Airbnb's discounts stack in ways that are catching landlords off guard

Airbnb's discounts stack in ways that are catching landlords off guard

Nadia DaggettBusiness Member
Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes

Is anyone else finding that Airbnb's pricing tools don't add up the way you expect them to anymore?

Between weekly and monthly discounts, early-bird and last-minute offers, new-listing promotions, and Smart Pricing, a host can end up with three or four discounts stacked on a single booking — and the combined number is nothing like what they thought they set. The one that worries me most is the monthly discount. Set 15–20% off for longer stays because that's what brings in the midterm guests, and then a promotion stacks on top of it — including, in some cases, a new-listing promo you can't even remove — and a month that was supposed to rent at your floor is suddenly booked well under it. The platform presents each discount like it's a small, separate nudge. Stacked together, they're a pricing structure of their own, and it feels like it was designed in a way that's catching landlords off guard.

Vrbo has its own version of this with member-only and mobile promotions stacking on length-of-stay discounts, but Airbnb's layering seems to be where most hosts I talk to get surprised — usually at payout time, not booking time.

So for the furnished and midterm landlords here: how are you handling this? Do you run the stacking math yourself before you set a discount, keep discounts at zero and compete on base price alone, or use a pricing tool that accounts for the stack? And has Airbnb's way of layering these offers changed how you think about monthly discounts specifically?

— Nadia, broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage here in the Tampa Bay area.

2Reply
449 views

Most Popular Reply

Diana KhanPro Member
Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 849 posts · 311 votes
2w
Quote from @Nadia Daggett:

Is anyone else finding that Airbnb's pricing tools don't add up the way you expect them to anymore?

Between weekly and monthly discounts, early-bird and last-minute offers, new-listing promotions, and Smart Pricing, a host can end up with three or four discounts stacked on a single booking — and the combined number is nothing like what they thought they set. The one that worries me most is the monthly discount. Set 15–20% off for longer stays because that's what brings in the midterm guests, and then a promotion stacks on top of it — including, in some cases, a new-listing promo you can't even remove — and a month that was supposed to rent at your floor is suddenly booked well under it. The platform presents each discount like it's a small, separate nudge. Stacked together, they're a pricing structure of their own, and it feels like it was designed in a way that's catching landlords off guard.

Vrbo has its own version of this with member-only and mobile promotions stacking on length-of-stay discounts, but Airbnb's layering seems to be where most hosts I talk to get surprised — usually at payout time, not booking time.

So for the furnished and midterm landlords here: how are you handling this? Do you run the stacking math yourself before you set a discount, keep discounts at zero and compete on base price alone, or use a pricing tool that accounts for the stack? And has Airbnb's way of layering these offers changed how you think about monthly discounts specifically?

— Nadia, broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage here in the Tampa Bay area.

@Nadia Daggett, I think I'd start by checking the final amount a guest would actually pay before offering any additional discounts. If the numbers don't work after everything is applied, I'd rather keep the pricing simple than risk accepting a booking for less than expected. I'd also be careful with monthly discounts since those longer stays involve a bigger commitment.

I'm a real estate attorney, broker, and investor based in Maryland, and I work with landlords and property owners on rental agreements and other real estate matters. I've seen how important it is to understand the terms of an agreement and what they mean financially before moving forward.

Thanks for bringing this up, @Nadia Daggett! It's a good reminder that landlords need to look at what they'll actually receive, not just the advertised rate. Happy to stay connected!

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 849 posts · 311 votes
    2w
    Quote from @Nadia Daggett:

    Is anyone else finding that Airbnb's pricing tools don't add up the way you expect them to anymore?

    Between weekly and monthly discounts, early-bird and last-minute offers, new-listing promotions, and Smart Pricing, a host can end up with three or four discounts stacked on a single booking — and the combined number is nothing like what they thought they set. The one that worries me most is the monthly discount. Set 15–20% off for longer stays because that's what brings in the midterm guests, and then a promotion stacks on top of it — including, in some cases, a new-listing promo you can't even remove — and a month that was supposed to rent at your floor is suddenly booked well under it. The platform presents each discount like it's a small, separate nudge. Stacked together, they're a pricing structure of their own, and it feels like it was designed in a way that's catching landlords off guard.

    Vrbo has its own version of this with member-only and mobile promotions stacking on length-of-stay discounts, but Airbnb's layering seems to be where most hosts I talk to get surprised — usually at payout time, not booking time.

    So for the furnished and midterm landlords here: how are you handling this? Do you run the stacking math yourself before you set a discount, keep discounts at zero and compete on base price alone, or use a pricing tool that accounts for the stack? And has Airbnb's way of layering these offers changed how you think about monthly discounts specifically?

    — Nadia, broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage here in the Tampa Bay area.

    @Nadia Daggett, I think I'd start by checking the final amount a guest would actually pay before offering any additional discounts. If the numbers don't work after everything is applied, I'd rather keep the pricing simple than risk accepting a booking for less than expected. I'd also be careful with monthly discounts since those longer stays involve a bigger commitment.

    I'm a real estate attorney, broker, and investor based in Maryland, and I work with landlords and property owners on rental agreements and other real estate matters. I've seen how important it is to understand the terms of an agreement and what they mean financially before moving forward.

