Damage coverage on midterm stays — deposit, waiver, or eat the risk?

Damage coverage on midterm stays — deposit, waiver, or eat the risk?

Nadia DaggettBusiness Member
Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes

Question for the midterm operators here — how are you handling damage coverage on 30+ night stays?

I've been reworking mine. For lease-based midterms I run everything through my PMS and use a deposit-alternative product (Obligo) — no cash deposit collected from the tenant, and it covers damage and missed rent, which keeps the move-in cost down and competitive. That's been working well.

Where I'm stuck is the platform stays — Airbnb/Vrbo furnished bookings in that 30–90 day range. A traditional cash deposit is clunky there: platforms discourage off-platform charges, tenants balk at tying up $1,000+, and frankly I don't love holding other people's money. So I'm evaluating a per-stay damage waiver instead — the guest pays a small per-booking fee, coverage runs $500–$20,000 per stay depending on the plan, accidental and intentional damage included, no deductible except pet damage. I've submitted for an enterprise consultation (Waivo) to get real per-booking pricing for my volume; nothing signed yet.

My hesitation: does the waiver actually pay out smoothly when something real happens, or is it deposit-or-nothing for anyone who's filed a claim? And for those collecting actual deposits on midterms — how are you holding them compliantly (Florida trust accounting) without it becoming an admin headache?

Would love to hear what's actually worked when a tenant leaves real damage behind.

— Nadia Daggett, broker of Investing N Florida, an investor-friendly brokerage.

1Reply
426 views

Most Popular Reply

John RacinePro Member
Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 284 posts · 149 votes
3w

@Nadia Daggett most of my units run 30–90 nights on Airbnb, so here's how I'm handling the platform stays.

Right now the deposit on 30+ night stays is a hold handled through my PMS. It gets released after checkout. That takes care of part of your "holding other people's money" concern, because nothing sits in an account of mine for months. Whether a hold on a furnished stay that long gets treated like a security deposit under Florida's landlord-tenant rules is a question for a Florida real estate attorney. I'd get that answer in writing before building a process around either option.

To be upfront, I haven't had to charge against one yet, so I can't tell you how a claim actually plays out, on a hold or a waiver. My understanding is that I'd make the claim through my PMS or through my merchant account, which is Stripe, but I haven't had to test that. What I'd decide before anything happens:

  • What counts as damage versus normal wear on a furnished unit after 60 days of someone living there, not a weekend.

  • How it gets documented: dated photos or video at check-in and checkout, plus an inventory list.

  • How fast the guest hears about it, and in what form.

Screening does more of the work for me than the deposit does. On 28+ night stays I still do an ID check and a signed agreement, which Airbnb's new rules still allow for those stays. I'm working with my PMS and background check vendors to keep it compliant. A guest who has been verified and signed something is rarely the one who leaves damage behind.

On the waiver, before signing I'd ask for their claims process in writing: what documentation they need, how long a typical payout takes, and how many claims get denied. I'd also ask how it works alongside Airbnb's own host damage protection, so you know which one you're expected to file with first.

Have you had a real damage claim on a 30+ night platform stay yet, or are you getting ahead of it?

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 284 posts · 149 votes
    3w

    @Nadia Daggett most of my units run 30–90 nights on Airbnb, so here's how I'm handling the platform stays.

    Right now the deposit on 30+ night stays is a hold handled through my PMS. It gets released after checkout. That takes care of part of your "holding other people's money" concern, because nothing sits in an account of mine for months. Whether a hold on a furnished stay that long gets treated like a security deposit under Florida's landlord-tenant rules is a question for a Florida real estate attorney. I'd get that answer in writing before building a process around either option.

    To be upfront, I haven't had to charge against one yet, so I can't tell you how a claim actually plays out, on a hold or a waiver. My understanding is that I'd make the claim through my PMS or through my merchant account, which is Stripe, but I haven't had to test that. What I'd decide before anything happens:

    • What counts as damage versus normal wear on a furnished unit after 60 days of someone living there, not a weekend.

    • How it gets documented: dated photos or video at check-in and checkout, plus an inventory list.

    • How fast the guest hears about it, and in what form.

    Screening does more of the work for me than the deposit does. On 28+ night stays I still do an ID check and a signed agreement, which Airbnb's new rules still allow for those stays. I'm working with my PMS and background check vendors to keep it compliant. A guest who has been verified and signed something is rarely the one who leaves damage behind.

    On the waiver, before signing I'd ask for their claims process in writing: what documentation they need, how long a typical payout takes, and how many claims get denied. I'd also ask how it works alongside Airbnb's own host damage protection, so you know which one you're expected to file with first.

    Have you had a real damage claim on a 30+ night platform stay yet, or are you getting ahead of it?

    • Nadia DaggettBusiness Member
      OP
      Real Estate Broker · Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 113 posts · 68 votes
      2w

      In the past we have had to pull against security deposit and worked well. But trying to get ahead of it, looking at other options.

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2w

    I have short term that on occasion are midterm. Anything over 28 days requires a lease and over 45 days includes a small security deposit.

  • Technology · Marietta, GA · Member since 2018 · 4 posts · 1 vote
    1d

    Whatever you pick, deposit or waiver, the claim only pays if you can prove the damage is new. We do a dated photo walk-through at move-in, room by room, that the guest signs, and the same at move-out. That signed move-in set has ended every "it was already like that" argument we've had.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.