Lets see how much thought is going to go into this housing / bank bailout . . . frankly, I'm starting to think that the move to make is to stop paying the mortgage so I can:
a) Get "bailed out"
b) Renegotiate my loan
c) get any or all of the other great perks that some people in politics will bestow on those people who walked from their home.
Why not, right?
What do you think? Isn't this bailout just rewarding bad behavior? Yes, some people got screwed by bad people, but lots of people made bad decisions. Why should they be rewarded and those of us who pay our bills not?
I am a real estate title examiner in KY and I don't think the consumer needs to be bailed out, but they do need help. I have done so many title searches for Countrywide that were forclosures that I began to think they were in the business to forclose on properties. Many of these people have owned their homes for 30 to 50 years. A lot of people were lied to when they got variable intrest rate loans. No sane person would take out a variable intrest rate loan to purchase a home they intend to live in unless interest rates are very high and will most likely go down, not up. I think the lenders should have to convert the variable interest rate loans to a fixed rate loan, at their expense, and the interest rate should be fixed at the original agreed upon rate on each mortgage. I feel like this would help stabilize the housing prices and help stop the foreclosures and bankruptcies so that when the goverment buys up all these mortgages at least the houses will still be valued at the amount of the mortgage. I am not a financial wiz and would like to know if anyone sees any problems with this idea.
There was nothing fraudulent about offering variable rate interest loans and I strongly disagree that lenders should be forced to re-write these loans. Adults should be allowed to take out any type of loan they like.
The more insidious loans were the teaser rate loans, where the lenders would advertise a $200,000 loan for $750 per month or something ridiculous like that. During the boom, you could not turn on the TV in our area without seeing a commercial by QUICKEN LOANS for this type of loan. To me, that makes it ironic that the CEO of quicken loans would have the nerve to suggest a fix when his company deserves a LOT of blame for this mess. If he was CEO during this period, I think he should be forced to resign in disgrace and pay back whatever salary he received, along with all the politicians in Washington who had a hand in this mess.
Even in the case of these teaser rate loans, I'm not in favor of a mandated adjustment of the loan terms - UNLESS THERE WAS FRAUD. The borrowers entered into these loans of their own free will and the contracts should not be modified by our socialist government.
Mike
On 9-25-08 I posted "I think the lenders should have to convert the variable interest rate loans to a fixed rate loan, at their expense..." and everyone blasted me.
Read the comments. The quicken loans guy got blasted too.
Why on Earth would we force a lender to convert a variable loan to a fixed rate loan?
What has happened to personal accountability in America?
but I would prefer the banks should clean up their own mess and they haven't really made a serious effort to fix it.
Shari, I kind of agree with you. The people who originated these crazy loans and sold them to some investor should help clean up the mess. But they won't. The guy that now owns the loan can't fix it, because he doesn't know what he owns.
Usually, there is no "Bank".
I am sort of torn on this subject. I have worked in the financial industry of many years one of whom was a credit card provider. The moment the government told banks to make credit more available is the day banks and other credit providers jumped for joy. They were given an open book on what they were allowed to do. So, who were the easiest targets? People who were in the sub prime market. Here are a group of people struggling to make it by and you are offering then an almost blank check. Yes they are to blame for trying to live above their means, but when you dangle a steak in front of a hungry dog you should not be surprised when he snatches it out of your hands and eats himself sick.
I remember sitting in meetings where companies would trying to think of the next way to leach money out of people they know they did not have it. This was more prevalent in the credit card industry than anywhere else. Here have this piece of plastic that will let you get whatever you want. We know you are not going to read the fine print and we are going to make sure that even if you try to read it you will be so confused that you will not know which way is up.
Here is an actual quote from a product manager of a credit card company I worked for. “We just have to get them to spend that first dollar and we will have them. Even if they go into collections, we will just sell the account to one of our subsidiaries; take the tax break and then collect on the whole debt.â€
I worked for banks where their lending department had the very same philosophy. “We just need to get them in the door and the deal closed and get as much money as we can upfront then if they default we will still make a nice profit.†That is why interest only loans were so popular for a while.
There is a reason why I don’t work in the financial industry any more. Here is an institution that is built on trust and sound principals that feed on the hopelessness of people. If consumers are to blame for taking out loans they could not afford, lending companies are to blame for giving them the money. That is why we are in the situation we are in now and why the rest of the world is in it with us.
People should have been more cautious and done more research, but the people who were targeted were just hungry for someone promising them a better life. Both sides are to blame. Who do you point the finger at, the starving dog or the person with the steak.
