Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes
I finally did something I should have done a while ago — I turned off Smart Pricing on my two Indian Rocks Beach units and set my own seasonal rates for the next 12 months.
For context, these are furnished beach rentals that do a mix of shorter stays and midterm bookings. My seasons now look like this: $200 in the low season (mid-April through May, and September through mid-December), $250 on the shoulders (early January, early June, late August), $300 for regular prime time, and $400 for the true peaks — Christmas/New Year's, spring break, and 4th of July week.
Two things I noticed while doing it. First, Smart Pricing had been quietly overriding the numbers I thought I had set, in both directions. Second, even with manual pricing, one unit is still showing $180 instead of $200 for the first week and a half of November because of a 10% last-minute discount I'd forgotten was on there. Layers on layers.
For those of you who price manually: how granular do you get with your seasons? Do you find the algorithm actually fills nights you'd otherwise miss, or does it just train guests to wait for lower prices? And do you audit your old discounts and promotions regularly, or am I the only one finding surprises buried in my own listings?
Curious how others are handling this.
— Nadia Daggett, broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage in the Tampa Bay area.
Nadia, the buried-discount surprise is more common than people think. Turning off Smart Pricing doesn't touch the other settings, so last-minute, length-of-stay and promo discounts keep stacking on whatever base rate you set. Auditing those regularly is worth it.
I don't use Airbnb's Smart Pricing. I use PriceLabs, mainly because I want to see what the market is doing, not just get handed a number. Before I discount anything, I check the market's booking window in the PriceLabs market dashboards. If guests in a market book 3-7 days out, I'm not discounting two or three weeks out. That just gives away rate to someone who was going to book anyway. It also means I don't add a last-minute discount unless it's 2 days out or less, and only when it gets the result I or the owner is after. I'd rather hold rate and watch how the market is pacing before I make a big change.
On your seasons: four tiers is a solid start, but a fixed 12-month grid can't react when a weekend fills faster than usual or a week sits soft. That's where a pricing tool earns its keep. It shouldn't pick your rates for you. It should move within limits you set.
Since your units mix shorter stays and midterm, I'd look at minimum stays as hard as price. Most of my units run 30-60 day minimums. Short stays only fill gaps of a few days to two weeks, and I keep 60 days open after a midterm stay so the guest can extend. I manage those minimums in PriceLabs too. In a beach market you might flip that by season: shorter stays in peak, midterm in the low season when your $200 nights are the hardest to fill.
How far out are your Indian Rocks Beach guests booking for the low season?
For my primarily STR with snowbird potential I felt the pricing programs in conjunction with PM who had an interest in heads in the beds filled but under priced. Unless I have a midterm tenant in place being booked solid 5 months out makes me think the property was underpriced. With only 2 it isn't too cumbersome to use enemy strategy, stay on top of local events and price accordingly.
Nadia, I’d test actual guest quotes for 3, 7 and 28 nights, especially a stay that crosses into your Christmas pricing. That will show whether a long-stay discount is undoing the premium you set for those nights. We use PriceLabs, but I still want to see what the guest can actually book, not just the number on my calendar.
Nadia, being booked through May on a Gulf beach unit in early November can mean two very different things, and Jules's point is worth testing against which one it is.
If most of that calendar is monthly snowbird stays at or above your floor, that's the hybrid working: long stays carry the winter and you're only managing the gaps between them. If it's mostly nightly bookings at your $300 and $400 tiers, I'd want to know how far ahead of the market you are. In PriceLabs I'd compare my own occupancy for January through April against the market's future occupancy for the same dates. If I'm well ahead of the comp set that far out, the rates are probably low. I'd leave the existing bookings alone and raise what's still open, especially spring break.
Either way it's a good problem to have. Roughly how much of that is 30+ day stays?
Nadia, you're definitely not the only one finding buried discounts! I see it all the time when I look at owners' listings up here on the Emerald Coast. Our calendar has some extra wrinkles too, like spring break, the Gulf Coast snowbird months, and fall weekends that fill up because of events. So I'd split your shoulder seasons a little finer. One thing I'd add to John's point: look at your low season minimum stays at the same time as price. A 30+ night minimum in January can do more for you than dropping to $180.