Use of Branding in Direct Mail

Use of Branding in Direct Mail

Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote

The expert consensus is that a campaign should include about 5-7 mailings. Statistics show the majority of the deals come from the 5th mailer and beyond. 

@Dev Horn has, on several occasions, stressed the importance of branding in direct mail campaigns in order to help stand out against competition. Moreover, @Jerry Puckett has advised that each subsequent mailer build on previous mailers (e.g. second mailer says "I have contacted you a few weeks back..."). These ideas make perfect sense if you want to create a campaign of 6 mailers, rather than 6 campaigns of one mailer. 

However, I would think that the synergies created would be lost if the recipient can't recognize a common brand from one mailer to the next. Yet, 1)  how does a homeowner distinguish two yellow letters sent from two different people (I'm not sure the name in the letter alone would do the trick)? 2) How can a homeowner recognize common brand between postcards and yellow letters? 

I am assuming several things here: the yellow letter is a handwritten letter the typical yellow paper. The only personal info of the sender included in the message is the name and phone number. There is no return address (according to @Michael Q., a return address could decrease the open rate). 

Any thoughts?   

1Reply
74 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · Greater LA/Orange County area, CA · Member since 2012 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
12y

Great thread. Something I may have missed in the discussion is how you build identity via your "voice" or if you prefer, the sound your copy makes in the readers head when read. 

I don't mean the vibrations, of course. I'm referring to the manner of copywriting and how your message (Headlines, sub-heads, USP, P.S., etc.) resonates and how you, as writer are able to connect with their current problem.

Well-crafted mail pieces will stand out as yours and yours alone. Especially when most of the stuff that I see is pure crap. Then you have the debate about long vs short copy. 

I tell you, I'm lazy. I'd rather find the exact guy or gal with the problem(s) that I want to encounter and solve and not even have contact with those folks who are still confused. So, I only look for targets who are absolutely going bat-sh*t crazy about their problem. Maybe that's why I prefer marketing to attorneys because when they can't resolve something, they call me. 

Gary Halbert always said to enter the conversation that's already going on in their head. The savvy marketer knows how to tap into this, agitate the problem in the mind of the reader, plant seeds of doubt (or worms in their brains) and offer something that hurts less (a 'palliative' proposition).

By the way, no one wants solutions. What they want is relief.  

See this reply in the discussion

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jerry PuckettPro Member
    Wholesaler · Fort Worth, TX · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Solomon Solomonov:

    Any thoughts?   

     Yes, a few:

    1) how does a homeowner distinguish two yellow letters sent from two different people? Timing is a key issue. I find that mailing more often than once a month ticks people off, and more than 6 weeks people tend to forget and not be able to connect the dots. The name, the envelope, the paper, the reminding within the letter body, the embedded commands and the calls to action...all of these elements serve to "brand" you. Not in the same sense a great Brand like We Buy Houses would, but in the sense that you are marked and memorable. Because I negotiate from the stance that I'm a one man shop, that serves me just fine.

    2) How can a homeowner recognize common brand between postcards and yellow letters? This is one of the reasons I gave up on Post Cards. People weren't connecting the dots no matter what I tried. Others have had far more success with Post Cards than I have. One of @Michael Quarles 's Video about the rule of 7. He says it better there than I ever could.

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Jerry Puckett 

    Thanks for the helpful feedback! So from I understand, it's not necessarily about having a logo on your mailer. It's more about having a unique and effective mailer (e.g. envelope, stamp, color ink, font, message content), while also being consistent in your mailings (e.g. once a month for six months). 

    I think I might consider only using yellow letters the first time around and testing a mix of YL and PC on a second campaign.

    Checked out @Dev Horns video. Brought the concept home. Thanks for the reference.  

    Quick follow up: 

    I'm guessing it would follow that when you're doing split tests, you want to test a single component on two separate groups, rather than on the same group. For example, say you want to test different envelope types. You would use envelope X for group 1 and envelope Y for group 2, but you wouldn't test envelopes X and Y during the same campaign on group 1, since your branding could get lost. Is my thinking correct? 

