Traditional vs Section 8 Rentals?

Traditional vs Section 8 Rentals?

Member since 2019 · 5 posts · 2 votes

I am a 23 years old born and raised in St. Louis looking to buy and hold real estate and grow a portfolio in the area. I am on road most of the time for work but typically spend about 8days/month in STL. Since graduating college about 18 months ago, I have been fortunate enough to saved up enough cash for a down payment. I want my first property to be proof of concept for myself but next I want to do the BRRR method and eventually scale to larger properties with more units.

I always pictured my first rental targeting traditional tenants in a decent or better neighborhood. However, I recently came across a bigger pockets podcast about section 8 that made me question whether I might be overlooking another opportunity.

I am trying to figure out which direction makes the most sense for me, especially given my time spent traveling for work.

I would love to hear from anyone with experience in either or both of these fields. What are some of the pros and cons of either? Are there specific neighborhoods, strategies, or things I should consider that I am overlooking?

Any advice is appreciated!

1Reply
521 views

Most Popular Reply

Delray Beach, FL · Member since 2024 · 49 posts · 26 votes
1w

First of all, congrats on being 23 and already thinking about building a portfolio! You're definitely starting earlier than most of folks here!

Personally, I wouldn't focus too much on traditional tenants vs Section 8 just yet. I'd focus on finding a property where the numbers actually make sense. Section 8 can be a great strategy, especially if the payment standards are competitive with market rents, but you also need to consider inspections, paperwork, and the local housing authority's processes.

One thing I've learned investing remotely is that your property manager can make or break the investment. Seriously, finding someone reliable who communicates well is just as important as finding a good deal. Especially if you're traveling most of the month.

For your first property, I'd probably lean toward something that doesn't need a massive renovation. Get comfortable managing the numbers, tenants, repairs, and unexpected expenses before jumping into a full BRRRR. And if you're looking at older properties, always keep a healthy reserve. Those surprises (unfortunately) will come

Also, don't just look at the rent. Run the numbers with realistic vacancy, maintenance, CapEx, management fees, and financing costs. A property that looks great on Zillow can look very different once you account for everything.

Happy to connect if you ever want to exchange ideas or have questions!

Always glad to talk real estate with other investors.

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Delray Beach, FL · Member since 2024 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    1w

    First of all, congrats on being 23 and already thinking about building a portfolio! You're definitely starting earlier than most of folks here!

    Personally, I wouldn't focus too much on traditional tenants vs Section 8 just yet. I'd focus on finding a property where the numbers actually make sense. Section 8 can be a great strategy, especially if the payment standards are competitive with market rents, but you also need to consider inspections, paperwork, and the local housing authority's processes.

    One thing I've learned investing remotely is that your property manager can make or break the investment. Seriously, finding someone reliable who communicates well is just as important as finding a good deal. Especially if you're traveling most of the month.

    For your first property, I'd probably lean toward something that doesn't need a massive renovation. Get comfortable managing the numbers, tenants, repairs, and unexpected expenses before jumping into a full BRRRR. And if you're looking at older properties, always keep a healthy reserve. Those surprises (unfortunately) will come

    Also, don't just look at the rent. Run the numbers with realistic vacancy, maintenance, CapEx, management fees, and financing costs. A property that looks great on Zillow can look very different once you account for everything.

    Happy to connect if you ever want to exchange ideas or have questions!

    Always glad to talk real estate with other investors.

    • Member since 2019 · 5 posts · 2 votes
      1w

      Thank you Maurizio! That is very helpful advice and helps take some pressure off knowing that I don’t have to decide between one or the other when framing my buy box. I also really appreciate your advice on the importance of considering all expenses and having a good property manager.

      Thanks again! I would love to connect!

  • Marc MoraPro Member
    Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2026 · 359 posts · 55 votes
    1w

    @Patrick Brown, being in town eight days a month matters more here than the tenant type. Section 8 brings inspections and appointments someone has to be there for, so I'd choose the property manager first and let what they run well decide it. I've seen a lot of that and have friends who do S8 also. Will you have a manager in place before you close? Besides BRRRR, which strategies are you weighing for the next one? I'd be open to talking strategy with you if that's useful.

  • Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1w

    I know a great agent in the STL area who focuses with investors. I'd honestly consider house hacking to start out the gate

    • Member since 2019 · 5 posts · 2 votes
      1w

      Hey Caleb, I would love to connect with you and the agent you know in stl! I have considered a house hack, but given my situation I’m not sure it makes the most sense for me right now. I don’t want to rule that out completely so I would love to have a conversation and hear you out!

  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 976 votes
    1w

    Hey Patrick, both strategies can work, but since you're traveling often, I'd focus on whichever is easier to manage with a reliable property manager in place. Section 8 can offer more consistent rent, while traditional rentals give you a different tenant pool and more flexibility. I'd also keep the Midwest open as you grow. There are still affordable buy-and-hold and BRRRR opportunities worth exploring, even out of state, as long as you have a solid local team behind you.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 775 votes
    1w

    Patrick, I run Section 8 in Memphis, and it works when the numbers work. I buy single-family under $100K, rehab it to an ARV of $180K-$265K, and rent it for $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+ on Section 8. That rent has to hit the 1% rule and cover vacancy, repairs, and management through my in-house team at Memphis Passive, plus the DSCR refinance at 70-80% LTV. Section 8 brings inspections and a longer lease-up, and the housing authority rent is set by their payment standards, not by what I ask. Traditional tenants are faster to place and more flexible, but the rent is not as steady. With you traveling eight days a month, the manager matters more than the tenant type. Pick the market and the manager first, then run both options on real numbers and take the one that clears the 1% rule. Which market are you underwriting first — St. Louis, or somewhere else?

    • Member since 2019 · 5 posts · 2 votes
      6d

      Hey James, I thank you for your response! Wow those sounds like some substantial rehabs. I am still doing my research on which stl market I want to invest in. I’m hoping to learn more about whether it would be safer or more advantageous to invest in a less expensive market or a market where homes prices are a bit higher. It seems like you have this down to a science and your response leaves me with a lot of questions. I would love to connect and pick your brain!

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 632 posts · 180 votes
    6d

    Sorting this out before the first purchase is the right order, and it'll matter more once you get to the BRRRR. One side of the choice that shows up at the refinance is how each tenant type's rent gets counted. Most DSCR lenders qualify the property on its rent, but the programs I see treat a Section 8 unit differently. Some will count the voucher contract rent, and others cap it at what the appraiser says the market supports, so an above-market S8 rent doesn't always carry into the loan amount. Lease-up timing differs too, because the housing authority inspects before the voucher payments start, which can stretch the gap between finishing the rehab and having a lease to show a lender. A rent only helps you as far as the lender is willing to count it.

  • Real Estate Broker · Member since 2024 · 141 posts · 63 votes
    6d

    Being gone most of the month matters more than the tenant type. S8 gives you steady rent and an inspector who finds your deferred items for you, but you need someone local who can turn a fail around in days, not weeks. Traditional gives you more control on screening, but turnover hits harder when you're not there. Either way, pick the neighborhood first, then the tenant pool that actually rents there. Do you plan to self-manage those 8 days a month or hire a PM from day one?

  • Amit PatelBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Bartlett, IL · Member since 2025 · 195 posts · 76 votes
    6d

    Great place to be at 23. I’d actually flip the question a little: instead of choosing Section 8 or traditional first, buy a solid property that works for both, then compare. Check the housing authority’s payment standard for that area against market rent. Sometimes the voucher pays more, sometimes less, and that alone makes the call for you.

    We’ve done Section 8 for a lot of years and here’s the honest version.

    The upside is real: the housing authority’s portion shows up every month, and good voucher tenants tend to stay for years, which means fewer turnovers. The downside is mostly timing and paperwork.

    The unit has to pass inspection before the subsidy starts, there are annual inspections, and rent increases go through approval. And you still have to screen carefully, because the voucher covers rent, not how someone treats your property.

    Your travel schedule is the bigger factor for me. Inspections get scheduled on their timeline, not yours, and a failed one means a re-inspection and delayed rent. If you go Section 8, you’ll want a reliable manager or at least a handyman who can be there on short notice. Same goes for traditional tenants, honestly, but voucher units have less wiggle room.

    One more thing for STL specifically: the city and the county run through different housing authorities with different rules and payment standards, so look at both before you pick a neighborhood.

    Casanomy Property Management562 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.