A successful (barely) first flip!

A successful (barely) first flip!

Accountant · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 409 posts · 362 votes

So I just finished doing all the calculations for this flip. Man it was a beast. Almost 10 months from close to close and a huge project for a first time flipper.

So here's what I got:

I had a call from a direct mail campaign and the seller offered me his duplex in an up and coming neighborhood of St. Louis known as Benton Park West. He was only asking $9,000 so I thought there's no way I can't make this work.

I went and looked at the place, it had been vacant for nearly 25 years and was in rough shape to say the least. But the foundation was solid, brick work was in good shape, and the floors and floor joists (that I could see in the basement), looked to be in good/salvageable shape.

My business partner decided it was worth it and we bought the place for $9852.00 including closing costs. About a month later after talking with about 6 general contractors, numerous subs, 4 architects, and a host of potential wholesale buyers I lined up contractors and decided to hire a GC to do/oversee most of the work and I would project manage/manage the GC. We put a budget of $132,000 for the contractors to do their part, and I would contribute another $8,000 worth of work mostly in tile and painting.

With that in hand I found a private money lender through a friend of mine, and showed him the comps my Realtor (I wasn't licensed at the time), had pulled and he was already funding a similar project 4 blocks over from mine. He agreed and gave us a loan of $150,000, Interest only, Rate was ~10.5% 3 month variable.

My GC thought he could start August 20th and finish by December 1st, so in our contract I gave him until January 1st to finish before penalties would kick in. Work started with demolition on August 20th as predicted and within 2 weeks the place was a shell. Literally everything except the studs were gone (and those would be gone soon also). Unfortunately work did not progress as fast as my contractor had hoped and it would be February 20th before he managed to finish enough for us to put the place on the Market. Fortunately my GC and I had a good relationship and he kept his word, paid the penalty (200/week), and through in a 1 year warranty transferrable to the new owner as of the close of a sale.

After getting staging set and pictures taken, landscaping completed, we listed the property around March 5th, right at the beginning of the spring selling season. We had 2 really positive open houses on back to back Sunday’s and a good amount of showings throughout the weeks. After the 1st open house we put out advertising saying something to the effect of “If something isn’t quite right, let us know, we’ll do what it takes to make it right for you!” This was a good and bad thing it turned out, but mostly good.

After almost exactly 30 days on market and a price drop we got an offer at $200k and a request we provide $5k in closing cost and a $550 home warranty, we had listed it at $230k-223k. We countered back with $213,000 and kept the other concessions. Closing was set May 7th. We had a deal!

After some trials with the occupancy inspector and home inspector on some relatively minor things, we finally made it to close. I cannot express how nerve racking the waiting period between listing a house and getting an offer is, this was the first house I had sold, and then the escrow period was almost worse. The buyer’s didn’t know, but had they cancelled the contract, we were probably screwed as our loan was due on May 17th.

So how were the final numbers? (all rounded)

Purchase: $9800

Renovation: $162,000 ($22,000 over budget)

Total Interest Paid: $8700

Closing Cost: $18,400 (including commissions and concessions)

Holding Cost (other than Interest): 1100

Sale Price: $213,000

Gross Profit: 13000

Takeaways:

I learned a ton on this rehab.

1) Don’t try to do work yourself, have a pro do it.

2) make sure you keep a good lock on what’s going on and when with your contractors, one of our costs overruns was time.

3) On a gut, just because you think you can salvage something (like the floor), put a contingency budget in for it.

4) My 10% contingency was not enough.

Photos to follow:

46Reply
551 views

Most Popular Reply

Providence, RI · Member since 2018 · 17 posts · 27 votes
7y

Just playing devil's advocate here: for only 13K profit... wouldn't it be worth to just rent it, then do a cashout refi? 

Let's say you got  $1800/month in rent for a fixed up 3 bed in that area, you get $21,600/year in rents. Most commercial lenders will give you 80% of the value of the property if it is stabilized (locked in a yearly lease)... my guess is it will assess for $216000+/- or 10 times yearly rents... so you cashout $172800 @ 4.5% commercial lender rates, that is $875/month for a mortgage.... minus expense, you are probably bringing home $700/month in profit virtually tax free (because of depreciation and other benefits of renting properties) versus $13K of profit flipping that you have to give between 10% and 37% to the IRS for short term capital gain... let' say you are in the middle tax bracket (24% capital gain tax) so $3120 of your profit goes towards taxes, so you really only made $9880!

 If you made a $700/month profit, it only takes a little over a year to make that same flipping profit in rents, but the best part is that after that point, you are now making additional monthly profit, and the house is brand new... nothing should break! You should be making that monthly profit easily for 5 years with only minimal repairs/maintenance. So $700 x 12 months x 5 years equals $42000 in profit virtually tax free, versus the short $9880 in 10 months...

