Omaha Property Management Companies - Advice?
My husband and I live in the Denver area but have a long term rental in Omaha. We bought it in 2023 and are on our second property management company in the 2.5 years we've owned it. Both PMCs have been horrible. Their monthly rate is reasonable, but they charge incredibly high rates for any maintenance issues, repairs, tenant turnover, etc. Examples: $30 fuel surcharges for every visit, receipts from 3-4 different hardware stores when all items could have come from 1, 6+ hours of labor charged on repairs that should take less than 2, going with third party vendors that are over an hour away from the property that charge for drive time, etc. We feel that they see our property and all maintenance issues as a way to make them as much money as possible rather than choosing vendors with reasonable prices and there is no way for us to verify how much time their maintenance team is actually taking to do the work. They pay themselves first before we get paid, so there is no way for us to not pay for items we don't agree with. We know we are a 'small fish' since we only have 1 property with them, but our experience with PMCs and long term rentals in general have been horrible. We know selling would lose us money since we've only owned it for 2 years so we are trying to hang on, but when we are losing money every month due to the PMCs and their outrageous charges, it is making it hard.
Are there any honorable PMCs in the Omaha area that actually try to protect owner margins? Have others experienced this 'charge owners for as much as possible' culture with property managers in the area too?
We've considered self managing and trying to find a reliable handyman who can handle much of the ad hoc stuff that comes up but we've even had a hard time finding anyone who checks that box too (and it wouldn't necessarily help with serving notices / showing the place when vacant / etc). Does anyone have any recommendations on possible routes that have worked for them?