Terrible experience with my property manager in Indianapolis.

Terrible experience with my property manager in Indianapolis.

Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2015 · 5 posts · 3 votes

I purchased a duplex in Indianapolis (46205) toward the end of 2025, and unfortunately, my experience with T&H Realty as the property manager has been extremely disappointing.

The property had one occupied unit when I purchased it, and that tenant has been great. The duplex was also in reasonably good condition. However, the amount of repairs recommended by the property manager has seemed excessive, and it has taken nearly a full year to finally get a tenant placed in the vacant unit.

Throughout the process, T&H repeatedly attributed the difficulty in finding a tenant to market conditions. However, I was pricing the unit at the rental rate they recommended, and I approved all the repairs they requested to get the property rent-ready.

One of the selling points when I interviewed T&H was that they had an in-house maintenance technician who handled minor repairs and general maintenance that didn't require a licensed contractor. Not once has that in-house technician been utilized. Instead, every repair has been outsourced to third-party vendors, with even minor repairs costing several hundred dollars. I've easily spent approximately $15,000 on repairs and maintenance for just the one unit.

For context, I also own rental properties in Milwaukee, and my property management experience there has been significantly better. The level of service, maintenance costs, and overall performance from T&H don't come close to what I'm accustomed to with my Milwaukee property manager.

Between the extended vacancy and excessive maintenance expenses, T&H has severely impacted the financial performance of this property during its first year of ownership.

I'm looking for recommendations from other Indianapolis investors:

Who are you using for property management in Indy, and would you genuinely recommend them? Ideally, I'm looking for a company that is investor-friendly, has reasonable maintenance costs, utilizes in-house maintenance staff when appropriate, and is proactive about getting units rented.

I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences, both good and bad.

1Reply
410 views

Investor-friendly agents in Indianapolis, IN

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in Indianapolis, IN.

Most Popular Reply

Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 69 votes
3d

Eric, can't give you a name in Indy, but a few things I'd put in writing with the next company so it doesn't go the same way.

Put a dollar limit in the agreement. Anything over $300 needs your ok first, and anything over $1,000 needs two bids. Ask for a photo before and after every repair, sent with the invoice. If they really have their own maintenance guy, they'll put his hourly rate in the agreement.

Lee's right about getting the leads, showings and applications. I'd ask the next manager for those three numbers every week a unit is listed, not after the fact. Lots of people asking and nobody coming to see it means the price or the photos are off. Showings with no applications means something about the unit is turning people away. "The market is slow" doesn't hold up when you can see those numbers.

Also ask your Milwaukee manager who they'd call in Indianapolis. Good managers tend to know each other, and that beats any review.

Last thing, read the cancellation part of your current agreement before you give notice. Some charge a fee or hold the tenant file and the deposit for 30 days. You want the lease, the ledger and the keys handed over on a set date.

See this reply in the discussion

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    3d

    Hi @Eric Gutierrez,

    I'm sorry the first year with this duplex has been such a headache. Approving every repair they asked for, pricing the unit where they told you to and still waiting nearly a year to get a tenant placed would frustrate anyone, especially when your Milwaukee manager has already shown you what good looks like.

    I'm not in Indianapolis, so I'll leave the names to the local investors here. Before you switch, though, I'd ask your current manager for two things in writing. The first is every repair invoice for that unit over the past year, with the vendor and the job on each line. With around $15,000 spent, you'll quickly see which jobs could have gone to the in-house technician they promised, and whether the same vendor keeps showing up.

    The second is the vacancy record: the date it was listed, the asking rent over time, and how many inquiries, showings and applications came in each month. That tells you pretty clearly whether it really was the market or the way the unit was being marketed.

    Having both in hand also gives you a great set of questions for the managers you interview next. I'd ask each one how they decide between their own technician and an outside vendor, and what their average days on market was in your part of town last year.

    Best of luck getting it turned around,
    Lee

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 69 votes
    3d

    Eric, can't give you a name in Indy, but a few things I'd put in writing with the next company so it doesn't go the same way.

    Put a dollar limit in the agreement. Anything over $300 needs your ok first, and anything over $1,000 needs two bids. Ask for a photo before and after every repair, sent with the invoice. If they really have their own maintenance guy, they'll put his hourly rate in the agreement.

    Lee's right about getting the leads, showings and applications. I'd ask the next manager for those three numbers every week a unit is listed, not after the fact. Lots of people asking and nobody coming to see it means the price or the photos are off. Showings with no applications means something about the unit is turning people away. "The market is slow" doesn't hold up when you can see those numbers.

    Also ask your Milwaukee manager who they'd call in Indianapolis. Good managers tend to know each other, and that beats any review.

    Last thing, read the cancellation part of your current agreement before you give notice. Some charge a fee or hold the tenant file and the deposit for 30 days. You want the lease, the ledger and the keys handed over on a set date.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 766 votes
    3d

    Lee is right, get the paper first, then decide. I run an in-house property management team in Memphis because a manager who cannot show rent landing, maintenance invoices, and days on market will cost you the deal. A year vacant and $15,000 in repairs on one unit kills the numbers, no matter how good the buy was. Ask the next manager how they handle a late payment on day one, how they price a vacant unit, how long a turnover takes, and what they report each month. Get the repair approval limit in writing. I buy single-family under $100K, target an ARV of $180K-$265K, and I underwrite to the 1% rule, so if management cannot protect the rent, I pass on the manager, not just the house.

