I am Pro Detroit but not ready to invest there yet.

I am Pro Detroit but not ready to invest there yet.

Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes

I posted this for discussion on the investment aspects of Detroit.

I am very pro Detroit, but not ready to invest there yet--too many problems.

I think it has a ways to go before I'd be comfortable investing there.

===

So many fixers, so much space for strip malls, if this were Austin, these places would sell for a Mint of money.

So many duplexes, all brick....

So many apartment buildings--all brick...

Too bad it's so Dangerous there.

===

Also I think it would be interesting to have a monopoly sized map of Detroit, and move all of the remaining (un-burned down) little houses and apartments into one area.

Put them on the Vacant lots and see how how really small Detroit is, if it were once again a city of homes side by side vs the acres and acres of burnt out lots with homes scattered in all directions. Condense the population so to speak into one proper town with new strip malls, and medical service areas---plus figure out what kind of work suits them and bring some of it there.

Might be easier to (weed out) the criminals if there were in one city of side by side homes, vs so spread out--and put a new BIG men's prison, women's prison and kids prison in that area too--and get rid of the crime.

===

Here a a couple of video tours:

[1] Class D Business District Tour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2qdMxzJsXY

[2] Class D Residential District Tour (Lots of Fixers here): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_rIv55jEq8

===

Any comments, observations, experiences, etc...

1Reply
45 views

Most Popular Reply

Joe HammelBusiness Member
Real Estate Agent · Metro Detroit, MI · Member since 2018 · 614 posts · 666 votes
4y

What is the bottom line for everyone in real estate investing? Passive income and a great ROI.

This is exactly what I (and so many others) have in Metro Detroit.

Drew said it well above.. "you're making a common mistake..."

Essentially by lumping in all the bad locations with the entire area...you (and many others) miss the sweet spot.

This is how so many people "see" Detroit. They only see Detroit as Vacant lots or burned houses and nothing more. In the mean time. I have a portfolio of houses in METRO Detroit that cash flows $300-$400+ a door and I've DOUBLED my equity in 3 years and it's very easy to manage with paying tenants. You can't tell me I've done poorly. I've used the cash flow to retire my parents. They don't work anymore because I have enough consistent cash flow to cover their needs. Did I fail? Nope. I've executed what everyone in Real Estate Dreams of, because of how good the investments are in Metro Detroit. 

Trust me, I'm NOT buying $10k-$20k houses in D markets. Those are the horror stories.. but there are near 100 individual cities within 50 mile radius of Detroit. Lots of people do make money buying in the up and coming neighborhoods of Detroit (a more difficult strategy) and I personally don't own a property IN Detroit, but my entire portfolio is in the suburbs bordering Detroit. 

Franklin, MI. A city just outside of Detroit... has an average home price of near $1,000,000. Is that a bad location? 

The locations I/we invest have an average price of $150k and I purchase the properties in the lower percentile and do extremely well.

The price/rent ratios are the best in the country. The sweet spot is the 1.2-1.4% deals. They cash flow so well and are in good working class locations. 

And on top of the great cash flow, i've personally seen double digit appreciation. The data doesn't lie.

Attached is an example of one of the cities I have a rental in. Oak Park. 24% average annual appreciation for 10 years straight. Paid $125k. Rents for $1500. Solid appreciating location. Average price in Oak park is $200k and I paid $125k for mine. Bought a solid house in the lower percentile and it cash flows extremely well and will continue to appreciate.

Just in metro Detroit there are over a DOZEN fortune 500 companies with Auto, Hospitals, and Mortgage industries leading the pack and supplying a lot of jobs. 

Metro Detroit is the best place in the Country to invest for the typical investor looking for passive cash flow and a good ROI. Prove me wrong.

FIRE Realty Team - Keller Williams5380 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4y

    Bump...

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4y

    @Scott Mac you're making the common mistake of lumping City of Detroit with Metro Detroit suburbs.

    Metro Detroit offers many options for meeting the 1% Rule and relatively high ROI.

    Follow our "Deep Dive" series we're doing about Metro Detroit cities and City of Detroit Neighborhoods: https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

    The two most common mistakes we see investors make, over & over again, are:

    1) Not understanding and running their own ROI numbers

    2) Not having a clear understanding of the type of asset a property is

    In our opinion, your best team member should be your Property Management Company (PMC). They have to deal with any property you buy every month until you sell or terminate them. Everyone else on your team will be transaction-based and not really involved after a purchase.

    We're in the Metro Detroit area, so you may want to follow our blog here on BP, but at least read the following posts:

    “How to Screen a PMC Better than a Tenant”: https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/3094/91877-how-to-screen-a-pmc-better-than-a-tenant-part-1-services-and-processes

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4y

    HI Drew,

    Great Blog post link!

    I was thinking more globally (for the city as a whole) than just for myself.

    I was looking at all of the fixers in actual D-town...all brick..."Cheap" but the crime is unpredictable.

    Unpredictable but it's there.

    I was postulating on how to make D-Town better...hence putting all of the remaining inhabited houses next to each other in the burnt out lots (like a monopoly board).

    Which in reality would mean building cheap new (burn proof) homes on the empty lots--and leaving the CHEAP brick fixers to be fixed up and flipped.

    But the problem is jobs--no jobs = no mortgages.

    So no one to flip to, other than Section-8 landlords.

    D-Town needs Good Paying Jobs...(and those car jobs are not coming back).

    Right now poverty is spread over a huge area, consolidating it MIGHT make helping it easier--and that would allow restoration of some of the original brick houses, apartments and commercial buildings in the area's the crime is removed from.