I have watched friends that were in great financial situations loose their jobs because businesses where doing the same as your common consumer and are now either facing foreclosure or have already been foreclosed upon. These are people that had no issues playing their expenses, but because of the overall situation of the world they are now jobless and searching for a place to live.
This is a problem that is above you and me. Letting all the blame fall on the end consumer and having them face the consequences while we sit back and watch the banks crumble would put the world in such a negative financial state that we may not recover. This is what happens when the world gets greedy.
If anyone is surprised that companies have meetings to actually figure out how to get people to spend money, then you are very naive.
but when you dangle a steak in front of a hungry dog you should not be surprised when he snatches it out of your hands and eats himself sick.
I understand the analogy, but we are talking about people, not dogs. People with brains. People who can reason. People who can think for themselves. That is, UNLESS, we are saying that some people cannot think for themselves. That's not an argument that I would support.
Credit card companies are notorious for using slimey selling tactics. Some lenders operate in the same manner. In my book, that does not absolve the borrower, myself included.
I agree that greed got us in this mess. Companies got greedy, but it is the consumer that bought it.
What planet do you all live on? Just as you did not understand what Jason Bourg said there are people in this world who do not understand financial documents thus they rely on the brokers and lenders to explain it to them. The definition of fraud is "intentional deception resulting in injury to another person" which sums up this whole mess if you ask me. I believe that what the bank and mortgage companies did was intentional and they knew exactly what the outcome would be, foreclosure. What screwed it up was the housing prices droping and all the sudden the homes they foreclosed on weren't bringing enough at auction to cover the loan and they couldn't get it from the mortgagee because they wised up and filed bankruptcy. I strongly believe this mess was intentionally perpetrated by the lenders and they bear the bulk of the responsibility to fix it. A simple loan modification is all it would take to convert these loans to fixed rate loans. Financial institutions modify loans every day. Speaking of accountability, what about the personal and professional accountability of the lenders? There is a video on U-tube that some you might find of interest.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MoSwkCog-Ro
A simple loan modification is all it would take to convert these loans to fixed rate loans. Financial institutions modify loans every day.
Lenders clearly created loan products destined to fail. Unfortunately, those that currently own the loans, did not originate them. Many that own the loans did not understand what they were buying either. Therefore, to ask them to modify a loan, because it was their fault to begin with, is a complete oversimplification.
There are four groups that are to blame here:
1. Government officials who promoted social engineering through their homeownership initiative that was designed to move minorities and the poor into being homeowners. To further their social goals, they pressured Freddie and Fannie to essentially lower underwriting standards.
2. Freddie and Fannie who lowered the standards for the loans they would buy and enticed/pressured banks to make loans to people who never should have been able to obtain a home loan.
3. Banks and mortgage companies for giving loans to borrowers who were not creditworthy.
4. Borrowers who took out loans they simply couldn't afford. These people are NOT VICTIMS - they are adults and are responsible for their actions.
5. Investment banks, big insurance companies, and others who bought securities that were based on mortgages that were no good.
EACH AND EVERY ONE OF THESE GROUPS SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO FAIL AND THE CRIMINALS THAT STARTED THIS MESS SHOULD BE EXPOSED AND PUNISHED. That won't happen because the true culprits are in government (President Clinton, President Bush, Barnie Frank, Chris Dodd, etc).
Mike
We have to acknowledge that most of the people reading and posting on this board are pretty sophisticated investors who think about pros and cons of each investment. I would guess we all have savings to fall back on in cases of emergency.
For the most part the people who got into interest-only ARMS and option ARMS and who got home equity loans to pay off credit cards understood the terms of the loan. I've seen a few cases of fraud but mostly the people I know who are in trouble are simply very bad money managers. They can't live within their means and don't know how to say no. Even in this crisis where everyone should know the result of crazy loans, I meet people at open houses who want to buy a 3BR/2BA remodeled home and have tons of credit card debt, car loans, etc. They don't want a condo or a 2BR/1BA home that is outdated but they can afford.
I have a past client who has zero control over her financial life and she is in the process of refinancing to pull out cash to pay off back taxes and credit card debt. This is not the first time for her to do this. There is a willing bank and she is a willing borrower.
What do you think? Isn't this bailout just rewarding bad behavior? Yes, some people got screwed by bad people, but lots of people made bad decisions. Why should they be rewarded and those of us who pay our bills not?
That was Josh's original question that started this thread. Shari, I think you just answered it.
