Advice on my father's turnkeys in Memphis, Dallas, and Philly

Advice on my father's turnkeys in Memphis, Dallas, and Philly

Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes

Hi All,

I'm a 30-year old man with two rental properties in the Washington, DC area.

As of last year, I've also started helping my father, also based in DC, make real estate investments. He is 60, had about $400,000 of investible cash saved from a long career, and also had just inherited a second home from relatives worth $600,000 approximately. Amazingly, he had been keeping the $400,000 in cash uninvested in the bank for almost a decade, and so after finally finding this out I was eager to help him get some return so that his money won't run out.

My father is quite backward when it comes to using technology (e.g. email, internet), and also somewhat ignorant about real estate and rentals, and so my help in researching and transacting property purchases is crucial. We looked at local properties for him in DC but quickly decided they were too expensive and the returns too low. Then we read about turnkey companies on BiggerPockets and decided we would visit some providers... over the last year we have made in person visits to take tours in Memphis (), Chicago (, ), and Philadelphia ().

We liked each of these companies, none of which I am affiliated with, and my dad decided to make the following investments, which are already done:

House #1 - $145,000, 4 BR/2BA single family house in Memphis through Memphis Invest bought in cash late last year. Rented currently for $1300/mo.

House #2 - $130,000, 3BR/2BA SFH in Dallas through Memphis Invest bought in cash early this year. Rented for $1250/mo.

House #3 - $90,000, 3BR/2BA SFH in Philadelphia through ABC Capital bought in cash; my dad is about to close this deal. It is not yet rented; but projections are it will rent for around $1,000/mo.

I am aware that the first two are retail cost and not the best return one can get through other approaches. However, my dad simply lacks the desire at this point to learn deal-hunting, to renovate and/or manage his own properties, etc. He has other priorities and wants something easy, and turnkey investments yielding about 7-9% returns per year seem to fit the bill. We also are stuck in Washington DC where opportunities for truly good non-turnkey deals are quite limited compared to less expensive cities.

Currently, we have also finished renovating and are selling my dad's inherited 2nd property, which is right now under contract for over $600k; he will get almost all of this money as there is no loan on the property and no other significant taxes on the sale; the property is being sold in a country in Europe with no major estate/inheritance or transfer taxes. My dad will then transfer the money here. We have been wondering what might be a good idea for how to diversify this money into different properties. I have suggested to him the following:

  • over the next year, using the 600k cash, buy 2 houses in Chicago, 2 more houses in Philadelphia, and perhaps 1 house in Indianapolis through turnkey companies. I like these markets as they seem to have many houses in the 90-130k price range with decent returns, managed by some pretty decent turnkey companies. I think owning houses in 4-5 major but diverse cities is a good way of diversifying while still remaining within one asset class (do other commenters agree?)

Among other considerations, I've strongly encouraged my father to keep a significant cash reserve and to apply for a HELOC – to be kept as an emergency line of credit, not used, of course. He is doing these things. My dad is a very conservative investor and person, and so I need to keep this in mind when helping him. He also does not live a lavish lifestyle and does not need to profit to the max, so therefore leverage is less attractive to him. Having said this, he does see the advantage of having loans on a limited number of the properties to allow investments in other additional properties.

The biggest question right now is should my father take out loans on some of these houses? Within the next year I expect he'll own 7-8 houses in cash, each worth around or a little over 100k, and each earning about $1000-1300/mo gross rent. I see no reason for him to take too much risk by getting heavily leveraged. Even if he got no loans, he could add another house every year or two just from the returns on the existing houses. My initial suggestion to him was to get conventional loans on two of the houses – this is something he can easily do, as he has very little other debt, and still has a good conventional income. That way if the economy turns bad in one or more of the cities, he will not struggle.

What do others think about the number of loans? I think it is better to be conservative and only have loans on half or less of the properties. But I don't know for sure. We are working on the 75% cash out refinance first loan against the Memphis property right now with SNMC Capital / Team Bighaus () out of Washington State, a company that specializes in making conventional loans to RE investors.

