Realtor · Houston, TX · Member since 2013 · 128 posts · 27 votes
The more I learn the less I know.
As I designed my first batch of postcards (3000 of which will be going in the mail this Friday) I realized I knew very little about the psychology behind getting a consumer to pay attention to my message long enough to get it across.
Can anyone recommend any good blogs/books/websites/online classes/audio books/mentors centered around direct mail? (I googled and found a few, but often those sites are great at SEO - I'm looking for the good info, not the easy to find info)
I realize I could pay someone to do the direct mail stuff for me, but I'm a fan of the teach a man to fish style of thinking. Once I know how to fish, then I'll turn it over to someone else with the knowledge that I can at least hopefully tell if they're fishing for ME or if they're fishing FOR me.
@Al - here are a few resources that I have found helpful:
The no BS guide to writing a sales letter Dan Kennedy ( title is something like that)
The ultimate marketing strategy Dan Kennedy ( title is something like that)
Outrageous marketing for outrageous results bill geyser or something like that
Duct tape marketing don't know author's names
I'm a big Dan Kennedy fan - yes he up sells in his books, but the content and psychology insights are well worth the cost. If I were you I would Drop 50-60 bucks in used books on Amazon and study the craft of sales copy.
I think that I could be of some help to your current situation. I'm a marketing director and I deal with questions like theses all the time. Your on the right track of wanting a short an precise message. With a postcard you will need to make it personal with the person your contacting. Such as their name and property address. This will catch the your target audience attention. For the majority of Postcard response rates are 0.2% to 5%. With 3000 that's That's why I always encourage creating a system of multiple forms of advertising for your marketing campaign. You can also us yellow letters, bandit signs, website seo attraction to bring in clients.
I've seen the YL website (many times). It's hard to miss when you research anything centering around marketing on BP or REI marketing in general. SEO skills for you guys - big win.
What I didn't see on the website was general info about direct mail marketing that I was looking for (yes, I even gave the site a 19th look). I swiped a couple of ideas from your yellow postcards, but I'm just "copying" ideas - without knowing how/why the idea works, I'm nothing more than a hack or a copycat.
I have a desire to understand the science and technology behind the marketing piece.
Check out John Carlton & Gary Halbert. Gary is the friggin man!!!
I'm huge on direct response marketing and LOVE copywriting but I don't write my own copies. I know enough to tell if my copywriters did a good job or not.
I believe that hiring a professional is the way to go. I leave my tax to my cpa and surgery to my doctor and copywriting/sales letter to my copywriter. haha hope that gets my point.
It's worth the investment to pay someone $1000-5000 to do your copywriitng if 1-2 deal can get your ROI right back.
@Al - here are a few resources that I have found helpful:
The no BS guide to writing a sales letter Dan Kennedy ( title is something like that)
The ultimate marketing strategy Dan Kennedy ( title is something like that)
Outrageous marketing for outrageous results bill geyser or something like that
Duct tape marketing don't know author's names
I'm a big Dan Kennedy fan - yes he up sells in his books, but the content and psychology insights are well worth the cost. If I were you I would Drop 50-60 bucks in used books on Amazon and study the craft of sales copy.
Joy Gendusa over at Postcardmania has a great $20 ebook specifically on postcard marketing. I interviewed her a while back for my blog. You can get it free through a link in the post there.
Sharon
I'm having technical issues over there today with my forms. Grrr! I hate it!
Dev Horn - see if you can work this into some copy for a postcard for direct mail to absentee owners:
"Friends teasing you about being a slum lord?"
Big yellow print - black background - 5.5 x 8.5 postcards with a "you might be a landlord if..." style list on the back of the card.
I prefer humor and/or shock for attention getters.
Chris Cho & Arthur Garcia - thanks! Great info on the websites and Mr. Kennedy has a ton of books on Amazon (fortunately at a discount for the kindle editions). I'll be spending lots of time on the deck reading this weekend.
Sharon Vornholt - I started reading your blog after your BP podcast. I was already headed towards direct mail before your podcast, but your endorsement of it made it a certainty. My meager $1500/month marketing budget shifted from bandit signs & sign rentals (with a little direct mail here and there) to direct mail with some bandit signs thrown in every once in awhile. Headed over to your blog right now to see if I can find a link to that book.