I was watching the Dave Ramsey show last night and it was obviously taped prior to approval of the bailout. The show was about coming up with solutions to the crisis rather than throwing taxpayer money at the banks. One CPA caller had a good idea--he suggested the banks allow people to pay principle only and double up the principle for a few years so they can build up some "skin" in the deal and add an extra year or two on the mortgage to make up the interest. Again, this suggestion requires the banks to agree and modify loans and we all know how likely that is with a bailout in place!
Every caller was against the bailout. Most of us on this forum were against it. I've written my Congress reps several times and they have all gotten tens of thousands of letters against it but it was approved anyway. I feel like our government must think we are incapable so they don't have to listen to us, when it's really the other way around.
Most of the mortgage issues could have been avoided if lenders simply required borrowers to put down 20% and required income and asset verification. It was fun and convenient to get a home loan by simply calling Countrywide and asking, and having the money in 2 1/2 weeks, but it was not good fundamentals.
Please accept this message with the best of intentions, my intentions are always honorable, my nature can be somewhat imperfect. With that disclosed here we go......
In the end, these people (GOV) have some votes to buy, does it really matter what we think? It is best not to get in the way of parasites and their herders
The best thing to do is not allow them to prey on you. :wink:
I think we should save all the people we can from foreclosure. it will make the housing market recover faster...
FYI, all of the money they lent, 2003 thru 2005 was not there own, in fact it did not really excist. It went from "vapor" to "paper" now back to "vapor".
Thanks to the mania we had in this country, a lots of people got to have a taste for sushi and the chance to own a hummer. Most would normally not have been able to do that. I guess it all evens out in the end :)
The unfounded run up in the money supply caused an urealistic amount of capital and leverage to be avaiable. This is now crashing down as it must. This happened 20 years ago........
This should not be news to a person who is able to read a book :roll:
The order of things
First the banks break the people
Then the banks go broke
Then the government goes broke
There are 3 types of people in the world.
Looters
Lemmings
Business People
Business People ad value to the commerce or transactions that they touch. There are more of them than you think.
Looters prey on Lemmings and their inability to use logic to make decisions.
The list of local examples is endless. It goes from Preconstruction houses at 120 percent of market value, to feeding kids in Africa for 99 a month with the promise of wealth, health and all that stuff, and of course the $7,000 course from guys who do not do real estate, with concepts that do not work in the real world ..... :)
All you can do is recognize what people are, amongst the 3 described above, run to the hills if they are 1 or 2.
You will not save the world. You can only save: you and the few around you who might listen.
These people (CEO and rest of his ilk) and companies (WAMU, Bear Stearns, ETC) looted their way to a financial crisis in the late 1980's. We bailed them out. They have recreated the same monster again. This time it is injected with the financial steroids known as CDO, SIV, ETC.......
The first clue should have been when the Fed quite publishing M3 in 2005. It was not pertinent anymore.... :) Meaning, we really do not want you to know how bad it is.
If you do not know what M3 is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply
That was the warning sign. The smart money got out of all things financial and financial based. This was about the same time the media trumpeted the "New Market", crash proof and all.
The key to survival is to know what the Looters will do to the Lemmings, then go the other way. At least get out of the way. The cool part about this whole cycle. When the Lemmings follow the looters over the cliff, they leave such cool stuff behind. Like brand new houses for $50 a SQFT.
Illegitimi non carborundum
If you do not know what that means click here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegitimi_non_carborundum
Be sure to notice what a beauty of a day we have outside, Booms and bust aside, this is paradise.Always remember, booms follow busts, not vice versa
In closing, the words of a wise man.
Enjoy the days - make of them what is allowed, play as hard as you work, don't forget to DO WHAT YOU WANT TO before it's too late even if you could later do it. Old folks who have money and no memories are pretty boring company, so that should NEVER be a goal.
Who I am doesn't matter - it's who we BECOME that might one day improve the world, if only by a fraction. My "Heroes" wear the Uniform of the USA, my mentors have been those whose lives have changed the world for the better. Be they good teachers, great Doctors, Vets, hard-working scientists, engineers, realtors, lenders, store owners, single Moms/Dads, if their lives somehow improved theirs AND others', I listen carefully to all they have to say
To the people who are crying "But I pay my bills, why should the debt ridden get a free ride, blah, blah, blah?"
The point you are not "getting" is that this is how things work in a capitalist system.
Nobody cries foul when a business declares bankruptcy, because it is understood that it is "just business." Then, throughout the process the "business" TAKES ADVANTAGE of every and all loopholes; and again, nobody cries foul because it is "just business."
But heaven forbid a "consumer" tries to TAKE ADVANTAGE of every and all loopholes, everyone cries foul. Everyone cries "lack of ethics" and "lack of morals", etc, etc...
