@John Allen - After searching for quite some time, I ended up with a good quote from Erie.
State Farm, USAA, and others were all at least 50% more for the same coverage.
But, the Erie agent I went through also specialized in multi-family properties in the neighborhood I purchased.
My advice (and what worked for me) was to ask other long-time investors in the neighborhoods I invest in who they recommend. Nothing beats a personal recommendation.
Each insurance company has different rates and a different underwriting appetite by state and even metropolitan area. @Brad M. makes a good point to ask other investors in your metropolitan area as to which company is winning accounts now.
If you come up short handed feel free to PM me for my top list for Texas.