roof and mechanicals, since that's where first builds usually drift. Then add a 5 to 10 percent contingency line on top.

    If you're borrowing for the build, many ground-up lenders count a lot you own toward your equity, but some credit it at what you paid, which for you is zero, so ask that first. Self-GC with no finished builds usually means less leverage, and an experienced builder on your entity helps a lot.

    Are you selling it or keeping it as a rental? A hold gets sized off the rent instead of the sale price.

  • Developer · Boston, MA · Member since 2017 · 267 posts · 142 votes
    1d

    Hey Austin, nice setup with the lot already paid for. The thing I'd push on is the comp math. Your house is 1,483 sf and every comp is between 1,158 and 1,361, and price per foot usually drops as homes get bigger. So I wouldn't multiply your square footage by the Grayston $190 a foot. I'd look at it as a total price instead: the best new 3/2 sold at $259,900, so I'd underwrite your sale around there, maybe a bit higher for the extra room and the porches, not $280k.

    At $197k that still leaves roughly $60k gross, but on a first build I'd assume it shrinks. A software report from June is a starting point, not a budget. On the ground-up work I've done, the stuff that moved the most was site work and utilities: sewer and water tap fees, the gas service, the electric drop, plus grading and fill under the slab. Call the city and the utilities now and get those numbers in writing, since they're easy to price before you dig and painful after.

    Then get real sub bids for slab, framing, roof and mechanicals and swap them in for the report numbers. If you still clear $40k or more after carry and selling costs, I'd build it. For the money, I'd talk to a local credit union about a construction loan and ask how they credit a lot you own free and clear.

    Redgy

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
    1d

    Austin, congrats on the first spec build — and owning the lot outright is a real head start, as others have said. One angle I'd add from the selling side: before you lock in finishes, talk with a local agent who sells new construction in 46806 about what buyers there actually expect at your price point. The 1-car garage is the detail I'd flag — in a lot of markets, that's the first thing a buyer hesitates on, and it's hard to fix after the slab is poured.

    Also, decide the exit before you break ground. A home built to sell and a home built to hold get finished differently, and that choice changes your budget and your timeline. And build your sale timeline into the math the way you'd build in carrying costs — every extra month on market eats the margin you're counting on.

  • New to Real Estate · Gaithersburg, MD · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    1d

    Jimmy and Redgy covered price per foot, so I’ll add pace. Your own search found 4 new-build 3-bed sales in 46806 over 3 months, which is a thin market for a spec house. Before you break ground, count the new builds listed or going up in the ZIP right now. Those are the houses you’ll be competing with when you list. If you find 3 or more, budget 2 to 3 extra months of carrying costs and keep your sale price near Redfin’s $259,900.

  • Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 24 posts · 4 votes
    20h

    Austin, underwrite the sale at $240k and see if you still like the deal. Take off agent commission, a few points of buyer concessions, and several months of interest or carry on the $197k. If what's left is thin for a first build, change the garage or finishes before you pour the slab. Cost is easy to cut before framing and impossible after.

  • Owen RosenBusiness Member
    Professional · Clinton Township, MI · Member since 2015 · 747 posts · 277 votes
    15h

    Insurance agent here: since you're the GC through your LLC, line up two policies before breaking ground. Builder's risk covers the structure and materials, and theft is common on job sites. General liability covers the LLC as the contractor. Get certificates of insurance from every sub naming your LLC as additional insured, and budget both premiums with your carry costs. Happy to help more by DM.

    Royal Oath Insurance Group4.9211 Reviews
  • Denise SuppleeBusiness Member
    Realtor · Willow Grove, PA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 667 votes
    5h

    I think the biggest thing I'd watch is the resale value. Your comps have a pretty wide range, so I'd want to be very comfortable with which ones are truly comparable before committing to the build. Since you already own the lot, you've got a nice head start on the project. I just wouldn't base the deal on getting the highest price per square foot from the comps. I'd also leave yourself plenty of room for construction overruns, delays and selling costs. New construction rarely goes exactly according to the original budget, and that's where I'd want my cushion.

    Spark Rental Co-Investing Club585 Reviews
  • Chicago, Cook County · Member since 2026 · 52 posts · 22 votes
    5h

    The number I'd worry about

    is the $197k. A cost report

    is not a bid.

    - Get real bids on the big

    lines: slab, framing, roof,

    HVAC, plumbing, electric.

    - Ask the city about tap,

    permit and impact fees early.

    - Add a contingency line.

    First builds run long.

    - Count carry costs while it

    builds and sits: loan, taxes,

    insurance, utilities.

    - Your comps are smaller

    homes. Check how $/sf holds

    up at 1,483 ft.

    Kyle

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.