Why can't we simply be honest with ourselves?
The honest truth is that if you create an "out" for a debtor, don't complain when the debtor takes FULL ADVANTAGE of it. And don't forget that with time, views of "ethics" and "morality" morph, change and in some instances do a 180 degree turn.
It was not too long ago that the concept of "Jingle Mail" was on the list of the "horribly unethical", and now it is mainstream; it is now accepted as just "A BUSINESS DECISION."
As time goes forward, people will realize that you have to be a fool not to try and take advantage of the loopholes that are being provided by government.
The government is in the process of attempting to PROP UP asset values. That in and of itself is unethical and immoral, as it is the utter antithesis of the "Free Market" philosophy which these same government agencies have espoused all along.
So, if it is "OK" for the government to ABANDON "ethical" principles of finance, and it is "OK" for Business (Corporations, etc, both small and large) to ABANDON ethical" principles of finance, then how can you possibly expect the individual "consumer" to play by rules which ALL FORMS OF BUSINESS are discarding in droves, in favor of the loopholes provided by government?
Let me be clear. I am an honest individual who has ZERO DEBT. I pay all my bills on time, and I DO NOT "take advantage" of "loopholes."
But let me also be honest...
I clearly see that I AM THE CHUMP who is being steamrolled by way of unethical loopholes being created by government, in an insane attempt to prop up a drowning system based on a debt pyramid.
Now, just in case THAT is not clear enough for you, let me also state that I do NOT encourage "loophole taking", but rather I clearly see that those who do so are no more "wrong" than the government and corporate interests that CREATED this ethical abyss.
Simply stated, if you create an "out" for a debtor, you should be prepared for ALL DEBTORS to be looking for a piece of that "Bailout Pie."
Flipper,
I'm sure that you realize that when I mentioned "minorities" in the context of social engineering, that comes DIRECTLY and ver batim from the US government. This social experiment in housing is just another example of the socialist manipulation of the left (including President Bush, the socialist) and is a NATIONAL DISGRACE!!!
Mike
Mike, I am not following you here. Please explain further.
First you say:
As I see it, if the consumer can take out any kind of loan they want, then the lender should likewise be able to offer any kind of loan they want.
Please explain.
Our system is not capitalism, nor has it been for quite some time. Of late, it is getting worse and worse, but there has been a creeping toward socialism for many years now.
When you say...
It seems there is a misundersatanding of capitalism. Do you think our system is 100% capitalistic?
Bankruptcy is socialism. Capitalism allows the business to fail. In a true system of capitalism: The owner(s) spend the rest of their life or lives working until they pay the debts back. If not, they go to debtors prison. Is our society following capitalism? Certainly not. We socialized this aspect of business a long time ago.
Loopholes? Where do loopholes come from? Socialism!
"From each according to their ability, to each according to their need" - Karl Marx.
Loopholes are the manifestation of socialism. The legislators tax more over here and spread the wealth over there. Take from the rich, give to the poor - that is socialism. Again, you are attempting to make an example of capitalism but are pointing to the socialism aspects of our current system.
I am with you here, brother. In fact, I pretty much have been with you all along (even though this post sounds otherwise).
If I read you right, you are yelling at the system and those who created it? I am beside you, also yelling at them (not at you)
Christian,
Hats off to you. That was very written very well.
To the people who are crying "But I pay my bills, why should the debt ridden get a free ride, blah, blah, blah?"
The point you are not "getting" is that this is how things work in a capitalist system.
Scott, let's not be so quick to lump all points contrary to your opinion in one big group of "people who don't get it". It's annoying to get chastised in a forum.
Having said that, you nailed the point that some of us have been alluding to:
The government is in the process of attempting to PROP UP asset values. That in and of itself is unethical and immoral, as it is the utter antithesis of the "Free Market" philosophy which these same government agencies have espoused all along.
Anything done to prop up home value is completely artificial, dishonest, and blatant manipulation. It could have catastrophic consequences.
Christian and David,
I apologize for lumping everyone together. And I am not looking to chastise anyone. I am just so po'd at this debacle that I went on a rant.
Thanks,
Scott Cook
Again Scott - I believe we are all POed here.
We are all just preaching to the choir.
If I stand in the forest and yell at the top of my voice - will a congressmen hear me?
How about if I stand on Main Street? On Wall St.? In the town hall? In DC?
Unfortunately - I believe all that the yelling would get me is - ARRESTED.
This thread is a bit toxic, why focus on this part of the correction?
I am more focused on the opportunity. Let them do what they do........
I intend to do what I think I should do. Which is better my financial status