Investor · Sapulpa, OK · Member since 2013 · 146 posts · 50 votes
Any experienced landlords know if tenants would prefer a 4th bedroom over a 1 car garage, or vice versa? I've been thinking about buying 3/1/1s or 3/2/1s then converting the garage into a 4th bedroom since they rent for more.
If your area lends itself to tenants not caring about a garage and it's in line with other surrounding properties then it may be a good idea. In my area, regardless of student-base, the city doesn't allow any more than 3 unrelated individuals to occupy a SFR zoned property. You may want to look into your zoning laws to be sure of the rules. And if you do decide to convert it, make sure you have a permit to do so and it's up to the local code. I've seen conversions like this in my area and they either didn't get it permitted or it was a bad conversion.
I always prefer to have a garage. That's just me personally. Usually that 4th bedroom will be converted into some other kind of use room, unless you are targeting large families. Large families will almost always cause more wear and tear on the house. I would leave it as a garage.
you'll probably find that tenants are split. so you'll need a more thorough strategy to determine which way to go
for example: partner of mine converts the garage on all his 3/2 houses to 4/2's and closes the garage because he rents for section 8 and S8 pays more for more bedrooms.
I personally don't convert them because converted garages almost always look awful, and my market shows more value towards a garage than a 4th bedroom. You have to analyze your specific strategy and market.
Look at your area and see what is the norm. Do all the houses have garages? If so, I'd keep it. If not, it may be a candidate to convert. In many areas of Colorado, yes I'm looking at you Colorado Springs, it's considered blasphemy to not have a garage. Do what everyone else does and you should be safe.
I would recommend keeping the garage. Almost always the value the garage brings to the property is greater than what another bedrooms would bring. But I would agree with what has been mentioned above. If there are virtually no garages in the area then it would be okay to convert the garage to a bedroom.