Barking Dog Advice needed

Barking Dog Advice needed

Member since 2024 · 35 posts · 13 votes

I have a three family in Providence, Rhode Island my second floor. Tenant has two small dogs that are EPA dogs that continuously bark throughout the day anytime anyone walks up the stairs or the cars park the dogs are barking. I was there last weekend doing work on the house and the dogs barked for hours on end, especially when the tenants were not home and sometimes even when the tenants were home they barked. I have never inquired about how things were going with the other tenants regarding the dog, but this time I casually asked the first and third floor Tenant how things were going in the house and even asked about the dog specifically I didn’t wanna make a big deal because I wanted them to bring it up the first and third floor tenants alluded to the fact that the dogs bark all the time it seemed like they didn’t wanna say anything cause they didn’t wanna start any trouble. How will you go about? Addressing this? I was thinking of mentioning that I was there and noticed that the dogs were barking all day. I just wasn’t sure if I should say anything because I do not have a formal complaints from the third or first floor. Please offer advisor if you think it’s worth bringing up even though I do not have a formal complaint but honestly, the barking is pretty bad thank you so much.

2Reply
816 views

Most Popular Reply

Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
2mo

What are your local Ordinances regarding noise in general or nuisance barking dogs? What does your rental agreement state regarding either of these issues, or "disturbing" neighbors in general?

ESA's do not get a free pass. Determine what laws/rules apply locally, then document (or have neighboring tenants document) dates, frequency, and length of disturbances. Send a notice of violation per local law, identifying these dates/times, with proper number of "days to cure", and follow through. 

I would NOT recommend telling the tenant to get shock collars or any other "advice".

I would say it seems obvious the animal owner is not present, which is likely why the animal is so vocal to begin with. 

See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Cleveland, OH · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 4 votes
    2mo
    Request for them to try shock collars for the dogs they work when the dog barks if they don’t want to do that you might have to escalate an barking dog is an problem if the area is an nicer area.
  • Investor · Warwick, RI · Member since 2014 · 38 posts · 10 votes
    2mo

    Just because they are Emotional assistant pets does not mean it’s okay to have them bark all day.  Eviction can still occur.  Obviously you don’t want to go that far.  Collars may help.  Sending written correspondence enforcing quiet hours.  Document disturbances.  Videos and audio of barking.  Pets may be able to go into work with tenant if they are assistant pets.  Chat gpt will give you great advice as well.  Best of luck with it.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo

    What are your local Ordinances regarding noise in general or nuisance barking dogs? What does your rental agreement state regarding either of these issues, or "disturbing" neighbors in general?

    ESA's do not get a free pass. Determine what laws/rules apply locally, then document (or have neighboring tenants document) dates, frequency, and length of disturbances. Send a notice of violation per local law, identifying these dates/times, with proper number of "days to cure", and follow through. 

    I would NOT recommend telling the tenant to get shock collars or any other "advice".

    I would say it seems obvious the animal owner is not present, which is likely why the animal is so vocal to begin with. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 363 votes
    2mo

    Yes, I’d bring it up. You personally heard the dogs barking for hours, so I wouldn’t wait for another tenant to make a formal complaint.

    I’d handle it this way:

    1. Tell the tenant what I personally observed, without mentioning what the other tenants said.

    2. Keep the issue focused on the excessive barking, not the dogs’ assistance-animal status.

    3. Give the tenant an opportunity to address the problem and document the conversation.

    4. If the barking continues, document those occurrences and make sure any formal notice or enforcement follows Rhode Island and applicable fair housing requirements.

    That keeps the other tenants out of it while still addressing a noise issue you witnessed yourself.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2mo
    Quote from @Gladys Cepeda:

    I have a three family in Providence, Rhode Island my second floor. Tenant has two small dogs that are EPA dogs that continuously bark throughout the day anytime anyone walks up the stairs or the cars park the dogs are barking. I was there last weekend doing work on the house and the dogs barked for hours on end, especially when the tenants were not home and sometimes even when the tenants were home they barked. I have never inquired about how things were going with the other tenants regarding the dog, but this time I casually asked the first and third floor Tenant how things were going in the house and even asked about the dog specifically I didn’t wanna make a big deal because I wanted them to bring it up the first and third floor tenants alluded to the fact that the dogs bark all the time it seemed like they didn’t wanna say anything cause they didn’t wanna start any trouble. How will you go about? Addressing this? I was thinking of mentioning that I was there and noticed that the dogs were barking all day. I just wasn’t sure if I should say anything because I do not have a formal complaints from the third or first floor. Please offer advisor if you think it’s worth bringing up even though I do not have a formal complaint but honestly, the barking is pretty bad thank you so much.

    Welcome to the community, Gladys! I’d address it even without a formal complaint since you personally witnessed the barking for hours, so you’re not relying on what the other tenants told you. I’d keep the conversation focused strictly on the excessive noise rather than the dogs being assistance animals. Something simple like letting the tenant know you were at the property doing work, noticed the dogs were barking for extended periods, and wanted to make them aware so they can work on correcting it. I also wouldn’t mention which neighbors you spoke with since that could create unnecessary tension between tenants. If the problem continues, start documenting dates, times, and any complaints you receive and follow whatever nuisance or noise provisions are already in the lease. Since assistance animals can involve fair housing protections, I’d also be careful about taking any enforcement action specifically because of the animals and get Rhode Island-specific legal guidance before escalating beyond the noise issue.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    2mo

    What does your lease say about nuisance and other tenants having a right to their "peace & quiet"?

