The line item nobody bids: what an empty Memphis house costs you every week it sits

The line item nobody bids: what an empty Memphis house costs you every week it sits

Josh HandlerPro Member
Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 78 posts · 87 votes

Full disclosure before anything: I run a construction company here in Memphis, all trades in house, so I have a bias and you should weigh everything below accordingly. My partner James Jones is also active on this forum and is a Memphis operator, so if you see us both in a thread, count us as one voice rather than two.

Every rehab budget I ever see is organized around the WORK. Roof, kitchen, HVAC, paint. Almost none of them have a line for the thing that quietly does the most damage, which is TIME. And the reason is simple: nobody bids time, because no contractor wants to be held to a date.

So here's what a week of an empty house actually costs here, in the order people discover it.

CARRY. Taxes, insurance, debt service and utilities, pro rated. Note the insurance part specifically, because a vacant house under renovation is usually not covered by the policy people think they have. Builder's risk or a vacancy endorsement costs more than a standard landlord policy, and some carriers restrict it entirely past a certain vacancy period. Find that out in week one rather than in week nine.

GENERAL CONDITIONS. This is the one most people have never heard of and it's the honest reason the cheap bid becomes the expensive job. General conditions are supervision, dumpsters, the portable toilet, temporary power, protection, cleanup and securing the house. They scale with DURATION, not with square footage. A 1,200 square foot house that takes twelve weeks carries more of them than a 1,800 square foot house that takes six. And they're the first line a low bidder deletes in order to win, which means the low number often carries a longer schedule and the longer schedule is what you actually pay for.

THEFT. In a lot of our neighborhoods an empty house is inventory. Condensers, copper, water heaters, appliances, and sometimes the panel itself. The direct cost is replacing it. The indirect costs are worse: the schedule restarts on that trade, and a claim on a vacant property can move your premium or get you non renewed, so a two thousand dollar condenser can turn into a permanent increase in what every one of your houses costs to insure. Most people price the condenser. Almost nobody prices the second part.

WEATHER. Mid South storm season plus a house that's open. A roof that's deferred to week ten is a roof that gets tested in week eight.

Now the part that actually determines all of the above, which is why I think people underestimate it so consistently.

Duration is not set by the amount of work. It's set by the longest item on the critical path, and the critical path is almost always controlled by somebody who doesn't work for you. The utility on a service upgrade or a meter set. The permit office. The inspector's calendar. A special order window or cabinet with a six week lead. You can have four weeks of labor and a ten week job, and the six weeks of difference is pure carry with nobody on site.

Which leads to the practical bit, and it costs you nothing.

When you take bids, ask every bidder for three things beyond the price. One, a DURATION in weeks with a start date, not a finish date. Two, the three longest lead items in the job and whether they've been ordered or just priced. Three, which items require an inspection and in what sequence. A bid without a schedule attached is a price without a number behind it, because you can't tell what you'll be carrying while it happens.

Then compare bids on price PLUS carry, not on price. On a cheap house here the carry difference between an eight week job and a fourteen week job is frequently larger than the difference between the two bids, and it runs entirely in the direction of the cheaper bidder, because the cheaper bidder usually wins on price by running your job as filler between his better paying ones.

Two Memphis specific notes to close. Get the power on early, because you need it to test, to inspect and to run tools, and MLGW timing belongs on your schedule rather than on your to do list. And if the house is going to sit open in a neighborhood where that's a problem, pay for real security up front and treat it as a scheduled cost rather than as a surprise, because it is far cheaper than buying the same condenser twice and much cheaper than losing the policy.

The honest counterweight: speed for its own sake is how you get work that fails an inspection and gets opened back up, which costs more than the weeks you saved. The goal isn't a fast job, it's a job with no dead weeks in it. Those are different things, and the dead weeks are where the money goes.

Curious what the longest dead stretch anybody here has had on a Memphis job was, and what caused it. My bet is the utility or an inspection, not the work.

1Reply
184 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 159 votes
    2d

    Josh, this is such a useful breakdown — thank you for writing it. From the agent side, I see the same thing on the buy side: the purchase price gets all the attention, and the carry is what decides whether the deal actually works.

    The point about the critical path is the one I repeat most to investors. Permits, inspections, and utility timing are outside everyone's control, so I encourage building a realistic hold time into the numbers before making an offer, not after. If the deal only works on a perfect schedule, it doesn't work.

    The insurance note matters too. I suggest buyers confirm in writing what coverage looks like while the house is vacant and under renovation, before closing — that is a much cheaper conversation than a denied claim later.

    What do you see as the single biggest cause of dead weeks on your jobs right now?

  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
    2d

    Good day Josh,

    One step after the bid: tie each payment to a stage that has its own date and is closed with photos. A schedule on paper is easy to slip. A stage that is overdue and still unpaid shows up in week two, not week nine.

    It also helps everyone on the job. Each trade sees which stage is holding them, the owner sees what the empty weeks cost before it grows, and the contractor who runs the job as filler is visible early.

    When MLGW or the inspector sets the date, who tells the other trades the new stage day on your jobs?

  • Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 4 votes
    2d

    Good day Josh,

    The point about dead weeks is particularly important because delays often create additional costs beyond the original budget. One thing that could help is tying payments to clearly defined stages, with dated photos and agreed milestones. This gives the owner better visibility into what's actually getting done and makes it easier to identify delays before they affect the entire project. It also keeps everyone accountable for their part of the schedule.

    When an inspection or utility connection gets pushed back, how do you usually keep the other trades moving without adding unnecessary downtime?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.