  • Member since 2023 · 188 posts · 73 votes
    2d

    Eric, a year to lease one unit and about $15,000 in repairs tells you the system broke, not just the market. Before you switch, pull the paper: the date it was listed, the asking rent over time, how many showings and applications, and every repair invoice with who did the work. That record is your interview sheet for the next manager. Ask them: how many days, on average, from rent-ready to a signed lease, and what is their rent-ready turnover schedule? Who actually does the small repairs, and what dollar amount can they approve without you? How do they screen — verified repeatable income, and does the story match the paperwork? And how often do they inspect, with photos? If they cannot answer with numbers and a schedule, keep looking. The next manager should be able to show you the work, not just promise it.

  • Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    2d

    Eric, before you switch, ask for the vendors’ original invoices, not just the lines on your owner statement. Side by side they show three things: whether a markup was added on top (many management agreements allow one), whether one vendor got most of the work, and how much was make-ready versus repairs after move-in.

    Then price the vacancy. Months vacant times the rent you ended up getting is likely close to the repair bill, and it’s the number to hold the next manager to.

    When you interview, ask every candidate for the same three numbers from their current doors: average days from rent-ready to signed lease, average turn cost per unit, and their markup on vendor work.

    I own a 5-unit and a rental house, and I’m building a free one-page manager scorecard for exactly this comparison. Let me know if you want it.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    1d

    We’re a Property Management Company (PMC) in Metro Detroit ONLY, with 25+ years of experience, and we’ve seen owners make the same mistakes, over & over again when looking to hire a PMC – which drives us nuts!.

    In our experience, the #1 mistake owners make is ASSUMING all PMCs offer the exact SAME SERVICES and PERFORM those services EXACTLY THE SAME WAY.

    So, owners mistakenly think price is the only differentiator – and look for a PMC like they’d shop for groceries☹

    We encourage you to learn from the mistakes of others by reading posts here on BiggerPockets from owners that picked a PMC solely by price and regretted it.

    We recommend exploring as many sources as possible to get referrals AND cross-reference them to get as much accurate information as possible.

    Check out NARPM.com, BP’s Property Manager Finder (), etc.

    Even if someone gives you a referral, do NOT make the mistake of assuming that just because a PMC met their expectations, they’ll meet your expectations. We all have our own expectations and what works for someone else, may not work for you.

    If you’re new to all of this, it's often a case of not doing enough research, as you don't know what you don't know!

    So, ask more questions!

    EXAMPLE: PMC states they will handle tenant screening – what does that specifically mean? What documents do they require, what credit scores do they allow, how do they verify previous rental history, etc.? You’d be shocked by how little actual screening many PMC’s do!

    This also leads owners to ASSUME simpler is better when it comes to management contracts. 

    The reality is the opposite - if it's not in writing then the PMC doesn't have to provide the service or can charge extra for it!

    A well written management contract should clearly spell out what is expected of both the PMC and the owner, to PROTECT both and avoid misunderstandings. Why do you think purchase contracts are so long and have such small print?

    We recommend you get management contracts from several PMCs and compare the services they cover and, more importantly, what they each DO NOT cover.

    EDUCATE YOURSELF - yes, it will take time, but will lead to a selection that better meets your expectations & avoids potentially costly surprises!

    P.S. If you just hire the cheapest or first PMC you speak with and it turns into a bad experience, please don’t assume ALL PMC’s are bad and start trashing PMC’s in general. Take ownership of your mistake and learn to do the proper due diligence recommended above😊

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 328 posts · 79 votes
    23h

    Eric, a year to place one unit is a long time, and I'd treat it as a performance question, not a market one. Since you're in LA and own in two other cities, here's how I'd run the switch.

    Before you give notice, ask T&H for a one-page vacancy log: list date, asking rent changes, and the count of inquiries, showings and applications by month. If they can't produce it quickly, that answers a lot.

    Next, pull every invoice for the unit and sort by vendor. If one or two vendors show up on most jobs, ask why the in-house technician was never dispatched, since that was part of the pitch.

    When you interview the next manager, ask how they handle a unit that sits more than 30 days: who decides on price changes, and when. Ask for two owner references with similar small multifamily, and call them.

    I manage in Orange County, so I can't name anyone in Indy, but your Milwaukee manager is a good source for a referral. Happy to compare notes by message.

    Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
  • Josh C.Pro Member
    Property Manager · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2010 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    23h

    Sorry you’ve had a bad experience in Indy. Unfortunately, we are coming into a poor time to rent a property as the weather changes, but there are several solid options for property management.

    We’d love to be a resource for property management here in Indianapolis. Please check us out CityPlaceIndy.com

  • Real Estate Agent · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 2 votes
    4h

    Check out Darin Moon and sycamore-management.com. They manage multiple properties all over Indianapolis, both long-term and Airbnb-style rentals. Best of luck finding a property manager you're happy with!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.