    Thanks for bringing this up, @Nadia Daggett! It's a good reminder that landlords need to look at what they'll actually receive, not just the advertised rate. Happy to stay connected!

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 5 votes
    2w

    We run 30+ furnished units, mostly 30+ night stays, and this is the reason we price our midterm units backwards now.

    We start with the monthly number we actually want to collect, then set the base rate so that after the length of stay discount it still lands at or above our floor. On the midterm units we leave the extra promos off. Before a listing goes live we check what a 30 night and a 90 night stay would actually pay out, not what the discount settings screen says.

    For monthly discounts specifically, I treat them as a display tool more than a pricing tool. They help you show up for longer stay searches, but the number that matters is what lands in your account per month. If a channel keeps stacking things under your floor, raise the base on that channel instead of chasing the discounts.

    The other thing that helped was not letting one platform be the only place our monthly rate lives. We keep the target rate and floor per unit in our own system and check each channel against it, so when a platform changes how it layers offers we notice at booking time instead of payout time.

    We're building something for this on our side because tracking it across channels got old.

  • Property Manager · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2019 · 571 posts · 197 votes
    2w

    I’d add a check on both sides of each discount threshold, not just a 30-night quote. Try the same arrival date with 27, 28, 29 and 30 nights, then save the displayed total and expected payout. Repeat after changing a promotion. A simple before-and-after record makes it much easier to spot which setting changed the result, especially when more than one person can edit the listing.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 284 posts · 149 votes
    2w

    Nadia, to answer your question directly: I let PriceLabs drive both the rate and the discounts.

    The only time I go into Airbnb's own tools is when there's something specific I want to accomplish, and I use Custom Discounts for it. That's mostly on the STR side. For example, I'll offer a big discount on a 4- or 5-night stay that includes a Tuesday night. Tuesdays are slow, and I'd rather that night earn some revenue than none. Because I'm setting it on purpose for one goal, I know exactly what it does to the payout.

    For 30+ day stays, I let the monthly discount in PriceLabs drive it. I have a newer property that's still eligible for Airbnb's new-listing discount, so I push the Base Rate up in PriceLabs to account for it. Managing it primarily in one place makes it so much easier.

    Disclosure: I co-host STRs for other owners.

    Have you seen the new-listing promo stack on a 30+ night booking yourself, or is that coming from other hosts?

  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2w

    I take a longer term view (I owned STR and MTR 2014 - 2020 but no longer do). At first a "deal" with Airbnb was 75% property owner (host) 25% platform. Somewhere in 2014 or 2015 it became 50/50. By 2022 it was 75% Airbnb and 25% host. Now for property owners whose only source of income is Airbnb/Vrbo they are actually working FOR the platform, and no longer running an independent business.

    A real good SEO program will run about $350 -$400 per month. Over 3 years it should TOTALLY REPLACE third party platforms. The problem is that 90% of the SEO “specialists” can’t deliver what they promise. The job of the host is to find those few SEO consultants that a deliver.

    It’s almost unbelievable how quickly you see results when you engage a highly qualified, knowledgable, experienced SEO specialist.

    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
  • Melissa HaworthBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Panhandle | The Emerald Coast | Panama City Beach | Destin · Member since 2017 · 303 posts · 113 votes
    2w

    Nadia, seeing the same thing with owners I work with on the Emerald Coast. Our winter months are already thin, so a monthly discount plus a promo on top can put a January stay under what they need to cover the note. Tyler's backwards pricing tip is what I'd do too: pick the monthly number you actually need, then set the base so the discount still lands there. I'd also turn off the extra promos on the shoulder months and only leave length-of-stay discounts on. Worth checking a 28-night and a 30-night quote side by side before you leave anything stacked.

  • Technology · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 1 vote
    1w

    Nadia, the payout-time surprise is the part I'd go after, because by then the stay is already on the calendar.

    One habit that catches it early: write down the payout you expect for each booking the day it comes in. The reservation's price breakdown lists each discount as its own line, so copy the expected payout from there and keep it next to the booking. When the money actually lands, check it against that number. If they don't match, the breakdown usually shows which discount did it, and you find out on the first booking instead of the third.

    On 28+ night stays the money usually comes in monthly pieces rather than one lump, so check each piece against its own month instead of waiting until checkout.

    Matthew's 27 to 30 night test pairs well with this. Has anyone seen a promo hit the first month of a long stay but not the later ones?

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 296 posts · 80 votes
    1w

    Hey @Nadia Daggett

    You've put your finger on something a lot of hosts only notice at payout. Each discount looks small on its own, but stacked together they quietly become a second price list that nobody actually chose.

    I can add the view from the other side of the booking. My wife and I have spent the past four years living mostly in short-term and monthly rentals, and when we book a month, the number we compare is the total for the stay. The percentage badge rarely decides it.

    That's why I think Tyler's approach of starting from the monthly number you need and working backwards is the safest one here. If the monthly total already lands where it needs to, a stacked promo can't push you under your floor, and the guest still sees a fair, simple price.

    All the best,
    Lee

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.