    Thanks again for the feedback. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Solomon Solomonov 

    @Dev Horn promotes a great brand. I think that it could be the best brand for real estate investors offered today.  However even though brand marketing is important the licensees would be foolish to only utilize the WBH brand.  Mixing in various media types and messages will serve a bucket load of benefit. 

    @Jerry Puckett promotes a kiss me approach which offers a great awareness for those prospects who are motivated by a stimulation that serves their desire. I believe a fantastic approach.  

    However consider a bigger picture and remember both Dev and Jerry's approaches are fringing awesome. 

    Think of this.  What do you see when you are within a crowd? Short of if that crowd were at a major sports arena or political campaign the answer is that you will notice individuality.  

    That individuality is a byproduct of choice.  If you pie shaped the crowd certainly a good portion would love the WBHes offer and another portion would consider Jerry's offer unmatched by any other.  But what about the remaining portion which would represent the majority. 

    Are you prepared to dismiss them?  The largest crowd.  

    My solution is wrapping everyone together by utilizing a marketing strategy which encompasses multiple mail pieces which speaks to multiple social and educational mentalities. 

    Don't limit your prosperity by limiting your marketing. 

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Michael Q. 

    "My solution is wrapping everyone together by utilizing a marketing strategy which encompasses multiple mail pieces which speaks to multiple social and educational mentalities."

    Mastering brand awareness just for yellow letters is challenging enough. Achieving the type of cohesive marketing strategy with multiple mail pieces seems like a tall order (at least for beginners). Does YellowLetters (or some other turnkey company) provide such comprehensive solutions?

  • Jerry PuckettPro Member
    Wholesaler · Fort Worth, TX · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Michael Quarles  wouldn't be telling you that if he couldn't make it happen. His site used to specifically offer a mixed campaign. Check it out

    looks like links don't work from tablets...

    http://www.YellowLetters.com/

  • Lender · Greater LA/Orange County area, CA · Member since 2012 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    Great thread. Something I may have missed in the discussion is how you build identity via your "voice" or if you prefer, the sound your copy makes in the readers head when read. 

    I don't mean the vibrations, of course. I'm referring to the manner of copywriting and how your message (Headlines, sub-heads, USP, P.S., etc.) resonates and how you, as writer are able to connect with their current problem.

    Well-crafted mail pieces will stand out as yours and yours alone. Especially when most of the stuff that I see is pure crap. Then you have the debate about long vs short copy. 

    I tell you, I'm lazy. I'd rather find the exact guy or gal with the problem(s) that I want to encounter and solve and not even have contact with those folks who are still confused. So, I only look for targets who are absolutely going bat-sh*t crazy about their problem. Maybe that's why I prefer marketing to attorneys because when they can't resolve something, they call me. 

    Gary Halbert always said to enter the conversation that's already going on in their head. The savvy marketer knows how to tap into this, agitate the problem in the mind of the reader, plant seeds of doubt (or worms in their brains) and offer something that hurts less (a 'palliative' proposition).

    By the way, no one wants solutions. What they want is relief.  

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Rick Harmon Great point!

    There are more complex components to direct mailing than I originally thought. It's not just about the types of envelopes, letters, font, ink, etc. You have to consider things like the "voice," a USP that provides "relief" to specific target markets, and embedded commands and calls to action. On top of that, all these components need to be presented as a cohesive brand across multiple pieces. 

    I think what I'll do is leverage the decades of experience that YellowLetters brings to the table. I think it would give me a head start. It might take years worth of testing and tweaking just to get to the point of what YellowLetters.com can provide. 

    This thread actually provided a lot of clarity. The next step for me is to contact YellowLetters and get some details on what a comprehensive campaign would look like. 