    And how big would D-Town really be if all of the remaining inhabited houses were lined up next to each other like a regular city? 10% of it's now size (???) 20% of it's now size (???)

    How much easier to administrate and how much easier to control the criminals.

    Which is kind of the crux of my post (look at all of those Residential fixers, and room for strip malls just sitting there.

    Good Luck!

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    4y

    The mortgage industry has shed tens of thousands of jobs this year, and is set to shed tens of thousands more. That's relevant because the city that was the "arsenal of democracy" became "motor city," it has now  become in no small part "mortgage city" (there are people who's families have literally done that transition, across a few generations, from grandpa building the bombers to dad building the cars to kid putting together the mortgages). Rocket/Quicken, Homepoint, UWM, if you've purchased more than 1 or 2 homes you've heard at least one of those names (I could have listed more), and all are in Metro Detroit (Rocket/Quicken employs more people than anyone but the legacy auto makers and public school system). I'm in California and do mortgages, but if both Los Angeles and Detroit have an unusual weather event on the same day, it's a good 50/50 coin toss which one I will hear about first (I'd only hear about a Texas or New York or Kentucky weather event on the news), dependent on if I talk to a client/realtor in SoCal, or a mortgage account executive, first, even though I'm on the other side of the country from one of those two locations, and in the same state as the other.

    Bust follows boom, so no surprise that mass layoffs are going on, but the "baseline" amount of mortgage business is going to be lower than pre-COVID 2019, moving forward. Which means I expect mortgage jobs in metro Detroit to be lower than they were in 2019 (each individual company is touting the line of "we're going to grow!" but they can't all be right, especially if total volume is lower, and the "we're growing!" line is a joke when uttered amid mass layoffs (amusing link), and stock valuations that are down >30% YTD across the board [see stock tickers: rkt, uwmc, hmpt]).

    A part of that "baseline" is always refinances, but anyone that rate/term refinanced in 2020/2021 will likely not rate/term refinance again for at least 6-10 years, just as folks that rate/term refid in 2012 ("omg 3.375%, rates can NEVER get that low again!") didn't do it again until 2020 (...they did... but it was 8 years later).

    I have no other specific knowledge about Detroit, just that one tidbit about one industry that's disproportionately located in that one city.

  • Real Estate Broker · Huntsville, AL · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 872 votes
    4y

    I've heard mixed reviews about Detroit and many of our clients have come down from that market because Toledo tends to perform better from a safety and quality standpoint, with just as great of cash flow. I'd be happy to discuss more in depth.

  • Joe HammelBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Metro Detroit, MI · Member since 2018 · 614 posts · 666 votes
    4y

    What is the bottom line for everyone in real estate investing? Passive income and a great ROI.

    This is exactly what I (and so many others) have in Metro Detroit.

    Drew said it well above.. "you're making a common mistake..."

    Essentially by lumping in all the bad locations with the entire area...you (and many others) miss the sweet spot.

    This is how so many people "see" Detroit. They only see Detroit as Vacant lots or burned houses and nothing more. In the mean time. I have a portfolio of houses in METRO Detroit that cash flows $300-$400+ a door and I've DOUBLED my equity in 3 years and it's very easy to manage with paying tenants. You can't tell me I've done poorly. I've used the cash flow to retire my parents. They don't work anymore because I have enough consistent cash flow to cover their needs. Did I fail? Nope. I've executed what everyone in Real Estate Dreams of, because of how good the investments are in Metro Detroit. 

    Trust me, I'm NOT buying $10k-$20k houses in D markets. Those are the horror stories.. but there are near 100 individual cities within 50 mile radius of Detroit. Lots of people do make money buying in the up and coming neighborhoods of Detroit (a more difficult strategy) and I personally don't own a property IN Detroit, but my entire portfolio is in the suburbs bordering Detroit. 

    Franklin, MI. A city just outside of Detroit... has an average home price of near $1,000,000. Is that a bad location? 

    The locations I/we invest have an average price of $150k and I purchase the properties in the lower percentile and do extremely well.

    The price/rent ratios are the best in the country. The sweet spot is the 1.2-1.4% deals. They cash flow so well and are in good working class locations. 

    And on top of the great cash flow, i've personally seen double digit appreciation. The data doesn't lie.

    Attached is an example of one of the cities I have a rental in. Oak Park. 24% average annual appreciation for 10 years straight. Paid $125k. Rents for $1500. Solid appreciating location. Average price in Oak park is $200k and I paid $125k for mine. Bought a solid house in the lower percentile and it cash flows extremely well and will continue to appreciate.

    Just in metro Detroit there are over a DOZEN fortune 500 companies with Auto, Hospitals, and Mortgage industries leading the pack and supplying a lot of jobs. 

    Metro Detroit is the best place in the Country to invest for the typical investor looking for passive cash flow and a good ROI. Prove me wrong.

    FIRE Realty Team - Keller Williams5380 Reviews
  • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    I would stick to the 696 and 275 corridors if I were to invest in the Detroit metro area. Safer communities and probably some bargain gems in need of some TLC in the better communities. Proximity to Ann Arbor is also a good appreciation play. 

  • Realtor · Detroit, MI · Member since 2018 · 387 posts · 129 votes
    4y

    @Scott Mac. Very well thought out post. I understand your hesitancy on investing here in the city. I hear that a lot. I think a lot of people views are skewed by what they see on the news and read in the paper. There are even a lot of realtors here in the metro area that only come to the city to sell a property ,never lived here ,never come to the city for entertainment or anything of that nature. So my suggestion would be to speak to agents who have lived in the city ,do a lot of business in the city ,that frequent the city ,that have property in the city ,they can give you a better perspective

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.