Would appreciate any criticism or suggestion you have of this “lazy” strategy of turnkey investing for my dad... what do you think about the leverage... what about the number / spread of different cities to be invested in... what about other types of real estate or other asset class investments... what about how much money to keep on reserve?

I realize that no one is giving financial advice and the risk is all mine/my dad's. Please just share how you might think if you were in my shoes helping your father. I appreciate any thoughts you have positive or negative.

Thanks,

Matt

2Reply
27 views

Most Popular Reply

Alex CraigBusiness Member
Real Estate Professional · Memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
10y

Your strategy is certainly not lazy, you are simply being a investor. I don't think most realize how hard it is to find deals, find financing, rehab the property, find tenants, deal with tenants and all the surprises that are in the middle. If you want to be conservative, I would not go all in at 75% cash out. I have 17 properties myself and my goal is to continue to buy, but put these on 10 and 15 yr mortgages, get most paid off and at the right time then cash out on a few to invest in more real estate or any other opportunity that may exist. My thought though is to take out 50% or less of the equity so that my cash on cash gross return after the cash out is 25%, which would be to take a $100,000 property, take 50k loan that rents for $1,095. which is very easy to do in the markets I own homes (Memphis and Little Rock). I am 39 and I see myself doing this around 50 to 55 yrs old. At that age, I don't want to take on a higher risk at 75% LTV. I want to make life more simple as I get older and if I have a untimely departure from this Earth, I don't want to leave my 3 daughters with highly leveraged real estate. My method leaves about $500 gross cash flow a month, which turns into about $300 a month cash flow. If I have 30 or so properties at that time, then I am having good cash flow.

See this reply in the discussion

22 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    10y

    Those price/rent ratios you are getting out of state are pretty achievable here in the DC area. You can find those types of numbers right on the MLS if you just look at some of the outer lying suburbs.

  • Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 51 posts · 9 votes
    10y

    Why not buy fewer units that net the same percentage?  If the percentage is the same, he'll be making the same amount and have less of a hassle factor to deal with in terms of renting them out. I'd rather have one quad with one roof, one lawn, etc. in an area I could get to in 45 minutes of beltway traffic.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Interesting, Russell, thanks. We primarily looked in the areas surrounding Washington DC by about a 15-20 minute radius, and not surprisingly didn't find much. We are based in Vienna, VA, and McLean, VA for our own properties, so we know Northern Virginia quite well. I did think of outlying suburbs as a possibility, but never followed through. Do you have specific suburbs in mind in MD or VA? I had thought of investigating areas like Quantico, Leesburg, Lorton, etc but never did it. I was a bit worried by how far outside of the city these areas are and whether they would remain rentable and commutable if the government contracts and the local economy worsens.

    I'm guessing the areas you have in mind would be at least 45 minutes or so out... as you know, traffic here is a nightmare. But as noted, my dad really doesn't want to manage properties, so investing here would likely involve property management too.

    On the other hand, investing in DC is only one more city, and having all his properties here would not be very diversified.

    On the other other hand, I am interested in acquiring another local property myself, and would look at outlying suburbs if you have any leads or suggestions. I do manage my own properties, but for various reasons I prefer not to do this for a family member.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Chris, thanks for thinking of this. In Chicago and Philadelphia there are duplexes and triplexes that we will be looking at. I had this thought, that having fewer properties would be simpler.

    As for properties 45 mins out from the Beltway, like I asked the other commenters, perhaps you could suggest areas near to DC where quadplexes like this exist? I have never seen a quad in Northern Virginia.

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    10y

    I own currently, or in the recent past have owned properties that meet the 1% rule, whI checked is about the ratio you stated in your properties in Frederick, Germantown and Laurel. You can do better than that ratio in PG County. I'm not sure why you would be worried about needing property management here but not in Memphis? 

    The DC economy has been going strong for 50 years. Everyone always says it is going to get worse, or the leviathan of the federal govt will stop growing....but it never happens and likely never will.

  • Queens, NY · Member since 2015 · 130 posts · 34 votes
    10y

    @Matthew S. my decision would be based on a couple of factors - 

    • How long would you like this money to last?
    • Does he have additional investments/assets and are they diversified?
    • What are his annual living expenses?