    If nothing, then you're limited to:

    1) Sending powerless warning letters, that hopefully work.
    2) Waiting for other tenant or neighbor to call the police and you get a copy of the police report.

    Keep in mind, there are no bad pets - just bad pet owners.

  • Real Estate Broker · Northeast PA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2mo

    @Drew Sygit makes good point.

    If nothing is in your lease yet, consider adding a pet and dog policy rider to this effect: 'tenant is responsible to maintain control of the dog at all times, including excessive barking. Don't use these words--but you get the idea. Have something in writing to cover this issue.

    In case the ESA is not a dog, add language for mini-horse, goat, parrot, llama, opossum, etc. ;-)

  • Mike FisherBusiness Member
    New Lenox, IL · Member since 2024 · 157 posts · 81 votes
    2mo

    You are right to act on this, and you do not need a formal complaint to do it. You personally heard hours of barking, and a firsthand observation is enough to open the conversation. Keep the first and third floor tenants out of it so you do not create tension between units.

    Two things worth adding to what has already been said.

    First, the assistance animal piece, because it is where people get stuck. An emotional support animal is a reasonable accommodation, which means you waive a no-pets rule and any pet fee for a verified ESA. It does not waive the tenant's duty to avoid creating a nuisance. Fair housing guidance lets you enforce conduct rules, and even pursue removal of a specific animal causing a genuine documented nuisance, as long as you apply the same noise standard you would apply to any tenant, ESA or not. So the safe lever is a neutral noise and nuisance standard enforced equally. The moment a notice references the animal being an ESA, you have handed the tenant a fair housing angle. Keep every word about times, duration, and volume, never the animal's status. Confirm the Rhode Island specifics before you send anything formal, since notice and cure periods are set by state and local law.

    Second, the flip side people miss: you also have a duty running to the first and third floor tenants. The covenant of quiet enjoyment is implied in most residential tenancies even when the lease is silent, so doing nothing carries its own risk if the barking is as bad as you describe. This is not only about the dog owner, it is about protecting the two units living with it.

    Practically:

    1) Start a dated log of what you witness yourself, and ask the other tenants to note date, time, and length going forward. A short log plus one or two audio clips turns "it seems bad" into an enforceable record.

    2) Lead with a calm, documented conversation and a reasonable window to fix it before any notice. Barking that spikes when the owner is gone is usually separation anxiety, which is a solvable behavior issue, so a good faith first step often fixes it and also builds your record if you ever have to escalate.

    3) Read your lease for the nuisance and quiet enjoyment language. If it is thin, that is what to tighten at renewal across every unit.

    I have owned and managed rentals since 1991, currently through M Property Group LLC in the south and southwest suburbs of Chicago, and the noise standard applied equally approach is what has kept these situations clean for me. At MF CashFlow Property Management, our business model is your cashflow.

    M Property Group LLC | MF Cashflow Property Management4.997 Reviews
  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2mo

    Post a 7-day curable notice letting the tenant know the exact verbiage of the lease and the law. Depending on the state, the law probably says something to the fact that tenants are allowed to have peace and quiet, or quiet enjoyment, or undisturbed tenancy.

  • Coral Springs, FL · Member since 2018 · 498 posts · 120 votes
    1mo

    definitely bring it up. you were there and heard it yourself, so you dont need to wait for a formal complaint. i had a similar situation a few years back and what worked was just being straight with the tenant. i told them i was at the property and noticed the dogs were going nonstop, especially when nobody was home. kept it friendly, not accusatory. turned out it was separation anxiety and they had no idea how bad it was until i mentioned it.

    one thing that helped me was recording a short audio clip on my phone while i was there. not to weaponize it, but just so i had something concrete if it ever needed to go further. never had to use it because the tenant was cooperative once they realized the extent of it.

    the esa status doesnt change the noise issue. you can enforce a quiet nuisance standard the same way you would for any tenant. just keep the conversation about the barking times and duration, not about the dogs being esAs. that keeps you on solid ground.

    id also check your lease for the nuisance clause. if its weak, add a pet behavior rider at renewal that covers excessive noise specifically. saves you from this conversation next time.

  • Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 287 posts · 49 votes
    2w

    Hours of barking while nobody is home must be wearing on you, and probably on the neighbors too. A kind note to the tenant describing exactly what you noticed, and asking what would help, often opens a better door than starting with a warning.

    Randy, Bunklow

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 130 posts · 34 votes
    1w

    Gladys — tough spot, especially living upstairs from it.

    First, check what your lease actually says about pets, and whether the dog is on the lease or was added later. Then talk to the tenant directly and in writing: note the dates and times of the barking, how long it goes, and that a neighbor has complained. Keep it calm and specific — you're asking for a fix, not starting a fight.

    If the tenant has ESA paperwork, take it seriously and keep that separate from the noise issue. The issue isn't the letter, it's the barking and the impact on the other tenants.

    Ask the tenant what their plan is — more time out, training, not leaving the dog alone for long stretches — and set a date to check back. If it doesn't improve, you'll have a clear record to work from. Happy to connect — my DMs are open.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.