Property manager hasn't paid me in 6 months and has gone unresponsive — what actually

Managing Your Property
2dFollow

Property manager hasn't paid me in 6 months and has gone unresponsive — what actually

Manas M.
CA · Member since 2017 · 57 posts · 19 votes

Out-of-state owner here (based in California) with two Section 8 single-family rentals in Birmingham, Alabama — one in Birmingham, one in Hueytown.

My property manager has not passed through a dollar in about six months, despite collecting the Housing Assistance Payments. The housing authority confirmed in writing that they paid the manager in full every month. The manager's own statement shows a substantial amount held. I have received nothing.

The manager has now stopped responding entirely — no replies to calls, texts, or emails.

What I've done so far:

- Filed complaints with the Alabama Real Estate Commission, BBB, Alabama Attorney General, and HUD OIG

- Sent a formal demand letter with a November 16, 2026 deadline

What I'm looking for is specific, practical advice from anyone who has actually been through this:

1. Did a demand letter on an attorney's letterhead get your PM to pay, or did you have to file suit?

2. For a claim this size in Alabama, is it worth filing in District Court, or did you go small claims and waive the excess over the cap?

3. Has anyone used the AREC Recovery Fund? How did that work in practice?

4. Anything else that actually moved the needle — mediation, collection agency, something I'm missing?

I have one attorney quote so far and it feels steep relative to the size of the claim, and I'm concerned about costs running away if the PM contests it. Open to cheaper routes if they actually work.

Appreciate any firsthand experience — especially from Birmingham / Jefferson County investors.

1Reply
443 views

Most Popular Reply

Ametria Chaney
Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 395 posts · 135 votes
2d

Manas, I'm so sorry you're dealing with this — six months of collected rent that never reached you is every out-of-state owner's nightmare, and you've already done the right things by getting the housing authority's confirmation in writing and filing the complaints. A few thoughts from the Realtor side: first, protect the properties themselves — make sure the tenants' Section 8 status and leases are intact, and line up a replacement manager now so you're not stuck if this one disappears entirely. Second, the attorney-letterhead demand often does move the needle where a self-written one didn't, because it signals you're ready to file; if you do file, many owners in your shoes weigh small claims for speed and cost against the amount they'd have to waive. And on the Recovery Fund, I'd ask the Alabama Real Estate Commission directly what it covers and what documentation they need. Keep everything in writing from here on out.

1Reply
See this reply in the discussion

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ametria Chaney
    Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 395 posts · 135 votes
    2d

    Manas, I'm so sorry you're dealing with this — six months of collected rent that never reached you is every out-of-state owner's nightmare, and you've already done the right things by getting the housing authority's confirmation in writing and filing the complaints. A few thoughts from the Realtor side: first, protect the properties themselves — make sure the tenants' Section 8 status and leases are intact, and line up a replacement manager now so you're not stuck if this one disappears entirely. Second, the attorney-letterhead demand often does move the needle where a self-written one didn't, because it signals you're ready to file; if you do file, many owners in your shoes weigh small claims for speed and cost against the amount they'd have to waive. And on the Recovery Fund, I'd ask the Alabama Real Estate Commission directly what it covers and what documentation they need. Keep everything in writing from here on out.

    1Reply
  • Vaibhav PuranikPro Member
    Member since 2025 · 115 posts · 59 votes
    2d

    This might be crazy idea but I will suggest anyways - Is it worth hiring a private investigator to see what exactly happened? Also, what about the service to the tenants? Are they responding to tenant requests? Also, why not immediately break it off with them and give it to some other property management while you keep dealing with the recovery? Speaking to other property managers in the market can also get you more intel.

    [email protected]
    0Reply
  • BJ Everson
    Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 170 posts · 67 votes
    2d

    Manas, sorry you're dealing with this. I'm not in Alabama and this isn't legal advice, but a few practical steps protect the properties while the money gets sorted out. (Disclosure: I'm a Realtor with Swiss Realty Group and assist at Swiss Property Management Group in Columbus.)

    • Send written termination under the management agreement's termination clause, and in the same letter demand the tenant files, signed leases, keys, the security deposit ledger and a trust account statement by a set date.

    • Ask the housing authority what they need to change the payee on the HAP contracts to you or a new manager. Stopping the next payment from going to this manager limits the loss.

    • Send each tenant a written notice saying who to pay and who to call for repairs from now on.

    • In the AREC complaint, ask specifically about the manager's trust account, since that's where the HAP money should have been held.