    From a strictly personal standpoint, I might have leaned towards investing that money in a mixture of stock/bond index funds. My Dad had a pension, would have probably needed the money to last about 30 years and 16k/year (4% of 400k) would have provided more than a sufficient amount of supplemental income for him, as well as having a high probability of success based on historical trends. 

    Your method seems great as well, but may require more "active" participation since you or your Dad would need to manage the managers. I also think you're doing a great job of diversifying to mitigate risk, but if I had a limited amount of money I would be more likely to diversify on the level of an index fund where I could potentially be invested in every publicly traded company in the world. 

    Your situation may differ, so I hope you're able to reach your goals with whatever investment method you feel comfortable with. I've heard good things about a number of the companies you've invested with.  

  • Real Estate Agent · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 51 posts · 9 votes
    10y

    My mate bought a quad in SE for $350k on the far side of the Anacostia. He put some work into it, but it was just deferred maintenance.  He kept all the original tenants. 

    This was 4 years ago or so though. Closer than Phila. Don't get me wrong- there are great deals in Philly and we'd love to have you. 

  • Alex CraigBusiness Member
    Real Estate Professional · Memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    Your strategy is certainly not lazy, you are simply being a investor. I don't think most realize how hard it is to find deals, find financing, rehab the property, find tenants, deal with tenants and all the surprises that are in the middle. If you want to be conservative, I would not go all in at 75% cash out. I have 17 properties myself and my goal is to continue to buy, but put these on 10 and 15 yr mortgages, get most paid off and at the right time then cash out on a few to invest in more real estate or any other opportunity that may exist. My thought though is to take out 50% or less of the equity so that my cash on cash gross return after the cash out is 25%, which would be to take a $100,000 property, take 50k loan that rents for $1,095. which is very easy to do in the markets I own homes (Memphis and Little Rock). I am 39 and I see myself doing this around 50 to 55 yrs old. At that age, I don't want to take on a higher risk at 75% LTV. I want to make life more simple as I get older and if I have a untimely departure from this Earth, I don't want to leave my 3 daughters with highly leveraged real estate. My method leaves about $500 gross cash flow a month, which turns into about $300 a month cash flow. If I have 30 or so properties at that time, then I am having good cash flow.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Hi All,

    Thanks for these these thoughts. Let me respond to each:

    Russell – I will take a look at these areas you mention. I recently visited Frederick and its such a beautiful little town. That might be a place for me to look for deals to rehab and rent at some point. I generally agree with you about the DC economy. My sense of caution is also based on the world economy, which is so heavily based on debt/fossil fuel consumption and will have another serious downturn at some point; we just don't know when. That's why I don't want to have too much leverage for my dad.

    Sean – Good questions. The money should continue for the rest of my dad's life, which will hopefully be at least a couple of decades. However, he is in quite poor physical health for a 60 year old man (very overweight), so I've emphasized to him that this area is even more important than having cashflow. Cashflow doesn't help you if you're 6 feet underground. My dad's financial situation is pretty good: he has a $1,000/mo small mortgage on his primary residence, owns everything else in cash with no other debts/loans, and also has a $10,000/month income from his work that will continue indefinitely as a pension of about $8,000/mo when he retires in two years. So he actually doesn't really need the income from these turnkey investments. But he (and I) think he should invest because otherwise he is wasting the opportunity to be even more secure. My dad does not spend much... he could probably be fine on $3000-4,000 a month in the DC area, including the primary residence mortgage. My dad and I also want to develop a family portfolio that will one day benefit me and my sister, who has serious physical illness challenges and could use an inheritance of income producing properties (but of course I want my dad to live as long as possible, and don't want to inherit right away!). Also... about other investments, no my dad doesn't have many stocks/bonds etc. He and I are very skeptical of the stock market and greatly prefer real estate, for a number of reasons.

    Chris – you are right that there are some quads in DC or very nearby. I forgot about that. I think now the DC market is much more inflated price-wise. Philly is a great market and we are going to buy more houses there, but probably through ABC Capital because my dad doesn't want to go and seek out deals there himself.