    @Jerry Puckett  @Michael Q  @Rick Harmon  

    Your posts on this site have been incredibly helpful. At some point I put down the books and shifted to BP exclusively, in large part due to your contributions. Thank you!  

  • Real Estate Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2014 · 158 posts · 100 votes
    12y

    @Solomon Solomonov great questions, and an issue I have been working through myself over the past couple of weeks. I do tons of YLs, and some other mail types with decent results, but was looking for something more organized, which I discovered last time I was looking through the yellowletters.com website. 

    If you haven't already, go to yellowletters.com and order @Michael Quarles Fundamentals of Success program. It's less than $100 and module 6 is a detailed break down of the direct mail strategy - how to combine multiple mail pieces for maximum effectiveness. I'm working through it now and can't wait to implement some of the new things I picked up. Aso has a great seller presentation script. Well worth the cost. Here's the URL:

     https://www.yellowletters.com/category/coaching-pr...

    Best of luck!

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

     @Chris Kennedy 

    Thanks for the suggestions. I'll be sure to pick up the material. 

  • Dev HornPro Member
    Flipper/Rehabber · Arlington, TX · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    A simple, straightforward brand, repeatedly presented, results in the ability to recall that brand at a later time when a need arises.  A brand is generally conveyed via a LOGO and brand equity is extended via the application of consistent color schemes, fonts, etc.  You can have a good logo designed professionally for just a few hundred bucks via a vendor such as Logoworks.com...

    Most of our mail will NOT arrive at a moment simultaneous to a seller's realization that they need to sell.  Real estate agents have known this for many many years, and as a result, they seek to do 2 things - a) Exploit a well known, trusted brand - e.g., Keller Williams and b) Present themselves (via photo and name) as a real estate solution provider that works under that trusted brand.  Not surprisingly, we employ those same elements in our branding strategy.

    Because they (typically) would not enable me to exploit my branding, I have never mailed yellow letters myself, so I'll leave that topic up to the experts.  I know they can be call generators.

    Also, since Jerry mentioned it and it speaks to the original posting, here's the video on the Rule of 7.

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Dev Horn 

    Thanks for the feedback! Your video set the foundation for the way I think about direct mail - the idea of consistency and repetition. 

    I'm also glad you chimed in on the topic of branding. This is the issue I've been having: I accept the principal that you should "touch" your target market 5-7 times if you hope to get a response. However, that presumes that there is some cumulative effect that your mail pieces have on the Homeowner. Yet, how is that possible if there is no cohesive brand across multiple mail pieces? And how can that even be achieved when coupling yellow letters with other types of mail pieces (e.g. postcards, zip letters, etc.). It almost seems to me that you either send yellow letters or you send something else. You cant send both. It would be like having 6 campaigns of 1 mailer rather than a single campaign of 6 mailers. 

    Thoughts? 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    When I research marketing I always look for the "Why"...

    So why does Coke have 112 brands?