    • Get both homes inspected soon. An unresponsive manager often means unanswered repair requests, and a failed HQS inspection can pause the HAP. On suit vs small claims, a local collections or landlord-tenant attorney can tell you quickly whether it fits small claims, and some will do a flat-fee demand letter. Is the manager still collecting the tenant portions too?

    1Reply
  • Denise Evans
    JD, CCIM , Real Estate Broker · Tuscaloosa, AL · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    I'm in Alabama.
    1) Is there an investor portal? Are there perhaps repairs and other charges that consume your rents?
    2) Have you confirmed the company has a broker licensed by the Alabama Real Estate Commission? You can call, or go on their website and check names. All managers of single family homes must have a real estate license.
    3) If licensed, have you filed a formal complaint with AREC? The forms are on their website.
    4) If not licensed, still file a complaint with AREC. They have assistant state attorneys in staff who can investigate and possibly bring criminal charges.
    5) You will have to sue. If you start in District Court and waive the excess, they'll probably appeal if they lose and you'll be in Circuit Court anyway. If the property s owned by an LLC, you can represent the LLC yourself in Small Claims, but not in District or Civil Court, you'll have to get a lawyer for that.
    6) There are procedures you have to go through regarding notice to AREC if you get a judgment, cannot recover it, and want to be paid out of the recovery fund. When you call, ask for those written instructions and follow them exactly.

    7) Who is the named landlord in the leases? Property management companies often name themselves as landlords because that is easier on them AND because they've been approved by the PHA to rent to section 8 tenants but perhaps you have not. If you are not the named landlord, you might have difficulty changing the payments to go someplace else. Discuss that with the PHA. Per common real estate law sense, AND an appellate decision in April of 2025, leases that name somebody other than the property owner as landlord are void. This is not widely know, but is very important.
    8) You can DM me if you want to discuss in more detail.

    0Reply
  • Jim Johnson
    Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 362 votes
    2d

    The fact that the housing authority confirmed payment and the PM's own statements show money being held makes this especially concerning.

    Two things I'd prioritize at this point:

    1. Protect future payments. Find out from the housing authority what it takes to redirect payments away from the current PM so the amount owed doesn't keep growing.

    2. Get a second legal opinion. With six months of payments involved, I'd want an Alabama attorney to compare the actual costs of pursuing the full claim versus small claims, including whether the AREC Recovery Fund is a realistic option.

    You've already taken several steps to recover the money. At this point, I'd be more concerned about stopping further losses and finding the most cost-effective way to pursue what's already owed.

    1Reply
  • Jason CoryPro Member
    Real Estate Broker · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2018 · 266 posts · 384 votes
    2d

    The real estate commission in every state has what is called a recovery fund. If you get a judgment and they still don't pay, the commission will pay.

    It's probably not what you want to hear but at least you know, there is a fund we all pay into for this exact type of scenario

    1Reply
  • Ezra Bennett
    Monroe, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 13 posts · 2 votes
    1d

    Sorry you're dealing with this. In order:

    1. Find out where the rent is going. Ask a tenant (politely) who they pay and how. If it's going into the PM's account, you want that to stop.

    2. Send a written termination per your management agreement, by certified mail and email, and demand the tenant ledgers, leases, security deposits, keys and the full trust account accounting for your properties within a set number of days.

    3. Notify the tenants in writing that rent should now be paid to you directly, starting with the next due date. Check your state's rules on how that notice should look.

    4. File a complaint with your state real estate commission. In most states a PM must hold client funds in a trust account, and six months of missing owner draws is exactly what the commission investigates. They often move faster than a lawsuit.

    5. Talk to a local attorney about recovering the funds and the deposits. If the PM is licensed, some states also have a recovery fund.

    Going forward, insist on monthly owner statements and access to the tenant ledger so you can see payments yourself.

    0Reply
  • Danny Gonzalez
    Real Estate Broker · Member since 2024 · 140 posts · 63 votes
    22h

    Rough spot, and the legal advice here is right. The fastest money move is stopping the bleed: get the HAP payee changed off the old PM this month so the next payment lands with you or your new manager. That doesn't wait on a lawsuit.

    Then a certified termination plus demand for the trust account ledger, security deposits and tenant files. If the PM is a licensed Alabama brokerage, a complaint to the AREC carries weight and goes on record. Were the deposits held by the PM or did you collect them?

    1Reply
  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 904 votes
    22h

    At this point, I’d stop treating this as a property management issue and treat it as a money issue. If the housing authority has confirmed they paid the manager and the manager’s own records show the money, I’d get an attorney involved and find out exactly what the cheapest path is to getting it back. I’d also be looking for a new property manager. I understand why you need one as an out-of-state owner, but the whole point is to make your life easier, not have to chase someone for six months of rent. Once you get this resolved, I’d want much tighter controls on how and when the rents are transferred to you.