    Alex – good idea re: 50% or less cash out refinances. Somehow I had not thought of this. It does make it a lot less risky. You are right that in the hands of someone who doesn't have other assets or doesn't know what they're doing, inheriting highly leveraged real estate can become a timebomb.

    Yes, managing property is a pain a lot of the time. I sometimes get tired even with just the two properties I have here in DC. I am thinking of investing in turnkeys or getting property management myself so that I can be relieved of the burden and just have more time to do what I want.

    Lastly, if anyone reading this knows a good Indianapolis turnkey company, please name it here.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Thank you, Clayton, for this information and encouragement.

    I will take a look at your company, and at the Birmingham market, which I hadn't considered before.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    10y

    @Matthew S.  personally I would not be buying any rental property that is not institutional grade. IE no RISK at all to tenant base like most of the lower end rentals are.

    you may want to explore Lending with a local VERY GOOD reputable HML in your market.

    I suspect you could make 10 to 12% and be truly passive... Since most turnkey type rentals do not go up in value over time.  and tenants = risk to your cash flow... and depereceation is not that important.  then well placed notes or private lending could work nicely for what you want to do

    @Russell Brazil  I bet Russell could refer you around town in this regard.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Hi Jay,

    Thanks for your thoughts. I will have a look around the forums to see what is meant by institutional grade, since I'm not sure. I guess you may mean A/B properties or well-run multifamily. If you can refer me to any more information on that I'd appreciate it.

    My dad prefers real estate over notes/lending due to the tangibility of owning real estate, even out of state, if that makes sense.

    So far, he's only bought nicer properties in B neighborhoods in Memphis/Dallas/Philly... and I think that will continue. We visited C properties, including duplexes with attractive return potential, in Chicago and Philadelphia, but he didn't feel comfortable with those neighborhoods or the risk of lower quality tenants. I told him he should incorporate a few C properties for diversity and because the risk of them is not that great, but he doesn't agree yet, and maybe it's not for him.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Also Jay, want to thank you for your site Turnkey Reviews. It was what got my dad and I started on the path of visiting these cities and buying the houses he has so far.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    10y

    @Matthew S.  I agree with your dad. !!!

    Institiutional grade is A properties for NNN investments. with national tenants as gurantors.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Matthew S.:

    Hi All,

    I'm a 30-year old man with two rental properties in the Washington, DC area.

    As of last year, I've also started helping my father, also based in DC, make real estate investments. He is 60, had about $400,000 of investible cash saved from a long career, and also had just inherited a second home from relatives worth $600,000 approximately. Amazingly, he had been keeping the $400,000 in cash uninvested in the bank for almost a decade, and so after finally finding this out I was eager to help him get some return so that his money won't run out.

    My father is quite backward when it comes to using technology (e.g. email, internet), and also somewhat ignorant about real estate and rentals, and so my help in researching and transacting property purchases is crucial. We looked at local properties for him in DC but quickly decided they were too expensive and the returns too low. Then we read about turnkey companies on BiggerPockets and decided we would visit some providers... over the last year we have made in person visits to take tours in Memphis (), Chicago (, ), and Philadelphia ().

    We liked each of these companies, none of which I am affiliated with, and my dad decided to make the following investments, which are already done:

    House #1 - $145,000, 4 BR/2BA single family house in Memphis through Memphis Invest bought in cash late last year. Rented currently for $1300/mo.

    House #2 - $130,000, 3BR/2BA SFH in Dallas through Memphis Invest bought in cash early this year. Rented for $1250/mo.

    House #3 - $90,000, 3BR/2BA SFH in Philadelphia through ABC Capital bought in cash; my dad is about to close this deal. It is not yet rented; but projections are it will rent for around $1,000/mo.

    I am aware that the first two are retail cost and not the best return one can get through other approaches. However, my dad simply lacks the desire at this point to learn deal-hunting, to renovate and/or manage his own properties, etc. He has other priorities and wants something easy, and turnkey investments yielding about 7-9% returns per year seem to fit the bill. We also are stuck in Washington DC where opportunities for truly good non-turnkey deals are quite limited compared to less expensive cities.

