Why we sold our first Atlanta co-living house instead of finishing the basement

Why we sold our first Atlanta co-living house instead of finishing the basement

Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes

We bought 343 Laquita in SE Atlanta as our first co-living conversion: renovate the main floor, then finish the basement for three more bedrooms and run it on PadSplit with our property manager.

We're selling it instead. City of Atlanta permitting stalled the basement phase, and we decided not to wait it out.

The numbers we walked away from (our PM's pro forma, 93% occupancy, 22% PadSplit + management fees):

• Main floor only: 5 residents, $737/wk gross, NOI ≈ $678/mo

• Full build: 9 residents, $1,329/wk gross, NOI ≈ $2,389/mo (3.5x)

• Value: ~$275K as-is vs ~$375K finished, for roughly $70K of build and furnishing

• After a 75% refi at 6.75%: about −$660/mo as-is vs +$565/mo finished

So the margin was clearly there. We picked smooth operations over margin. We don't want our realtor or GC spending time on work outside their specialty, and chasing city permits was exactly that.

The fix going forward: we've lined up a resource to coordinate City of Atlanta permitting on behalf of our GCs, so the builders build and the paperwork has an owner.

For anyone running co-living inside the city: how are you handling permit timelines on basement conversions? Is a dedicated permit expediter worth it in your experience?

1Reply
380 views

Most Popular Reply

Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 276 posts · 76 votes
1w

Afternoon @Michael Kaminski,

I think the reviewer question nobody answered is usually the bigger time sink. A missing drawing revision tends to be obvious once someone looks, but the city's comments often come back as one long letter, and it's easy for a single request on page three to slip past everyone.

For the weekly update, I'd break every comment letter into a numbered list the day it arrives, one line per request, with who on your side is answering it and the date it's due back. That way you're working from exactly what the city asked for, in plain words, instead of a general "still in review."

Best of luck with the next one,
Lee

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 276 posts · 76 votes
    1w

    Hi @Michael Kaminski,

    Thank you for sharing the real numbers. Walking away from roughly $1,700 a month of extra NOI is not an easy call, and I think a lot of investors would have pushed through and regretted it when the permit timeline kept slipping.

    I like your fix a lot, because "the paperwork has an owner" is usually the missing piece. From what I see with property managers and builders, an expediter helps most when someone on your side still owns the follow-up. That means one simple list of every submission, who at the city has it, what they asked for and the date you'll check back, plus a short weekly update to you even when nothing moved.

    When nobody owns that list, a permit can sit for weeks waiting on one missing drawing, and everyone assumes someone else is chasing it.

    All the best,
    Lee

    • Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes
      1w

      Lee, owning the follow-up is the part I'm taking. Your list (each submission, who at the city has it, what they asked for, the date we check back) defines the job better than "hire an expediter."

      Curious which you see more: a missing drawing revision, or a reviewer question nobody answered? It changes how I'd set up the weekly update.

    • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 276 posts · 76 votes
      1w

      Afternoon @Michael Kaminski,

      I think the reviewer question nobody answered is usually the bigger time sink. A missing drawing revision tends to be obvious once someone looks, but the city's comments often come back as one long letter, and it's easy for a single request on page three to slip past everyone.

      For the weekly update, I'd break every comment letter into a numbered list the day it arrives, one line per request, with who on your side is answering it and the date it's due back. That way you're working from exactly what the city asked for, in plain words, instead of a general "still in review."

      Best of luck with the next one,
      Lee

    • Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes
      1w

      That numbered-list-per-comment-letter approach is what I'm taking. One line per request, an owner and a due date, the day the letter lands. Thanks, Lee.

  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    1w

    If you’re scared away from a profitable deal because of the permitting process, maybe buying property where “value added” consists of remodeling/construction is not for you. Lots of difference between passive “collecting rent checks” and active

    “full Participation” investing. One is not necessarily “better” than the other, just depends on your available time, knowledge, capital, abilities, interests, organization, etc.

    I personally moved (or so I thought) to a passive investment stance about 5 years ago. Then last year an opportunity presented itself by way of a property we held the loan on which the borrower in default offered us a deed in lieu of foreclosure. We could have sold the property “as is” for maybe $3 million, but decided to invest $700,000 in building out the property, lease it out, and sell for (hopefully) $5.5 million based on cap rates, once stabilized. This involved not only permitting with the city, but also negotiations with and “overlay” improvement district. Our operations manager not only got the improvement district to support our efforts, but the improvement district gave us a $200,000 zero interest loans $75,000 grant, and provided our first two tenants.

    Look, there’s ALWAYS a choice to be made. One choice is “we don’t have the expertise so let’s forgo the opportunity”. The other side is “we’ll expand and stretch our parameters (and hopefully gain the experience to open up new opportunities for wealth enhancement) and take advantage of this opportunity for wealth building staring us in the face”. Only the individual investor knows which choice is right for them.

    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
    • Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes
      1w

      Don, agreed that there’s always a choice. We made ours, and fear had nothing to do with it.

      The deal is profitable either way, with or without the permitted scope. Skipping the permit path is about how fast we can move. It isn’t about whether we can handle construction.

      The problem is the City of Atlanta specifically. Its permitting timelines keep getting pushed out, and that doesn’t happen in the other jurisdictions we work in. If the city can move the finish line after you’ve started, you can’t plan around the timeline.

      That just means we adjust our IRR by pushing out timelines, meaning City of Atlanta properties receive dampened valuations on any properties that require permitting - opportunities abound - we'll just shift a few miles and keep moving with another jurisdiction.

      Our priority is to minimize risk, not to squeeze out every last dollar. Most of the risk in this deal is operational, and that’s the risk we’re set up to manage. Administrative risk, where the outcome sits in someone else’s queue, isn’t something we’re willing to take on.

      Congrats on the deed-in-lieu project. Getting the improvement district to put up a $200K zero-interest loan, a $75K grant and your first two tenants is a strong result. It sounds like your ops manager more than earned their keep. Different deal, different jurisdiction, different call.

  • Jim SternBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · ATLANTA Metro and Surrounding Counties · Member since 2025 · 39 posts · 13 votes
    6d

    Michael, thanks for sharing real numbers. Most of the co-living guys we're working with these days are shying away from large permit jobs because they are a pain, and on a value add project you often want to phase the buildout so that your appraiser doesn't freak out, but sees a somewhat normal single family home, then you finish the rest of the co-living after that. There are so many homes that are co-living friendly in ATL and don't need extensive rehab, I'd focus there and try to stay sub-$50k if you can. Also having a GC that understands the permit game, does everything up to code, but. is ok with operating in the gray a little bit is also helpful.

    Atlanta's Investor Friendly Team533 Reviews
    • Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes
      5d

      Jim, thanks. Phasing so the appraiser sees a normal single family first makes sense, since this house had a $100K gap between as-is ($275K) and finished ($375K).

      How long do lenders usually want between phase one and the basement work? And does the sub-$50K rehab rule hold on a 75% refi?

    • Atlanta, Fulton County · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 3 votes
      5d

      Jim, thanks. Phasing so the appraiser sees a normal single family first makes sense, since this house had a $100K gap between as-is ($275K) and finished ($375K).

      How long do lenders usually want between phase one and the basement work? And does the sub-$50K rehab rule hold on a 75% refi?

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5d

    thanks for sharing really appreciate the insights. and the frame around your mindset in the decision, I like the identification of having your specialists be specialists and not doing extra work outside their scope.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.