What did your worst turnover cost — and how do you document the damage?

What did your worst turnover cost — and how do you document the damage?

Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 0 votes

Just had a brutal turnover (trashed unit, holes in walls, full repaint) and I'm trying to figure out what it really costs other landlords.

How much did your worst one run you all-in? And how do you document the damage — phone photos, spreadsheet, an app, or nothing formal? Do you use any software for this, or is it all manual? California's AB 2801 now requires move-in/move-out photos — how are you handling that?

0Reply
327 views

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 282 posts · 148 votes
    1d

    Richard, sorry you're dealing with that one. Mine was years ago at a rough duplex I owned in Orlando. A tenant was running a brothel out of the unit, and I had to evict him. The place was trashed. I don't think he was letting his people use the bathroom, because I found a 5-gallon jug filled with what should have gone in the toilet. The walls were a disaster and the kitchen cabinets were all damaged. It was almost a complete interior remodel, and that's when I put it up for sale.

    For the all-in number, count the empty weeks while the work gets done, not just the contractor bills. That's the cost people leave out.

    On documenting: photos, every time. I recently had a guest at one of my furnished mid-term/short-term units whose dogs tore the place up, and it needed extensive cleaning and repairs. That stay was booked through Booking.com, and the photos are what got me reimbursed through their Host Protection. I'm not a California landlord, so I can't speak to how people are handling AB 2801 day to day, but a consistent set of dated photos at move-in and move-out is the habit that law pushes you toward anyway.

  • Monroe, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 7 votes
    1d

    The documentation is where most landlords lose the money, not the repair. What holds up: a move-in checklist the tenant signed, dated photos of the same corners at move-in and move-out, receipts for every repair with dates, and an itemized deduction letter sent inside your state's deadline. Without the signed move-in report, even real damage gets argued down to "normal wear and tear."

  • Real Estate Coach · Austin · Member since 2022 · 28 posts · 10 votes
    1d

    On the books side, I keep the deposit in a liability account until move-out. When the itemized letter goes out, the part I keep moves to income, and the patching and repaint get booked as repair expense on that unit. Drywall patches and a full repaint usually count as restoring, so they're expensed, while new flooring or cabinets are usually improvements you depreciate. I tag every turnover receipt with the unit and move-out month so the all-in cost is one filter away. Worth confirming the bigger items with your CPA.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 162 votes
    1d

    Richard, sorry you're dealing with that one — a trashed unit is a lesson nobody forgets. The advice here is solid, and I'd add one thing from the leasing side: the documentation that protects you at move-out starts at move-in. Dated photos and video of every room, a move-in checklist, and receipts for every repair — that file is what turns a deposit dispute into a non-event, and it protects you if the damage ever becomes a claim or a sale disclosure issue later.

    On the all-in number, John is right — count the empty weeks, not just the contractor bills. A $4,000 repair that costs you six weeks of rent is a bigger hit than the invoice suggests. And on AB 2801, the landlords I know in California treat the photo requirement as a habit now: same corners, same angles, move-in and move-out, always. Consistency is what holds up.

  • Member since 2025 · 19 posts · 6 votes
    1d

    On documentation, the system matters more than the camera:

    1. Move-in: walk every room with the tenant, take a timestamped video plus photos of each wall, floor, fixture, and appliance, and have them sign a condition report within the first few days. Note existing scratches and stains on the report itself.

    2. Store everything in one folder per unit and lease (photos, signed report, receipts for any work done before move-in). If you can't find it later, it doesn't help you.

    3. Move-out: repeat the same walkthrough in the same order, so before-and-after shots line up room for room.

    4. Separate normal wear and tear from damage on the itemized list. Faded paint and light carpet wear after a long tenancy are wear; holes, burns, pet stains, and broken fixtures are damage. Price damage with receipts or written bids.

    5. Know your state's deadline and itemization rules and calendar them on day one of the move-out.

    Doing this every time is boring, but it turns deposit disputes from "he said, she said" into a photo comparison.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 83 votes
    1d

    Richard, sorry about the unit. On cost, I'd count three buckets: repair and paint, the vacant weeks while work gets done, and the re-leasing cost. Many owners only add the first one, and the other two are often half the real number.

    For documentation, a phone camera works if you are consistent. Shoot the same walls in the same order at move-in and move-out, narrate the room and date in a short video, then keep photos in one folder per unit and lease, named by room. Pair that with a simple itemized sheet: item, age, repair cost, and whether it is damage or normal wear. Age matters because depreciation is usually considered when you charge a deposit deduction.

    California now has the photo requirements you mention for move-in and move-out, plus tight deadlines for returning the deposit with an itemized statement, so build the habit before you need it. Not legal advice, and check the current rules for your situation.

    Happy to compare notes by message.

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
  • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 201 posts · 75 votes
    1d

    @richardl579 Documentation is mostly about being able to compare move-in and move-out side by side. Use a room-by-room condition checklist signed by the tenant at move-in, with a timestamped video walkthrough and photos of every wall, floor, and fixture saved in one folder per unit. At move-out, repeat the same walkthrough in the same order. Then itemize each deduction with the matching before and after photo and the invoice or quote, separate normal wear from damage, and send it within your state's deadline. On cost, it helps to track turnover spend per unit per year so you can see whether stricter screening or a slightly larger deposit (where allowed) would have paid for itself.

  • Property Manager · Denver, CO · Member since 2026 · 32 posts · 13 votes
    2h

    Sorry about the unit, that's a rough one.

    On the AB 2801 part since nobody's gotten specific, my understanding is it's really three sets of photos now, not two. Move-in (for leases starting after April 1, 2025), then move-out before you touch anything, and then again after the repairs or cleaning are done. That third set is the one I'd guess most people miss, because by then the contractor's gone and you just want it listed. The photos are also supposed to go to the tenant along with the itemized statement, so however you store them it needs to be easy to send as a link or attachment inside the 21 days.

    So for the app or manual question I'd honestly just want whatever keeps date stamps and lets you share one folder per lease. Not a lawyer, so worth double checking the details with one in CA.

    Did you get before-repair photos on this one?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.