    Currently, we have also finished renovating and are selling my dad's inherited 2nd property, which is right now under contract for over $600k; he will get almost all of this money as there is no loan on the property and no other significant taxes on the sale; the property is being sold in a country in Europe with no major estate/inheritance or transfer taxes. My dad will then transfer the money here. We have been wondering what might be a good idea for how to diversify this money into different properties. I have suggested to him the following:

    • over the next year, using the 600k cash, buy 2 houses in Chicago, 2 more houses in Philadelphia, and perhaps 1 house in Indianapolis through turnkey companies. I like these markets as they seem to have many houses in the 90-130k price range with decent returns, managed by some pretty decent turnkey companies. I think owning houses in 4-5 major but diverse cities is a good way of diversifying while still remaining within one asset class (do other commenters agree?)

    Among other considerations, I've strongly encouraged my father to keep a significant cash reserve and to apply for a HELOC – to be kept as an emergency line of credit, not used, of course. He is doing these things. My dad is a very conservative investor and person, and so I need to keep this in mind when helping him. He also does not live a lavish lifestyle and does not need to profit to the max, so therefore leverage is less attractive to him. Having said this, he does see the advantage of having loans on a limited number of the properties to allow investments in other additional properties.

    The biggest question right now is should my father take out loans on some of these houses? Within the next year I expect he'll own 7-8 houses in cash, each worth around or a little over 100k, and each earning about $1000-1300/mo gross rent. I see no reason for him to take too much risk by getting heavily leveraged. Even if he got no loans, he could add another house every year or two just from the returns on the existing houses. My initial suggestion to him was to get conventional loans on two of the houses – this is something he can easily do, as he has very little other debt, and still has a good conventional income. That way if the economy turns bad in one or more of the cities, he will not struggle.

    What do others think about the number of loans? I think it is better to be conservative and only have loans on half or less of the properties. But I don't know for sure. We are working on the 75% cash out refinance first loan against the Memphis property right now with SNMC Capital / Team Bighaus () out of Washington State, a company that specializes in making conventional loans to RE investors.

    Would appreciate any criticism or suggestion you have of this “lazy” strategy of turnkey investing for my dad... what do you think about the leverage... what about the number / spread of different cities to be invested in... what about other types of real estate or other asset class investments... what about how much money to keep on reserve?

    I realize that no one is giving financial advice and the risk is all mine/my dad's. Please just share how you might think if you were in my shoes helping your father. I appreciate any thoughts you have positive or negative.

    Thanks,

    Matt

    Memphis Invest is top tier in that space. I would expect those to be as solid as you can get. Perhaps your father would also like a REIT with good dividends and flexibility like OHI as a 100% passive option.

  • Sheffield, IL · Member since 2012 · 85 posts · 27 votes
    10y

    @Matthew S. I would not go the duplex-quadplex route unless you are buying brand new in very nice areas. Either stay with SFR's which have many more exit strategies than duplex/quad or go to commercial residential where you can keep the complexities down. Most guys do the 2-4 unit stuff because it still qualifies for long-term fannie lending. With you not needing to do that, I'm not sure why you would take risks with any older property (pre Y2K) or small multi-family.

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Ok thanks for the advice Steve, I didn't know about the risks of duplex/quads.

    We had been considering a duplex in Chicago (south side, older part of city, some of them in section 8 areas). I presume this is something you'd consider risky.

  • Lender · Morgan Hill, CA · Member since 2015 · 55 posts · 24 votes
    10y

    @Matthew S. This is a great post! Lots of great ideas and it is clear what the "why" is here. Which is the most important aspect of any investing!

    I would agree with earlier comments about staying clear of the multifamily unless you really know what the areas are like, we have a duplex and it was not our best investment choice.

