Before you close on a FL rental, check which carrier you are pricing against

Before you close on a FL rental, check which carrier you are pricing against

Technology · Singapore · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 1 vote

If you are buying a rental in Florida from out of state, here is the thing that quietly wrecks your numbers.

The same house does not have one insurance price. On one Broward home I looked at, the premium ran from about $5,500 to over $13,000 depending only on which carrier you land with. Same roof, same address.

Most people find that out after they are under contract, when the quote comes back and the deal math moves.

The state actually publishes the approved rates by carrier, so you can see the range before you make an offer. It is just buried where nobody looks.

If you tell me the county you are shopping, happy to pull what carriers are approved to charge on a standard home there. Might save you a surprise at closing.

0Reply
1,144 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Melissa HaworthBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Panhandle | The Emerald Coast | Panama City Beach | Destin · Member since 2017 · 299 posts · 112 votes
    1w

    This is so true, and it's even more extreme up here on the Panhandle. I tell my out of state buyers to get a real quote during the inspection period, not a ballpark from a friend. Things that move the number a lot out here: roof age and the wind mitigation report, flood zone, and whether the place is in a condo where the master policy covers more or less than you think. Two houses on the same street in Navarre can come back thousands apart. Get the quote before you get attached to the deal.

  • Realtor · South Florida | Broward & Miami-Dade, FL · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    5d

    Hikaru, were the Broward figures property-specific quotes with matching coverage limits and deductibles, or estimates from published rate information?

    I’m a South Florida Realtor with LoKation Realty, and I’d be interested in understanding what was included in that comparison—particularly wind coverage, roof settlement terms, and the intended rental use. That context would help buyers understand what the price difference actually represents.

  • Technology · Singapore · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 1 vote
    4d

    Those were estimates from the published rate information, not property-specific quotes with matched coverage. Florida OIR publishes what each carrier is approved to charge on a standard home scenario by county, and the Broward figure was that carrier-to-carrier spread on a common baseline, not a set of bound quotes.

    So you are right that it is not the delivered number. Wind coverage, roof settlement terms (replacement cost versus actual cash value), the deductible, and non-owner-occupied rental use all move it from there. A landlord DP3 policy in particular prices differently from the standard scenario the published rates assume.

    What the published range is good for is the early direction: which carriers sit high and which sit low before anyone orders a quote. It does not replace the quote you or an agent would pull. It just says where to expect the spread.

    Happy to pull the published range for any county you work, if it is useful.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.