Real Estate Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2017 · 142 posts · 35 votes
Say you buy a rental and plan a major renovation in the first year — new kitchen, baths, flooring, maybe HVAC. Do you do the cost seg study before the renovation, after it, or both?
Before, you capture the old components while they are still there, and you can write off what gets demolished. After, you capture the new 5- and 7-year property at full cost, plus bonus on it. Doing it twice costs twice.
Curious how others have actually sequenced this. Did anyone do the study before the reno and regret missing the new work, or wait until after and lose the demo write-off? What did your CPA say about the timing?
Great question, Sagiv — and one where the order genuinely matters. The way I think about it, a study before the renovation captures the old components while they're still in place, which is how the demolition write-off gets documented. A study after captures the new kitchen, baths, and flooring at their new values. What I've seen work well for investors doing a big first-year rehab is doing the study before the demo starts, then updating it after the renovation so both sides are documented. The piece I'd flag is timing: once the old components are in the dumpster, you can't photograph or measure them. This is also one of those decisions worth a quick call with your CPA before the demo crew shows up, since the right answer depends on your tax situation and whether the property goes into service before or after the work. How are you timing the renovation relative to your first tenant?
I would typically do one study after the renovation is placed in service, and have it include the components you tore out, rather than paying for two full studies.
You are really trying to capture two different things:
1) A write-off of the remaining basis in the kitchen, baths, or HVAC you demolished.
2) The new invoices, including any 5- and 7-year property or qualified improvement property that may be eligible for faster depreciation or bonus.
The new work is based on what you actually spend, so a study done before the renovation will not automatically pick that up. A study done after can still support the demo write-off if you have a decent purchase-price allocation and you document what was removed. That is the piece people worry they will lose by waiting, and it is usually manageable without a second full engagement.
A pre-renovation study can still help when the books have one lump “building” number and no one knows what basis is sitting in the old kitchen. On a smaller rental, that is often something your CPA can estimate from the settlement statement and a simple allocation, and then the formal study happens once the work is done.
So if you buy a rental for $400,000 (say $80,000 land and $320,000 building) and then put $80,000 into a kitchen and baths, you want the remaining basis of the old finishes written off, the new $80,000 on the right recovery lives, and the rest of the structure left on 27.5 years. Doing the study twice is typically not worth the extra cost unless the property is large or the records are a mess.
This depends on the size of the job and how clean the purchase allocation is, but that is the sequencing I usually prefer. Hope this helps.
Sagiv, when clients ask me this, I usually recommend planning the cost seg before the renovation, but not necessarily paying for two full studies.
If the property was already in service, we want to document the components being removed so we can evaluate a potential partial disposition deduction. Then, once the renovation is complete, one properly scoped study can often address both the old components and the new improvements.
If you're renovating a newly acquired property before it's ever ready to rent, I'd generally lean toward doing the study after the renovation.
For larger or more complex projects, two studies might make sense, but I would want to see the additional tax benefit justify the cost.
@Sagiv O. I usually land on one study after the reno. Two only makes sense in a few cases. The demo write-off is the part people worry about, but you don't need a study ahead of time to get it. You can still write off what you rip out with a partial disposition election and value the old stuff afterward. What matters is the paper trail: photos before demo, the closing statement, and the demo invoice.
The other thing is that a new kitchen and baths in a residential rental don't reclassify as much as people hope. Cabinets, tile, plumbing and normal HVAC mostly stay 27.5-year. Appliances, carpet and a few fixtures are what move to 5 and 7. Ask the engineer for a rough split before paying for a second report, because sometimes it won't cover its own fee.
I'd do both if the demo is big, the purchase price is high, or the work runs into the next tax year. Ask about update pricing up front, since it's usually well below a full study. Not tax advice, just my take. Check with your own CPA.
The answer usually depends more on when the property is placed in service than on when the study is done. If you renovate before the property is ever rented, the old kitchen and baths were never placed in service as rental property, so there’s no partial disposition to claim. The demo write-off only exists if the property was rented first and then renovated. In that case, the old components have depreciable basis, and the partial disposition election on that year’s return lets you write off what you tore out.
If it was rented first, you don’t need two studies. Most firms will do one study after the renovation that values the original components as of acquisition, using the inspection report, listing photos, and purchase-date condition, plus the new work at actual cost. That captures both the disposition and the new 5 and 7-year property for one fee. The key is documenting the “before” condition at closing, since that’s the evidence the retroactive allocation rests on. Also keep in mind that new structural work like HVAC stays 27.5-year on residential property, so the bonus benefit on the renovation is mostly in the cabinets, appliances, flooring, and site work. Happy to connect!