Big headache - tenant won't move after lease expired

Big headache - tenant won't move after lease expired

Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes

She told us she would not renew the lease in Jun as she bought a house and would close in July.  However, on July 30th, she said her closing date was postponed to Aug 9th and she wanted to stay until Aug 10th.

We found our new tenant in July and signed a lease with them starting Aug 1st.   But they were flexible with the move-in date so we renewed the lease to a later date, which is not so bad as we plan to install new floorings before they move in.


Now the old tenant is not cooperating -

1. she does not answer our phone

2. we sent her the addendum with the original rent proportioned by date but put on a late fee $500 per day after Aug 10 (to motivate her to move!).  She changed it to $50 without telling us, signed and sent it back (we have not signed it) so basically, I think, a, she knows there is a possibility that she won't be able to close on Aug 9th and she plans to stay! b, has she conducted a contract fraud?

3. the addendum said $532 be paid on Aug 1st.  she paid $500 on Aug 2nd.

4. her mom (not on the lease) keeps sending us long texts, saying she is working on our property, fixing up, and charging us $25 per hour.   Saying we had not maintained the property.   And she threatens to report us for mold and fire hazards.

Fact: we fixed things she reported and for the past four years, she was a pretty ok tenant.  She was a PhD student now post Doc. and a single mom, that's why we had tried to be accommodating.  The mold she was talking about was a roof leakage 3 years ago, which we hired a company to fix it.  We sprayed the anti-mold thing to the ceiling.  They only told us three days ago there were dark marks.  and also in 2019, she reported dishwasher leakage, which we replaced with a new one.  She told us there was water damage to the floor but it looked ok until three days ago they removed the floor and sent us a picture it was black.  The fire hazard was ridiculous as we replaced the fire detectors 2 years ago, but she said they were yellow and old.

We are in VA. What shall we do now?

0Reply
206 views

Most Popular Reply

JD MartinBusiness Member
Moderator
Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
4y

You need to be filing for eviction pronto on the first available day (August 11, it sounds like). At least get the process started. She is not going to want a public eviction on her record.

I would also have an attorney send her a letter. You need to show her you mean business, plain and simple. You should not have changed anything on her behalf but filed for eviction as a squatter when she didn't leave by August 1st. Forget about the mother, you should only be talking to whomever is on the signed lease. Let her do what she wants about a lawyer.

Future lesson: unless you're 100% certain the unit will be vacant, don't rent it out before then OR be sure there's no recourse for your future tenants if you have to cancel the lease because you can't perform. Otherwise you could be on the hook both sides. 

Skyline Properties
View Page
See this reply in the discussion

51 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

    @Clara Tang Good, get her out of there...stick to your guns, you are in the right. Just do everything legally....


     The lawyer burst into laughters when we showed him all those lengthy text messages from her mom.  She even sent us a selfie today. 

    I don't feel safe interacting with them.  Anyway we can have a no contact exit walk through and keys handover? You guys have any suggestions?


     Now that you have an attorney, just STAY AWAY. No calls , no texts.

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Clara Tang:
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

    @Clara Tang Good, get her out of there...stick to your guns, you are in the right. Just do everything legally....


     The lawyer burst into laughters when we showed him all those lengthy text messages from her mom.  She even sent us a selfie today. 

    I don't feel safe interacting with them.  Anyway we can have a no contact exit walk through and keys handover? You guys have any suggestions?


     Now that you have an attorney, just STAY AWAY. No calls , no texts.

    But I doubt that the attorney would take care of the exit inspection.
  • Lender · CO CA TX WA ID OR · Member since 2020 · 419 posts · 542 votes
    4y

    @Clara Tang I didn’t read the comments, but tell them you are selling and have a RE Agent show up to the home

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:
    Quote from @JD Martin:

    You need to be filing for eviction pronto. At least get the process started. She is not going to want a public eviction on her record.

