Harold, a 24% margin on ARV on a flip that size makes me check the ARV first. Your numbers back into an ARV near $958k on a $452k purchase, so I'd want three sold comps close by at that price before trusting anything else. Then get the rehab number from a contractor walking the house, not an estimate. The $5,675 a month in holding only holds if the job finishes on schedule.
Trevor, I appreciate the pushback—you’re absolutely right to flag a $958k ARV on a 1,904 sq ft home, and a 24% margin only holds water if the exit price is real.
To address your specific concerns:
1. The ARV and the 3 Comps ($958k Exit) The $958k ARV isn't pulled from thin air; it's based on a $912k baseline plus a 5% 'eco-premium.' Here are three recent renovated comps in Sunnyside that support a baseline ARV near $912k ($479/sq ft):
4208 Umatilla St: 1,802 sq ft, sold for $875,000 ($485/sq ft).
2426 King St: 1,982 sq ft, sold for $870,000 ($438/sq ft).
3320 W 33rd Ave: 1,601 sq ft, sold for $940,000 ($587/sq ft).
My 1,904 sq ft footprint at a conservative $479/sq ft yields a $912,000 baseline. The remaining $46k premium is specifically tied to the 'Triple Crown' certifications we are securing: LEED, ENERGY STAR, and EPA Indoor airPLUS. In the 80211 market, high-performance, certified green homes with striking architectural elements (the A-frame addition) consistently command a measurable premium over standard cosmetic flips.
2. The Rehab Budget ($172,880) This is not a back-of-the-napkin estimate. The $172,880 budget is based on specific contractor bids. For example, the EIFS exterior wrap with the required drainage plane is capped at $27,000. Furthermore, I have a $14,700 contingency built into that $172,880 figure to absorb any structural or masonry surprises when we demo the porch and prep the brick.
3. Credentials and Execution I operate Packer Development LLC, a development company focused on high-performance, certified green housing. I hold a Denver Class C Residential Contractor License, so im not just the developer i'm the designer and contractor . We are also working directly with an EPA-credentialed Home Energy Rater (HERS) to guarantee compliance for the ENERGY STAR and LEED certifications.
The $5,675/month holding cost is accurate, and the timeline is aggressive, but the $14k contingency and the 24% margin provide the exact buffer needed to protect the downside."
Looks like that $653K cash to start is running it as an all-cash deal. If you're planning to use a flip loan, I'd rerun it that way, since the cash you need up front drops a lot but the holding costs go up once you add the interest each month. Trevor's point on the ARV matters on the loan side too. A lot of flip lenders size the loan off the after-repair value, so if that number comes in low on the appraisal, the loan shrinks with it.
I'm a mortgage broker licensed in Arizona, California, Colorado, Kansas, Texas, and Arkansas, and I like helping investors. Happy to be a resource. No pressure at all!
Are you planning to pay cash on this one or use a loan? Either way, sounds like a fun project.
Harold, a $232k projected spread on a $451k purchase definitely grabs attention, though Trevor nailed the biggest risk at an implied ~$950k+ ARV in Denver, one weak comp or an extra 60 days of $5,675/mo holding costs eats that cushion fast.
When we pull off-market data across Colorado metros, isolating true deep-equity distress (15–40%+ below live sub-market medians) upfront is usually what keeps high-ticket flips from relying on best-case retail comps.
Did you source this one off-market directly, or is it a listed deal you're underwriting?
Harold, I've flipped over 100 houses. On a gut rehab that size the lender's going to want a line-item budget and a GC they can vet before they fund draws, so get that tight before you write the offer. Message me if you want to run it with a loan instead of all cash.
Trevor covered the ARV, so here's the other missing line, the rehab. Your cash needed is $653,308. Take off the $451,800 price and $17,458 in closing costs and about $184K is left for rehab and holding. At $5,675 a month, 6 months of holding is about $34K. That leaves roughly $150K for the work. So the question is what $150K of work turns a $452K Denver house into a $958K one. I'd want that scope line by line before I believed the profit.