Tax ooops on rental condo

Tax ooops on rental condo

Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 6 votes

Hi guys,

I'm brand new to the site, and I'm loving it.  I've learned so much in the past month - I've already listened to 80+ episodes of the podcast and spent a ton of time browsing the site - so thank you @Joshua D. and @Brandon Turner for monopolizing all of my limited free time - my wife thanks you too :).  I'm starting my investment business in Louisville, KY in the near future, but this question is actually related to my rental condo I have here in San Diego, CA.  I've made a huge tax boo boo that is going to cost me tens of thousands of dollars.  Wouldn't have known about it if I hadn't learned so much on BP, but now that I have, I'm super annoyed at the situation - I guess ignorance would have been bliss - thanks a lot guys for stealing my innocence :)

The stats:

I bought a condo in 2009. It's a beautiful 2B/2BA in a nice area of San Diego (Hillcrest) in a newly constructed building (2007). I paid $405K for it - currently I'm in 7/1 ARM at 2.875% that doesn't adjust until 2020. I got married, got a dog and had a baby, so we bought a house and moved out of the condo in 2013. We've been renting the condo out (for ~$2000 - a little below market value, but not much) and losing money every month since that time - PITI is $1900 but HOA fees are $450 - it's not a big loss compared to my salary, so I was justifying it based on appreciation. And it has appreciated - it's probably up to about $500K market value - But if I've learned anything from you guys it's that cash flow is king and I should never bank on appreciation. And if I've learned anything else, it's that HOAs suck - and sure enough they just jacked up the required elevator move-in/move-out fee from $75 to $500 after the first move-in/move-out. Presumably this is to discourage rentals. So, my plan was to sell after the current lease ends and probably funnel the profit into my newly formed LLC in Louisville. Unfortunately, I just figured out that I hosed myself on taxes. If I sell by 3/16, I'd only be responsible for paying taxes on maybe $5000 after accounting for depreciation and our net losses, because I would have lived in the condo for 2 of the last 5 years. If I sell after 3/16, I'll be responsible for paying taxes on like $100,000+. And I have the mixed blessing of being in the highest tax bracket, so that will be quite a huge hit. And of course, the punchline here is that we just had someone sign a new lease through 8/16. What would you guys do? Here are the ideas I've thought of:

1) Pay the tenant to move out early - this seems cruel as they've just moved in, love the place and they're our acquaintances.

2) Find a buyer before 3/16 that would be willing to assume our tenant's lease.  Doubtful since I don't even cash flow at 2.875% on $318K left on my mortgage.  Any buyer would undoubtedly have a higher interest rate and higher principal, thus even more cash flow negative.

3) 1031 exchange - but I'm looking to use the profit in my LLC, not my personal property, so that might complicate issues? Also,even if that is OK, I'm not sure if I can bank on identifying a good property and closing long distance (San Diego to Louisville) in the required short time period.

4) Continue to hold the property despite losing money. Though I know the general BP feeling is against betting on appreciation, this property really is nice and in a great area and SoCal can be prone to impressive appreciation. I have a great interest rate on a low maintenance property with low maintenance tenants. Also the monthly loss will eventually help me on taxes when I finally do sell. But I'm recently feeling more pessimistic about this as a long term hold because the HOA looks to be getting a little power-trippy with age.

5) See if the tenants would want to buy the condo with some creative financing - I don't think they can afford it or are interested in owning though.

6) Could I sell it to my wife?  She isn't on the condo mortgage since I bought it before we got married, but we do file taxes jointly, so I'm guessing this isn't kosher.

7) Sell when their lease ends 8/16, pay the extra tax hit and chalk it up to a learning experience.

What would you guys do?  Any other creative ideas?  Thanks!  Michael

1Reply
48 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · San Diego, CA · Member since 2011 · 664 posts · 231 votes
11y

@Michael Richardson this will be an outside the box option to consider.

Offer to sell the condo to your tenants with a wrap around mortgage on the 1st trust deed with identical terms as the mortgage and have your tenants pay your mortgage and HOA dues so you have no monthly loss.

Then give the buyers (your tenants) a second trust deed/note for $100k that you carry for five years, or some agreed upon time period, with no payments that accumulates interest with the whole thing due and payable at the end of the note period. At that time they can sell or refinance.

They would owe you $128,335.87 if they held the condo for five years with an interest rate of 5% and everything above that would be their own capital gain which would be tax free up to the $250k/$500k allowable max. You would save yourself from the capital gains tax and have a secured note on the property and your tenant gets into the condo for no money down with the upside of the equity buildup over the next five years. Win win for both of you.

If you have a RMLO (residential mortgage loan originator) do the loan you should be okay with Dodd Frank, but I'm no expert on this and someone on BP with an RMLO license could comment on that.

The other thing to consider is the due-on-sale clause on the mortgage which could be triggered by your mortgage holder when the deed is transferred into your tenants name. Transferring the home into a trust might help to avoid this but it could possibly still happen.

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Shawn CouchBusiness Member
    Investor · Encinitas, CA · Member since 2013 · 116 posts · 48 votes
    11y

    @Michael Richardson 

    I'm not an accountant or tax attorney, so please seek the proper legal advice....

    However....

    You should only be paying capital gains taxes,  plus 25% on the depreciation recapture which is probably not a big amount.  Most likely the cap gains tax is lower than your personal income tax rate. I'm also under the impression that if the occupancy period was originally longer than 2 years, but time out of the residence goes beyond 3 years, that you can prorate that primary residence deduction. 

