First new construction infill build: How to make this a great deal?
Hey BP,
This is my first new-construction spec build, and I'd like experienced builders and investors to look at this deal and make some comments and suggestions on how you would go about this project. I'm self-managing as a GC through my LLC on an infill lot in Southeast Fort Wayne (ZIP 46806).
The product
1,483 sf, 3 bed / 2 bath, single-story, split-bedroom slab ranch
1-car attached garage (300 sf), front and rear covered porches (278 sf combined)
Lot is about 1/4 acre with city water, sewer, gas, and electric available
Land
I already own the lot. It was acquired at no cost, so there’s no land basis in this deal.
Cost estimate
My total build estimate is $197,012 (about $133/sf), from a StartBuild Cost-to-Build report run in June 2026 at a “Good” material class. That covers everything from soft costs and site work through foundation, shell, mechanicals, and interior finishes.
Comps: new construction (built 2020+) in 46806, 3 bed, sold in the last 3 months as of 11/17/26
4292 Werling Dr (0.7 mi from my lot): built 2026, sold October 27, 2026 for $220,000, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,203 sf. That’s $183/sf.
3704 Grayston Ave (1.3 mi): built 2025, sold October 16, 2026 for $259,900, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,361 sf. That’s $191/sf.
3708 Grayston Ave (1.3 mi): built 2025, sold October 2, 2026 for $257,800, 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,361 sf. That’s $189/sf.
4528 S Park Dr (0.9 mi): built 2026, sold August 25, 2026 for $182,000, 3 bed / 1 full + 1 half bath, 1,158 sf. That’s $157/sf.
I would love your feedback!
Thanks in advance.