My Experience with RealWealth: Over $40K in Estimated Losses and a Costly Lesson

My Experience with RealWealth: Over $40K in Estimated Losses and a Costly Lesson

Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 2 votes

TL;DR: Bought a $355K Florida rental through RealWealth based on projections of positive cash flow and a 21% five-year IRR. Construction delays, rising rates, and a deposit-refund promise that wasn't honored undermined the investment before closing. Nearly four years later, my estimated economic losses are around $40K–$44K, with over $6K in maintenance bills on a nearly new home and ongoing property-management problems.

The Investment

In February 2022, I contracted to purchase a $354,900 new-construction rental property in Palm Coast, Florida, through RealWealth's recommended Florida property team, Holistic Investments, led by Brian Scrone.

The home was built by Southern Impression Homes and managed by SunCoast Property Management.

The original pro forma projected:

  • $226/month in positive cash flow, assuming 25% down and a 3.375% mortgage rate.

  • 21% projected five-year IRR.

  • May–July 2022 completion.

  • "Maintenance and Vacancy not included" in the fine print.

As a first-time rental-property investor, I was attracted to RealWealth's reputation for education, investment guidance, and access to vetted property teams.

RealWealth markets a model built around giving investors access to experienced professionals and income-producing properties. That was a significant part of why I felt comfortable moving forward.

The Problems Started Before Closing

One of my biggest concerns before signing was the possibility of mortgage rates increasing during construction. I raised this directly with Brian Scrone. He assured me that if interest rates increased to the point where the property became cash-flow negative, we could cancel the contract and I would receive a full refund of my 10% earnest-money deposit ($35,490).

That assurance was a significant factor in my decision to proceed.

Unfortunately, construction was repeatedly delayed, pushing completion from mid-2022 into January 2023.

Meanwhile, mortgage rates increased dramatically.

By September 2022, I was projecting $370–$470 in monthly losses. By October, nearly $582 per month.

I documented these concerns in emails to Brian's team and my RealWealth investment counselor, Leah Collich, explicitly reminding them of Brian's deposit-refund assurance.

Leah acknowledged my concerns and confirmed she had discussed them with Brian. She suggested exploring financing alternatives, but the underlying economics remained problematic.

When I subsequently reminded Brian of his promise, he told me he didn't remember making it and that we had to follow the written contract. (of course!)

I faced a choice: close on an investment already projected to lose money every month or risk forfeiting my $35,490 deposit.

I ultimately closed in January 2023 at 6.02% interest, compared with the 3.375% illustrated in the original projections, even after paying $5,656 in mortgage discount points.

The property then remained vacant for approximately five months, requiring me to carry the mortgage and property expenses without rental income.

The Financial Reality Through October 2026

I've reconciled my property-management ledgers against my actual mortgage payments.

Here's the financial picture:

  • -$17,585.75 cumulative cash-flow shortfall: $76,245.83 in net owner distributions after contributions versus $93,831.58 in mortgage payments.

  • -$25K to -$29K estimated property-value decline from the original purchase price.

  • +$13,905.75 in mortgage principal reduction, partially offsetting the economic loss.

  • Approximately $11,463 in estimated net upfront financing and closing expenses, including the $5,656 mortgage rate buydown.

Together, these figures suggest an estimated negative economic impact of approximately $40,000–$44,000, assuming the stated upfront expenses are nonrecoverable.

This includes an unrealized property-value decline and doesn't represent a realized loss from selling the property.

The Property Management Experience: Over $6,000 in Maintenance Bills on a Nearly New Home

One of the biggest selling points of new construction was the expectation of relatively low maintenance costs.

My experience has been the opposite.

According to my SunCoast ledger, from April 2023 through September 2026:

  • $6,037.53 in gross maintenance bills.

  • $5,353.28 after $684.25 in tenant chargebacks.

  • Five separate work orders totaling $1,983.75, each billed at exactly $396.75.

I own two other properties approaching ten years old, and their repair expenses have been a fraction of what I've experienced with this home.

Five identical charges just below my approval threshold

My management agreement establishes a $400 owner-approval threshold for nonemergency repairs.

