While clearing, we found what looks like an old hand-dug well. That's a line I didn't have in the budget.
For those who've flipped rural properties:
What do you test first before deciding the old well is usable (flow, quality, casing)?
What did a new drilled well actually cost you, and did buyers or appraisers care either way?
Did well-to-septic setbacks ever force a redesign on you?
I'll post what we find.
@Brandon Hadler, I'd have a qualified well contractor inspect the existing well and test the water quality and flow before deciding whether to repair it or drill a new one. Since you've already had the septic assessment done, I'd also let that professional know about the well before moving forward with the design. Its location could affect your plans. I can't speak to current drilling costs in central Virginia, but I'd get a few local estimates before making that decision.
In my experience working with previous clients as a real estate attorney and broker in Maryland, I've seen how important it is to address unexpected property issues before resale. For example, having the proper inspection records and documentation for major systems can help answer buyers' questions and avoid complications during closing.
I appreciate you sharing the progress on your farmhouse project, @Brandon Hadler! These are exactly the kinds of surprises that can make renovations challenging. Property condition and disclosure concerns are closely related to my work, so I'll be interested to hear what you find. Happy to stay connected!
Brandon, this is exactly the kind of surprise that makes rural rehabs interesting — thank you for sharing the real numbers.
From the agent side, I would focus on what the next buyer — and their lender — will need to see. A well you plan to use should have water quality and flow tests documented, and the well-to-septic setbacks are worth confirming with the county now, not when a buyer's appraisal comes back with conditions. Those are the two items I have seen hold up a closing on rural homes.
On your second question, buyers and appraisers do care, because a well is a system the next owner has to live with. Keeping the test results, the contractor's notes, and any permits in a file to hand over at sale makes the property much easier to sell.
Will you update the thread with what the testing comes back with?
One thing about order: the well decision sits in front of two other stages. The plumbing bid and the septic design both change with it, through the water line route and the pressure tank location.
I would make the well its own priced stage and close it before the plumber starts the repipe. Then the plumber, the septic designer and the well driller each know their day, and nobody redoes work because the water source moved.
Does the plumbing bid assume the water enters the house where the old supply did?
@Vladimirs Veiss good question on sequencing. I don't know yet whether the plumbing bid assumes the water comes in where the old supply did. I'm confirming that with the plumber before the repipe starts.
@Ametria Chaney agreed on keeping a file for the next buyer. We'll get flow and water quality tested and I'll post what comes back here.
@Diana Khan good reminder to make sure the septic design accounts for the well location.
@Brandon Hadler, thank you for the update. If the water comes in at a different point than the old supply, the trench and the pressure tank move too. One sketch shared with the plumber before the repipe keeps everyone on the same line.
Brandon, a hand-dug well usually won't pass for a sale. Most lenders and appraisers want a drilled well with a proper casing, so I'd budget for a new one and treat the old one as a bonus if it tests clean. Around me a drilled well runs roughly $8k to $15k depending on depth, so get two local quotes. Have the septic designer mark the well spot before you drill so the setbacks don't surprise you.
Hey Brandon, I'd lean the same way Trevor did and plan on drilling, but there's one piece nobody mentioned. If you drill new, the old hand-dug well usually has to be properly closed out, filled and sealed under the health department's rules, and until it is, it can still count as a well for setback purposes. On a tight rural lot that can squeeze where the drainfield and the new well can go. So I'd have your AOSE put the old well, the proposed new well and the drainfield on the same drawing before anyone drills, and ask the county what they require to close the old one. Budget a line for that too.
If you want to test the old one anyway, a hand-dug well is shallow and open to surface water, so bacteria (coliform and E. coli) and nitrates are the tests that usually fail. Pull the sample after a good rain if you can, since that's the worst case. Flow on a dug well is really about recovery, so ask for a pump test that draws it down and times the refill, not just a quick gallons per minute reading.
On buyers, a lot of them will be using loans where the lender wants a passing water test and proper distance from the septic, so a new drilled well with paperwork makes the sale much cleaner.
@Trevor Rice the lender/appraiser point is the one that matters most for the exit, so I'm getting driller quotes before I put any money into the old well. Thanks for the range.
@Redgy Saint-Germain good catch on closing out the old well. The septic repair design just went to the county health department, so I'll ask them how they want the old well abandoned and whether it still counts for setbacks until it's sealed. Did you have the driller do the close-out or a separate contractor?
@Vladimirs Veiss agreed. I'll get the new entry point and tank location on one sketch for the plumber before the water line work starts.