    I would also have an attorney send her a letter. You need to show her you mean business, plain and simple. You should not have changed anything on her behalf but filed for eviction as a squatter when she didn't leave by August 1st. 

    We've talked to a couple of lawyers and got a few different opinions.  
    A. stay put and pray they leave on Aug 10th.  
    B. have an attorney send a letter, and warn her of the consequences.

    We have gone to the General Court and got the forms for eviction.  I suppose if we submit the form she would instantly be notified?  I am curious how the eviction would impact her house purchasing and credit score.  What if she moves out before the court rules?  Would that impact her?  I agree, she is educated and she has got a decent job.  She would not want an eviction on her record.  

     The consequences should include potentially losing a signed tenant that initially was expecting to move in Aug 1.  This would place any vacancy cost on current tenant.   

    Note existing tenant when they modified contract and you did not agree means they have no extension.  Their end of lease is July 31 due to them not signing the contract as provided.  In many states (but not my state) you can get them removed from the property immediately at end of lease.  I would start to get them removed immediately. 

    I would so block the mom’s number.  She is not your tenant.  There is no need to listen to/reading any of the garbage she is texting.  Ignore it. Any deficiencies reported by her mean nothing.  

    Time to get tough.  


  • Rental Property Investor · Marion, IA · Member since 2020 · 14 posts · 10 votes
    4y

    If your worried about the "Mold" contact your insurance company you should be covered by them for that. However it is very unlikely that could happen they would have to prove it was mold and prove beyond doubt that it has affected them. I have had several tenants with any mildew or dark spot anywhere on the property try to use that as leverage for there situation just part of the business. Other than that I agree with all that have said just use a lawyer and do not respond to any contact other than maintenance calls. Could try a Cash For Keys exit. The walk through bring a 3rd party witness someone they don't know (friend or family member) don't introduce them and just be polite and get through it. Good luck. 

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Jamie Hoth:

    If your worried about the "Mold" contact your insurance company you should be covered by them for that. However it is very unlikely that could happen they would have to prove it was mold and prove beyond doubt that it has affected them. I have had several tenants with any mildew or dark spot anywhere on the property try to use that as leverage for there situation just part of the business. Other than that I agree with all that have said just use a lawyer and do not respond to any contact other than maintenance calls. Could try a Cash For Keys exit. The walk through bring a 3rd party witness someone they don't know (friend or family member) don't introduce them and just be polite and get through it. Good luck. 

    I think it is far-fetched.  They already asked someone to evaluate the 'mold' and sent us the quote - they said they wanted to make sure we hired someone before they left, which is totally none of their business.  I suppose if the company said it bad definitely, they would have been all over on us.  They just said they 'were concerned about the long-term effect on our health'

    When we sent the last friendly email asking for a face2face conversation, we were thinking of Cash for keys - giving back the $500 to them.  They refused to talk decently.  Now we hired an attorney.  I guess we passed the point of no return.
  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    To give you folks an update:

    We engaged a lawyer and sent out a notice stating that 

    1. as the tenant modified the $500 fee if they stay after Aug 10th, the addendum is void and their current stay is unlawful

    2. as in our lease any repairment or alteration to the property over $30 needs our written agreement, which they don't have, we are not obligated to reimburse any cost.

    3. exit walkthrough would be on Aug 11th.


    Our tenant with a doctor of education degree replied -

    1. she signed the addendum so she is not an illegal squatter.  She did mention that she revised the addendum "However he had added an extra modification that was untenable, of 500 per day for vacancy, and I was able to accept $50 per day, and thus signed the addendum that stated $50 instead of $500.', which double-baffled me with her reading comprehension! We said $500 late fee for the stay after Aug10th! and our lawyer made it clear that the addendum is void BECAUSE she revised it!!

    2. the lease agrees on repairment under $30, so what they have been doing is ok.  Well, that is 'tenant's responsibility', so don't ask us to pay for the supplies and $25 per hour * 20+ hours! You cannot have both ways!