Don't get me wrong, $9880 is a profit! You should be happy, just the same way that everyone on here is happy for you, but every deal is different...  if its not worth flipping, pivot and look at what other options you have to make a better profit...

See this reply in the discussion

79 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2019 · 1 post · 0 votes
    7y

    Thanks so much for sharing.  I am new to investing in STL and looking to get started in South City.  It was great hearing about your experience, and I really learned a lot from your detailed post.  Congrats and best of luck on your next project.

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2016 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    7y

    Congrats Donald.  As soon as I saw the photo of the exterior, I knew it was a St. Louis House.  Congrats on making it profitable.  There are so many opportunities out there.  I am too gun shy to take on a project as big as you did.  

    I work for an Accounting company here in town.  I would be curious where you work.

  • Louisivlle, KY · Member since 2017 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    7y

    I knew it was STL the second I saw the front of the building - so iconic! Love Benton Park Neighborhood! Nicely done interior. Way to take it all as a learning experience 

  • Accountant · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 409 posts · 362 votes
    7y

    Wow, thanks for the feedback everyone. Let me see if I can answer some of the questions..

    @Lilian Ruwende our loan on this was from a private lender who gave us a 9 month 150k loan at 10.1875% interest. We (I should have mentioned @naveen C. Reddy and I were partners on this deal) bought the house with cash and a month later decided to flip it ourselves after we couldn’t wholesale it, so the 9 month loan worked out perfectly. We were actually scheduled for the loan to be due May 17th and closed the sale May 7th. (whew!)

    @Jesse Bender it turned out our rehab cost/sf was ~$69.88

    @Ty Davis “Honest people” lol. Some of my contractors were honest…but I may not have been the GC on this, but I surely had to keep a thumb on everything going on, God only knows how long it would’ve taken to do the job had I not. My concrete guy for example instead of pouring the new parking pad and sidewalk in November in relatively good weather, waited until January and then we got lucky with a “warm” 40 degree string of dry days he could pour.

    @Glenna Wood wood lol yeah, most of my real estate friends thought I was nuts. I only started investing in Feb 2018 (research began Nov 2017), so didn’t have much experience at all, but figured I’d make it work.

    @Oliver Perry I listed my main takeaways in the last part of the post. Aside from that, keeping a close eye on what your contractors are doing is key. And everything takes longer than expected.

    @Brian Barnhart I’m a staff accountant, not a CPA. I work for a medium size retail goods wholesaler. Feel free to PM me if you want to talk more. 

    @Carlos Varum Jr thank you for the detailed devil’s advocate. Around the 25 DOM mark we started looking at holding it as a rental as it looked like we weren’t going to get the 230k asking price, but after figuring out rents vs costs we were looking at best a breakeven. Rents in the area for a 3/2 (even rehabbed) top out at 1400/mo and that’s optimistic, more like 1300/mo to be conservative. But yes we definitely looked at renting it as an option and we calculated a roughly breakeven after reserves. That said, if our contract had fallen through and the buyers backed out, we were ready to do a refi since our loan went from 10.1875% to 15% if we needed an extension. Then we’d probably would have looked for a rent to own situation.
     

    Wow, wasn't expecting such a reaction, thanks again everyone and wish you all luck in your endeavors also. 

    Cheers!

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 29 votes
    7y

    Congrats on getting through the flip and not losing money. The place looks fantastic! It takes guts to take on a project like that. I close on a huge 4 family in Tower Grove South (over 5k sq ft) right near Rooster Cafe tomorrow. Debating whether I take on an ambitious high-end rehab, or keep it cosmetic as I do with most of my properties. Would you recommend your GC? I'm out of state, so definitely need someone reliable. If done high end, the comps suggest it could pull in $1,400/unit. Just a bit scared of the unknown when opening those walls. :)

  • Investor From Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 87 posts · 26 votes
    7y

    @Donald S. Great job! I’ve been and and feel your pain. Welcome to the club...

  • Rental Property Investor · Mililani, HI · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 9 votes
    7y

    Great job, way to take the leap!

  • Member since 2019 · 1 post · 0 votes
    7y

    Nice job! Thanks for sharing

  • Columbus, OH · Member since 2018 · 29 posts · 20 votes
    7y

    What a big job for your first flip. Congrats!

  • Greg ParkerBusiness Member
    Realtor, Contractor, Property Manager · Montgomery AL and Kowaliga, AL · Member since 2017 · 670 posts · 536 votes
    7y

    Great job.  A profit is a profit.  And, I love to see those old houses rejuvenated.  Win/win.

