Philadelphia Mortgage Sheriff Sales – What Should Investors Watch Out For?

Question

Hi everyone,

I’m a European investor using a U.S. LLC and Im looking into Philadelphia mortgage foreclosure Sheriff Sales.

I’d really appreciate advice from anyone with first-hand experience.

My main questions are:

If the mortgage debt is $150,000 but the property sells for $60,000, what happens to the remaining debt? Does it stay with the former owner, or can it affect the buyer or the property?

Also, what should I be especially careful about regarding liens, taxes, water/sewer bills, judgments and other claims?

And if the property is occupied by the former owner or a tenant, what problems should I expect after the purchase?

Finally, what are the biggest red flags you check before bidding, and how do you determine your maximum bid?

Any practical advice from Philadelphia investors would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Kevin Moyer · Answer

My advice is to stay far far away from sheriff sales in Philadelphia until you have a lot of experience operating in the market. You are bidding against a bunch of people who don't really know what they're doing. As a result the values are inflating beyond where they should be with properly forecasted returns. Generally speaking the bidders are underestimating costs and risks unique to the Sheriff sale process and Philadelphia.

Stuart Udis · Answer

Sheriff Sales haven't been a worthwhile place to source deals for 5-6 years. Its ordinarily a bunch of novices bidding against each other. Layer on top the inability to conduct adequate diligence makes it even worse.

Hossein Sharifi · Answer

Quick answers, with the usual caveat that I'm not a PA attorney and you should confirm with a Philadelphia title company or lawyer before bidding.

1. The leftover $90K. The shortfall stays with the former owner. You don't inherit the mortgage balance. In Pennsylvania the lender generally has a limited window after the sale to ask for a deficiency judgment against the borrower, so that's their problem, not yours.

2. Liens. The mortgage being foreclosed and liens junior to it generally get wiped by the sheriff's sale. What can still follow the property is the senior or special stuff, and municipal claims like water/sewer, so a title search before every auction is non-negotiable. A report costs a few hundred dollars, and a surprise lien can cost thousands.

3. Cash timing. These are generally cash deals with a deposit at the sale (about 10%) and the balance due within about 30 days, plus transfer taxes of roughly 4% in Philadelphia. Confirm the current terms in the sale notice.

4. Max bid. Work backward. Example: ARV $120K x 70% = $84K, minus $25K repairs, $6K back taxes/water, $5K transfer tax and closing, and $4K of carry and possession time, and you're at about $44K. If the starting bid is above your number, pass.

5. Occupied. You can't get inside to see it, and former owners often stay. Budget for an ejectment or possession action or cash-for-keys, and months of delay.

Biggest red flag: bidding without a title search and a drive-by.

Luca Marotta · Answer

Thanks for the advice. What alternative approach would you recommend for finding good deals around Philadelphia?

Ashish Acharya · Answer

Luca, the replies here cover the Philadelphia sheriff sale due diligence really well. The one piece I’d add, especially since you’re investing from Europe through a U.S. LLC, is to get the tax and ownership structure reviewed before you start bidding.

If the property will be a rental, I’d want the acquisition costs, rehab, repairs, improvements, basis, depreciation, and eventual sale modeled from the beginning. If the intention is to renovate and sell, the tax treatment can be very different.

I’d also have a CPA who understands foreign investors review how the U.S. LLC is owned and taxed, along with any U.S. reporting and withholding considerations that could apply to you. The structure that works for a U.S. resident isn't necessarily the right structure for a nonresident investor.

For the auction itself, I’d build the maximum bid around the true all in basis, not just the winning bid. Purchase price, taxes, title and legal costs, repairs, carrying costs, possession costs, and the expected tax impact should all be part of the model.

A property can look incredibly cheap at the sheriff sale and still be an expensive investment once everything is accounted for.

Feel free to DM me I’d be happy to send over a few resources that might be helpful.

Rob Lawrence · Answer

@Luca Marotta , I invest in the area around Philadelphia and I have not personally bought at sheriff sale. It just has a lot of pit falls. That being said, you can invest in the area, but I would just recommend a different approach.

Luca Marotta · Answer

Thanks, this is really helpful. I’d appreciate those resources, especially regarding LLC taxation for foreign investors and fix-and-flip deals. I’ll make sure to review the structure before bidding.

Luca Marotta · Answer

Thanks for the honest advice. I agree that having reliable people on the ground is essential. Which acquisition strategy would you recommend for a remote investor starting in Philadelphia?

Sheryl Sitman · Answer

The practical advise from us Philadelphian investors to trying to do this remotely from Europe without experience or boots on the ground is NO! There are many ways to acquire property in Philly without taking this risk. Get to know the market, the buying opportunities, people you can trust . . . If you have a budget and some goals in mind, a good idea could be to work with a local advisor who will guide you to making decisions that won't lead to a disaster. IMO, what you are thinking of doing is not investing - it is gambling.

Joseph Scorese · Answer

Luca, good questions. Philadelphia Sheriff Sales can present some great opportunities, but there are definitely risks you need to understand before bidding.

I've been involved in real estate investing and private lending for years, and one thing I've learned is that buying a property cheap doesn't necessarily mean you're getting a good deal.

Regarding your $150,000 mortgage example, if the property sells for $60,000, the remaining balance generally doesn't become your personal responsibility. However, certain liens and claims can survive the sale depending on their priority. That's why a proper title search is critical.

I'd pay particular attention to outstanding property taxes, municipal liens, water and sewer balances, judgments, and any other encumbrances. Don't assume everything gets wiped out at foreclosure.

Occupied properties are another concern. Whether it's the former owner or a tenant, getting possession can take time and money. Philadelphia has tenant protections, so make sure you understand what you're walking into.

As far as determining your maximum bid, I would start with a conservative property value, subtract repairs, carrying costs, financing expenses, closing costs, and your desired profit. I'd also build in a contingency because surprises are common with distressed properties.

One other consideration is financing. Sheriff Sales have strict payment deadlines, and you don't want to win a bid only to find out your financing can't close in time.

My suggestion is to build relationships with a good Philadelphia real estate attorney, title company, and contractor before attending your first sale.

And since you're investing through a U.S. LLC from overseas, make sure your ownership structure and financing eligibility are addressed upfront.

There are opportunities in distressed real estate, but the money is made through proper due diligence and buying right, not simply buying cheap.

Happy to connect if you'd like to discuss the financing side.

Joseph V. ScoreseBuilt Lending | Nationwide Direct Private Lender

Philadelphia Mortgage Sheriff Sales – What Should Investors Watch Out For?

Philadelphia Mortgage Sheriff Sales – What Should Investors Watch Out For?

Most Popular Reply

15 Replies