Dev Horn
Check out uprinting.com (no affiliation) for the high-zoot stuff. So far I haven't been able to find anyone in Houston that can touch their prices for 20k pieces. (I haven't stopped looking though).
So far I haven't been able to find anyone in Houston that can touch their prices for 20k pieces. (I haven't stopped looking though).
Hi Al Bunch - I had to jump in here when I read your last post. Are you thinking of printing 20k pieces right off the bat? If so, I would strongly advise against that. Ask any direct response marketer - marketing is synonymous with testing. Test test test before you invest.
I once printed several thousand full-color mailers, only to find out that they bombed in terms of response rate. I was out all that money because I wanted to be cheap and get a better price per postcard by printing larger quantity. Never again.
I too am a fan of Dan Kennedy. I believe it was one of his audio programs, can't remember which, where he was interviewing a direct response marketer who was doing half and full page newspaper ads with great success. However, this DR marketer said they started with a tiny little classified ad and grew slowly from there as they tested and tweaked their message. He said that if anyone thought to jump straight to the full page ads, he'd call them crazy and reckless with their money. It's just not smart.
So, pay a little more per piece in the beginning, it will be worth it in the long run.
By the way, don't forget about click2mail.com - no minimum quantity order and does what you need it to.
Blair H. Thanks for watching out for my best interests. I'm not quite ready to buy that many identical postcards quite yet, I just use the 20k cards as a benchmark for volume pricing. Once I get my message figured out, I'll definitely buy in quantity.
Blair H. That ad had to have been from quite some time ago...I thought that phone number looked familiar. (1010tires.com) 1010's website says they started in 2000 - no telling if the got the ph# at the same time, but that's 13 years ago if they did.
I let it go in 2008. One of the dumbest things I've done. Stupid stupid stupid. The other was not fighting homevestors after the government granted my trade mark when they appealed. Stupid stupid stupid.
We were one of the many that got a patent infringement trademark cease and desist letter from them. Looking around these days it seems like they've lost some of their steam as I see quite a few people snuggled right up to the edge of the we buy *gly houses slogan.
Hindsight is 20-20. I wish I had stayed in the stick built market instead of doing mobile home deals.
Dev Horn- I really love the company - Postcardmania; and Joy is a brilliant marketer. They have over 5000 articles on marketing in their site for anyone that is interested. Her ebook on marketing is definitely worth getting. She has a lot of general info in there.
They have georgeous postcards, but unfortunately after trying two different cards they just didn't work in my niches. I think they are just too "pretty" or maybe too commercial looking. Plainer postcards work better.
Sharon Vornholt - that's so interesting that you said that. I've been collecting all kinds of postcards from my mailbox for a few weeks now - just to see what other industries & companies are doing. I was looking at this PILE of postcards today and they just seemed to blend together. Almost all had very high production values. Most had a blend of photography and graphics (I've been pondering the use of photos), but it just struck me that nothing stood out, nothing was memorable. I appreciate your observation that "Plainer postcards work better." - Thank you!
Russell Ponce I haven't stopped reading since I made this post. I found some really good reports/slide decks that illustrate how even the tiniest of changes can increase or decrease response rates:
http://www.the-dma.org/whitepapers/TestingDMWhitePaper-GAWrightFINAL100305.pdf
Then some metrics about direct mail:
http://www.ruthstevens.com/pdf/Allegra-DM-White-Paper-FINAL.pdf
Head on over to Sharon's blog and watch her video interview with Joy Gendusa of Postcardmania and then pick up a free copy of Joy's e-book on postcards and direct mail:
http://louisvillegalsrealestateblog.com/amazing-entrepreneurs-interview-with-joy-gendusa
Dan Kennedy has a ton of books on direct mail marketing that are filled with some excellent points - if you have an Amazon Kindle, you can check out some of his books for free - start with the relevant titles first.
I've got two more months of postcards queued up before I can start doing any real testing, but I was able to expand my list to just a little over 7500 names, split it into 4 groups of almost exactly equal size. I mail twice per month, so with the new lists I'll mail a control and a test piece out every two weeks. I'll be tracking my results by giving each piece a distinct phone number that I can count calls on.
The control I'll be mailing out will be the same postcard I've been using. Each test piece will have some tiny change on it for the first few rounds (font, card color, layout).