    MGM Property Pros LLC
    View Page
  • Accountant · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 409 posts · 362 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Edward Burke:

    Congrats on getting through the flip and not losing money. The place looks fantastic! It takes guts to take on a project like that. I close on a huge 4 family in Tower Grove South (over 5k sq ft) right near Rooster Cafe tomorrow. Debating whether I take on an ambitious high-end rehab, or keep it cosmetic as I do with most of my properties. Would you recommend your GC? I'm out of state, so definitely need someone reliable. If done high end, the comps suggest it could pull in $1,400/unit. Just a bit scared of the unknown when opening those walls. :)

     If you're near Rooster on Grand then you're in a high end and appreciating part of town. You can probably risk going higher end and still come out ahead, although without seeing the property myself I can't tell you what to do. 

    As for my GC, the one I used on this I wouldn't recommend because his crew is too small to take on all the jobs he wants to take on. I have another GC I've since started working with and am happy with his performance in most things. I use a separate landscaper, window installer, and flooring guy because this new GC isn't competitive on those trades, but other than that I am using him on another flip now that is just getting under way. Feel free to PM me if you want to discuss further. 

  • Member since 2019 · 1 post · 0 votes
    7y

    looks amazing!!!

  • Fruitport, MI · Member since 2019 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    7y

    Great success!  Thanks for sharing, it's a great inspiration!

  • Eastern Michigan · Member since 2018 · 83 posts · 144 votes
    7y

    The finished product looks great! Congrats on your first flip!!

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 29 votes
    7y

    @Donald S. Thanks for the feedback. Yes, that's the area of the property.

    Wow...on to the next one! Good for you!

  • Real Estate Investor · Marysville, OH · Member since 2014 · 242 posts · 196 votes
    7y

    I am going to take small exception with your categorization of this as a barely successful flip.  You flipped a huge project, on your first attempt.  You got it all the way to the finish line.  You made money.  Importantly, you also learned a ton of valuable lessons and leveled up your real estate investing IQ for your next project.  That sounds like a great success to me, setting the 'disappointing' profits aside.  Well done and on to your next project!

  • Investor · Anchorage, AK · Member since 2016 · 222 posts · 294 votes
    7y

    Looks very nice in the end! This was a huge learning experience for you!

  • San Antonio, TX · Member since 2019 · 930 posts · 836 votes
    7y

    Wow!  Finished product looks great!

  • Investor · Biddeford, ME · Member since 2017 · 282 posts · 181 votes
    7y

    Nice job!  Did you ever consider holding it or were you thinking sell from the beginning?

  • Rob BeemanPro Member
    Specialist · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2010 · 310 posts · 119 votes
    7y

    CONGRATS!  By the way, its not just the FIRST flip that will a learning experience.  Everyone will have some element that will be new and not yet encountered (in the property, with the buyer, with a contractor, etc.).  

    The good news is, you fished it, you conquered it, not it conquering you! Pat yourself on the back and start searching for the next one (perhaps with less rehab needed). I have a saying, regardless of how much fun they were, or profit earned - : "They all look best in the rear view mirror."

    Thanks for sharing your flip experience with us.

  • Accountant · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 409 posts · 362 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Rob Beeman:

    CONGRATS!  By the way, its not just the FIRST flip that will a learning experience.  Everyone will have some element that will be new and not yet encountered (in the property, with the buyer, with a contractor, etc.).  

    The good news is, you fished it, you conquered it, not it conquering you! Pat yourself on the back and start searching for the next one (perhaps with less rehab needed). I have a saying, regardless of how much fun they were, or profit earned - : "They all look best in the rear view mirror."

    Thanks for sharing your flip experience with us.

     Thanks!

    My business partner and I actually bought 2 more flips already, closed on those purchases about 1 and 3 weeks after this one closed. Currently going through some permitting pains, but should be cleared up this week and then hope to have them ready before August is over. Both are only ~65k in repairs so significantly less work. I'll definitely be making more posts in the future once those finish up. 

  • Central Jersey · Member since 2018 · 9 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    Would it have been worth to flip it, as is, selling it for 25k to someone with more experience?

  • Accountant · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 409 posts · 362 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Barry B.:

    Would it have been worth to flip it, as is, selling it for 25k to someone with more experience?

     I tried for the 1st month we owned it while I was also talking with GC's and subs. Couldn't find a buyer who wanted it, so decided do to it myself. 

  • Specialist · Newport Beach, CA · Member since 2016 · 25 posts · 18 votes
    7y

    I can't tell you how grateful I am to have you list out your experience and numbers.  What a great case study for use new investors!  Thank you for the takeaways, and hopefully you have strength for another.

  • Santa Rosa, CA · Member since 2017 · 325 posts · 701 votes
    7y

    These are the stories of "gentrification" that never get told.   You literally lifted this duplex from chaos and decay and not just made money for yourself, but improved the neighborhood and gave a grand old building another 50+ years of life.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.