    0Reply
  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    9h

    Contact the S8 agency and have them start sending payment directly to you while you find a new PMC.

    Chasing this PMC for the money may cost you a LOT from another state.

    [email protected]248-209-6824
    Logical Property Management4.9465 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    1Reply
  • Sundeep Babbar
    Real Estate Coach · Austin · Member since 2022 · 24 posts · 9 votes
    8h

    Manas, alongside the legal route I'd get the books straight now so tax time doesn't make it worse. The HAP money the housing authority paid the manager is yours, so I'd record each month as rent income when the PM received it, with the unpaid amount sitting as a balance owed to you by the manager, and file the authority's letter and the PM's statement as backup. If some of it never comes back, ask your CPA how to handle the write-off instead of just leaving that income off.

    0Reply
  • Ryan SpathBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 609 posts · 387 votes
    7h

    Thank you for posting this and sharing your experience.

    [email protected]208-600-2814
    0Reply
  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 318 posts · 78 votes
    6h

    Manas, I'm sorry, that's a hard spot, and you've already done the right things by getting the housing authority's payment confirmation in writing. A few practical thoughts from the operator side.

    First, get a replacement manager lined up now and put the tenants on written notice of who to pay and call, so the Section 8 leases and inspections don't lapse while this plays out. Second, send the housing authority a request to redirect future payments or update the owner of record, and ask the bank or trust account custodian for the account details. Third, ask your attorney whether a demand letter plus a claim against the manager's license bond or recovery fund is cheaper than a full suit, and get a flat-fee quote for the letter only.

    Keep a single timeline with dates, statements, and every contact attempt. If the November 16 deadline passes, that file makes small claims or district court much cheaper to start. This is general information only. Not legal advice.

    Happy to compare notes by message.

    [email protected]949-391-1019
    Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Bill B.
    Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    5h

    I know it’s too late thsi time, and maybe like me you hate conflict. But this discussion should have come 4 or even 5 months ago. I would freak out if my PM was a week late with my money I’d want answers. They wouldn’t be allowed to collect the next months rent.

    If you plan to keep using a PM reach out to a couple and get a feel for what they can do for you in regards to getting payments transferred, properties inspected, and so on. It might be time to spend a weekend out there.

    0Reply
    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 318 posts · 78 votes
      4h

      Bill, I agree the six-month gap is a serious signal, and an owner should not have to discover it after months of statements. Since Manas says the housing authority confirmed payment and the PM’s own statement shows funds held, I’d prioritize a written reconciliation and stop future payments from continuing through the same path, while confirming the lease, HAP paperwork, and local requirements with the authority and counsel. A site visit may help, but I’d get the records and tenant coverage secured first. Not legal advice.

      [email protected]949-391-1019
      Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
      WebsiteView Page
      0Reply
    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 318 posts · 78 votes
      4h

      Bill, I agree the six-month gap is a serious signal, and an owner should not have to discover it after months of statements. Since Manas says the housing authority confirmed payment and the PM’s own statement shows funds held, I’d prioritize a written reconciliation and stop future payments from continuing through the same path, while confirming the lease, HAP paperwork, and local requirements with the authority and counsel. A site visit may help, but I’d get the records and tenant coverage secured first. Not legal advice.

      [email protected]949-391-1019
      Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
      WebsiteView Page
      0Reply
  • Daniel Jung
    Member since 2026 · 87 posts · 31 votes
    5h

    The part of this story is how long it ran before it surfaced. Six months of missing payments is not a one-month problem, it is a six-month problem, and that is the part an owner can control next time. We check three things every month: the owner statement, the deposit in our bank account, and the tenant ledger. If any one of those three does not match the other two, we ask about it the same week. A good manager expects that question. A bad one hopes you never ask it.

    Going forward, we would ask a new manager for the tenant ledger and a copy of the management agreement before signing, and confirm how owner payments are sent and when. Keep your copies of leases, ledgers, and every message. When the money stops matching the paperwork, stop sending more business to that manager and sort the payments out first.

    0Reply
    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 318 posts · 78 votes
      4h

      Daniel, that three-way check is a practical control: the statement, bank deposit, and tenant ledger should reconcile each month, and a mismatch gets a question the same week. In this case, matching the six-month gap against the housing authority’s written payment confirmation and the manager’s own statement gives Manas a clear record to work from. I’d keep each follow-up dated and save the responses with those records, so the accounting and next steps stay connected. Not legal advice.

      [email protected]949-391-1019
      Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
      WebsiteView Page
      0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free