    Also, you can't just roll over the profits in a 1031 exchange. You can take out some cash or lower the mortgage some (boot), but there is a threshold.

    Call your tax guy, I think you may still be in the clear at the end of your lease.  You can always start to market it towards the end of the lease if you have good tenants. You may need to offer an incentive for good cooperation.  Let me know if you want to see some comps on your unit. 

    Sometimes paying the taxes is the best option too. Maybe you can roll the profits into a turnkey deal in Louisville and end up with some juicy cash flow. I'm sure there's plenty of options for that with folks from BP.

    Good luck.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    11y

    Ahh- capital gains instead of personal income tax rate. Amateur mistake by me! Thanks @Shawn Couch.  You saved me some sleep tonight now that I know I didn't totally screw myself out of tens of thousands! Will definitely run it by my tax guy too.

  • Developer · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    @Michael Richardson I immediately went to the possibility of selling it to your new LLC (though you'd then have to register the LLC in CA) or to a trusted friend/family member who has the means to hold it for a little while. #6 on your list. Or, as you mentioned, seller-finance it to them if you've got the means.

    Then, sell it after the lease is over.

    I don't recall the specifics, but as @Shawn Couch mentioned there is some proration on the primary residence use test... But maybe that's just when converting a rental to a primary residence (N/A in this case).  Someone more familiar with it should comment on that part.

    Good luck!

  • Lender · San Diego, CA · Member since 2011 · 664 posts · 231 votes
    11y

    @Michael Richardson this will be an outside the box option to consider.

    Offer to sell the condo to your tenants with a wrap around mortgage on the 1st trust deed with identical terms as the mortgage and have your tenants pay your mortgage and HOA dues so you have no monthly loss.

    Then give the buyers (your tenants) a second trust deed/note for $100k that you carry for five years, or some agreed upon time period, with no payments that accumulates interest with the whole thing due and payable at the end of the note period. At that time they can sell or refinance.

    They would owe you $128,335.87 if they held the condo for five years with an interest rate of 5% and everything above that would be their own capital gain which would be tax free up to the $250k/$500k allowable max. You would save yourself from the capital gains tax and have a secured note on the property and your tenant gets into the condo for no money down with the upside of the equity buildup over the next five years. Win win for both of you.

    If you have a RMLO (residential mortgage loan originator) do the loan you should be okay with Dodd Frank, but I'm no expert on this and someone on BP with an RMLO license could comment on that.

    The other thing to consider is the due-on-sale clause on the mortgage which could be triggered by your mortgage holder when the deed is transferred into your tenants name. Transferring the home into a trust might help to avoid this but it could possibly still happen.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    11y

    Thanks @Justin R. and @Bruce May  - I really appreciate you guys sharing your insights!

  • Kevin FoxPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 635 votes
    11y

    @Michael Richardson

    Like most others posting in this thread, I am not a tax professional and suggest you seek guidance from a professional more qualified on the matter before taking action.

    Having said that, my personal understanding of how the tax code would apply to your situation is as @Shawn Couch described his interpretation. 

    As far as "amateur" mistakes are concerned; thinking that you had made a mistake that could potentially be very costly, actively working to fix it, and figuring out that you had not put yourself in the less than advantageous position you had thought; seems much better than many of the alternatives.  Imagine if the opposite had been true and you did in fact make a costly error, but failed to recognize and address the issue until it was too late.  

  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    11y

    Since you occupied it for more than 24 months and have only been renting it out since 2013, you may still be eligible for the section 121 tax exclusion on the gain.  Consult a competent tax person @Michael Richardson!  

    Keep things simple. Family member sales, transfers/sales into an LLC and such just sound like trouble to me.

  • Dave FosterBusiness Member
    Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    11y

    @Michael Richardson, You're right that you can't sell the condo and put the profit into your LLC via a 1031. That would not qualify. Deeding the property to your LLC and then selling will not help you either. The taxes will flow through to you.

    But why not keep the property in rental now while you jump start your investing in KY. Then next year when tenant leaves do a 1031 and sell as yourself and buy as yourself in KY and then contribute the new property or properties into your LLC?

    You maintain all the tax advantages of the 1031.  You've minimized bleed with rental in place that is providing some equity build as well as saving the huge tax bill vs a small monthly shortage.

    And you give yourself some time to educate on the KY market.  

    The 1031 Investor5140 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    11y

    Thanks guys!  @Dave Foster - that sounds like a very good idea. So, would the tax hit come when I contribute the Louisville properties that were obtained as myself into the LLC? Or would it still carry over based on the 1031 until the LLC sold the properties?

  • Dave FosterBusiness Member
    Qualified Intermediary for 1031 Exchanges · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    11y

    You should be able to contribute the property to the LLC after the 1031 and not create a taxable event. Your LLC is probably a pass through LLC so the property will continue to be reported on your personal return and a change in deed of that manner should not change the beneficial interest - but verify this with your accountant.

    If that's the case then there would be no recognition of gain until the LLC sells the property - unless the LLC also does a 1031 to buy something in KY or wherever in which case tax is once again deferred - lather rinse repeat.

    The 1031 Investor5140 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    11y

    Gotcha - thanks so much for clarifying @Dave Foster!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.