3 Co-Living Builders I’ve Researched — All Have Red Flags. Who Else Is Out There?

3 Co-Living Builders I’ve Researched — All Have Red Flags. Who Else Is Out There?

Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 19 votes
Hi BP community — looking for some intel on co-living new construction builders in Jacksonville FL, Houston TX, or other high-demand co-living markets. I’m trying to build a co-living duplex or triplex (PadSplit-ready, ensuite rooms) in B/C class neighborhoods. I’ve been researching three builders in this space and running into red flags with all three: 1. SHRCASA Homes (Jacksonville) — brand new LLC, less than a year in business, no escrow on buyer deposits, no contractor’s bond, and a PSA with some s dangerous terms. Cant do it. 2. Flight Builders (Jacksonville) — legitimate builder with a real track record, but they will only build in ghetto D and F grade zip codes. 3. Passive Investor Network — PadSplit-endorsed, but their sales rep also told me they won’t send any deal information until I put down a deposit. That’s a hard no. What I’m looking for is a GC or builder who: ∙ Is licensed and bonded ∙ Uses proper escrow for buyer deposits ∙ Has a real track record building a co-living product ∙ Operates in any high-demand PadSplit market — Jacksonville FL, Houston TX, Atlanta GA, Charlotte NC, Dallas TX, Columbus OH, or similar landlord-friendly metros Has anyone worked with a builder who fits this profile? Ideally someone who builds investor-spec co-living or multifamily and understands PadSplit room layout requirements — ensuite bathrooms, egress windows, etc… Also open to hearing from anyone who has gone the route of hiring a traditional multifamily GC and bringing their own PadSplit spec sheet to the table rather than using a co-living specialist. Any leads, referrals, or cautionary tales appreciated. DMs welcome.
2Reply
273 views

Most Popular Reply

Todd AndersonPro Member
Real Estate Agent · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2023 · 392 posts · 176 votes
7mo

@David G.,

I have worked with a number of builders in many of the areas that you are looking into.  I have not specifically dove Pad Split but I have had good luck with typical LTR.  Depending on let layouts the builders have converting to a different strategy may be fairly easy.

The big concern that I and many of the investors I talk with have is the Exit plan.  the home needs to be able to be sold or used for other strategies down the road.  That's why many of the investors that I work with stay with the LTR model.  

It sounds like you have done a lot of ground work already.  feel free to reach out for some other names.

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Coppell, TX · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7mo

    Why build new? Your best ROI is probably converting and perhaps minimally converting existing housing?

    • Technology · Orange County, CA · Member since 2026 · 1 post · 0 votes
      2d

      @Bruce Lynn - New homes can be optimized better for cashflow and have less capex risk. Most properties that fit the co-living model have to meet several criteria:

      1. No HOA

      2. In a city with no restrictive zoning

      3. In a B/C class neighborhood where neighbors won't frown upon street parking (or enough parking on property to accommodate 5-7 members).

      4. Close commute to metro areas

      The homes that fit all these criteria are usually older and have many aging components. You need to pay for design to ensure the layout is not choppy and awkward. You need to open walls to add new bathrooms if the current configuration doesn't accomodate enough members to cashflow. Then you have aging components and CapEx costs which can kill your profits from year 1. You also have member friction due to shared bathrooms. Many lots have 1-2 parking spots in front of the home and you have 5-8 members who drive and have to do street parking. This can trigger neighbor complaints and possibly issues with member vehicles being broken into or hit by careless drivers. The list goes on.

      A custom co-living home built to spec is usually designed where all rooms have an ensuite, allowing the investor to charge top rent per room and minimizing member friction. It minimizes CapEx costs (at least for the first few years). You can optimize parking based on lot layout and size. The members get a new home, so you have less complaints about failing components. The build is built to latest code, which can reduce insurance costs in some states. But the biggest downside - cost of materials today is not cheap and you have to find the right builder.

  • Diego AlvaradoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Flower Mound, TX · Member since 2016 · 303 posts · 142 votes
    7mo

    Hi @David G.

    Could you tell us why you are trying to build one? Requirements are similar than a small motels model. What is you ROI if you do padsplit instead of building a motel?

    Padsplit work best when converting a large house to a coliving space.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 19 votes
    7mo
    I’m looking to build because I want a purpose-built co-living product from day one. Every bedroom will have its own en-suite bathroom, everything will be brand new (electrical, plumbing, etc.), and it’s designed specifically for co-living — not retrofitted into something it wasn’t meant to be. The alternative is buying an older home with outdated systems, not enough bathrooms, and then spending a lot of money converting it, while still dealing with ongoing maintenance issues. That ends up being more unpredictable and often more expensive long term. On top of that, these builders are offering 7-bedroom homes around $300K and 14-bedroom setups around $600K, and I can get DSCR financing on them, which makes the model scalable. As for motels, they’re just not designed for long-term co-living. Different use case entirely. For me, this is about building something efficient, scalable, and designed correctly from the start.
  • Todd AndersonPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2023 · 392 posts · 176 votes
    7mo

    @David G.,

    I have worked with a number of builders in many of the areas that you are looking into.  I have not specifically dove Pad Split but I have had good luck with typical LTR.  Depending on let layouts the builders have converting to a different strategy may be fairly easy.

    The big concern that I and many of the investors I talk with have is the Exit plan.  the home needs to be able to be sold or used for other strategies down the road.  That's why many of the investors that I work with stay with the LTR model.  

    It sounds like you have done a lot of ground work already.  feel free to reach out for some other names.

    • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 19 votes
      7mo

      @Todd Anderson Great to meet you. It's not letting me DM you. Can you send me a DM please?

  • Member since 2024 · 5 posts · 0 votes
    7mo

    Hey!  Trey here with PadSplit Houston.  I am a Onboarding Rep here with many great connections to builders, not only in Houston, but all the other markets you mentioned.  I would be more than happy to connect you with some.  Send me a PM.

    • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 60 posts · 19 votes
      7mo

      @Trey Watkins Great to meet you. Just sent you a connection request

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.