    As for your plan about buying turnkeys and using cash flow to buy more/live on, this is one of my plans as well. We are in the midst of doing a 1031 on one of our rentals and turning it into 6 turnkey's in Indy. I would be happy to connect you with the team we are using offline. The analysis that I did/do when acquiring new property is make sure that the asset is a good deal first. That is a single type of analysis, lots of which can be found here on BP. The next is understanding how you are going to pay for it. It sounds like your dad has cash which is good. I would recommend that he holds back 12 months of living expenses for himself and 6-12 months of emergency funds for all current and near term properties he is looking to buy. This will make him look much better on paper for bank financing and keep him liquid enough to deal with issues should something happen.

    Next is understanding the finance structure of the deal. Putting all cash or 25% down sound like the main options. I personally would leverage the properties. Or if you buy all cash, then do a cash out refi when you can. This is where the second step of deal analysis comes in. Just knowing the Cap rate or NOI or other property specific numbers loses its power. You need to make sure that the finance around the property works for you and not against you. I calculate the loan constant of the mortgages that I get and make sure that it is less, much less if possible, than the cap rate of the property/portfolio. This is where you make your money on a deal. As an example, I am doing this 1031 and I have built in all the aspects of owning the properties as well as significant reserve growth for the properties to cover myself, and still have a spread of over 1% between the cap and loan constant. This is where the money is really made in a deal.

    As far as financing goes, the the longest term you can at the best loan constant possible. Then if you want to mitigate your risk on the deal you can run the numbers and see if the property can handle a 15 yr mortgage or not. If it can and you don't need the cash, then I would say to pay the amount of the 15 year note on your 30 year note. This will pay down the note much faster, giving you peace of mind, having the tenants pay it down for you. Also this will give you huge flexibility. If something happens and you can't pay the amount of the 15 yr note, then you can drop down to the actual payment on the 30 yr note. This way you won't lose the property or get really sideways. It may not stop it, but it could give you 2-6 months to figure things out rather than 1-2 months. 

    Lastly, I would recommend that your dad sit on all his cash at this point, and do a 1031 of the inherited property into his turnkey's in a specific market. I know it's not really spreading things around geographically, but if you can get 5-10 properties in a market buying you a new house every year or less, then you can afford to look around more. This gives you economies of scale in a specific area and can increase your yield on the properties. For instance, if you you sell the inherited property for lets say $600k ( I know it will be more) and assume 6% closing costs on that end. That leaves you with $564k in proceeds that are now tax free to invest in new property. This is now your down payment on whatever new stuff you want to buy. Assuming there is no note on the $600k. So, let's say you want to do the $90k property in Indy, since thats what I'm most familiar with. That's a down payment of $22.5k/SFR. That yields 25 doors. TWENTY FIVE! You will have to deal with closing costs and such, so either you come out of pocket or you reduce somewhat. Still even at 20 doors with a cash flow in the area of $200/door that is $5,000/mo in positive cash flow. That could be the final deal you ever need to do. I admit that getting the mortgage for this will be the hardest part. We've been looking for a while for a smart banker, and have yet to find one. But if you learn how to cover your downside really well and just let the upside take care of itself. YOur dad could be set for life. And doing this after could set you and your sister up for life as well.

    I have some other ideas as well. But I'm looking back and this has become a very long response. ;-) Please feel free to reach out to me with any questions. Good luck! Let us know what you end up doing!

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Chad, thank you so much for taking time to write this. I read it through once and am going to come back read it through again later. A lot to absorb. I am unfamiliar with some of the terminology you use so am going to read up on some of the things you mention.

    Right now, I'll say that I have been using the BP rental property calculator to look the numbers for the deals on BP. I didn't do this for the first couple of deals, but should have. Now going forward we will.

    I think your idea about holding back living and emergency expenses is excellent. He has no reason to take too much risk, and does want to start getting more refinance loans. Thank you.

    Yes, he will usually be buying all cash and then refinancing. We can get better deals and have access to more properties buying in cash, and refinancing later. Unless there are strategies I'm not aware of, it's a lot easier to buy in cash and get loans later... we have been finding this out with multiple turnkey companies we've been working with. It may take a bit longer, but keeping 25% in for a refinance is not so bad or different compared to putting only 20% down for an initially leveraged buy, I don't think.

