Lease-to-own from the landlord's side: what my Orlando lease options taught me

Lease-to-own from the landlord's side: what my Orlando lease options taught me

John RacinePro Member
Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes

There's been a lot of seller-finance and subject-to talk here lately, so I wanted to add a creative strategy that doesn't get much airtime from the landlord's side: lease options.

Before I ever ran a mid-term or short-term rental, some of my first rental income in Orlando came from lease-to-own deals. I got into them through a mortgage broker I knew. When he had a borrower he couldn't get approved, he'd bring that buyer in and the home became a lease-to-own instead. Later I bought a 3-bed/2.5-bath home and sold it on a lease option myself.

Why I liked them

For a landlord, the appeal is real. The buyer handled the repairs, so I collected rent and that was about it. No maintenance calls, no late-night emergencies.

Where it went wrong

On the 3/2.5, the monthly payment was set slightly above market rent because of the option. That premium looked like cash flow. It wasn't. That tenant-buyer turned out to be running what looked like a bad-check scheme, and I had to evict. When I put the house on a regular lease, I couldn't get anywhere near that rate. Rent went back to market, and I was fortunate to break even.

What I'd check before doing one today

  1. Underwrite to market rent, not the option payment. If the deal only works with the premium, it doesn't work.

  2. Plan for the buyer not buying. Three of my tenant-buyers did close. The one on the 3/2.5 didn't, and that's the one that taught me the most. Make sure the numbers still hold if you end up a regular landlord again.

  3. Screen like it's a regular lease. A buyer who can't get a mortgage today might have a good reason, or might not. Find out which before you sign. I also don't accept personal checks for move-in funds anymore.

  4. Know your exit before you need it. Mine went through the same eviction process as a regular tenant. In Florida that took about 25 days, so I took roughly a month's rent hit. Don't assume that's true everywhere. Depending on your state and how the agreement is written, a tenant-buyer may not be treated like a plain tenant.

  5. Have it papered properly. Keep the lease and the option clear and separate, and have an attorney who does these regularly draft or review it.

For those of you doing seller finance or lease options right now: do you underwrite the deal as if the buyer never closes, or do you count on the option premium?

0Reply
131 views

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 229 posts · 90 votes
    13h

    John, thank you for sharing what the Orlando deals taught you. I am still learning this side of the business, and the part that stays with me is your line about underwriting to market rent. I look at it the same way. If the deal only works when the buyer closes, I am counting on something I do not control. I want the rent to carry it on its own, and I want the lease and the option written down clearly so everyone knows where they stand. The paper is what protects the person on both sides. Appreciate you posting this.

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
      9h

      Thanks, Chris. You nailed it: the paper protects both sides. The option premium on my 3/2.5 looked like cash flow right up until it wasn't, so now if a deal only works because the buyer closes, I pass. Are you looking at lease options as a way to buy, or to sell something you own?

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    9h

    Yes, and if the house carries a DSCR loan, the lender has mostly made that call for you. Lenders generally size the loan off the lesser of the lease rent and the appraiser's market rent, so an option premium gets capped at market before it ever counts. Sharing the 3/2.5 is the generous part of your post, since most people only write up the ones that closed.

    What I'd add is where the option fee goes. Spent as income, it disappears into the mortgage. Held as a reserve, it pays for the eviction, the vacant months and whatever the tenant-buyer let slide. A tenant who handles repairs on a house they end up not buying usually stops handling them well before they leave. On the 3/2.5, did you credit the option fee toward the purchase price or keep it as the turnover reserve?

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    7h

    I believe over 60% of lease options do NOT close.

    Google it!

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    1h

    Noah, that one had traditional financing, so DSCR wasn't something I had to work with back then. Great info for anyone doing a lease option on a DSCR loan, though. And it was a non-refundable option fee, never meant to be credited toward the purchase price, so it went into cash flow.

    Drew, that number doesn't surprise me. Three of mine closed and one didn't, but I'd never plan around those odds. If the deal only works when the buyer closes, it doesn't work.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.