My ledger shows five separate work orders from five different vendors, each billed at precisely $396.75—just $3.25 below the threshold. The work included cleaning, general repairs, LED light replacement, sink and drain repairs, and plumbing. I can't establish why the amounts were identical, but I believe the pattern warrants an explanation.

Construction quality or property-management oversight?

The property has also experienced plumbing problems, fixture replacements, and an HVAC evaporator-coil repair costing $1,175.90.

Are these construction-quality issues, poor maintenance oversight, or unnecessarily expensive vendor work? I don't know, but these aren't the maintenance costs I expected from a relatively new home.

Southern Impression Homes and SunCoast Property Management are also tied together under the same company. That doesn't establish wrongdoing, but it raises questions about the independence of the parties assessing construction-related repairs and warranty coverage.

I've also been billed recurring $5 monthly ShowMojo fees, including periods when the property was occupied, which I'm questioning under my management agreement.

My Issue with RealWealth

RealWealth didn't build or manage the property, but it recommended the team, promoted its vetted network, and guided me through the purchase.

My closing statement shows that Real Wealth Realty received a $10,647 seller-paid referral fee, equivalent to 3% of the purchase price. Referral fees are part of their business model, but what accountability does a referral network have when an investment's economics deteriorate dramatically before closing?

To add insult to injury, in June 2026, I was contacted by Leah, their investment counselor, encouraging me to purchase another property. I wasn't asked how my first investment with them was doing. Kathy Fettke has built a brand around investment education and vetted property teams. My experience has left me questioning how much support and accountability investors actually receive when things go wrong.

My Takeaway

I accept responsibility for signing the contracts and understand that real estate carries risk. But the gap between RealWealth's marketed investment experience and my actual results has been substantial.

For anyone considering an out-of-state turnkey investment, my advice is simple: stress-test the pro forma, get every verbal assurance in writing, investigate the property manager, and understand how the companies involved are connected and compensated.

I'm sharing this so other investors can make more informed decisions.

Has anyone else invested through RealWealth, Holistic Investments, or SunCoast? How did your actual returns and maintenance costs compare with the original projections?

1Reply
374 views

Most Popular Reply

JD MartinBusiness Member
Moderator
Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
4d

Don't take this the wrong way or as demeaning, but honestly you might want to consider just selling and looking for a new investment. Knowing your PM contract is pretty basic stuff if you're not going to self-manage. If I thought there was good rental profit possibility wherever the house is, I would break the contract, eat the 2 grand and self manage to help dig yourself out of this hole. If none of that is an option, then sometimes your best bet is to just take your loss and start over.

Skyline Properties
View Page
See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    5d

    Ouch. Sounds like a bad deal all the way around. This is why BP is really around in the first place. You should have dropped in here for some advice before you signed. There would have been a lot of people that would have likely told you that a 3% annual COC return and ~4% annualized over 5 years is pretty much a loser deal in RE unless you stand to realize some crazy appreciation, unlikely in that market. You can do better than that in a bank CD. And that was best case scenario.

    All you can do now is try to salvage the situation. What exactly is included in the maintenance charges over that time period, that wasn't chargeable to the tenant? Have you considered switching property management? You don't have to settle for poor PM - in fact, plenty of people do it themselves even from far away.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 2 votes
    4d

    I've certainly learned a lot. It seems like almost every month there is a charge for something - $397 to replace LED lights, $391 to replace smoke alarms, the latest was them trying to charge me $150 for a broken light fixture. This is all for a house that's just barely over 3 years old. I've since asked for a detailed break down of every charge showing what they are paying the vendor and what they are keeping for themselves off the top.

    Unfortunately by just a few days I missed the 60 day window I have to give notice for non-renewal, otherwise they will charge me one month's rent of $2150 to cancel. So it feels like I'm stuck with them for another year.