    I am not sure what you mean when you say, "make sure that the finance around the property works for you and not against you"? When you use the term "loan constant", I assume this means "loan rate"? In other words, speaking simply, you would want a property, say for a cash buy, where the cap rate of the property is 9% and the loan rate is at 5%... not where the cap rate of the property is 6-7% and the loan percentage rate is the same%? Maybe I am misunderstanding what the loan constant refers to.

    The property being sold is actually in a foreign country without inheritance taxes, and where the realtors charge very little on the transaction compared to the USA. So we cannot do a 1031 I don't think. But we can bring the money over here, and won't be taxed on it, as far as I know. But that is something else to look into as well.

    Thank you again for taking your time to explain these concepts to me!

  • Lender · Morgan Hill, CA · Member since 2015 · 55 posts · 24 votes
    10y

    @Matthew S. I'm glad that this was helpful. To answer a few of your questions.

    I would leverage his W-2 and buying power now while he has it. As you stated, in 2 years he will be retired and much, much harder to get a conventional loan. Additionally, having cash on hand is much better than having equity on hand. You can't eat equity. It is mostly a personal choice/situation and you have to feel it out. But there are many ways to skin this cat. If need be get your 10 conventional loans first and then figure out how to refi them all into a blanket mortgage and start over.

    So, making sure that the financing works for you and not against you. As many gurus out there say "you make your money when you buy." I find this to be mostly true, but with the caveat that "you make your money when you buy with the right financing."

    A great deal is a great deal, but bad financing is the fastest, and most common, way to kill a great deal. We should all know how to calculate the cap rate so I won't go into that. Investopedia defines the loan constant here. Essentially, this is the inverse of the mortgage payment. It is based on the interest rate of the loan, the duration of the loan, and the compounding factor of the loan. For instance, an interest only loan of 7% has a loan constant of 7%. But a 30 year fixed loan of 7% has a loan constant of 7.98%. And a 15 year fixed at 7% has a loan constant of 10.79%. So, if you were to go out and get "the best 15 year mortgage" out there as many gurus suggest to get rid of the debt faster you would actually get rid of it much faster. Because you would lose your shirt and the property! You have to know your spread. spread is calculated as Cap Rate minus Loan Constant. If it is negative you are in trouble. If it is positive you have a chance if you manage it right.

    So, if you had on the same property a cap rate of 7% the interest only loan would be neutral to you at the end of the day. Not great, but not bad. Any volatility in the property would be dangerous if not disastrous to you. Now the 30 yr fixed is nearly 1% negative. So you are going into the deal at a disadvantage. This is where knowing your numbers is key and making sure you have reserves. But, if you took the gurus advice, and got the shortest term financing out there you would be nearly 4% negative! Any tax, inflation, cash flow, etc advantage you think you are going to have is going to be eaten up from the moment you sign on the dotted line.

    Now some may say that 7% is high. Ok. I'll give you a phenomenal rate of 4% on a 15 year fixed. You know what? I still wouldn't do this loan because the loan constant is 8.88%! Still 2% negative on the deal! And you are on the hook for the full PITI if you have a vacancy. The larger the spread is, the higher volatility you can handle in your asset.

    That got a little long, but I think that this is a very important point that nearly all investors I've talked to miss. The deal has to be good, yes. But how you pay for the deal is more important. There are three sides to every deal, the asset, the capital to buy and the finance structure. The way you structure the finance is probably the most important of the three, and the least understood.

    And last, bummer about the inherited place. But if you aren't going to pay taxes its good. Just be careful about repatriating money and any tax consequences that may bring. I think that the same concept still applies though where you can use that money as a good portion of your emergency fund and reserves and the rest used as down payment money on financing for turn key rentals.

    Good luck!

  • Investor · Vienna, VA · Member since 2013 · 41 posts · 6 votes
    10y

    Wow... awesome Chad, thank you. Did not even know about some of this stuff at all.

    Am glad that this site and people like you are here.

    I will do more research based on your leads and apply this thinking to the deals. You are also quite right that we want to make the best use of the 2 years or so that my dad has left of regular income to get loans.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.