    Aquapure

    Aquarius

    Bacardi Mixers *

    Bacardi Premium Mixers *

    Barq's

    Barrilitos

    Beverly

    Bright And Early

    Caffeine-free Barq's

    Caffeine-free Coca-Cola

    Caffeine-free Diet Coke

    Cascal

    cherry Coke

    Chippewa

    Citra

    Coca-Cola

    Coca-Cola Black Cherry Vanilla

    Coca-Cola Cherry Zero

    Coca-Cola Zero

    Coca-Cola Zero Caffeine-Free

    Cumberland Gap

    DANNON *

    DASANI

    Delaware Punch

    diet Barq's

    Diet cherry Coke

    Diet Coke

    Diet Coke Black Cherry Vanilla

    Diet Coke with Lime

    Diet Coke with Splenda

    Diet Fuze Tea

    diet Inca Kola

    Diet Master Pour

    Diet Northern Neck

    Diet Sprite

    Diet Sprite Zero

    Dr Pepper*

    Evian *

    Fanta

    Fanta Sugar Free

    Fanta Zero

    Five Alive

    Flavor Rage

    Fresca

    Fruitopia

    Full Throttle

    FUZE

    FUZE TEA

    Georgia

    glacéau fruitwater

    glacéau smartwater

    glacéau vitaminenergy

    glacéau vitaminwater

    glacéau vitaminwater zero

    Gold Peak

    H2OK

    Hi-C

    Honest Ade

    Honest Fizz

    Honest Kids

    Honest Tea

    Honest Tea Zero

    Illy *

    Inca Kola

    Java Monster*

    Jericho

    Kinley

    Krest

    Lift

    Master Chill

    Master Pour

    Mello Yello

    Mello Yello Zero

    Mezzo Mix

    Minute Maid

    Minute Maid Enhanced

    Minute Maid Fruit Falls

    Minute Maid Juices To Go

    Minute Maid Light

    Minute Maid Orchards

    Monster *

    Northern Neck

    NOS

    Odwalla

    Peace Tea *

    Pepe Rico

    Pibb Xtra

    Pibb Zero

    POWERADE

    POWERADE PLAY

    POWERADE ZERO

    Red Flash

    Schweppes

    Simply

    Southern Sun

    Spring!

    Sprite

    Sprite Zero

    Sugar Free Full Throttle

    Sugar Free NOS

    Sugar Free Sprite

    Sunfill

    Surge

    TaB

    Vanilla Coke

    Vanilla Coke Zero

    VAULT

    Vault Zero

    Vegibeta

    Vegitabeta

    Worx Energy *

    Zico *

    If they only sold a single brand, say Coke, would they have the same market share OR by selling different brands is their market share bigger? Do they really need to sell TaB? Or do they?

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Michael Quarles 

    I see your point, but it also depends on the level of generalization. Coke has a greater market share in the beverage industry, but I doubt that Powerade helps sell Sprite (although having different flavors of Powerade can probably help sell more Powerade). 

    As I understand, the cumulative effect of consistent mailing stems from receivers developing recall, which is achieved through awareness, branding, etc. I can see how mailing 6 postcards, or 6 yellow letters, or 6 zip letters would achieve this cumulative effect. I'm just not sure about a mixed approach (e.g. YL, PC, ZL, YL, PC, ZL).  

    I've gotten a bunch of help from Norma and Alexis at YellowLetters.com and I am about 30 days away from launching my first campaign. I'm just on the fence about whether I should just go with yellow letters only or mix it up.  

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    Let me try again...

    When marketing our job is to create a perceived and factual solution(s) that is reasonable to the prospect which ultimately solves their underlying motivation. As we present those solutions we tell a story of "pick me".

    But what if what we said within our marketing couldn't speak to all types of people so that they could understand us in a way that creates a solution for them to pick us? How do we speak to people who don't see the solution within a series of yellow letters or a series of postcards or even zipletters?

    I sit in a very unique spot. I know what works because besides the millions of pieces of mail I send for investors and agents I too use my service and I absolutely would only send out Postcards or only send out YellowLetters etc. if doing so allowed me a higher return however I know that doing so would diminish my return.

    My only agenda is the best return for you on your marketing dollar.

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    Empirical data is convincing enough for me. Gona go with the YL, PC, ZL, YL, PC, ZL structure through YellowLetters.com. Should launch in about 30 days. Stay tuned for results. Thanks for all the help!

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Michael Quarles 

    Would you suggest the same yellow letter ("Investor 1") on both yellow letter rounds or to use a different template on the second yellow letter round? Same postcards on both postcard rounds? Same zip letters on both zip letter rounds? 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Bakersfield, CA · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    I would... People don't see what they don't need and a 90 day cycle is long enough to penetrate the procrastination that occurs in the beginning of needing to sell a house.

    Besides three pieces are the work horses of direct mail so there's little reason to change copy.

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2014 · 16 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    @Michael Quarles 

    Got it. Thanks! 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.