    Any advice on what I should do? My average monthly cash flow is -$163 so I've just been biting the bullet. I feel if I try to sell right now I'd realize a loss of around $40k so I've just been hanging onto it in the hopes that either rates will drop and I can refinance for a lower mortgage payment, or the house will appreciate and I can sell it and possibly break-even.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    4d

    Don't take this the wrong way or as demeaning, but honestly you might want to consider just selling and looking for a new investment. Knowing your PM contract is pretty basic stuff if you're not going to self-manage. If I thought there was good rental profit possibility wherever the house is, I would break the contract, eat the 2 grand and self manage to help dig yourself out of this hole. If none of that is an option, then sometimes your best bet is to just take your loss and start over.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4d

    Full disclosure I am not a fan of the new build rent ready model. I think it preys on inexperienced buyers who want an easy way which generally comes at a cost. In my opinion new construction is a consumption item which is great as a primary home but like a new car can be difficult to recapture expenses early and there is no such thing as maintenance free. You know all this but I think worth saying again for others who are tempted to think anything about brick and mortar RE is passive. I’m sorry this happened and would encourage you to immediately consider sunk cost fallacy. It is something I learned the hard way in the stock market.

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4d

    I’m sorry you’ve had to deal with this. I agree with JD that the deal had problems even if rates had stayed unusually low. Where I’d focus is the purchase agreement. There absolutely should have been a termination provision built into the purchase agreement if the builder missed a firm settlement deadline. There also should have been a financing contingency that allowed you to terminate if specific financing terms were not available. Did you have an attorney review the agreement? Also why no builder warranty?

  • Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 2 votes
    4d

    There was no termination provision on completion time or financing terms, they would have never agreed to that. The builder warranty was for 1 year only, which was also interesting in that it started when the CO was issued, not when the home was complete and I took ownership about 3 months later. Near the end of that first year I got hit with $515 in maintenance repairs that would have normally been covered.

    That's part of the problem I have with RealWealth. They include disclaimers on their marketing materials, but their whole value proposition is that they are supposed to be the experts to would-be investors with each of us getting an "investment counselor" to help guide us through the deal. And yes, part of their sales pitch was new construction homes that are supposed to have minimal maintenance costs. As construction kept getting delayed and rates kept rising, I was very vocal with my counselor about my concerns but was encouraged to keep going. I've even thought about legal action, but my case probably isn't strong enough.

    I appreciate all the feedback on here. I've been carrying this all on my own, so it's nice to know there is a community of support. I feel pretty foolish about the whole thing, but I remember at the time I signed the deal and gave my $35K deposit, rates were still low and there was a serious case of FOMO going on in the market.

    • JD MartinBusiness Member
      Moderator
      Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
      3d

      Don't worry about feeling foolish - there's hardly an experienced investor in here that hasn't lost money somewhere. I lost a big bunch at the beginning. Some people hit home runs in the beginning and then get full of themselves and turn into Dave Kingman. Some people are just Mario Mendoza all the time. If you're humble enough to learn and ask questions and take advice and admit things you don't know, you can get a lot of good information here (and elsewhere) and make some nice investments. First things first here is righting this ship. It sounds like you've got a conflict of interest with the management company, so unless you just want to sell and take your lumps I would probably start there. Begin talking to and interviewing management companies in that area. If you become a member here you can post in the classifieds, and it may be worthwhile to try to trawl for management companies doing business in that area. Short of that, you might try asking some of the better managers in here for referrals.

      I think it would be very short sighted to stick with a management company that you don't feel is representing your interests in order to try to save $2k.

      Skyline Properties
      View Page
  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4d

    Why would you stay with the management company after this overall experience?

    • Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 2 votes
      3d

      It was a 2-year contract initially that then renews each year. I mistakenly thought it renewal date was when the house is rent ready (Feb), but then found it's based on the close date (Jan) so I missed the 60 day cut off date for notice of non-renewal. This is my first time dealing with a property management company so to some extent I thought this is normal and just comes with the territory of owning real estate. There was also fear of the unknown in that after going through all the expense and pains of getting another PM that who knows if they will be any better - the devil you know vs. the one you don't.

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3d

    I have reviewed turnkey deals in past EVERY one from different companies had completely fake financial analysis. You probably would of lost even with the 3% rate. Single family houses very rarely cash flow in real life, you really need 2-4 unit buildings and also to do some value add yourself.

    Just chalk it up as a lesson, eventually with inflation you will be able to sell it for profit. If you have the funds don’t be afraid to add a lump sum and recast your mortgage to get a lower payment for the time being, many lenders allow this.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.