    3. mold again.  We did a thorough dig through our communication.  After she told us about the dishwasher leakage, we asked a mold company to check, the response was 'replace the dishwasher' without any mention of mold.  After that no complaints for 2 years at least, until last week, she flipped the floor and took pictures telling us there may be mold.


    After reading her response, I said we don't need to discuss any further as either she lacks basic reading comprehension and knowledge of contract law, or she is distorting the facts.  We decided to ask a handyman to go through the inspection with us, to check any work they said they did (if they cause any damage?), and any repairs we need to do before the new tenants move in. 

    I have one last question - can we deduct the legal fee from her deposit?

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    BTW, we gave a heads up to our new tenants, both in writing and verbal, telling them the worst situation would be eviction that could take a few weeks, but we have hired an attorney to try our best to get the current tenant out on Aug 10th.  They were cool.

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

    Our tenant with a doctor of education degree replied -

    Ahhh , you should have said so....these are the most muddled people on the planet...

  • Member since 2022 · 115 posts · 49 votes
    4y

    Like someone posted, I would block the mother's contact.  You have no obligation to communicate with her. If she still steps outside of her boundary, I would get the law involved as I am perceiving this as a form of harassment now.  

    Based on your comments, I sense that you are taking this rather emotionally.  Remember that it's a business.  As much as you want to be sympathetic to people and their issues, the property is still yours at the end of the day.  In my mind, if there were so many concerns about it, then why not move out sooner instead of delay the inevitable?

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Mariel DeVito:

    Based on your comments, I sense that you are taking this rather emotionally.  Remember that it's a business. 

    ^^And there you have it. It is a business and a very expensive one, holding a valuable asset, worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. Treat it with the respect it deserves and it will take care of you. Treat it like you have been, and well........

    Sounds like you are on the right track though! Live and learn...


  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Mariel DeVito:

    Like someone posted, I would block the mother's contact.  You have no obligation to communicate with her. If she still steps outside of her boundary, I would get the law involved as I am perceiving this as a form of harassment now.  

    Based on your comments, I sense that you are taking this rather emotionally.  Remember that it's a business.  As much as you want to be sympathetic to people and their issues, the property is still yours at the end of the day.  In my mind, if there were so many concerns about it, then why not move out sooner instead of delay the inevitable?

    You are right.  I might have been really lucky that I have not run into many jerks and lunatics before.  

    "if there were so many concerns about it, then why not move out sooner instead of delay the inevitable? " My husband said so too.  I have no idea why they have been fixating on fixing our property all of sudden.  At first, I was thinking they tried to be nice so we would let them stay.  When they started mentioning they could report us to the health department and talking about working the whole weekend 8*2 hours and her hourly rate is $25, I started to think they may want to stay for free.  But if money is the concern, why not pick up our phone call, and talk to us?

    I don't get it.  Honestly.

    And she called herself "an absolute model tenant"


  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Mariel DeVito:

    Like someone posted, I would block the mother's contact.  You have no obligation to communicate with her. If she still steps outside of her boundary, I would get the law involved as I am perceiving this as a form of harassment now.  

    Based on your comments, I sense that you are taking this rather emotionally.  Remember that it's a business.  As much as you want to be sympathetic to people and their issues, the property is still yours at the end of the day.  In my mind, if there were so many concerns about it, then why not move out sooner instead of delay the inevitable?


     Well, her mom sent a selfie to my husband, which is the last straw.  It took me a while to see why she did it.  In our last effort to have a meaningful conversation with the tenant, I said 'we need to talk to you as you are the one and only tenant on the lease.  Although we know your mom must be a lovely lady, we just cannot speak with her about our lease'  so she replied 'yes, I am beautiful, intelligent and lovely ' and a selfie to my husband.  And I said to my husband, let's go to see the lawyer.  She is insane.

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:


    Someone can't just start working and then say you owe them money. That's ridiculous. Did they give you a bid first? Did you sign a legal contract with her? 

