Loyalty isn't never shopping. My once-a-year check on insurance, lenders, HELOCs/PM

Loyalty isn't never shopping. My once-a-year check on insurance, lenders, HELOCs/PM

Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes

A lot of us think loyalty means you never look around. Same insurance agent for 15 years. Same lender. Same property manager. Same HELOC at whatever rate it drifted to. You never ask, because asking feels disloyal.

That's not loyalty. That's autopilot.

You should be pricing out your insurance, your lending, your HELOCs and your management all the time. That's just part of business. Nearly all of my clients use my insurance guy, and I still tell every one of them: always shop your rates.

Loyalty isn't never shopping. Loyalty is getting shopped and still winning. The good ones don't mind being compared. The ones who get nervous when you ask for a quote are telling you something.

Here's an easy once-a-year checklist. Put it on your calendar the same week every year.

  1. Insurance. At renewal, get two other quotes on the exact same coverage. Same deductible, same limits, apples to apples.

  2. Lending. If you're buying or refinancing, get a Loan Estimate from two or three lenders. That's the standard three-page form a lender has to give you within three business days of applying, so you can compare rates and fees line by line.

  3. Your HELOC. Check the rate you're actually paying today, not the one you had when you opened it. Most of them are variable.

  4. Property management. Add up what you paid this year: the monthly fee, the leasing fee, the renewal fee, and how many days your units sat empty. Then ask two other managers what they'd do with the same doors.

  5. Your people. Same question, for the humans. Who's sharpening you? Who's just there?

My mentor, Harry Borders, has a line I think about all the time. When it comes to partnerships, one plus one has to equal three. If you bring one and they bring one and you both walk away with two, that's not a partnership. That's two people standing next to each other.

Nearly all the leadership in real estate here in Louisville is using my CPAs, my lenders, my litigation attorneys and my closing attorneys. That didn't happen by accident. It's 13 years of shopping, testing, and keeping only the ones who make it one plus one equals three.

When's the last time you priced out your insurance, lender or property manager?

0Reply
158 views

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 438 posts · 148 votes
    1d

    Rob, this is such a practical reminder — and I love the framing that loyalty is getting shopped and still winning. I do a version of this once a year too, and insurance is usually where I start, because coverage and deductibles quietly drift while the premium creeps up. Comparing the same coverage apples-to-apples, like you said, is the only way the quotes mean anything. The HELOC point matters a lot as well — a variable rate that felt fine when you opened it can look very different a year later. And with property managers, I look at total cost, not just the monthly fee: leasing and renewal fees plus vacancy days tell the real story. The partners worth keeping are the ones who welcome the comparison.

    • Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1d

      Ametria, the vacancy days point is the one I wish more owners tracked. A manager with a low monthly fee who takes an extra few weeks to fill a unit can cost you more than one who charges a bit more and turns it fast. Here in Louisville I ask owners to pull their own records for the year: days vacant per turn, leasing fees, renewal fees, and what maintenance got marked up. That page usually settles the question before any quotes come in.

      On insurance, the drift you describe is real. Deductibles get changed at renewal, wind and hail terms get swapped, and nobody reads the declarations page until there's a claim. Same coverage, side by side, is the only fair test.

      And I agree on the last line. The good partners don't get defensive when you shop them. They usually just sharpen the pencil or show you why they're still the better deal.

      When you run your yearly check in Memphis, which one tends to move the needle most for your clients, insurance or management?

  • Virtual Assistant · Remote · Member since 2020 · 156 posts · 67 votes
    20h

    Good checklist, but one caution before you start shopping the PM every year. The books tell you whether the PM is actually the problem. Pull the year-to-date P&L per property and add up what you really paid the manager this year: monthly fees, leasing fees, renewal fees, all of it. That total hides across twelve statements and is almost always bigger than people remember. Same for insurance, last year's premium per property next to this year's quote, same coverage and deductible.

    But shopping the PM every year has a cost of its own. Every switch means new onboarding, new systems, and a transition period where things slip. That eats the savings fast. And PMs talk. Their people jump between firms, and an owner who changes managers every year gets a reputation as a problem owner. The good firms notice, and eventually none of them want the account.

    So shop it once a year, yes. Just make sure the numbers say the quality is not there before you move. A mediocre PM you know is usually cheaper than a new one you don't.

    • Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      16h

      Fair point, Rachel, and I agree on the order. Shopping isn't the same as switching. The once-a-year check is mostly about getting a real quote to hold up against what you're paying now, and most years the answer is to stay put.

      The full-year fee total is the piece people skip. Leasing and renewal fees don't show up on the monthly line, so the effective rate ends up higher than the number in the management agreement. A lot of owners here in Louisville with a handful of doors have never added it up for a full twelve months.

      When you've seen an owner move and it paid off, what was the gap that justified the switch, cost or service?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.