    No. So she has nothing to stand on here.

    I would keep a record of all contact to this point. Block all future contact. Get a lawyer already before this goes any further.....


  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Clara Tang:


    Someone can't just start working and then say you owe them money. That's ridiculous. Did they give you a bid first? Did you sign a legal contract with her? 

    No. So she has nothing to stand on here.

    I would keep a record of all contact to this point. Block all future contact. Get a lawyer already before this goes any further.....


    They told my husband there were things needed to be fixed before the new tenants move in and they can help.  My husband said okay please take pictures and let me know first what they were first.  That's what they called our verbal agreement.  And they started "updating" us the status of their progress.  I replied in the text that we had not given any agreement to them to work on anything.  And asked them to sign the addendum as without one, they occupied our property illegally.  At that time, we still believed they would move out on Aug 10 and was okay if they stay but we wanted to have a contact to say they know and accept our flooring project (prevent them from complaining the project makes the property inhabitable)

    I don't know why they were so reluctant to sign an addendum, if they planned to move out on Aug 10.  I don't know why they are so eager to fix our property when they are busy packing and leaving.  Everything is just beyond my comprehension.


  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

    BTW, we gave a heads up to our new tenants, both in writing and verbal, telling them the worst situation would be eviction that could take a few weeks, but we have hired an attorney to try our best to get the current tenant out on Aug 10th.  They were cool.


     I really hope they leave on their own.  The current tenants sound 'special' and things will be simpler when they are gone.  Until the, don't reply to any of the mom's texts or calls.

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:


    Sounds like they are not planning on leaving........


  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    The mom called us and left a message this morning saying the AC was down.

    what should we do now?

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

    The mom called us and left a message this morning saying the AC was down.

    what should we do now?

    First, do nothing until the actual tenant reports the problem. No communication with the Mom, remember? Send over an HVAC Tech to diagnose, and if this is a prank call, they pay for it, send them the bill. If there actually is a problem, get it fixed....you are still a landlord, right???

    Please tell us you have an appt with an attorney tomorrow....?


  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

    The mom called us and left a message this morning saying the AC was down.

    what should we do now?

    First, do nothing until the actual tenant reports the problem. No communication with the Mom, remember? Send over an HVAC Tech to diagnose, and if this is a prank call, they pay for it, send them the bill. If there actually is a problem, get it fixed....you are still a landlord, right???

    Please tell us you have an appt with an attorney tomorrow....?


    Okay. We ignored her mom and she finally sent a message to my husband report the AC problem.  We will ask our contractor to go and check.
  • Investor · FL · Member since 2013 · 26 posts · 29 votes
    4y

    @Clara Tang

    Sounds like your likely going to spend a lot of money. Have you considered asking her if instead of charging her late penalties, can you offer to give her $500 to help with moving expenses, will she move out today?

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Jarod Rotolo:

    @Clara Tang

    Sounds like your likely going to spend a lot of money. Have you considered asking her if instead of charging her late penalties, can you offer to give her $500 to help with moving expenses, will she move out today?

    We did think about it but wanted to make sure they moved out before 10th so we suggested sit down and talk.  But before we engaged the attorney, the tenant just refused to talk and kept threatening us with the mold issue.  And her mom was harassing us, even after we stopped communicating with her.  

    we will just wait until 11th. Hopefully with the attorney involvement, she will move as she promised.
  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

     So you did get an attorney? Good!

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

     So you did get an attorney? Good!


     Yes after her mom sending us selfie, her reluctance to talk, and constant threat of mold issue, we feel we had no choice but engaging an attorney.

  • Member since 2022 · 26 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Clara Tang:

     So you did get an attorney? Good!

    The tenant moved out and we had the walkthrough this noon.  Her mom came too.  Neither of them mentioned anything they said in texts and emails.  

    Phew!

    Thanks, everyone for your suggestions and support!


Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.